際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Social media in
government
Craig Thomler
Managing Director
Delib Australia
18 March 2013
What is
social media?
Many definitions for social media
ProPR  Social media are online communications in which
individuals shift fluidly and flexibly between the role of audience and
author. To do this, they use social software that enables anyone
without knowledge of coding, to post, comment on, share or mash up
content and to form communities around shared interests
Fresh Networks  Social media is people having
conversations online. These conversations can
take a variety of forms; for example, blogs and
comments or photo sharing
Health is Social  Social Media is the
meeting place between people and
technology

About.com  Media is an instrument on
communication, like a newspaper or a radio,
so social media would be a social instrument
of communication

Optimize Your Web Presence  Social media are online venues,
such as social networking sites, blogs and wikis that enable people
to store and share information called content, such as text,
pictures, video and links
BlackBox Social Media  Social media is any online media platform
that provides content for users and also allows users to participate in
the creation or development of the content in some way

CubixDev - Social Media is the new term for socialising
online. It allows people to freely interact with each other
online where-ever they are and whenever they want

Michelle Digital  Social
media is life online

Webgeekly - Social Media is generally any
website or service that uses Web 2.0
techniques and concepts

Relationship Economy 
Social media is
communications

Get a Social Boost 
Digital word of mouth

Affilorama - Social media is content created and shared by individuals
on the web using freely available websites that allow users to create
and post their own images, video and text information and then share
that with either the entire internet or just a select group of friends
Wikipedia - Social media are media
for social interaction, using highly
accessible and scalable publishing
techniques

The Financial Brand  Social
media isnt about the media, its
about being social
Social media has in common









Facilitates user-generated content
Facilitated by social connections
Distribution is zero or low cost
Supports flowing discussions (low barriers to
participation)
Allows the community to do for themselves
Use open frameworks that support integration &
extension
Social media includes



Blogs (Over 50 government blogs at Govspace)
Groups and Forums (Whirlpool, Google Groups)
Wikis (Wikipedia, Wikispaces)
Social networking (Facebook, MySpace, LinkedIn, Google+)
Social bookmarking (Delicious)
Social news (Digg, Reddit)
Micro-blogs (Twitter, Yammer)
Community Q&A (Yahoo Answers)
Multimedia sharing (YouTube, 際際滷share, Scribd)
Ideas markets (Dialogue App, Ideascale, GetSuggestion)
Collaborative budgeting (Budget Simulator)
Product and service reviews (Epinions, Yelp)
Emerging tools (Group buying, Pinterest, Crowd funding)



Each has different uses
What social media is not


Just for teenagers and young adults






All low quality content






An independent study in 2005 by Nature Magazine found Wikipedia and
Encyclopedia Britannica had about the same rate of errors
Since then, reviews in 2007, 2008 & 2012 have found Wikipedia is at least as,
if not more, reliable than commercial encyclopedias in a range of topics.

Unproductive




50+ age group is the fastest growing on Facebook and Twitter
30% of Facebook users are aged 35-49
Average age of Twitter users is 31, of LinkedIn users 39 years old.

People who surf the Internet for fun at work - within a reasonable limit of
less than 20% of their total time in the office - are more productive by about
9% than those who dont.
Dr Brent Coker, Dept of Management & Marketing, University of Melbourne

Going away
What about
Australia?
Australias internet use
Total
Male
Female
14-39yrs
40-49yrs
50-64yrs
65+ yrs
NSW

98%
99%
97%
100%
99%
99%
93%
98%
Source: Sensis Social Media Report May 2012
Australias social media use
62%
Use social media
62%

38%
Never
38%
2011

2012
Source: Sensis Social Media Report May 2012
Australias social media use
30%

Everyday

36%
24%

Weekly
Less than weekly

19%
9%
6%
38%
38%

Never
2011

2012
Source: Sensis Social Media Report May 2012
Facebook in NSW
Based on residents aged 15+
2,620,620 (72%)
Sydney
1,020,701

3,599,380 (63%)
NSW
2,109,315
Use Facebook

Don't use Facebook
Source: Facebook March 2013 / ABS Census 2012
20130318 socialmediaingov-craigthomler-130319003343-phpapp02
What about
Australian
governments?
The social media majority
In mid-2012:

73%
of Australian Government agencies
reported using social media for
official purposes
What the Australian Government is
using social media for..
Answer choice

Response

Share

For stakeholder engagement or collaboration

32

54.24%

Operating an information campaign

25

42.37%

Responding to customer enquiries/comments/complaints

25

42.37%

For engaging with journalists and media outlets

24

40.68%

For engagement or collaboration with other government
agencies

24

40.68%

Monitoring citizen, stakeholder and/or lobbyist views and
activities

17

28.81%

For a public consultation process

16

27.12%

For a stakeholder or other restricted access consultation

13

22.03%

Other type of activity (i.e. recruitment, crowdsourcing, staff)

11

18.64%

For policy or services co-design

7

11.86%
NSW government has
At least:
 173 Twitter accounts

 75 Facebook pages
 50 YouTube accounts

 21 Flickr accounts
 9 Google+ accounts
Selecting the right
tools for the job
Rule 1: Dont start with the tools!
Start with - POST

People
Objectives

Strategy
Technology
What are you trying to achieve?
Inform
Consult

Involve
Collaborate

Empower
Source: IAP2.org
Online engagement spectrum
Announce Inform Consult Involve Collaborate Empower
Information dissemination tools




Document
sharing











Basic website









Online video













Podcasts













Presentations























Photo sharing

Key:

Optional



Recommended



Essential
Online engagement spectrum
Announce Inform Consult Involve Collaborate Empower
Information collection tools
Feedback
form















































Essential



Polls
Surveys
Events
planning
Feedback
form

Key:

Optional



Recommended
Online engagement spectrum
Announce Inform Consult Involve Collaborate Empower
Interaction tools
Blogs



Forum



















Document
editing/annot
ation









Wikis









Social
networks
Geospatial
location





































Mashups
Key:

Optional



Recommended



Essential
Online engagement spectrum
Announce Inform Consult Involve Collaborate Empower
Announcement tools
Email
newsletters













Micro-blogs













Newsfeeds

























Widgets

Key:

Optional



Recommended



Essential
Online engagement spectrum
Announce Inform Consult Involve Collaborate Empower
Engagement in 3rd party online properties
Blogs













Forums













Newsletters













Social
networks























Websites

Key:

Optional



Recommended



Essential
Building a
future-proof social
media structure
Dont build on feet of clay
Online infrastructure
Engagement/
project practice

Guidance and
training
Strategy and framework
Social media policy
Agency instructions and policies
Government policies and guidelines
Legislation and international agreements
Online infrastructure
Branch/
Team
Engagement/
project practice

Whole
of
agency

Guidance and
training
Strategy and framework
Social media policy
Agency instructions and policies

Whole of
Governmen
t

Government policies and guidelines
Legislation and international agreements
Support systems
Engagement hub
Blogs
Groups

Polls

Monitoring suite

Forum

Web reporting

Idea market

Archiving

Social media monitoring

Your website
Outreach activities
Blogs

Forums

Enabling services
Social media publishing

Groups

URL shortener
File transfer

Social media presence
Facebook
LinkedIn

Twitter
Yammer

YouTube

Groups

Foursquare

Forums

Survey
Email
Email

Storage (image, video, docs)

Mapping

Apps
Managing risks

Weve considered every potential risk
except the risks of avoiding all risks.
Social media risk

Whats the risk to your
organisation of
NOT engaging
via social
media?
Social media risk
The biggest risk for agencies assessing social
media risks is when the people assessing the
risks dont understand
and/or use the social
mediums involved.
Awareness threshold or risk level?
Avoid confusing awareness with risk.
Becoming aware of something doesnt necessarily
mean the level of risk associated with it has increased.

Aware

Unaware
Top areas of social media risk
 Conversational  what people say
 Reputational  how agency is seen

 Privacy/security  what information exposed
 Administrative  How policies are followed

 Technological  how systems operate
Risks should be owned by the business owner
with advice and support with Communication,
Legal & IT groups  depending on approach.
Recommend: http://www.egov.vic.gov.au/pdfs/vmia-risk-insight-12-11-2010.pdf
Risk varies by audience, goals and
content
Theres no standard risk level  plus levels vary
as an online channel matures
Risk area

Likelihood

Consequence

Conversational

High - very high

Low - very high

Reputational

Low  very high

Low - very high

Privacy/Security

Low  very high

Low - very high

Administrative

Low  high

Low  very high

Technological

Low  very high

Low  very high
For example.an online community
Size/engagement

Technological

Conversational
Security

Technological

Reputational

Privacy

Conversational
Administrative

Technological

Reputational

Time
So how to mitigate?
 Assess versus comparable existing social media
channels
 Have risk assessments done by people who
understand the social mediums AND organisational
context
 Review risk plan regularly over time and when
environment/context changes
 Develop agency and project social media guidance
documents and review them regularly as well!
 Test your risk mitigation strategies
Key documents to develop
Social media strategy  how your organisation will
use social media to help it meet its goals (including
risk mitigation)
Social media guidelines/policy  how your staff are
expected to engage officially via social media and
advice for personal use to help staff avoid issues
Escalation plan  How you will escalate incidents,
including decision trees
Moderation policy  how you will moderate user
comments via appropriate social media
Intels social media guidelines:

Source: http://www.intel.com.au/content/www/us/en/legal/intel-social-media-guidelines.html
YMCA Chicago escalation plan

Source: http://www.flickr.com/photos/43118383@N00/4668895145/sizes/l/in/photostream/
Areas to pay attention to


Negative comments & misinformation
(workflow, context, moderate, engage)



Inappropriate comments
(set context, limit rich content, moderate, block & report)



Overwhelming level of responses
(employ management tools, resourcing, broaden responses)



Hacking & spamming
(integrate spam control, complex passwords, moderate)



Privacy (users AND staff)
(Strong policies and clear guidelines to users, test tools first)



Inappropriate use by staff
(social media guidance and training)
Prepare your social media channels
before you need them
Such as:


Twitter (for real-time news distribution)



Blog hosted externally (for long-form updates)



Facebook page (for community building)



Flickr group (for photo capture)



Ushahidi instance (for geomapped incident reports)



Youtube (for video footage and reports)



Provide context and user guidance for all, set right
settings per channel (ie: no commenting on YouTube)
Use appropriate social media
management tools
Such as:






Hootsuite/Measured Voice
(for social channel management, approvals
and auditing)
Backupify
(for archival/storage)
A social media monitoring service
(for tracking externally reported
incidents/issues/sentiment)
Best practice
examples
Inform

http://www.police.act.gov.au/crime-and-safety/crime-statistics.aspx
Inform

https://www.facebook.com/theline
Consult

http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/spend_spendingchallenge.htm
Involve

http://www.challenge.gov
Collaborate

http://transcribe.naa.gov.au/
Empower

http://stjornlagarad.is/english/
100% correct information
delivered too late or in the
wrong context is worthless
(and causes more issues!)
Craig Thomler
craig@delib.net
@CraigThomler
http://eGovAU.blogspot.com
www.delib.net/australia/
@Delibaunz

More Related Content

20130318 socialmediaingov-craigthomler-130319003343-phpapp02

  • 1. Social media in government Craig Thomler Managing Director Delib Australia 18 March 2013
  • 3. Many definitions for social media ProPR Social media are online communications in which individuals shift fluidly and flexibly between the role of audience and author. To do this, they use social software that enables anyone without knowledge of coding, to post, comment on, share or mash up content and to form communities around shared interests Fresh Networks Social media is people having conversations online. These conversations can take a variety of forms; for example, blogs and comments or photo sharing Health is Social Social Media is the meeting place between people and technology About.com Media is an instrument on communication, like a newspaper or a radio, so social media would be a social instrument of communication Optimize Your Web Presence Social media are online venues, such as social networking sites, blogs and wikis that enable people to store and share information called content, such as text, pictures, video and links BlackBox Social Media Social media is any online media platform that provides content for users and also allows users to participate in the creation or development of the content in some way CubixDev - Social Media is the new term for socialising online. It allows people to freely interact with each other online where-ever they are and whenever they want Michelle Digital Social media is life online Webgeekly - Social Media is generally any website or service that uses Web 2.0 techniques and concepts Relationship Economy Social media is communications Get a Social Boost Digital word of mouth Affilorama - Social media is content created and shared by individuals on the web using freely available websites that allow users to create and post their own images, video and text information and then share that with either the entire internet or just a select group of friends Wikipedia - Social media are media for social interaction, using highly accessible and scalable publishing techniques The Financial Brand Social media isnt about the media, its about being social
  • 4. Social media has in common Facilitates user-generated content Facilitated by social connections Distribution is zero or low cost Supports flowing discussions (low barriers to participation) Allows the community to do for themselves Use open frameworks that support integration & extension
  • 5. Social media includes Blogs (Over 50 government blogs at Govspace) Groups and Forums (Whirlpool, Google Groups) Wikis (Wikipedia, Wikispaces) Social networking (Facebook, MySpace, LinkedIn, Google+) Social bookmarking (Delicious) Social news (Digg, Reddit) Micro-blogs (Twitter, Yammer) Community Q&A (Yahoo Answers) Multimedia sharing (YouTube, 際際滷share, Scribd) Ideas markets (Dialogue App, Ideascale, GetSuggestion) Collaborative budgeting (Budget Simulator) Product and service reviews (Epinions, Yelp) Emerging tools (Group buying, Pinterest, Crowd funding) Each has different uses
  • 6. What social media is not Just for teenagers and young adults All low quality content An independent study in 2005 by Nature Magazine found Wikipedia and Encyclopedia Britannica had about the same rate of errors Since then, reviews in 2007, 2008 & 2012 have found Wikipedia is at least as, if not more, reliable than commercial encyclopedias in a range of topics. Unproductive 50+ age group is the fastest growing on Facebook and Twitter 30% of Facebook users are aged 35-49 Average age of Twitter users is 31, of LinkedIn users 39 years old. People who surf the Internet for fun at work - within a reasonable limit of less than 20% of their total time in the office - are more productive by about 9% than those who dont. Dr Brent Coker, Dept of Management & Marketing, University of Melbourne Going away
  • 8. Australias internet use Total Male Female 14-39yrs 40-49yrs 50-64yrs 65+ yrs NSW 98% 99% 97% 100% 99% 99% 93% 98% Source: Sensis Social Media Report May 2012
  • 9. Australias social media use 62% Use social media 62% 38% Never 38% 2011 2012 Source: Sensis Social Media Report May 2012
  • 10. Australias social media use 30% Everyday 36% 24% Weekly Less than weekly 19% 9% 6% 38% 38% Never 2011 2012 Source: Sensis Social Media Report May 2012
  • 11. Facebook in NSW Based on residents aged 15+ 2,620,620 (72%) Sydney 1,020,701 3,599,380 (63%) NSW 2,109,315 Use Facebook Don't use Facebook Source: Facebook March 2013 / ABS Census 2012
  • 14. The social media majority In mid-2012: 73% of Australian Government agencies reported using social media for official purposes
  • 15. What the Australian Government is using social media for.. Answer choice Response Share For stakeholder engagement or collaboration 32 54.24% Operating an information campaign 25 42.37% Responding to customer enquiries/comments/complaints 25 42.37% For engaging with journalists and media outlets 24 40.68% For engagement or collaboration with other government agencies 24 40.68% Monitoring citizen, stakeholder and/or lobbyist views and activities 17 28.81% For a public consultation process 16 27.12% For a stakeholder or other restricted access consultation 13 22.03% Other type of activity (i.e. recruitment, crowdsourcing, staff) 11 18.64% For policy or services co-design 7 11.86%
  • 16. NSW government has At least: 173 Twitter accounts 75 Facebook pages 50 YouTube accounts 21 Flickr accounts 9 Google+ accounts
  • 18. Rule 1: Dont start with the tools!
  • 19. Start with - POST People Objectives Strategy Technology
  • 20. What are you trying to achieve? Inform Consult Involve Collaborate Empower Source: IAP2.org
  • 21. Online engagement spectrum Announce Inform Consult Involve Collaborate Empower Information dissemination tools Document sharing Basic website Online video Podcasts Presentations Photo sharing Key: Optional Recommended Essential
  • 22. Online engagement spectrum Announce Inform Consult Involve Collaborate Empower Information collection tools Feedback form Essential Polls Surveys Events planning Feedback form Key: Optional Recommended
  • 23. Online engagement spectrum Announce Inform Consult Involve Collaborate Empower Interaction tools Blogs Forum Document editing/annot ation Wikis Social networks Geospatial location Mashups Key: Optional Recommended Essential
  • 24. Online engagement spectrum Announce Inform Consult Involve Collaborate Empower Announcement tools Email newsletters Micro-blogs Newsfeeds Widgets Key: Optional Recommended Essential
  • 25. Online engagement spectrum Announce Inform Consult Involve Collaborate Empower Engagement in 3rd party online properties Blogs Forums Newsletters Social networks Websites Key: Optional Recommended Essential
  • 27. Dont build on feet of clay
  • 28. Online infrastructure Engagement/ project practice Guidance and training Strategy and framework Social media policy Agency instructions and policies Government policies and guidelines Legislation and international agreements
  • 29. Online infrastructure Branch/ Team Engagement/ project practice Whole of agency Guidance and training Strategy and framework Social media policy Agency instructions and policies Whole of Governmen t Government policies and guidelines Legislation and international agreements
  • 30. Support systems Engagement hub Blogs Groups Polls Monitoring suite Forum Web reporting Idea market Archiving Social media monitoring Your website Outreach activities Blogs Forums Enabling services Social media publishing Groups URL shortener File transfer Social media presence Facebook LinkedIn Twitter Yammer YouTube Groups Foursquare Forums Survey Email Email Storage (image, video, docs) Mapping Apps
  • 31. Managing risks Weve considered every potential risk except the risks of avoiding all risks.
  • 32. Social media risk Whats the risk to your organisation of NOT engaging via social media?
  • 33. Social media risk The biggest risk for agencies assessing social media risks is when the people assessing the risks dont understand and/or use the social mediums involved.
  • 34. Awareness threshold or risk level? Avoid confusing awareness with risk. Becoming aware of something doesnt necessarily mean the level of risk associated with it has increased. Aware Unaware
  • 35. Top areas of social media risk Conversational what people say Reputational how agency is seen Privacy/security what information exposed Administrative How policies are followed Technological how systems operate Risks should be owned by the business owner with advice and support with Communication, Legal & IT groups depending on approach. Recommend: http://www.egov.vic.gov.au/pdfs/vmia-risk-insight-12-11-2010.pdf
  • 36. Risk varies by audience, goals and content Theres no standard risk level plus levels vary as an online channel matures Risk area Likelihood Consequence Conversational High - very high Low - very high Reputational Low very high Low - very high Privacy/Security Low very high Low - very high Administrative Low high Low very high Technological Low very high Low very high
  • 37. For example.an online community Size/engagement Technological Conversational Security Technological Reputational Privacy Conversational Administrative Technological Reputational Time
  • 38. So how to mitigate? Assess versus comparable existing social media channels Have risk assessments done by people who understand the social mediums AND organisational context Review risk plan regularly over time and when environment/context changes Develop agency and project social media guidance documents and review them regularly as well! Test your risk mitigation strategies
  • 39. Key documents to develop Social media strategy how your organisation will use social media to help it meet its goals (including risk mitigation) Social media guidelines/policy how your staff are expected to engage officially via social media and advice for personal use to help staff avoid issues Escalation plan How you will escalate incidents, including decision trees Moderation policy how you will moderate user comments via appropriate social media
  • 40. Intels social media guidelines: Source: http://www.intel.com.au/content/www/us/en/legal/intel-social-media-guidelines.html
  • 41. YMCA Chicago escalation plan Source: http://www.flickr.com/photos/43118383@N00/4668895145/sizes/l/in/photostream/
  • 42. Areas to pay attention to Negative comments & misinformation (workflow, context, moderate, engage) Inappropriate comments (set context, limit rich content, moderate, block & report) Overwhelming level of responses (employ management tools, resourcing, broaden responses) Hacking & spamming (integrate spam control, complex passwords, moderate) Privacy (users AND staff) (Strong policies and clear guidelines to users, test tools first) Inappropriate use by staff (social media guidance and training)
  • 43. Prepare your social media channels before you need them Such as: Twitter (for real-time news distribution) Blog hosted externally (for long-form updates) Facebook page (for community building) Flickr group (for photo capture) Ushahidi instance (for geomapped incident reports) Youtube (for video footage and reports) Provide context and user guidance for all, set right settings per channel (ie: no commenting on YouTube)
  • 44. Use appropriate social media management tools Such as: Hootsuite/Measured Voice (for social channel management, approvals and auditing) Backupify (for archival/storage) A social media monitoring service (for tracking externally reported incidents/issues/sentiment)
  • 52. 100% correct information delivered too late or in the wrong context is worthless (and causes more issues!)