This document discusses how IT functions can help address the UK's public sector debt crisis through digital transformation and reducing costs. It identifies two major ways IT can contribute: 1) reducing the cost of IT operations by 25% and 2) helping the government use IT to reduce costs through initiatives like digital-by-default services. The document also examines progress on the UK's digital agenda and challenges for IT functions to become more agile, work with smaller suppliers, and focus on continuous change rather than maintenance. It concludes that IT functions must adapt to play a role in accelerations digital transformations or risk becoming irrelevant.
1 of 24
More Related Content
Gov ict conf.2014v10
1. IT, Digital Transformation
and the National Debt
Government ICT 2014
Ben Grinnell
14 January 2014
To follow on your own device go to
[Insert client logo
on master]
http://www.slideshare.net
Proprietary and Confidential to North Highland
-
-
2. Contents
1.
Public Sector Debt the ultimate burning platform
2.
Two Major contributions from the IT function
3.
Progress on the Digital agenda and the challenges for IT
4.
How does IT need to change to contribute
5.
Summary and consequences
To follow on your own device go to
http://www.slideshare.net
2
4. Public Sector Debt The ultimate burning platform
Not a great position, but a great opportunity
Because transformation needs a crisis
4
5. Two major contributions the IT function can help with
1. Reducing the cost of IT
- IT is about 2% of PS spend at 贈13.8Bn
- Reduce 25%
5
6. Two major contributions the IT function can help with
1. Reducing the cost of IT
- IT is 2% of PS spend at 贈13.8Bn
- Reduce 25%
贈3.45Bn
/year
6
7. Two major contributions the IT function can help with
1. Reducing the cost of IT
- IT is 2% of PS spend at 贈13.8Bn
- Reduce 25%
贈3.45Bn
/year
---- and/or ----2. Help Government use IT to reduce cost
- Digital by default 2014
贈1.7Bn
- Full Digital Transformation 贈24Bn
* Smaller, Better, Faster, Stronger policy exchange.org.uk
7
8. Two major contributions the IT function can help with
1. Reducing the cost of IT
- IT is 2% of PS spend at 贈13.8Bn
- Reduce 25%
贈3.45Bn
/year
---- and/or ----2. Help Government use IT to reduce cost
- Digital by default 2014
贈1.7Bn
- Full Digital Transformation 贈24Bn
贈24Bn
/year
* Smaller, Better, Faster, Stronger policy exchange.org.uk
8
9. Digital agenda progress and challenges for IT
At the close of 2013 almost every element of the Government digital
strategy had been proved - somewhere
9
10. Digital agenda progress and challenges for IT
At the close of 2013 almost every element of the Government digital
strategy had been proved - somewhere
Agile Procurement & using SMEs
10
11. Digital agenda progress and challenges for IT
At the close of 2013 almost every element of the Government digital
strategy had been proved - somewhere
Agile Procurement & using SMEs
Agile Development
11
12. Digital agenda progress and challenges for IT
At the close of 2013 almost every element of the Government digital
strategy had been proved - somewhere
Agile Procurement & using SMEs
Agile Development
Open Data
G
I
S
T
12
13. Digital agenda progress and challenges for IT
At the close of 2013 almost every element of the Government digital
strategy had been proved - somewhere
Agile Procurement & using SMEs
Agile Development
Open Data
Channel Shift Savings
Transactions Explorer
G
I
S
T
13
15. Digital agenda progress and challenges for IT
FROM:
- Long term Dependency
- Waterfall Development
- Outsourced Risk
TO:
- Brains of IT in-house
- Agile Development
- Build to change
IT
15
16. Digital agenda progress and challenges for IT
-
FROM:
Eliminate Risk
Fire & Forget
Bigger longer
High entry cost
Lockdown on entry
Lengthy process
Procurement
-
TO:
Tolerate Risk
Ongoing management
Simpler shorter
Low entry cost
Built to change
Speed
16
17. Digital agenda progress and challenges for IT
-
FROM:
Maintenance
Guaranteed Revenue
Minimising Risk/Penalties
Monopolising IT supply
IT
Suppliers
-
TO:
Continuous Change
Co-operation
Continuous competition
Agile Development
Open technologies
17
18. Digital agenda progress and challenges for IT
TO:
- Brains of IT in-house
- Agile Development
- Build to change
IT
-
TO:
Tolerate Risk
Ongoing management
Simpler shorter
Low entry cost
Built to change
Speed
-
TO:
Continuous Change
Co-operation
Continuous competition
Agile Development
Open technologies
18
19. Digital agenda progress and challenges for IT
Comms or Customer Services
Transformation Team
Agile methods
Two week plan
Constantly changing
requirements
Unconstrained
Exciting Customers
19
20. Digital agenda progress and challenges for IT
Comms or Customer Services
Transformation Team
Agile methods
Two week plan
Constantly changing
requirements
Unconstrained
Exciting Customers
Cowboys!
20
21. Digital agenda progress and challenges for IT
Comms or Customer Services
Transformation Team
Agile methods
Two week plan
Constantly changing
requirements
Unconstrained
Exciting Customers
Dept of
No!
Cowboys!
21
22. Digital agenda progress and challenges for IT
Comms or Customer Services
Transformation Team
Agile methods
Two week plan
Constantly changing
requirements
Unconstrained
Exciting Customers
Dept of
No!
Cowboys!
22
23. IT needs to get ready to play with the new kids
1. Get the Brain of IT in-house
whatever your sourcing strategy retain knowledge about how services work in-house
2. Outsource the commodity stuff for value and agility
Provisioning a server really should take 10 mins
3. Explain your needs for integration and agility to your suppliers
Check your contracts, can you manage them or are they managing you
4. Explain your needs for agility to your procurement function
Both understand agile procurement facilitated by G-Cloud & Digital Services frameworks
5. Organise the IT function to focus on new business need
Make it the primary focus for a significant proportion of the function
6. Integrate your IT Service Design function with the agile projects
7. Design your IT function for continual evolution not maintenance
What will you need to maintain and evolve further after the project has gone
What capabilities do you need to maintain and evolve services in the BAU world
Where are Gov-ICT attendees on these 7 points?
Share and discover at
http://goo.gl/UwAfU9
23
24. Summary and consequences
Public Sector debt is a unifying crisis for
transformation
The digital strategy is now proven
The pace will significantly accelerate
Todays IT functions can be tomorrows
transformation champions or slide into irrelevance
2014
Todays IT Function
CHOICE
Internal focus & Reactive
2016
Costly Legacy Relic
Proactive bus change focus
Digital Efficiency Champion
http://goo.gl/UwAfU9 today only
24
Editor's Notes
WelcomeGreat to be here again. Ive spent the last 15 years helping CIOs and IT Directors improve their IT Functions including a 3 year spell as an IT Director in central government. At North Highland Im our global lead for CIO services. Today Id like to share Our thoughts on - The IT function - The Digital Transformation - and their roles in reducing the cost of government and thereby the national debt.and hopefully get some of your thoughts too.If youd like to follow on your own device the slides are available at
Ill be very brief on the Debt as I think we are all familiar with that, moving quickly on to the contribution IT can make and the challenges facing the IT function if it is to play a significant role.North Highlands business has been built on being the friend of the CIO and weve improvedcapability in many of our clients IT functions. I think today many PS IT functionsstand at a junction with Transformation Champion one way and irrelevance the other. Ill finish by talking about what we think they need to do to take the road to stardom.
The red bars on the left show weve increased PS debt every year since 2001-2 and we are going to be increasing it until 2018The annual interest on that debt is about 贈45Bn or to make that real 贈1500 a year from every person paying income taxYou can see from the pie chart its not an insignificant amount. Its the same as our spend on DefenceWe stop increasing the debt by 2018 if we achieve the 贈25Bn cuts the Chancellor outlined last week.From 2018 we can start paying back and the interest will decrease, but its a long road.
One thing we can all agree on. Its a big problem, and its not going away anytime soonAnd whilst that is not a great position, it is a great opportunity that we must seize. Transforming large established organisations requires a crisis that everyone can unite behind and this is ours.
So focusing on two major contributions the IT function can help with. The first is to reduce the cost of IT which the OfT estimated at 贈13.8Bn for 2011-12.If we could reduce this by 25% over the next few years we would end up saving 贈3.45bn a year.
Better sourcing models, sharing risk, more efficient procurement, using SMEs and cheaper solutions such as open source may be able to deliver this.The second is to help the operations outside of the IT function save money by transforming.
Transforming isnt just about IT but IT has a huge roleThe current digital by defaultfocus on services and transactions for the top 25 exemplars will deliver 贈1.7Bn annuallyThe Policy Exchange report last year estimated savings of 贈24Bn per year could be realised through digital transformation by 2020.
But this isnt necessarily a choice!Indeed, we believe that some of the internal changes IT needs to make to reduce cost will also give it the agility it needs to help the rest of the organisation reduce costs So whats the status and the challenges ahead
At the close of 2013 almost every element of the Government digital strategy had been proved - somewhere
G-Cloud has proved we can do agile procurement - 贈77m March-Oct 50% on SMERecently joined by Digital Services Framework opened in Nov with 183 suppliers of which 84% are SMEs.
Gov.uk Agile in PS at scale. The 24 Ministerial departments all live on Gov.uk
William Perrin did a great job of showing us the power of information in 2008 The Open data movement in government is now past critical mass. Looking at: - data.gov.uk and the ToGo package - the Government Interrogating Spending Tool (GIST) and you can see there has been a very fundamental mindset shift.
Channel Shift Savings are provenGov.uk is an order of magnitude cheaper than its successors.The transactions explorer gives transparency on the cost by channelAll of this is fantastic progress, which has been exciting to watchbut its a few hundred people driving the change in a population of 5m.Now the trailblazers and heroes have provided the trail2014 is the year we need to follow en-masse. This year we all have a choice. to follow the trailblazers, or be part of the legacy problem.For IT functions following presents some huge challenges and I think their actions next year will determine whether they can become digital efficiency champions or get stuck on the slow road to irrelevance.
This Triangle Ive drawn represents a simplified ecosystem of public sector IT supply. I think there are some quite fundamental changes required at each Vertex And its very difficult to change the fundamentals of how you do things if those you work with arent changing too.
The IT function itself needs to move from trying to outsource overall risk - one throat to choke to sourcing simpler commodity services where its easy to switch any one supplierIt needs to - build technical knowledge in-house about how the services are integrated - move from 5 year refresh to monthly releases - focus on building to change rather than building to last, - work with the business on their ideas, - play with solutions that might meet the user need, Stop demanding a detailed statement of requirements before considering a change
Procurement needs to Focus less on the art of procurement and more on the customer needsIt needs to tolerate risk, both in the process and in the contractsMore agile procurement means less fire and forget more ongoing managementIt needs to create contracts that are simpler to get into and to get out ofIt needs to move away from contracts that provide a technology refresh in exchange for years of sweating the assets and are hugely focused on contractual keep the lights on SLAsIt needs to become fast lean and agile
IT BPO Suppliers have built businesses on delivering against keep the lights on contracts for their clients as cheaply as possible.Often buying run contracts and making the margin on changes the run contract gives them a monopoly on.They need to change to a business model that isnt so dependent on the long guaranteed revenue streamsThey need to be able to compete for smaller bits of work continuouslyThey need to get to grips with new technologies and new build cycles.
So each vertex has to effect a fundamental change, And in many organisations the drive for change is coming from outside this ecosystemThe first question on digital leaders lips when looking at transforming services is rightly what is the user need so they are often working with Customer services, Marketing, Communications or a Service Transformation programme, which may or may not have IT on board
So what we often see is a Service Transformation programme using Agile methods reaching out to IT: - it has changing requirements, - it doesnt have a detailed specification, - it wants to try something that is likely to change as they go, - it wants to go live in a few weeks and the plan after that is unclearThis is difficult for most IT functions, even if they are open to it, the ecosystem might not be equipped to deal with it. There will probably be a need to procure something quickly They might need to get an API from one of their suppliers working quicklyContracts not built for this scenario might get in the waySo the likely result isvery different views from either side
The IT ecosystem views the programme as cowboys
The programme views the IT ecosystem as the department of No.And they dont co-operate
This is not a UK PS problem. The growing turf war in the private sector between marketing and IT is well documented but not resolved.If its war, there will be casualties on both sides, and progress will be slowed, but if IT functions choose to fight we dont think this is a war they are going to win.So what should those of us on the IT side do
So I think IT functions need to act fast and be very proactive in addressing this agendaIve identified 7 things I think they need to do, it would be useful for us to all share where we are on these, you can share and see that by completing the short poll Now as we go through, or throughout the day.
The Public Sector debt problem creates an essential unifying burning platform for transformation, our opportunityVirtually all the elements of the digital strategy have now been proven somewhereBut its a few people doing some really good work (a few 100 out of 5m LG&CG civil servants)and to accelerate the pace we need to follow en-masseIf IT functions are going to be part of this they need to be very proactively preparing themselves, otherwise they will be viewed as the dept. of no and left with the soul destroying job of keeping the legacy IT lights on and getting a kicking every-time they go out. I believe transformation will deliver value quicker if todays IT function can be tomorrows Digital Efficiency champion