This talk uses Cynefin as a sense-making framework to understand where to use agile vs big upfront planning. By understanding our own biases in disorder, we can better step back and choose the right approach based on the complexity of the work.
1 of 21
Download to read offline
More Related Content
Agile, complexity, and the art of not queueing at DisneyWorld
2. Whats this all about then?
Many people see agility as the new way to do everything,
This is not so.
Some activities work best with agile
Others activities need detailed planning
But how can you tell the difference?
3. Cynefin Complex Complicated
ClearChaotic
Best Practice
Good Practices
Novel Practices
Emergent Practices
Act-Sense-Respond
Probe-Sense-Respond
Sense-Categorise-Respond
Sense-Analyse-Respond
Disorder
4. Disorder is the problem
British taxpayers have contributed to the cost of major government
projects that have overrun to the tune of 贈17 billion
TaxPayers Alliance analyses of data on 10 UK projects covering
everything from Astute submarines to Crossrail found overruns
have grown to a total of 32.7 years and 贈17.2 billion, or 贈624 per
UK household.
Between 2013 and 2019 the number of major projects deemed at
least probable of a successful delivery by the Infrastructure and
Projects Authority has fallen from 48 per cent in 2013 to only 17 per
cent in 2019.
We keep deciding on our approach rather than letting the work
decide
7. Anyone shocked yet?
Im assuming not, weve heard this story a few times before..
Lets look at this the other way around
Whos been to DisneyWorld速鏝 in Florida?
9. My disorder defaults to complex
What does agile look like at DisneyWorld速鏝?
Ride 7 Dwarfs Mine Train That was fun, what
shall we do next?
Discussion Ensues
Decision arrived at
(without dot voting)
Walk to next ride
QUEUE
Ride a ride
10. What the Jiminy Cricket just happened?
We used a complex approach for work which was clear or
complicated
All of those discussions and queues were the result
We spend thousands of pounds to take our kids away to shout
at them at a theme park
Using a complex approach for clear work actually makes the
work more complex!
11. I HATE queues
If you are going to go to DisneyWorld速 you
need to research and plan
Ive never queued more than 15 minutes
in DisneyWorld速
Heres how
12. Step 1
Work out your dates ahead of time
TouringPlans.com (and others) have crowd
calendars that tell you how busy each Disney park
will be a year ahead
Book early at least 6 months ahead
14. Hot Tip 1- Onsite vs Offsite
Disney Onsite hotels are pretty expensive
Offsite hotels are often better value
Disney onsite guests get 60+ days ahead FastPass+ bookings
Offsite guests only get 30 days ahead FastPass+ bookings
All of the good / difficult to get FastPasses are gone before 30
days ahead (bad times)
Book 1 night in a cheap onsite hotel and you get the 60+ days
Buy your theme park tickets independently, package tours for
offsite guests only give you your ticket reference 30 days ahead
15. Hot Tip 2 -Book your food
Disney restaurants take
bookings 180 days ahead
Some restaurants have no
bookings left 179 days ahead
You can cancel the booking with
$0 cost up to 24 hours ahead
16. Hot Tip 3 - Book your events
Want to do Savis workshop to build a lightsaber?
Book at least 2 months ahead, but as early as 180 days
17. Hot Tip 4 Use
touring plans
Touring plans run the
travelling salesman
problem on a bunch of
cloud servers using
known data
Work out what order to
use and where to target
FastPass+
18. Hot Tip 5 Lie-ins and breakfast?
People on holiday want to have a lie in and big breakfast
Rookie mistake.
19. Hot Tip 6 - Going to Universal?
Universal doesnt do free FastPasses so queues can be epic
You can buy an unlimited express pass for about $200 per
person per day
2 days for 4 people is $1600 ouch
Booking 1 night at one of the top 3 Universal hotels gets you
unlimited express pass for 2 days for each guest, for about
贈400 per night
20. What does this all mean?
1. If youre thinking of going to DisneyWorld速, lets have a chat
2. Waterfall in complex domain is doomed to fail / overrun
3. Agile in clear domain makes the work become complex
4. You have a default setting, know your blind spot
5. Let the Work decide how it should be delivered
6. Complexity is key
7. Never argue with a Wookie
Editor's Notes
#7: In traditional projects we try to go as efficiently as possible from A to B, which is great, but it turns out we dont usually end up wanting to be at B, we want to be somewhere else, say C. We then enter that wonderfully expensive and chaotic Change Management Phase.
In Agile, we instead set out towards B but after a short time usually 2 weeks we have a Sprint Review where we show what weve done and get the feedback to Pivot and change direction. And repeat.
Before we get to C we realise we have diminishing returns so we trim the tail and move onto something else more valuable