際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
The Nitty Gritty on Comparative Studies
Step 1:  Find some stuff
selection of artifacts
Spring 2005
Spring 2006
1728 & 1738
Step 2:  Make sure the stuff is comparable.
Textual relationship
油
油
油
Step 3:  Figure out what youre going to do with all that.
Articulate a method.
textual analysis
油
Wikipedias 5 Pillars
Fine.  But not enough.
sampled texts
How, oh how will I select articles?
Look for precedents
Emigh & Herring 2005
random article selection
Problem:  then is not now
油
Conics?  Catoptrics?  Nah.
Minerals Trigonometry Fortification Falconry Garden
Make it do-able.
Trigonometry:  2,500+ edits
First and last 100 edits
Step 4:  Execute.  Adjust.
油
How do I create a comparable comparison?
comparator
油
Convert files.
Easy access to  digital versions
Typical Problems:
18c British English  and OCR
PDF to .txt
Stupid problems:
1728 ed. = beautiful
1738 ed.=  bad archiving practices
4 foot wide pages
bad scans
missing sections
Solution:  hand-correcting
Solution:  talking to librarians
油
Eventually:  prevail.
Clean .txt files  of 18c texts
油
1400 edits total
Coded for  65 edit types
Chambers 1738
High edit incidence
Title 1728 length 1738 length Total Edits Typographic Changes Falconry 168 166 35 33 Fortification 2134 2039 419 365 Garden 970 970 205 200 Mineral 800 802 144 137 Trigonometry 1636 1607 365 352
Germanic capitalization Long s shift
1668
油
油
distributed agency
Terminal
油
stubs
Article Creation Date Creation Length Current Length Falconry 1/16/03 21 6,075 Fortification 3/31/03 32 3,486 Garden 2/27/02 1 1,393 Minerals 12/12/01 236 2,698 Trigonometry 9/8/01 157 (69) 2,240
Communal and participatory
Effected through form
Open ended

More Related Content

Comparative Studies