際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Giving back to the African People Fostering rural community development through mineral development funds Shishir A. Shahnawaz Institute for Development Policy and Management University of Manchester, UK 3 rd  International Conference on   Sustainable Development Indicators in the Minerals Industry (SDIMI) 17-20 June 2007, Milos island, Greece.
Introduction Why are Africas mineral rich countries performing so poorly economically? Poor economic performance of many mineral rich developing countries is more a result of corruption and host govt.s mismanagement of royalty payments  Resource curse v/s. welfare of mining communities
However Prudent management of mineral development funds =>  social development
Basic economic interpretation of mineral development funds Stabilization mechanism Reduced impact of commodity prices Improves budget predictability by stabilizing investment patterns Savings mechanism Share of wealth for future generations
Examples of funds off natural resources revenue Venezuelas Stabilization Investment Fund Norways State Petroleum Fund Irans Foreign Currency Reserve Account Omans General Reserve Fund Other trailblazers: Chad, Ghana, Nigeria, Chile, Kuwait, Tanzania etc.
Two questions Why and how are these funds so popular in many developing countries? How are such popular funds devised in order to foster community development?  While the aims seem to be ideal  their utilization has since provoked criticism   examples :  - Kuwaits Reserve Fund - Revenue in Chad-Cameroon  pipeline project - Sierra Leone, Gabon, Ivory Coast,  Angola  . the conflict zones
油
Ghanas Mineral Development Fund (MDF) MDF is funded with 20% of royalties paid by mining companies to redress some of the harmful effects of mining activities; to undertake development projects in mining communities; and to support the budgets of mining sector institutions and carry out special mineral projects Background of establishment of MDF to see mining as a catalyst for its own growth; to set up a Mineral Development Bank (funded through royalties); to establish financing schemes to support small-scale mining; and to support non-mining economic activities in mining communities.
Distribution of MDF to beneficiaries
Stakeholders Govt. take :  corporate income tax, dividend tax and royalties Local take :  percentage of royalties contributing MDF
Economic environment of MDF Mining in Ghana contributes    33% of total exports    11% of Govt. revenue    5% of GDP    7% of corporate tax earning    Mining employs 50% of the labour force in Ghana
MDF: An Analysis Mining law enacted in 1986 Article 22 Effectiveness?  Bill passed in 2006 in the Ghanaian parliament to better manage MDF  Recommendations
Weaknesses in mineral development funds management  Who pays what to whom Contribution of funds to development? Appropriate reporting and accounting of monies paid to beneficiaries? Absence of legal backing Unplanned and sometimes illicit use of funds Passive involvement of mining companies in the management of funds Linkage with creation of alternative livelihoods
In short The main political consequences of relying solely on external rents  Countries relying on mineral exports: implications The empirical evidence till date?
Looking ahead Mineral funds be covered by a legislative act Board of Trustees to be incorporated to monitor Additional act to be incorporated.  Separation of executive from judiciary! Mining companies should put all-out effort to adhere to and comply with the rules and regulations implemented Mining communities need to be engaged in dialogues concerning their  effective  welfare Civil society may be empowered to have a say in  who-pays-what-to-whom  Mining, MDF and .. an Alternative Livelihood Model ?
Thank you & Questions [email_address]
Ad

Recommended

Global Investments in Mining: Trends and Lessons
Global Investments in Mining: Trends and Lessons
World Bank Publications
Management of Mineral Resources in the DR Congo
Management of Mineral Resources in the DR Congo
RCS Global
Financial management in watsan sector
Financial management in watsan sector
Kanika Saxena
Development finance in the post 2015 context
Development finance in the post 2015 context
European Centre for Development Policy Management (ECDPM)
Remittances: Lessons Learned and Private Sector Opportunities
Remittances: Lessons Learned and Private Sector Opportunities
Robert
African Mining Vision
African Mining Vision
African Minerals Development Centre
Introduction to the 6th Brussels Development Briefing
Introduction to the 6th Brussels Development Briefing
Euforic Services
DOMESTIC RESOURCE MOBILIZATION FOR ZIMASSET
DOMESTIC RESOURCE MOBILIZATION FOR ZIMASSET
Innocent Bayai
SGP Stroke
SGP Stroke
norach10
Delfin
V28INFINITO
Iris In The Wonderland
Iris In The Wonderland
Alice Wu
Congress Ppt
Congress Ppt
Jon-Leslie Williams
Istrazivanje racunari i internet rezultati - 29.5.2016
Istrazivanje racunari i internet rezultati - 29.5.2016
Sne転ana Markovi
Epismen4pi
Epismen4pi
Sne転ana Markovi
Matera 2019 | Case history
Matera 2019 | Case history
Gianluca Punzi
Obras de arte .h bandres
V28INFINITO
Objasnjene predloga redefinisane nastave informatike i nu転nih korekcija tehni...
Objasnjene predloga redefinisane nastave informatike i nu転nih korekcija tehni...
Sne転ana Markovi
Istrazivanje uspesnost na zadacima
Istrazivanje uspesnost na zadacima
Sne転ana Markovi
Istrazivanje upitnik i test 26.4.2016
Istrazivanje upitnik i test 26.4.2016
Sne転ana Markovi
The stakes for Africa in Mineral Resources Development
The stakes for Africa in Mineral Resources Development
daniel edwin
EIRT paper
EIRT paper
Stephen Macey
lecture_2[1].pptx financial valuation onmining
lecture_2[1].pptx financial valuation onmining
Mekonen15
Evaluation of government equity participation in the minerals sector of Tanza...
Evaluation of government equity participation in the minerals sector of Tanza...
James AH Campbell
AN ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENT FRAMEWORK FOR AFRICAS EXTRACTIVE SECTOR: A PERSPEC...
AN ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENT FRAMEWORK FOR AFRICAS EXTRACTIVE SECTOR: A PERSPEC...
KROTOASA FOUNDATION
Mining, Domestic revenue mobilisation, Women.
Mining, Domestic revenue mobilisation, Women.
Lyla Latif
Great Opportunities for Natural Resources Investing in Africa - A Fund's Pers...
Great Opportunities for Natural Resources Investing in Africa - A Fund's Pers...
Objective Capital Conferences
Developing a Tenable Fiscal Framework for Artisanal Small Scale Miners (ASMs)...
Developing a Tenable Fiscal Framework for Artisanal Small Scale Miners (ASMs)...
Quincy Jibril
Efficacy of diamond beneficiation on fiscal mobilisation
Efficacy of diamond beneficiation on fiscal mobilisation
Clement Nzenzema
DfID, extractives and development, focus on africa
DfID, extractives and development, focus on africa
daniel edwin

More Related Content

Viewers also liked (12)

SGP Stroke
SGP Stroke
norach10
Delfin
V28INFINITO
Iris In The Wonderland
Iris In The Wonderland
Alice Wu
Congress Ppt
Congress Ppt
Jon-Leslie Williams
Istrazivanje racunari i internet rezultati - 29.5.2016
Istrazivanje racunari i internet rezultati - 29.5.2016
Sne転ana Markovi
Epismen4pi
Epismen4pi
Sne転ana Markovi
Matera 2019 | Case history
Matera 2019 | Case history
Gianluca Punzi
Obras de arte .h bandres
V28INFINITO
Objasnjene predloga redefinisane nastave informatike i nu転nih korekcija tehni...
Objasnjene predloga redefinisane nastave informatike i nu転nih korekcija tehni...
Sne転ana Markovi
Istrazivanje uspesnost na zadacima
Istrazivanje uspesnost na zadacima
Sne転ana Markovi
Istrazivanje upitnik i test 26.4.2016
Istrazivanje upitnik i test 26.4.2016
Sne転ana Markovi
SGP Stroke
SGP Stroke
norach10
Delfin
V28INFINITO
Iris In The Wonderland
Iris In The Wonderland
Alice Wu
Istrazivanje racunari i internet rezultati - 29.5.2016
Istrazivanje racunari i internet rezultati - 29.5.2016
Sne転ana Markovi
Matera 2019 | Case history
Matera 2019 | Case history
Gianluca Punzi
Obras de arte .h bandres
V28INFINITO
Objasnjene predloga redefinisane nastave informatike i nu転nih korekcija tehni...
Objasnjene predloga redefinisane nastave informatike i nu転nih korekcija tehni...
Sne転ana Markovi
Istrazivanje uspesnost na zadacima
Istrazivanje uspesnost na zadacima
Sne転ana Markovi
Istrazivanje upitnik i test 26.4.2016
Istrazivanje upitnik i test 26.4.2016
Sne転ana Markovi

Similar to 3rd SDIMI Presentation (20)

The stakes for Africa in Mineral Resources Development
The stakes for Africa in Mineral Resources Development
daniel edwin
EIRT paper
EIRT paper
Stephen Macey
lecture_2[1].pptx financial valuation onmining
lecture_2[1].pptx financial valuation onmining
Mekonen15
Evaluation of government equity participation in the minerals sector of Tanza...
Evaluation of government equity participation in the minerals sector of Tanza...
James AH Campbell
AN ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENT FRAMEWORK FOR AFRICAS EXTRACTIVE SECTOR: A PERSPEC...
AN ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENT FRAMEWORK FOR AFRICAS EXTRACTIVE SECTOR: A PERSPEC...
KROTOASA FOUNDATION
Mining, Domestic revenue mobilisation, Women.
Mining, Domestic revenue mobilisation, Women.
Lyla Latif
Great Opportunities for Natural Resources Investing in Africa - A Fund's Pers...
Great Opportunities for Natural Resources Investing in Africa - A Fund's Pers...
Objective Capital Conferences
Developing a Tenable Fiscal Framework for Artisanal Small Scale Miners (ASMs)...
Developing a Tenable Fiscal Framework for Artisanal Small Scale Miners (ASMs)...
Quincy Jibril
Efficacy of diamond beneficiation on fiscal mobilisation
Efficacy of diamond beneficiation on fiscal mobilisation
Clement Nzenzema
DfID, extractives and development, focus on africa
DfID, extractives and development, focus on africa
daniel edwin
Myths and Mining: The reality of Resource Governance in Africa
Myths and Mining: The reality of Resource Governance in Africa
KROTOASA FOUNDATION
Extracting A Fair Share Kato Lambrechts Missing Millions
Extracting A Fair Share Kato Lambrechts Missing Millions
Scotland Malawi Partnership
Minerals and Africa's Development
Minerals and Africa's Development
KROTOASA FOUNDATION
International Journal of Business and Social Science Vol. 2
International Journal of Business and Social Science Vol. 2
nurul fadhilla yuzia putri
International Journal of Business and Social Science Vol. 2
International Journal of Business and Social Science Vol. 2
nurul fadhilla yuzia putri
why Ethiopia cannot extract mineral and cannot usels
why Ethiopia cannot extract mineral and cannot usels
juke1
The-social-and-economic-impacts-of-gold-mining
The-social-and-economic-impacts-of-gold-mining
Andrew Britton
the-social-and-economic-impacts-of-gold-mining
the-social-and-economic-impacts-of-gold-mining
Ross Lakhdari
The growing role of dfi
The growing role of dfi
minda_brillantes
Is gbulletin1
Is gbulletin1
KROTOASA FOUNDATION
The stakes for Africa in Mineral Resources Development
The stakes for Africa in Mineral Resources Development
daniel edwin
lecture_2[1].pptx financial valuation onmining
lecture_2[1].pptx financial valuation onmining
Mekonen15
Evaluation of government equity participation in the minerals sector of Tanza...
Evaluation of government equity participation in the minerals sector of Tanza...
James AH Campbell
AN ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENT FRAMEWORK FOR AFRICAS EXTRACTIVE SECTOR: A PERSPEC...
AN ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENT FRAMEWORK FOR AFRICAS EXTRACTIVE SECTOR: A PERSPEC...
KROTOASA FOUNDATION
Mining, Domestic revenue mobilisation, Women.
Mining, Domestic revenue mobilisation, Women.
Lyla Latif
Great Opportunities for Natural Resources Investing in Africa - A Fund's Pers...
Great Opportunities for Natural Resources Investing in Africa - A Fund's Pers...
Objective Capital Conferences
Developing a Tenable Fiscal Framework for Artisanal Small Scale Miners (ASMs)...
Developing a Tenable Fiscal Framework for Artisanal Small Scale Miners (ASMs)...
Quincy Jibril
Efficacy of diamond beneficiation on fiscal mobilisation
Efficacy of diamond beneficiation on fiscal mobilisation
Clement Nzenzema
DfID, extractives and development, focus on africa
DfID, extractives and development, focus on africa
daniel edwin
Myths and Mining: The reality of Resource Governance in Africa
Myths and Mining: The reality of Resource Governance in Africa
KROTOASA FOUNDATION
Extracting A Fair Share Kato Lambrechts Missing Millions
Extracting A Fair Share Kato Lambrechts Missing Millions
Scotland Malawi Partnership
Minerals and Africa's Development
Minerals and Africa's Development
KROTOASA FOUNDATION
International Journal of Business and Social Science Vol. 2
International Journal of Business and Social Science Vol. 2
nurul fadhilla yuzia putri
International Journal of Business and Social Science Vol. 2
International Journal of Business and Social Science Vol. 2
nurul fadhilla yuzia putri
why Ethiopia cannot extract mineral and cannot usels
why Ethiopia cannot extract mineral and cannot usels
juke1
The-social-and-economic-impacts-of-gold-mining
The-social-and-economic-impacts-of-gold-mining
Andrew Britton
the-social-and-economic-impacts-of-gold-mining
the-social-and-economic-impacts-of-gold-mining
Ross Lakhdari
The growing role of dfi
The growing role of dfi
minda_brillantes
Ad

3rd SDIMI Presentation

  • 1. Giving back to the African People Fostering rural community development through mineral development funds Shishir A. Shahnawaz Institute for Development Policy and Management University of Manchester, UK 3 rd International Conference on Sustainable Development Indicators in the Minerals Industry (SDIMI) 17-20 June 2007, Milos island, Greece.
  • 2. Introduction Why are Africas mineral rich countries performing so poorly economically? Poor economic performance of many mineral rich developing countries is more a result of corruption and host govt.s mismanagement of royalty payments Resource curse v/s. welfare of mining communities
  • 3. However Prudent management of mineral development funds => social development
  • 4. Basic economic interpretation of mineral development funds Stabilization mechanism Reduced impact of commodity prices Improves budget predictability by stabilizing investment patterns Savings mechanism Share of wealth for future generations
  • 5. Examples of funds off natural resources revenue Venezuelas Stabilization Investment Fund Norways State Petroleum Fund Irans Foreign Currency Reserve Account Omans General Reserve Fund Other trailblazers: Chad, Ghana, Nigeria, Chile, Kuwait, Tanzania etc.
  • 6. Two questions Why and how are these funds so popular in many developing countries? How are such popular funds devised in order to foster community development? While the aims seem to be ideal their utilization has since provoked criticism examples : - Kuwaits Reserve Fund - Revenue in Chad-Cameroon pipeline project - Sierra Leone, Gabon, Ivory Coast, Angola . the conflict zones
  • 7.
  • 8. Ghanas Mineral Development Fund (MDF) MDF is funded with 20% of royalties paid by mining companies to redress some of the harmful effects of mining activities; to undertake development projects in mining communities; and to support the budgets of mining sector institutions and carry out special mineral projects Background of establishment of MDF to see mining as a catalyst for its own growth; to set up a Mineral Development Bank (funded through royalties); to establish financing schemes to support small-scale mining; and to support non-mining economic activities in mining communities.
  • 9. Distribution of MDF to beneficiaries
  • 10. Stakeholders Govt. take : corporate income tax, dividend tax and royalties Local take : percentage of royalties contributing MDF
  • 11. Economic environment of MDF Mining in Ghana contributes 33% of total exports 11% of Govt. revenue 5% of GDP 7% of corporate tax earning Mining employs 50% of the labour force in Ghana
  • 12. MDF: An Analysis Mining law enacted in 1986 Article 22 Effectiveness? Bill passed in 2006 in the Ghanaian parliament to better manage MDF Recommendations
  • 13. Weaknesses in mineral development funds management Who pays what to whom Contribution of funds to development? Appropriate reporting and accounting of monies paid to beneficiaries? Absence of legal backing Unplanned and sometimes illicit use of funds Passive involvement of mining companies in the management of funds Linkage with creation of alternative livelihoods
  • 14. In short The main political consequences of relying solely on external rents Countries relying on mineral exports: implications The empirical evidence till date?
  • 15. Looking ahead Mineral funds be covered by a legislative act Board of Trustees to be incorporated to monitor Additional act to be incorporated. Separation of executive from judiciary! Mining companies should put all-out effort to adhere to and comply with the rules and regulations implemented Mining communities need to be engaged in dialogues concerning their effective welfare Civil society may be empowered to have a say in who-pays-what-to-whom Mining, MDF and .. an Alternative Livelihood Model ?
  • 16. Thank you & Questions [email_address]