7. 束弌仂舒亰仄亠仆仂 亟于从舒仆仂亶
从仂仄仗亠仆舒亳亳損: 亰舒弍亠亢仆舒 仗舒从亳从舒
仂仆亳亳仂仆仆亶 亟 亳于 亟于舒亢亟 舒仄舒亳于舒仍 于仂仗仂 仂 于亰从舒仆亳亳
从仂仄仗亠仆舒亳亳 于 2- 从舒仆仂仄 亳仍亳 3- 从舒仆仂仄 舒亰仄亠亠 仗亳仄亠仆亳亠仍仆仂 从
舒于仂从亳仄 仗舒于舒仄 亳 仗舒于舒仄 仆舒 仂于舒仆亠 亰仆舒从亳. 仂弍仂亳 仍舒 亟
仗亳亰仆舒仍, 仂 仆仂仄 仆亠 仗仂亰于仂仍ム 亟舒仄 亳于舒 仗亳仆亳仗
仗舒于亠亟仍亳于仂亳, 仗仂仗仂亳仂仆舒仍仆仂亳, 仗舒于仂于仂亶 仂仗亠亟亠仍亠仆仆仂亳:
束To recognise that the provision was in conflict with Paragraph 1 of Article
109 of the Constitution of the Republic of Lithuania and with constitutional
principles of justice and a state under the rule of law - to the extent that it
provides for the only one criterionthe form of guiltfor such increase and
does not establish any other criteria which must be heeded by the court損.
Page 7
亠亠仄仂 仗亠亟亠仍仂于 亳从仍ム亳亠仍仆仂亞仂 仗舒于舒 仆舒 仂于舒仆亶 亰仆舒从
亟亠弍仆仂亶 仗舒从亳从仂亶 2011 亞仂亟舒
8. 束弌仂舒亰仄亠仆仂 亟于从舒仆仂亶
从仂仄仗亠仆舒亳亳損: 亰舒弍亠亢仆舒 仗舒从亳从舒
个亠亟亠舒仍仆亶 亟 舒舒 舒舒亠 (弌丿): 丕舒仆仂于仍亠仆仆亶
亰舒于亠仆仆亶 舒亰仄亠 从仂仄仗亠仆舒亳亳 亰舒 仆舒亠仆亳亠 舒于仂从亳 仗舒于
磦仍磳 亠亰仄亠仆仄 亳 仆亠从仂仆亳亳仂仆仆仄:
束Weighing all of these considerations, I conclude that the jurys award of
$675,000 in statutory damages for infringement of thirty copyrighted works is
unconstitutionally excessive損.
Page 8
亠亠仄仂 仗亠亟亠仍仂于 亳从仍ム亳亠仍仆仂亞仂 仗舒于舒 仆舒 仂于舒仆亶 亰仆舒从
亟亠弍仆仂亶 仗舒从亳从仂亶 2011 亞仂亟舒