際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Joining the Collaborative knowledge-building space of wikisScaffolding participation in increasingly public spheres
Scaffolding participation across activitiesPosition Paper:Wikipedia in the classroom
Reading the Moby-Dick article
Learning the norms
Following the talk
Tracking the history
Analyzing informationChecking factsJudging credibility Reading & comparing information from other sourcesLooking for gapsProbing the information for what it doesnt sayConducting research (e.g., between what years did Melville write the book?)Evaluating validity of their knowledge (e.g., Wrath of Khan as an appropriation)Considering the value of potential contributions to the Moby-Dick community
Joining the community
Using the tools
Adding informationNoted that Moby-Dick was selected as the state book for MAAdded Wrath of Khan as an example of appropriating themes of Moby-Dick Added Moby Dick: Then and Now as an example of a contemporary remix

More Related Content

Similar to Scaffolding Participation (16)

From Public Pedagogy to Critical Digital Praxis: Learning/Writing as Reflecti...
From Public Pedagogy to Critical Digital Praxis: Learning/Writing as Reflecti...From Public Pedagogy to Critical Digital Praxis: Learning/Writing as Reflecti...
From Public Pedagogy to Critical Digital Praxis: Learning/Writing as Reflecti...
Matthew Vetter
Wikis In Education - Leadership Council
Wikis In Education -  Leadership CouncilWikis In Education -  Leadership Council
Wikis In Education - Leadership Council
Corinne Carriero
An Analysis Of Wikipedia Digital Writing
An Analysis Of Wikipedia Digital WritingAn Analysis Of Wikipedia Digital Writing
An Analysis Of Wikipedia Digital Writing
Sherri Cost
Using Web 2.0 and the Public Sphere to Foster Public Writing in Composition ...
Using Web 2.0 and the Public Sphere to  Foster Public Writing in Composition ...Using Web 2.0 and the Public Sphere to  Foster Public Writing in Composition ...
Using Web 2.0 and the Public Sphere to Foster Public Writing in Composition ...
Casey McArdle
Fantasy
FantasyFantasy
Fantasy
Megan Mize
How Affordances of Digital Tool Use Foster Critical Literacy: GCLR Webinar pr...
How Affordances of Digital Tool Use Foster Critical Literacy: GCLR Webinar pr...How Affordances of Digital Tool Use Foster Critical Literacy: GCLR Webinar pr...
How Affordances of Digital Tool Use Foster Critical Literacy: GCLR Webinar pr...
Richard Beach
A Brief Review Of Studies Of Wikipedia In Peer-Reviewed Journals
A Brief Review Of Studies Of Wikipedia In Peer-Reviewed JournalsA Brief Review Of Studies Of Wikipedia In Peer-Reviewed Journals
A Brief Review Of Studies Of Wikipedia In Peer-Reviewed Journals
Sandra Long
Literature review
Literature reviewLiterature review
Literature review
Leonardo Langaro
Elizabeth Pollard - History
Elizabeth Pollard - HistoryElizabeth Pollard - History
Elizabeth Pollard - History
Course Design Institute and pICT SDSU
Web 2.0 Chillicothe High School
Web 2.0 Chillicothe High SchoolWeb 2.0 Chillicothe High School
Web 2.0 Chillicothe High School
OHIO ITSCO
Student to Author: Using Wikipedia to Improve Undergraduate Research & Writing
Student to Author: Using Wikipedia to Improve Undergraduate Research & WritingStudent to Author: Using Wikipedia to Improve Undergraduate Research & Writing
Student to Author: Using Wikipedia to Improve Undergraduate Research & Writing
Margot
Susan Zeiger, Primary Source, Teaching Informational Texts June 6, 2012
Susan Zeiger, Primary Source, Teaching Informational Texts  June 6, 2012Susan Zeiger, Primary Source, Teaching Informational Texts  June 6, 2012
Susan Zeiger, Primary Source, Teaching Informational Texts June 6, 2012
Center for Global Education at Asia Society
2012 blogging, self publishing and discoverability
2012 blogging, self publishing and discoverability2012 blogging, self publishing and discoverability
2012 blogging, self publishing and discoverability
JohnMillsonline
How the OER movement is transforming College Writing and Reading
How the OER movement is transforming College Writing and ReadingHow the OER movement is transforming College Writing and Reading
How the OER movement is transforming College Writing and Reading
Flat World Knowledge Publishing
Mediawiki and Wiki As a Medium
Mediawiki and Wiki As a MediumMediawiki and Wiki As a Medium
Mediawiki and Wiki As a Medium
Randy Thornton
Dissecting Wikipedia
Dissecting WikipediaDissecting Wikipedia
Dissecting Wikipedia
Andrew Gray
From Public Pedagogy to Critical Digital Praxis: Learning/Writing as Reflecti...
From Public Pedagogy to Critical Digital Praxis: Learning/Writing as Reflecti...From Public Pedagogy to Critical Digital Praxis: Learning/Writing as Reflecti...
From Public Pedagogy to Critical Digital Praxis: Learning/Writing as Reflecti...
Matthew Vetter
Wikis In Education - Leadership Council
Wikis In Education -  Leadership CouncilWikis In Education -  Leadership Council
Wikis In Education - Leadership Council
Corinne Carriero
An Analysis Of Wikipedia Digital Writing
An Analysis Of Wikipedia Digital WritingAn Analysis Of Wikipedia Digital Writing
An Analysis Of Wikipedia Digital Writing
Sherri Cost
Using Web 2.0 and the Public Sphere to Foster Public Writing in Composition ...
Using Web 2.0 and the Public Sphere to  Foster Public Writing in Composition ...Using Web 2.0 and the Public Sphere to  Foster Public Writing in Composition ...
Using Web 2.0 and the Public Sphere to Foster Public Writing in Composition ...
Casey McArdle
How Affordances of Digital Tool Use Foster Critical Literacy: GCLR Webinar pr...
How Affordances of Digital Tool Use Foster Critical Literacy: GCLR Webinar pr...How Affordances of Digital Tool Use Foster Critical Literacy: GCLR Webinar pr...
How Affordances of Digital Tool Use Foster Critical Literacy: GCLR Webinar pr...
Richard Beach
A Brief Review Of Studies Of Wikipedia In Peer-Reviewed Journals
A Brief Review Of Studies Of Wikipedia In Peer-Reviewed JournalsA Brief Review Of Studies Of Wikipedia In Peer-Reviewed Journals
A Brief Review Of Studies Of Wikipedia In Peer-Reviewed Journals
Sandra Long
Web 2.0 Chillicothe High School
Web 2.0 Chillicothe High SchoolWeb 2.0 Chillicothe High School
Web 2.0 Chillicothe High School
OHIO ITSCO
Student to Author: Using Wikipedia to Improve Undergraduate Research & Writing
Student to Author: Using Wikipedia to Improve Undergraduate Research & WritingStudent to Author: Using Wikipedia to Improve Undergraduate Research & Writing
Student to Author: Using Wikipedia to Improve Undergraduate Research & Writing
Margot
2012 blogging, self publishing and discoverability
2012 blogging, self publishing and discoverability2012 blogging, self publishing and discoverability
2012 blogging, self publishing and discoverability
JohnMillsonline
How the OER movement is transforming College Writing and Reading
How the OER movement is transforming College Writing and ReadingHow the OER movement is transforming College Writing and Reading
How the OER movement is transforming College Writing and Reading
Flat World Knowledge Publishing
Mediawiki and Wiki As a Medium
Mediawiki and Wiki As a MediumMediawiki and Wiki As a Medium
Mediawiki and Wiki As a Medium
Randy Thornton
Dissecting Wikipedia
Dissecting WikipediaDissecting Wikipedia
Dissecting Wikipedia
Andrew Gray

Recently uploaded (20)

QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the MoveQuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
TechSoup
Information Technology for class X CBSE skill Subject
Information Technology for class X CBSE skill SubjectInformation Technology for class X CBSE skill Subject
Information Technology for class X CBSE skill Subject
VEENAKSHI PATHAK
Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025
Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025
Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Prelims - El Dorado 2025
Conquiztadors- the Quiz Society of Sri Venkateswara College
Adventure Activities Final By H R Gohil Sir
Adventure Activities Final By H R Gohil SirAdventure Activities Final By H R Gohil Sir
Adventure Activities Final By H R Gohil Sir
GUJARATCOMMERCECOLLE
Digital Tools with AI for e-Content Development.pptx
Digital Tools with AI for e-Content Development.pptxDigital Tools with AI for e-Content Development.pptx
Digital Tools with AI for e-Content Development.pptx
Dr. Sarita Anand
N.C. DPI's 2023 Language Diversity Briefing
N.C. DPI's 2023 Language Diversity BriefingN.C. DPI's 2023 Language Diversity Briefing
N.C. DPI's 2023 Language Diversity Briefing
Mebane Rash
How to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of Sale
How to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of SaleHow to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of Sale
How to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of Sale
Celine George
How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18
How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18
How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18
Celine George
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷s
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷sHow to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷s
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷s
Celine George
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
heathfieldcps1
English 4 Quarter 4 Week 4 Classroom Obs
English 4 Quarter 4 Week 4 Classroom ObsEnglish 4 Quarter 4 Week 4 Classroom Obs
English 4 Quarter 4 Week 4 Classroom Obs
NerissaMendez1
Useful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷s
Useful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷sUseful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷s
Useful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷s
Celine George
Blind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdf
Blind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdfBlind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdf
Blind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdf
Ajaz Hussain
Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Finals - El Dorado 2025
Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Finals - El Dorado 2025Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Finals - El Dorado 2025
Rass MELAI : an Internet MELA Quiz Finals - El Dorado 2025
Conquiztadors- the Quiz Society of Sri Venkateswara College
EDL 290F Week 3 - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
EDL 290F Week 3  - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdfEDL 290F Week 3  - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
EDL 290F Week 3 - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
Liz Walsh-Trevino
Essentials of a Good PMO, presented by Aalok Sonawala
Essentials of a Good PMO, presented by Aalok SonawalaEssentials of a Good PMO, presented by Aalok Sonawala
Essentials of a Good PMO, presented by Aalok Sonawala
Association for Project Management
A PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of Fire
A PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of FireA PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of Fire
A PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of Fire
Beena E S
Database population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slides
Database population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slidesDatabase population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slides
Database population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slides
Celine George
Storytelling instructions...............
Storytelling instructions...............Storytelling instructions...............
Storytelling instructions...............
Alexander Benito
Principle and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby Basnet
Principle and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby BasnetPrinciple and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby Basnet
Principle and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby Basnet
Boby Basnet
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the MoveQuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online  How to Make the Move
QuickBooks Desktop to QuickBooks Online How to Make the Move
TechSoup
Information Technology for class X CBSE skill Subject
Information Technology for class X CBSE skill SubjectInformation Technology for class X CBSE skill Subject
Information Technology for class X CBSE skill Subject
VEENAKSHI PATHAK
Adventure Activities Final By H R Gohil Sir
Adventure Activities Final By H R Gohil SirAdventure Activities Final By H R Gohil Sir
Adventure Activities Final By H R Gohil Sir
GUJARATCOMMERCECOLLE
Digital Tools with AI for e-Content Development.pptx
Digital Tools with AI for e-Content Development.pptxDigital Tools with AI for e-Content Development.pptx
Digital Tools with AI for e-Content Development.pptx
Dr. Sarita Anand
N.C. DPI's 2023 Language Diversity Briefing
N.C. DPI's 2023 Language Diversity BriefingN.C. DPI's 2023 Language Diversity Briefing
N.C. DPI's 2023 Language Diversity Briefing
Mebane Rash
How to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of Sale
How to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of SaleHow to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of Sale
How to Configure Restaurants in Odoo 17 Point of Sale
Celine George
How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18
How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18
How to attach file using upload button Odoo 18
Celine George
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷s
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷sHow to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷s
How to Setup WhatsApp in Odoo 17 - Odoo 際際滷s
Celine George
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 6pptx.pptx
heathfieldcps1
English 4 Quarter 4 Week 4 Classroom Obs
English 4 Quarter 4 Week 4 Classroom ObsEnglish 4 Quarter 4 Week 4 Classroom Obs
English 4 Quarter 4 Week 4 Classroom Obs
NerissaMendez1
Useful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷s
Useful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷sUseful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷s
Useful environment methods in Odoo 18 - Odoo 際際滷s
Celine George
Blind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdf
Blind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdfBlind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdf
Blind spots in AI and Formulation Science, IFPAC 2025.pdf
Ajaz Hussain
EDL 290F Week 3 - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
EDL 290F Week 3  - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdfEDL 290F Week 3  - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
EDL 290F Week 3 - Mountaintop Views (2025).pdf
Liz Walsh-Trevino
A PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of Fire
A PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of FireA PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of Fire
A PPT on the First Three chapters of Wings of Fire
Beena E S
Database population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slides
Database population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slidesDatabase population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slides
Database population in Odoo 18 - Odoo slides
Celine George
Storytelling instructions...............
Storytelling instructions...............Storytelling instructions...............
Storytelling instructions...............
Alexander Benito
Principle and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby Basnet
Principle and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby BasnetPrinciple and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby Basnet
Principle and Practices of Animal Breeding || Boby Basnet
Boby Basnet

Scaffolding Participation

Editor's Notes

  • #4: Article tab: what most Wikipedia users read for information
  • #5: Discussion tab: Discussions of Moby-Dick fans/scholars/readers about whats in the article (and should or should not be and their rationale for why)
  • #6: Take a look at this discussion, for instance, about whether or not Moby-Dick should be hyphenated
  • #7: The History tab is another level, where users can see the changes that have been made to the Moby-Dick article.
  • #8: Students were reading through all this informationbut reading it consequentiallyreading it through a framework of thinking about what they might contribute to the article. So they were checking facts, looking for gaps, and evaluating the validity of their knowledgewould the contributions they were considering be useful? Redundant? Would they be deleted?
  • #9: Becoming a member of the Wikipedia community
  • #10: Using the tools: Mark, a proficient Wikipedia user, taught everyone how to use the Sandbox feature to practice editing.
  • #11: It should be noted that the Moby-Dick Wikipedia community is an active one; the article was a nominee for a Language and Literature good article award. Facts from the article have been featured on Wikipedias main page 7 times, over a 4-year span. The editing talk page is 76 kilobytes long. In other words, this is an active, established community who seem to care deeply about the content.