際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
FAB LABS AND
SUSTAINABILITY
#sustmake
London, Machines Room, 26 Oct 2015
Cindy Kohtala
Aalto University
https://blogs.aalto.fi/makerculture/
Fab labs have altered the landscape of innovation by providing
the general public with an opportunity to appropriate the digital
fabrication process: to make things personally.
 They enable rapid prototyping but are not suited to
production on a larger scale (a limited number of identical
pieces can be made if the hardware is not overused), nor are
they suited to distribution, repair, or recycling.
SOURCE: Eychenne, F. (2012). Fab Labs Overview.The Fing (Fondation internet nouvelle g辿n辿ration). Retrieved from
http://www.slideshare.net/slidesharefing/fab-labs-overview
the inverse of digital fabrication is
digital recycling 
the construction of digital
materials can contain the
information needed for their
deconstruction.
Bad guys are already impressively
effective at acquiring the best
available technology for the
destruction of their enemies; fab
labs are likely to have a far
greater impact on the stability of
the planet by helping everyone
else acquire the technology they
need for their survival.
SOURCE: Gershenfeld, N., 2005. FAB:The Coming Revolution onYour Desktop 
From Personal Computers to Personal Fabrication. Basic Books, NewYork.
SOURCE: Kohtala, C., Hyysalo, S., 2015.Anticipated environmental sustainability of personal fabrication. Journal of Cleaner
Production 99, 333344. Open access from http://authors.elsevier.com/a/1R0Rk3QCo9EPdT until 1 July 2015.
SOURCE: Kohtala, C., 2014.Addressing sustainability in research on distributed production: an integrated literature review.
Journal of Cleaner Production. doi:10.1016/j.jclepro.2014.09.039
bespoke fabrication:
tailored, individualized
products, design and
fabrication in hands of
producer
mass fabrication:
unique products,
design and
fabrication in hands
of users in interaction
with each other
mass customization:
batch/modular
personalized products,
design and fabrication
in hands of producer
personal fabrication:
unique products,
design and fabrication
in hands of user,
shared designs
market
influence
non-market
influence
WHAT IS
DISTRIBUTED
PRODUCTION?
control over user/consumer input
scale
large
small
digital
manufacturing
peer-to-peer
production
mass fabrication:
transformed supply
chains, elimination of
embodied energy of
redundant
intermediaries
mass customization:
less pre-consumer waste,
greater potential for
re-manufacturing,
eco-guiding configurators
for consumers
bespoke fabrication:
localized production
and lower transport
emissions, less
product replacement
personal fabrication:
localized production,
higher environmental
impact per unit but
overall lower volumes
(than MP and MC)
ENVIRONMENTAL
BENEFITS
exploit user/consumer input
exploit
scale
exploit
modularization
exploit small
and local
ensure quality for
attachment, satisfaction
exploit learning
opportunities
SOURCE: Kohtala, C., 2014.Addressing sustainability in research on distributed production: an integrated literature review.
Journal of Cleaner Production. doi:10.1016/j.jclepro.2014.09.039
According to
existing
research
claims, these
are the
environmental
benefits.
mass fabrication:
distanced from
consumer recycling
systems and safety
standards, increased
transport of
components and
materials
mass customization:
customized products
add to mass production
material flow rather than
replace
bespoke fabrication:
high quality leads to
resource and energy
intensive production,
difficulty to reuse
bespoke products
personal fabrication:
greater personal
exposure to toxic
materials/emissions,
unregulated emissions
to environment
ENVIRONMENTAL
CONCERNS
regulations and standards
scale
global
local
quality drivers less regulation
SOURCE: Kohtala, C., 2014.Addressing sustainability in research on distributed production: an integrated literature review.
Journal of Cleaner Production. doi:10.1016/j.jclepro.2014.09.039
What those
previous
researchers
didnt mention
Fab Labs and Sustainability
In Fab Labs today,
BARRIERS
>invisibility of issues
>lack of eco-
champions
>time poverty
>situatedness
OPPORTUNITIES
>visions of societal
responsibility
>material
understanding and
time engagement
>openness and
willingness to share
>stepping stone to
new paradigm

More Related Content

Fab Labs and Sustainability

  • 1. FAB LABS AND SUSTAINABILITY #sustmake London, Machines Room, 26 Oct 2015 Cindy Kohtala Aalto University https://blogs.aalto.fi/makerculture/
  • 2. Fab labs have altered the landscape of innovation by providing the general public with an opportunity to appropriate the digital fabrication process: to make things personally. They enable rapid prototyping but are not suited to production on a larger scale (a limited number of identical pieces can be made if the hardware is not overused), nor are they suited to distribution, repair, or recycling. SOURCE: Eychenne, F. (2012). Fab Labs Overview.The Fing (Fondation internet nouvelle g辿n辿ration). Retrieved from http://www.slideshare.net/slidesharefing/fab-labs-overview
  • 3. the inverse of digital fabrication is digital recycling the construction of digital materials can contain the information needed for their deconstruction. Bad guys are already impressively effective at acquiring the best available technology for the destruction of their enemies; fab labs are likely to have a far greater impact on the stability of the planet by helping everyone else acquire the technology they need for their survival. SOURCE: Gershenfeld, N., 2005. FAB:The Coming Revolution onYour Desktop From Personal Computers to Personal Fabrication. Basic Books, NewYork.
  • 4. SOURCE: Kohtala, C., Hyysalo, S., 2015.Anticipated environmental sustainability of personal fabrication. Journal of Cleaner Production 99, 333344. Open access from http://authors.elsevier.com/a/1R0Rk3QCo9EPdT until 1 July 2015.
  • 5. SOURCE: Kohtala, C., 2014.Addressing sustainability in research on distributed production: an integrated literature review. Journal of Cleaner Production. doi:10.1016/j.jclepro.2014.09.039 bespoke fabrication: tailored, individualized products, design and fabrication in hands of producer mass fabrication: unique products, design and fabrication in hands of users in interaction with each other mass customization: batch/modular personalized products, design and fabrication in hands of producer personal fabrication: unique products, design and fabrication in hands of user, shared designs market influence non-market influence WHAT IS DISTRIBUTED PRODUCTION? control over user/consumer input scale large small digital manufacturing peer-to-peer production
  • 6. mass fabrication: transformed supply chains, elimination of embodied energy of redundant intermediaries mass customization: less pre-consumer waste, greater potential for re-manufacturing, eco-guiding configurators for consumers bespoke fabrication: localized production and lower transport emissions, less product replacement personal fabrication: localized production, higher environmental impact per unit but overall lower volumes (than MP and MC) ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS exploit user/consumer input exploit scale exploit modularization exploit small and local ensure quality for attachment, satisfaction exploit learning opportunities SOURCE: Kohtala, C., 2014.Addressing sustainability in research on distributed production: an integrated literature review. Journal of Cleaner Production. doi:10.1016/j.jclepro.2014.09.039 According to existing research claims, these are the environmental benefits.
  • 7. mass fabrication: distanced from consumer recycling systems and safety standards, increased transport of components and materials mass customization: customized products add to mass production material flow rather than replace bespoke fabrication: high quality leads to resource and energy intensive production, difficulty to reuse bespoke products personal fabrication: greater personal exposure to toxic materials/emissions, unregulated emissions to environment ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERNS regulations and standards scale global local quality drivers less regulation SOURCE: Kohtala, C., 2014.Addressing sustainability in research on distributed production: an integrated literature review. Journal of Cleaner Production. doi:10.1016/j.jclepro.2014.09.039 What those previous researchers didnt mention
  • 9. In Fab Labs today, BARRIERS >invisibility of issues >lack of eco- champions >time poverty >situatedness OPPORTUNITIES >visions of societal responsibility >material understanding and time engagement >openness and willingness to share >stepping stone to new paradigm