際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Executive Offices (Bestuursbureaus)
         of Pension Funds



                  Alfred Slager
  Tilburg University, TiasNimbas Business School
            April 26 2012, Noordwijk
Remember 1628?
2012
 Pension funds organizations evolve:
    Coordination: Internal organization grows more complex

    Counterweight: Outside world more complex and challenging

 Executive Offices increase in importance, to
    Own policy and monitoring capabilities after spin off investment organisation.

    Separate policy and practice, focus on the core responsibilities of Trustees

    Organize countervailing power: pension funds goals  asset managers.

    Be better equipped to manage pensions in increasingly complex markets.

    Coordination mechanism to cope with new (internal) units, organisations, etc.
Different structures emerge
                     1   2   3   4   5


Board of Trustees


Committees


Executive Office


Investment Manager



Custodian
Tasks Executive Office

 Support the Board of Trustees: organization and servicing meetings of the
   Board and its committees
 Centralization to promote controlled, efficient and effective
   management. Sets priorities and manages internal decision-making
 Ensure that key decisions and management responses to challenges are
   consistent with the Funds mission, values and strategy.
 First point of contact with regulators, participants, journalists, etc.
 Carry out reviews and analyses of policy issues relating to the plan design.
Different approaches to Executive Office
Approach        Description                Executive Office

Resourcing      Buying-in investment       Building blocks;
                services "as a             market practice
                commodity.
Coordination/   Transfer to outside        SLA Management
outsourcing     suppliers of in-house
                activities.
Co-creation     Pooling of facilities to   Product              Resourcing
                profit from                Development
                complementary              R&D Agenda
                expertise.




                                              Outsourcing/Coordination       Co-creation
Issues in a few years time
 Different shapes and sizes of in control
 Organizational growth of Executive Office
 Shift in agenda: your or mine beliefs
 Best/Worst of both worlds in decision making.
 Mandate fuzzyness
 Effectiveness
Different shapes and sizes of in control


Board of Trustees


Committees


Executive Office


Investment Manager



Custodian
Issues in a few years time
 Different shapes and sizes of in control
 Organizational growth of Executive Office
 Shift in agenda: your or mine beliefs
 Best/Worst of both worlds in decision making.
 Mandate fuzzyness
 Effectiveness
Shift in agenda: your or mine beliefs.
What about the Executive Office?

 Pension fund                                   Asset manager


                Risk diversification                 Inefficiencies

                Risk premiums          Focus
                                                     Active
                                                     management
                Responsible            Impact
                Investments                          Teams and staff
                                       Risk man.
                Goals
Issues in a few years time
 Different shapes and sizes of in control
 Organizational growth of Executive Office
 Shift in agenda: your or mine beliefs
 Best/Worst of both worlds in decision making.
 Mandate fuzzyness
 Effectiveness
1628
 Dont temper with a slim and
  elegant design
 Top heavy is inherently unstable
 Respect the craftsman
 Clarity of roles
 Early warning signals

More Related Content

What's hot (19)

How Managers Add Destroy Value
How Managers Add Destroy ValueHow Managers Add Destroy Value
How Managers Add Destroy Value
John D. Robeda
Strategic planning gsw
Strategic planning gswStrategic planning gsw
Strategic planning gsw
woznite65
Introduction to WSD Capital Management
Introduction to WSD Capital ManagementIntroduction to WSD Capital Management
Introduction to WSD Capital Management
WSD Capital Management
ENC 3250_Belayneh
ENC 3250_BelaynehENC 3250_Belayneh
ENC 3250_Belayneh
Winta Yemane
ENC 3250 1
ENC 3250 1ENC 3250 1
ENC 3250 1
Winta Yemane
Ch01
Ch01Ch01
Ch01
Aqsa Ch
Ch01
Ch01Ch01
Ch01
Institute of management studies (UOP)
Proactive crisis management: Expecting the unexpected
Proactive crisis management: Expecting the unexpectedProactive crisis management: Expecting the unexpected
Proactive crisis management: Expecting the unexpected
Osler, Hoskin & Harcourt LLP
Managing in uncertainty
Managing in uncertaintyManaging in uncertainty
Managing in uncertainty
Agency for Cooperation and Research in Development
Ten principles of fm
Ten principles of fmTen principles of fm
Ten principles of fm
IvanDuran38
Case study on financing capital for a new startup
Case study on financing capital for a new startupCase study on financing capital for a new startup
Case study on financing capital for a new startup
Amitava Sengupta
Small Cap Investor Activism in Canada and Crescendo Partners - Nov 2010
Small Cap Investor Activism in Canada and Crescendo Partners - Nov 2010Small Cap Investor Activism in Canada and Crescendo Partners - Nov 2010
Small Cap Investor Activism in Canada and Crescendo Partners - Nov 2010
Dave Litwiller
Managing distressed private equity and credit investments
Managing distressed private equity and credit investmentsManaging distressed private equity and credit investments
Managing distressed private equity and credit investments
Steven Rosenblum
Understanding The Investment Term Sheet
Understanding The Investment Term SheetUnderstanding The Investment Term Sheet
Understanding The Investment Term Sheet
Mohammad Albattikhi
From Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case Study
From Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case StudyFrom Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case Study
From Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case Study
Roger Ehrenberg
Shareholder Activism & The Rise of Shareholder Value
Shareholder Activism & The Rise of Shareholder ValueShareholder Activism & The Rise of Shareholder Value
Shareholder Activism & The Rise of Shareholder Value
WSD Capital Management
2011 Endeavor Summit Hot Topic workshop: Term Sheet Negotiations, the devil i...
2011 Endeavor Summit Hot Topic workshop: Term Sheet Negotiations, the devil i...2011 Endeavor Summit Hot Topic workshop: Term Sheet Negotiations, the devil i...
2011 Endeavor Summit Hot Topic workshop: Term Sheet Negotiations, the devil i...
Ariel Muslera
Guide A Best Financial Adviser who's right for you!
 Guide A Best Financial Adviser who's right for you! Guide A Best Financial Adviser who's right for you!
Guide A Best Financial Adviser who's right for you!
TCM Financial Services
Avenir Capital Value Fund
Avenir Capital Value FundAvenir Capital Value Fund
Avenir Capital Value Fund
AvenirCapital
How Managers Add Destroy Value
How Managers Add Destroy ValueHow Managers Add Destroy Value
How Managers Add Destroy Value
John D. Robeda
Strategic planning gsw
Strategic planning gswStrategic planning gsw
Strategic planning gsw
woznite65
Introduction to WSD Capital Management
Introduction to WSD Capital ManagementIntroduction to WSD Capital Management
Introduction to WSD Capital Management
WSD Capital Management
ENC 3250_Belayneh
ENC 3250_BelaynehENC 3250_Belayneh
ENC 3250_Belayneh
Winta Yemane
Proactive crisis management: Expecting the unexpected
Proactive crisis management: Expecting the unexpectedProactive crisis management: Expecting the unexpected
Proactive crisis management: Expecting the unexpected
Osler, Hoskin & Harcourt LLP
Ten principles of fm
Ten principles of fmTen principles of fm
Ten principles of fm
IvanDuran38
Case study on financing capital for a new startup
Case study on financing capital for a new startupCase study on financing capital for a new startup
Case study on financing capital for a new startup
Amitava Sengupta
Small Cap Investor Activism in Canada and Crescendo Partners - Nov 2010
Small Cap Investor Activism in Canada and Crescendo Partners - Nov 2010Small Cap Investor Activism in Canada and Crescendo Partners - Nov 2010
Small Cap Investor Activism in Canada and Crescendo Partners - Nov 2010
Dave Litwiller
Managing distressed private equity and credit investments
Managing distressed private equity and credit investmentsManaging distressed private equity and credit investments
Managing distressed private equity and credit investments
Steven Rosenblum
Understanding The Investment Term Sheet
Understanding The Investment Term SheetUnderstanding The Investment Term Sheet
Understanding The Investment Term Sheet
Mohammad Albattikhi
From Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case Study
From Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case StudyFrom Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case Study
From Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case Study
Roger Ehrenberg
Shareholder Activism & The Rise of Shareholder Value
Shareholder Activism & The Rise of Shareholder ValueShareholder Activism & The Rise of Shareholder Value
Shareholder Activism & The Rise of Shareholder Value
WSD Capital Management
2011 Endeavor Summit Hot Topic workshop: Term Sheet Negotiations, the devil i...
2011 Endeavor Summit Hot Topic workshop: Term Sheet Negotiations, the devil i...2011 Endeavor Summit Hot Topic workshop: Term Sheet Negotiations, the devil i...
2011 Endeavor Summit Hot Topic workshop: Term Sheet Negotiations, the devil i...
Ariel Muslera
Guide A Best Financial Adviser who's right for you!
 Guide A Best Financial Adviser who's right for you! Guide A Best Financial Adviser who's right for you!
Guide A Best Financial Adviser who's right for you!
TCM Financial Services
Avenir Capital Value Fund
Avenir Capital Value FundAvenir Capital Value Fund
Avenir Capital Value Fund
AvenirCapital

Similar to Executive Offices (pensioenbureaus) of Pension Funds (20)

Leading change gsw
Leading change gswLeading change gsw
Leading change gsw
woznite65
Book review framenewp_mnotes.doc
Book review framenewp_mnotes.docBook review framenewp_mnotes.doc
Book review framenewp_mnotes.doc
Edelweiss broking ltd
Efin cfo services_june10
Efin cfo services_june10Efin cfo services_june10
Efin cfo services_june10
Takecarehelp
The Effective Director
The Effective DirectorThe Effective Director
The Effective Director
Financial Poise
Developing Project Leadership
Developing Project LeadershipDeveloping Project Leadership
Developing Project Leadership
Donnie MacNicol
Developing Project Leadership
Developing Project LeadershipDeveloping Project Leadership
Developing Project Leadership
Donnie MacNicol
The Effective Director
The Effective Director  The Effective Director
The Effective Director
Financial Poise
Strategic implementation
Strategic implementationStrategic implementation
Strategic implementation
Anurag Srivastava
Talent Pipeline Optimisation: Ensuring Your Talented People Realise Their Po...
Talent Pipeline Optimisation:  Ensuring Your Talented People Realise Their Po...Talent Pipeline Optimisation:  Ensuring Your Talented People Realise Their Po...
Talent Pipeline Optimisation: Ensuring Your Talented People Realise Their Po...
The HR Observer
Community of Practice Webinar - What makes a good (or great) change manager?
Community of Practice Webinar - What makes a good (or great) change manager? Community of Practice Webinar - What makes a good (or great) change manager?
Community of Practice Webinar - What makes a good (or great) change manager?
Prosci ANZ
Strategic planning in agribusiness lecture1
Strategic planning in agribusiness lecture1Strategic planning in agribusiness lecture1
Strategic planning in agribusiness lecture1
CSIR-CRI (crop research instituete)
Developing Talent Solutions Aligned with Business Strategies
Developing Talent Solutions Aligned with Business StrategiesDeveloping Talent Solutions Aligned with Business Strategies
Developing Talent Solutions Aligned with Business Strategies
jcmundy
Developing Talent Solutions Aligned with Business Strategies
Developing Talent Solutions Aligned with Business StrategiesDeveloping Talent Solutions Aligned with Business Strategies
Developing Talent Solutions Aligned with Business Strategies
jcmundy
Mark Ventry - Effective Boards
Mark Ventry - Effective BoardsMark Ventry - Effective Boards
Mark Ventry - Effective Boards
Hannah Renglich
Building exceptional boards of directors in growth stage technology businesse...
Building exceptional boards of directors in growth stage technology businesse...Building exceptional boards of directors in growth stage technology businesse...
Building exceptional boards of directors in growth stage technology businesse...
Dave Litwiller
Investment Deal Breakers & Business Turnaround
Investment Deal Breakers & Business TurnaroundInvestment Deal Breakers & Business Turnaround
Investment Deal Breakers & Business Turnaround
Incubate Advisory
entrepreneurship development .pjhjhhhjptx
entrepreneurship development .pjhjhhhjptxentrepreneurship development .pjhjhhhjptx
entrepreneurship development .pjhjhhhjptx
ChandrikaDani
Creating Value Through Good Corporate Governance
Creating Value Through Good Corporate GovernanceCreating Value Through Good Corporate Governance
Creating Value Through Good Corporate Governance
EstherMM
Moving your organization into the fast lane metro
Moving your organization into the fast lane   metroMoving your organization into the fast lane   metro
Moving your organization into the fast lane metro
Mike Vincent
Summary for Managing Organizational Design
Summary for Managing Organizational Design Summary for Managing Organizational Design
Summary for Managing Organizational Design
Joseph Riad
Leading change gsw
Leading change gswLeading change gsw
Leading change gsw
woznite65
Efin cfo services_june10
Efin cfo services_june10Efin cfo services_june10
Efin cfo services_june10
Takecarehelp
The Effective Director
The Effective DirectorThe Effective Director
The Effective Director
Financial Poise
Developing Project Leadership
Developing Project LeadershipDeveloping Project Leadership
Developing Project Leadership
Donnie MacNicol
Developing Project Leadership
Developing Project LeadershipDeveloping Project Leadership
Developing Project Leadership
Donnie MacNicol
The Effective Director
The Effective Director  The Effective Director
The Effective Director
Financial Poise
Talent Pipeline Optimisation: Ensuring Your Talented People Realise Their Po...
Talent Pipeline Optimisation:  Ensuring Your Talented People Realise Their Po...Talent Pipeline Optimisation:  Ensuring Your Talented People Realise Their Po...
Talent Pipeline Optimisation: Ensuring Your Talented People Realise Their Po...
The HR Observer
Community of Practice Webinar - What makes a good (or great) change manager?
Community of Practice Webinar - What makes a good (or great) change manager? Community of Practice Webinar - What makes a good (or great) change manager?
Community of Practice Webinar - What makes a good (or great) change manager?
Prosci ANZ
Developing Talent Solutions Aligned with Business Strategies
Developing Talent Solutions Aligned with Business StrategiesDeveloping Talent Solutions Aligned with Business Strategies
Developing Talent Solutions Aligned with Business Strategies
jcmundy
Developing Talent Solutions Aligned with Business Strategies
Developing Talent Solutions Aligned with Business StrategiesDeveloping Talent Solutions Aligned with Business Strategies
Developing Talent Solutions Aligned with Business Strategies
jcmundy
Mark Ventry - Effective Boards
Mark Ventry - Effective BoardsMark Ventry - Effective Boards
Mark Ventry - Effective Boards
Hannah Renglich
Building exceptional boards of directors in growth stage technology businesse...
Building exceptional boards of directors in growth stage technology businesse...Building exceptional boards of directors in growth stage technology businesse...
Building exceptional boards of directors in growth stage technology businesse...
Dave Litwiller
Investment Deal Breakers & Business Turnaround
Investment Deal Breakers & Business TurnaroundInvestment Deal Breakers & Business Turnaround
Investment Deal Breakers & Business Turnaround
Incubate Advisory
entrepreneurship development .pjhjhhhjptx
entrepreneurship development .pjhjhhhjptxentrepreneurship development .pjhjhhhjptx
entrepreneurship development .pjhjhhhjptx
ChandrikaDani
Creating Value Through Good Corporate Governance
Creating Value Through Good Corporate GovernanceCreating Value Through Good Corporate Governance
Creating Value Through Good Corporate Governance
EstherMM
Moving your organization into the fast lane metro
Moving your organization into the fast lane   metroMoving your organization into the fast lane   metro
Moving your organization into the fast lane metro
Mike Vincent
Summary for Managing Organizational Design
Summary for Managing Organizational Design Summary for Managing Organizational Design
Summary for Managing Organizational Design
Joseph Riad

Executive Offices (pensioenbureaus) of Pension Funds

  • 1. Executive Offices (Bestuursbureaus) of Pension Funds Alfred Slager Tilburg University, TiasNimbas Business School April 26 2012, Noordwijk
  • 3. 2012 Pension funds organizations evolve: Coordination: Internal organization grows more complex Counterweight: Outside world more complex and challenging Executive Offices increase in importance, to Own policy and monitoring capabilities after spin off investment organisation. Separate policy and practice, focus on the core responsibilities of Trustees Organize countervailing power: pension funds goals asset managers. Be better equipped to manage pensions in increasingly complex markets. Coordination mechanism to cope with new (internal) units, organisations, etc.
  • 4. Different structures emerge 1 2 3 4 5 Board of Trustees Committees Executive Office Investment Manager Custodian
  • 5. Tasks Executive Office Support the Board of Trustees: organization and servicing meetings of the Board and its committees Centralization to promote controlled, efficient and effective management. Sets priorities and manages internal decision-making Ensure that key decisions and management responses to challenges are consistent with the Funds mission, values and strategy. First point of contact with regulators, participants, journalists, etc. Carry out reviews and analyses of policy issues relating to the plan design.
  • 6. Different approaches to Executive Office Approach Description Executive Office Resourcing Buying-in investment Building blocks; services "as a market practice commodity. Coordination/ Transfer to outside SLA Management outsourcing suppliers of in-house activities. Co-creation Pooling of facilities to Product Resourcing profit from Development complementary R&D Agenda expertise. Outsourcing/Coordination Co-creation
  • 7. Issues in a few years time Different shapes and sizes of in control Organizational growth of Executive Office Shift in agenda: your or mine beliefs Best/Worst of both worlds in decision making. Mandate fuzzyness Effectiveness
  • 8. Different shapes and sizes of in control Board of Trustees Committees Executive Office Investment Manager Custodian
  • 9. Issues in a few years time Different shapes and sizes of in control Organizational growth of Executive Office Shift in agenda: your or mine beliefs Best/Worst of both worlds in decision making. Mandate fuzzyness Effectiveness
  • 10. Shift in agenda: your or mine beliefs. What about the Executive Office? Pension fund Asset manager Risk diversification Inefficiencies Risk premiums Focus Active management Responsible Impact Investments Teams and staff Risk man. Goals
  • 11. Issues in a few years time Different shapes and sizes of in control Organizational growth of Executive Office Shift in agenda: your or mine beliefs Best/Worst of both worlds in decision making. Mandate fuzzyness Effectiveness
  • 12. 1628 Dont temper with a slim and elegant design Top heavy is inherently unstable Respect the craftsman Clarity of roles Early warning signals