1) Many businesses do not properly evaluate their insurance needs and options, often relying too heavily on brokers who may not have the businesses' best interests in mind.
2) Key mistakes include not performing risk assessments, not thoroughly reviewing policy details and exclusions, and not focusing enough on safety programs to reduce long-term costs.
3) CFOs should take a more active role in their risk management and insurance procurement to avoid overpaying or having coverage gaps by seeking multiple competitive quotes and ensuring brokers are representing the business's interests alone.
1 of 3
Download to read offline
More Related Content
5 5 mistakes
1. 5.5 Most Expensive Mistakes
CFO’s, CEO’s, COO’s, Business Owners, and Board Members Face
When Reviewing Insurance Options
by: Scott Wolff, Premier Risk Management, LLC
James King, Premier Risk Management, LLC
and agents are the sales force of the insurance
Insurance is something you deal with companies.
every year and for the typical Most state regulatory employees are plucked from
consumer the world of insurance can within the insurance industry and once that job is
be filled with confusion, aggravation over they typically go back to the sell side of
insurance thus it is a very closed industry group.
and even heartache. CFO’s we speak
with are frustrated with their insurance. There are no real consumer perspectives to
balance out the many industry voices pushing for
They don’t have time to thoroughly the industry policies.
evaluate what they are getting… they
The only real advocate a corporation has is one
don’t fully understand the coverage that is Independent and represents only their
especially the exclusions and how they interest.
may affect a loss… they are not even "An error doesn't become a mistake until you
certain that they are getting the “best” refuse to correct it." – Orlando Battista
deal.
The Mistakes of Going at It Alone
The Statistics
The US Department of Labor estimates that forty 1. Not Performing a Risk Assessment – The
percent (40%) of businesses never reopen after biggest assumption CFO’s make is that the
experiencing a disaster. Twenty five percent current insurance program is set up properly.
(25%) of surviving businesses will lose their The real problem is that an assessment has
market and shut down within two (2) years of a not been performed to evaluate what are the
misfortune. true risks and exposures of the company
business operations. Often they focus on the
According to a report of nearly 400 CFO’s and premium not the coverage. Without knowing
Treasurer’s of some of the world’s major what the true risk and exposures are you can’t
corporations by leading institutions found that 85 intelligently purchase the property insurance.
percent of the respondents indicated that they Thus, the insurance program is flawed from
view risk management as an investment. the start. Sorry to say, but this error is
discovered when an underinsured or
Outnumbered and Outspent uncovered loss occurs. In the haste to sell
When it comes to understanding the insurance products coverage issues and exclusionary
industry consumers have few options and language contained in policies are often
resources available to them when looking for missed by brokers.
assistance or guidance, meanwhile insurance
companies have an army of resources. Brokers
PREMIER RISK MANAGEMENT, LLC
110 Warren Ave, Suite 3, Ho-Ho-Kus, NJ 07423 * 201.573.1100 ph * www.premierriskmgt.com
2. Beyond the insurance product often More time and devotion should be focused on
overlooked is the risk transfer mechanism a sound pro-active safety and loss control
during contract review. Many organizations program for the long term cost savings to be
rely on their lawyers to advise in this area … realized. Safety and loss control programs
the problem is lawyers tend to use boilerplate should be instituted with the big picture in
language or do not fully appreciate the mind which is geared toward the protection of
insurance language as it relates to the company assets and human capital.
operations and associated liabilities.
4. Competitively Market the Insurance
The CFO acting as the risk manager and not Program in a Professional Fashion. CFO’s
being an expert in insurance can miss these explain to us that their brokers solicit quotes
finer points as well. from multiple insurance carriers, they market
the insurance program by bringing in a few
2. Not Reviewing Insurance Coverage in brokers, or they are just simply happy with
Detail – insurance policies are contracts. their broker.
Insurance companies and their claims
adjusters know the significance of every word We know that not all brokers can deliver the
in the contract and it is important for you to same price and product thus to get the best
know how the policy will respond to a claim. results from a marketing effort it must be
You have an expectation that a loss is managed and controlled properly. Remember
covered. Unfortunately, exclusions are not that a Brokerage is a business just like you …
discovered until a loss occurred. motivated by profits.
Coverage gaps, underinsured and even over- In the property and casualty world only one
insured issues exist … the policies were not broker can work with a particular insurance
reviewed properly or with an eye toward company... all brokers do not represent the
recovery. CFO’s need to validate their same carriers or even all of the carriers…
insurance; if the policy is not written correctly some brokers say they can deal with all the
from the start then you are just wasting money carriers… but in reality they do not.
… it will not respond the way you assumed it Typically a substantial amount of money is
would. Remember the statistic. “left on the table” and the best bottom line
3. Not Focusing on Safety Programs and the results are not achieved.
Big Picture – Many companies use the 5. The Right Insurance Broker – a False
purchase of insurance as the only approach to Truth. The insurance business is about
their formal risk management program... Big relationships and we tend to do business with
Mistake… not paying attention to safety and people we like and trust though organizations
loss control is where many companies miss place too much faith in one broker. In an
the boat in terms of the ultimate savings. insurance brokerage relationship CFO’s place
CFO’s are caught up in too many details of their trust and guidance in the hands of an
their daily business to pay close attention ... insurance broker who becomes their sole
sometimes this responsibility is given source of information. We should also
internally but the real problem is that they do understand that brokers are the marketing
not have an eye for the bigger picture. arm of the insurance industry.
Page | 2
3. CFO’s should consider the following questions:
The Brokerage service is vital but like other 1. How do you view Risk Management … an
business dealings organizations should perform a Expense or an Investment?
due diligence study on the broker you are going to
do business with … the carriers they represent … 2. Can you internally duplicate long term industry
their ability to provide needed services. Ultimately knowledge and expertise?
organizations should receive Stewardship Reports 3. Understanding of the business model of both
that outline standards of excellence that a broker broker and insurance carrier to ascertain certainty
will adhere to when servicing your account. that the Best Price and Coverage was achieved.
We’ve seen clients who have had the same broker 4. What is your company’s risk appetite? If might be
for many years only to find out that they (the client) larger than you want.
were paying the highest insurance rates for many 5. Corporate Governance & Duty of Care … What is
years while still not having the right coverage. you comfort level in this area?
The insurance brokerage income is based on sales
Conflict Free
commissions, fees and contingent commission all
based on a contractual relationship with an With the CFO wearing so many hats and because of
insurance carrier. There are great insurance resource constraints priority is given to top initiatives,
brokers out there… but the services provided are abandoning many other meaningful savings programs,
geared toward the sale. including insurance opportunities that could lead to
significant cash savings. However, these opportunities
Has a broker ever given you advice at the same
can be captured - an Independent Advisory can bring
time telling you to buy from a different Broker?
greater transparency and deal experience to the process.
5.5 Lack of Negotiation in the procurement process.
There is a misconception that the insurance Advisors have developed strategies and solutions to
product is standard and an even greater erroneous ensure risks are mitigated, major problems are avoided,
time is managed, and cost reduction is a priority.
belief that prices are somewhat fixed.
This is simply not the case … insurance coverage How we get Started
and premium is negotiable and by utilizing a
professional competitive marketing effort managed
by an independent advisor not only can coverage
be enhanced but premium 9 times out of 10 are
reduced.
About Premier Risk Management
Premier has offices in Ho-Ho-Kus, NJ and White Plains, NY providing middle market firms throughout the US and internationally with fee
based risk management and insurance advisory expertise in the areas of commercial insurance and employee benefits.
As risk management professionals, Premier Risk Management brings to the table technical skills that enhance the risk management process,
proper competition, independence and uncomplicated advice. Their principals are guided and proven by the multitude of everyday practical
business experiences spanning from every type of market scenario. Equipped with a combination of current market understanding and deep
industry knowledge, they bring a hands-on approach, knowing that careful attention to your unique operations is the key to successful risk
management which results in value creation. Their goal is to create true value for you the client. The outcome is an established track record
of success and with Premier as your advocate you can focus on the business you know best.
Contact
www.premierriskmgt.com Scott Wolff James King
201-573-1100 x100 201-573-1110
swolff@premierriskmgt.com jking@premierriskmgt.com
Page | 3