狠狠撸

狠狠撸Share a Scribd company logo
@talraviv
talraviv.org
algorithms are
*already*
our bosses
@talraviv
talraviv.org
I work at Patreon
so i get to meet a lot of online
creators.
@talraviv
talraviv.org
online creators are
fascinating people
they are basically living in the future
@talraviv
talraviv.org
online creators
have audiences
I love asking creators how their
fans discovered them
Every story is delightful and unique
@talraviv
talraviv.org
with one major similarity
@talraviv
talraviv.org
Theres always a
discovery platform
involved
Youtube
M
edium
Twitch
Spotify
Twitter
Facebook
Instagram
Soundcloud
napchatterestdin
@talraviv
talraviv.org
The discovery platform
is the destination
person
arrives at
platform
& told what
to consume
@talraviv
talraviv.org
In the middle is a
recommendation algorithm
@talraviv
talraviv.org
The algorithm does
whatever it wants
@talraviv
talraviv.org
What does the
algorithm want
?What drives the business? Ad revenue
@talraviv
talraviv.org
What does the
algorithm want
?What drives the business? Ad revenue
?What drives ad revenue? People
looking at stuff
@talraviv
talraviv.org
What does the
algorithm want
?What drives the business? Ad revenue
?What drives ad revenue? People
looking at stuff
?What gets people to look at stuff?
Content that makes people look at
stuff for a long time, or makes people
come back often, or both
@talraviv
talraviv.org
What the algorithm
doesnt really care about
?Who clicked “subscribe” to you
@talraviv
talraviv.org
What the algorithm
doesnt really care about
?Who clicked “subscribe” to you
?Whether a fan wants to see your
content today
@talraviv
talraviv.org
What the algorithm
doesnt really care about
?Who clicked “subscribe” to you
?Whether a fan wants to see your
content today
?Ideas that are good and important
but may not be popular
@talraviv
talraviv.org
You dont have to understand
tech or robot psychology
@talraviv
talraviv.org
You just have to
understand the incentives
@talraviv
talraviv.org
This brings me back to
online creators
@talraviv
talraviv.org
Creators are
independent
entrepreneurial
expressive
free
right?
@talraviv
talraviv.org
but they all have a boss
that boss is an algorithm
@talraviv
talraviv.org
think about it
@talraviv
talraviv.org
they have a boss
@talraviv
talraviv.org
and here’s the thing:
@talraviv
talraviv.org
it’s not a good boss.
@talraviv
talraviv.org
would you want to work
for someone who
@talraviv
talraviv.org
holds unclear expectations of you
that change over time
(and you have to figure them out
from rumors or coworkers)
https://www.theverge.com/2017/8/30/16222850/youtube-google-
brain-algorithm-video-recommendation-personalized-feed
@talraviv
talraviv.org
compensates you
inconsistently, on factors
outside your control
https://in?uencermarketinghub.com/4-factors-
a?ect-youtube-earnings-potential/
@talraviv
talraviv.org
promotes people unrelated
to their contribution
“How the Youtube algorithm created Logan Paul” Jarvis Johnson
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2GYXemlyd_Q
@talraviv
talraviv.org
fires people
without feedback
https://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2017/09/18/
adpocalypse-2017-heres-what-you-need-to-know-about-
youtubes-demonetization-troubles/
@talraviv
talraviv.org
expects you to work
while on vacation or sick
https://creatoracademy.youtube.com/page/lesson/trendsetter#strategies-zippy-link-1
http://techtipswithtea.com/youtube-tips/consistency-really-matter-youtube/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wVJ6Gp6L6rA
@talraviv
talraviv.org
burned out
your co-workers
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/sep/08/
youtube-stars-burnout-fun-bleak-stressed
@talraviv
talraviv.org
holds power by being deeply embedded in
the business and institutional knowledge
and so can never get fired because it’s not
worth it and no one has the courage or
will to do it
@talraviv
talraviv.org
if i was thinking
about a job
@talraviv
talraviv.org
and this was what i heard
@talraviv
talraviv.org
I would say nah
@talraviv
talraviv.org
the algorithm
is a boss
@talraviv
talraviv.org
the algorithm
is a toxic boss
@talraviv
talraviv.org
let that sink in
@talraviv
talraviv.org
@talraviv
talraviv.org
thats one reason why i think creators live
in the future
they are the canaries in the coal mines
@talraviv
talraviv.org
@talraviv
talraviv.org
and its more than content creators
many more of us work for algorithms
@talraviv
talraviv.org
uber and lyft drivers
@talraviv
talraviv.org
uber and lyft drivers
etsy makers
@talraviv
talraviv.org
uber and lyft drivers
etsy makers
amazon sellers
@talraviv
talraviv.org
uber and lyft drivers
etsy makers
amazon sellers
thumbtack professionals
@talraviv
talraviv.org
uber and lyft drivers
etsy makers
amazon sellers
thumbtack professionals
airbnb hosts
@talraviv
talraviv.org
uber and lyft drivers
etsy makers
amazon sellers
thumbtack professionals
airbnb hosts
all work for algorithms
@talraviv
talraviv.org
we keep talking about future AI
overlords
@talraviv
talraviv.org
we keep talking about future AI
overlords
but we already hired them
to be our bosses
@talraviv
talraviv.org
so what do you do
@talraviv
talraviv.org
when you want to create
@talraviv
talraviv.org
and you have a toxic AI overlord boss
@talraviv
talraviv.org
be antifragile*
*a term and a book by Nasim Taleb. My favorite non-fiction book ever.
I keep it on my nightstand. I’m not joking
@talraviv
talraviv.org
how to be antifragile
enjoy the upside
?use the platforms to reach an
audience and get discovered
@talraviv
talraviv.org
how to be antifragile
enjoy the upside
?use the platforms to reach an
audience and get discovered
?that’s uh, the upside
@talraviv
talraviv.org
how to be antifragile
cap your downside
?the downside comes when you want to
reach your viewers but you can’t without
adulterating your content or following
orders from the algorithm
@talraviv
talraviv.org
how to be antifragile
cap your downside
?the downside comes when you want to
reach your viewers but you can’t without
adulterating your content or following
orders from the algorithm
?always make sure you can reach your
fans even at times when it doesn't benefit
the algorithm (more on this in a bit)
@talraviv
talraviv.org
use the platforms to get
discovered
@talraviv
talraviv.org
direct decentralized ways
to maintain contact
@talraviv
talraviv.org
collect emails
collect phone numbers
collect mailing address
host an online community
build your own app
whatever is most natural to your
audience
@talraviv
talraviv.org
so you don’t have to
fake things like this
@talraviv
talraviv.org
in order to achieve this
@talraviv
talraviv.org
(btw thanks to everyone who joined
through that post and didn’t unfriend me)
@talraviv
talraviv.org
in short disintermediate
@talraviv
talraviv.org
dont let
the algorithm
own you
@talraviv
talraviv.org
the end
well sort of
@talraviv
talraviv.org
guess what im gonna ask you for now
@talraviv
talraviv.org
if you enjoyed this
@talraviv
talraviv.org
which is obvious
because youre still clicking
@talraviv
talraviv.org
however you found this
@talraviv
talraviv.org
the most dependable way to hear about
the next one
@talraviv
talraviv.org
is to leave your email
@talraviv
talraviv.org
so i can spam you
@talraviv
talraviv.org
with lots of emails
@talraviv
talraviv.org
and clickbait subject lines
@talraviv
talraviv.org
that is my promise to you
@talraviv
talraviv.org
kidding
@talraviv
talraviv.org
talraviv.org
@talraviv
talraviv.org
otherwise
@talraviv
talraviv.org
this interaction will be like
a fleeting glance on the subway
@talraviv
talraviv.org
but theres no craigslist missed
connections for content
@talraviv
talraviv.org
oh wait theres google search
@talraviv
talraviv.org
thats an algorithm too though
@talraviv
talraviv.org
talraviv.org
Ad

Recommended

Content Strategy Triage: Who lives? Who dies? Who do you fight to save?
Content Strategy Triage: Who lives? Who dies? Who do you fight to save?
Scriptorium Publishing
?
Unified Content Development: Integrating Tech Comm, Marcom, and Technical Sup...
Unified Content Development: Integrating Tech Comm, Marcom, and Technical Sup...
Scriptorium Publishing
?
The Rocky Road to DITA
The Rocky Road to DITA
Scriptorium Publishing
?
How To Succeed In Web Design
How To Succeed In Web Design
Shawn Rider
?
Pimp my Plone
Pimp my Plone
Philip Bauer
?
1030 track2 kloss
1030 track2 kloss
Rising Media, Inc.
?
Google+ Profile PageRank: The Real AuthorRank? - SMX Advanced 2013
Google+ Profile PageRank: The Real AuthorRank? - SMX Advanced 2013
Mark Traphagen
?
Tips, Tricks, Tactics and Technology in the Digital Marketing World (ttttdmw)
Tips, Tricks, Tactics and Technology in the Digital Marketing World (ttttdmw)
Jason Wright
?
The Dark Side of YouTube:Platform Challenges Explained
The Dark Side of YouTube:Platform Challenges Explained
sam ranjith paul
?
Kimberley-Go: Apps, social media & augmented reality
Kimberley-Go: Apps, social media & augmented reality
Ray Wills
?
Social Media 102 For Artists
Social Media 102 For Artists
SOMArts
?
7 smart ways to optimize your digital presence
7 smart ways to optimize your digital presence
Invisible Puppy
?
Social Media Algorithms: How to Stay Ahead
Social Media Algorithms: How to Stay Ahead
Hot Fuego, LLC
?
SPARK 2016: Why Your Social Content is Killing Your Bottom Line
SPARK 2016: Why Your Social Content is Killing Your Bottom Line
TrackMaven
?
Facing Facebook for Small Business
Facing Facebook for Small Business
Aerin Guy
?
Webinar: Keeping Up With the Ever-Changing Social Media Algorithms
Webinar: Keeping Up With the Ever-Changing Social Media Algorithms
Falcon.io
?
Leveraging Facebook Marketing, Insights and EdgeRank for Small Business
Leveraging Facebook Marketing, Insights and EdgeRank for Small Business
Joshua Panzer
?
The Web Is Your Oyster
The Web Is Your Oyster
Chi-chi Ekweozor
?
The future of social media
The future of social media
Mal Chia
?
Social media FBLA presentation
Social media FBLA presentation
Angela Lechtenberg
?
A Visual History of Google Algorithm Updates [Infographic]
A Visual History of Google Algorithm Updates [Infographic]
Mohamed Mahdy
?
Social Media Week Bristol 2019 - Stop The Scroll
Social Media Week Bristol 2019 - Stop The Scroll
Noisy Little Monkey
?
How Maximizing Your LinkedIn Exposure and Leveraging Dark Social Can Make You...
How Maximizing Your LinkedIn Exposure and Leveraging Dark Social Can Make You...
Adam Chronister
?
Humanity vs. Algorithm - A world of misguided incentives
Humanity vs. Algorithm - A world of misguided incentives
Jesper ?str?m
?
The Future for Facebook and Social Media Strategy
The Future for Facebook and Social Media Strategy
Marcus Nelson
?
Social Media for Arts Entrepreneurs at ASU
Social Media for Arts Entrepreneurs at ASU
Devon Smith
?
ComplianceBrief
ComplianceBrief
Daryl McNutt
?
Emerging Social Media Trends, Tools and Technologies
Emerging Social Media Trends, Tools and Technologies
Centerline Digital
?
The ARUBA Kind of new Proposal Umum .pptx
The ARUBA Kind of new Proposal Umum .pptx
andiwarneri
?
Make DDoS expensive for the threat actors
Make DDoS expensive for the threat actors
APNIC
?

More Related Content

Similar to Algorithms are already our bosses (20)

The Dark Side of YouTube:Platform Challenges Explained
The Dark Side of YouTube:Platform Challenges Explained
sam ranjith paul
?
Kimberley-Go: Apps, social media & augmented reality
Kimberley-Go: Apps, social media & augmented reality
Ray Wills
?
Social Media 102 For Artists
Social Media 102 For Artists
SOMArts
?
7 smart ways to optimize your digital presence
7 smart ways to optimize your digital presence
Invisible Puppy
?
Social Media Algorithms: How to Stay Ahead
Social Media Algorithms: How to Stay Ahead
Hot Fuego, LLC
?
SPARK 2016: Why Your Social Content is Killing Your Bottom Line
SPARK 2016: Why Your Social Content is Killing Your Bottom Line
TrackMaven
?
Facing Facebook for Small Business
Facing Facebook for Small Business
Aerin Guy
?
Webinar: Keeping Up With the Ever-Changing Social Media Algorithms
Webinar: Keeping Up With the Ever-Changing Social Media Algorithms
Falcon.io
?
Leveraging Facebook Marketing, Insights and EdgeRank for Small Business
Leveraging Facebook Marketing, Insights and EdgeRank for Small Business
Joshua Panzer
?
The Web Is Your Oyster
The Web Is Your Oyster
Chi-chi Ekweozor
?
The future of social media
The future of social media
Mal Chia
?
Social media FBLA presentation
Social media FBLA presentation
Angela Lechtenberg
?
A Visual History of Google Algorithm Updates [Infographic]
A Visual History of Google Algorithm Updates [Infographic]
Mohamed Mahdy
?
Social Media Week Bristol 2019 - Stop The Scroll
Social Media Week Bristol 2019 - Stop The Scroll
Noisy Little Monkey
?
How Maximizing Your LinkedIn Exposure and Leveraging Dark Social Can Make You...
How Maximizing Your LinkedIn Exposure and Leveraging Dark Social Can Make You...
Adam Chronister
?
Humanity vs. Algorithm - A world of misguided incentives
Humanity vs. Algorithm - A world of misguided incentives
Jesper ?str?m
?
The Future for Facebook and Social Media Strategy
The Future for Facebook and Social Media Strategy
Marcus Nelson
?
Social Media for Arts Entrepreneurs at ASU
Social Media for Arts Entrepreneurs at ASU
Devon Smith
?
ComplianceBrief
ComplianceBrief
Daryl McNutt
?
Emerging Social Media Trends, Tools and Technologies
Emerging Social Media Trends, Tools and Technologies
Centerline Digital
?
The Dark Side of YouTube:Platform Challenges Explained
The Dark Side of YouTube:Platform Challenges Explained
sam ranjith paul
?
Kimberley-Go: Apps, social media & augmented reality
Kimberley-Go: Apps, social media & augmented reality
Ray Wills
?
Social Media 102 For Artists
Social Media 102 For Artists
SOMArts
?
7 smart ways to optimize your digital presence
7 smart ways to optimize your digital presence
Invisible Puppy
?
Social Media Algorithms: How to Stay Ahead
Social Media Algorithms: How to Stay Ahead
Hot Fuego, LLC
?
SPARK 2016: Why Your Social Content is Killing Your Bottom Line
SPARK 2016: Why Your Social Content is Killing Your Bottom Line
TrackMaven
?
Facing Facebook for Small Business
Facing Facebook for Small Business
Aerin Guy
?
Webinar: Keeping Up With the Ever-Changing Social Media Algorithms
Webinar: Keeping Up With the Ever-Changing Social Media Algorithms
Falcon.io
?
Leveraging Facebook Marketing, Insights and EdgeRank for Small Business
Leveraging Facebook Marketing, Insights and EdgeRank for Small Business
Joshua Panzer
?
The future of social media
The future of social media
Mal Chia
?
A Visual History of Google Algorithm Updates [Infographic]
A Visual History of Google Algorithm Updates [Infographic]
Mohamed Mahdy
?
Social Media Week Bristol 2019 - Stop The Scroll
Social Media Week Bristol 2019 - Stop The Scroll
Noisy Little Monkey
?
How Maximizing Your LinkedIn Exposure and Leveraging Dark Social Can Make You...
How Maximizing Your LinkedIn Exposure and Leveraging Dark Social Can Make You...
Adam Chronister
?
Humanity vs. Algorithm - A world of misguided incentives
Humanity vs. Algorithm - A world of misguided incentives
Jesper ?str?m
?
The Future for Facebook and Social Media Strategy
The Future for Facebook and Social Media Strategy
Marcus Nelson
?
Social Media for Arts Entrepreneurs at ASU
Social Media for Arts Entrepreneurs at ASU
Devon Smith
?
Emerging Social Media Trends, Tools and Technologies
Emerging Social Media Trends, Tools and Technologies
Centerline Digital
?

Recently uploaded (20)

The ARUBA Kind of new Proposal Umum .pptx
The ARUBA Kind of new Proposal Umum .pptx
andiwarneri
?
Make DDoS expensive for the threat actors
Make DDoS expensive for the threat actors
APNIC
?
Clive Dickens RedTech Public Copy - Collaborate or Die
Clive Dickens RedTech Public Copy - Collaborate or Die
Clive Dickens
?
PROCESS FOR CREATION OF BUSINESS PARTNER IN SAP
PROCESS FOR CREATION OF BUSINESS PARTNER IN SAP
AhmadAli716831
?
TCP/IP presentation SET2- Information Systems
TCP/IP presentation SET2- Information Systems
agnesegtcagliero
?
BroadLink Cloud Service introduction.pdf
BroadLink Cloud Service introduction.pdf
DevendraDwivdi1
?
history of internet in nepal Class-8 (sparsha).pptx
history of internet in nepal Class-8 (sparsha).pptx
SPARSH508080
?
狠狠撸s: Eco Economic Epochs for The World Game (s) pdf
狠狠撸s: Eco Economic Epochs for The World Game (s) pdf
Steven McGee
?
Topic 2 - Cloud Computing Basics,,,.pptx
Topic 2 - Cloud Computing Basics,,,.pptx
oneillp100
?
DDoS in India, presented at INNOG 8 by Dave Phelan
DDoS in India, presented at INNOG 8 by Dave Phelan
APNIC
?
B M Mostofa Kamal Al-Azad [Document & Localization Expert]
B M Mostofa Kamal Al-Azad [Document & Localization Expert]
Mostofa Kamal Al-Azad
?
Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) and Starlink
Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) and Starlink
APNIC
?
Lecture 3.1 Analysing the Global Business Environment .pptx
Lecture 3.1 Analysing the Global Business Environment .pptx
shofalbsb
?
Global Networking Trends, presented at the India ISP Conclave 2025
Global Networking Trends, presented at the India ISP Conclave 2025
APNIC
?
Pitch PitchPitchPitchPitchPitchPitch.pptx
Pitch PitchPitchPitchPitchPitchPitch.pptx
157551
?
BASICS OF SAP _ ALL ABOUT SAP _WHY SAP OVER ANY OTHER ERP SYSTEM
BASICS OF SAP _ ALL ABOUT SAP _WHY SAP OVER ANY OTHER ERP SYSTEM
AhmadAli716831
?
Almos Entirely Correct Mixing with Apps to Voting
Almos Entirely Correct Mixing with Apps to Voting
gapati2964
?
最新版加拿大奎斯特大学毕业证(蚕鲍颁毕业证书)原版定制
最新版加拿大奎斯特大学毕业证(蚕鲍颁毕业证书)原版定制
taqyed
?
ChatGPT A.I. Powered Chatbot and Popularization.pdf
ChatGPT A.I. Powered Chatbot and Popularization.pdf
StanleySamson1
?
inside the internet - understanding the TCP/IP protocol
inside the internet - understanding the TCP/IP protocol
shainweniton02
?
The ARUBA Kind of new Proposal Umum .pptx
The ARUBA Kind of new Proposal Umum .pptx
andiwarneri
?
Make DDoS expensive for the threat actors
Make DDoS expensive for the threat actors
APNIC
?
Clive Dickens RedTech Public Copy - Collaborate or Die
Clive Dickens RedTech Public Copy - Collaborate or Die
Clive Dickens
?
PROCESS FOR CREATION OF BUSINESS PARTNER IN SAP
PROCESS FOR CREATION OF BUSINESS PARTNER IN SAP
AhmadAli716831
?
TCP/IP presentation SET2- Information Systems
TCP/IP presentation SET2- Information Systems
agnesegtcagliero
?
BroadLink Cloud Service introduction.pdf
BroadLink Cloud Service introduction.pdf
DevendraDwivdi1
?
history of internet in nepal Class-8 (sparsha).pptx
history of internet in nepal Class-8 (sparsha).pptx
SPARSH508080
?
狠狠撸s: Eco Economic Epochs for The World Game (s) pdf
狠狠撸s: Eco Economic Epochs for The World Game (s) pdf
Steven McGee
?
Topic 2 - Cloud Computing Basics,,,.pptx
Topic 2 - Cloud Computing Basics,,,.pptx
oneillp100
?
DDoS in India, presented at INNOG 8 by Dave Phelan
DDoS in India, presented at INNOG 8 by Dave Phelan
APNIC
?
B M Mostofa Kamal Al-Azad [Document & Localization Expert]
B M Mostofa Kamal Al-Azad [Document & Localization Expert]
Mostofa Kamal Al-Azad
?
Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) and Starlink
Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) and Starlink
APNIC
?
Lecture 3.1 Analysing the Global Business Environment .pptx
Lecture 3.1 Analysing the Global Business Environment .pptx
shofalbsb
?
Global Networking Trends, presented at the India ISP Conclave 2025
Global Networking Trends, presented at the India ISP Conclave 2025
APNIC
?
Pitch PitchPitchPitchPitchPitchPitch.pptx
Pitch PitchPitchPitchPitchPitchPitch.pptx
157551
?
BASICS OF SAP _ ALL ABOUT SAP _WHY SAP OVER ANY OTHER ERP SYSTEM
BASICS OF SAP _ ALL ABOUT SAP _WHY SAP OVER ANY OTHER ERP SYSTEM
AhmadAli716831
?
Almos Entirely Correct Mixing with Apps to Voting
Almos Entirely Correct Mixing with Apps to Voting
gapati2964
?
最新版加拿大奎斯特大学毕业证(蚕鲍颁毕业证书)原版定制
最新版加拿大奎斯特大学毕业证(蚕鲍颁毕业证书)原版定制
taqyed
?
ChatGPT A.I. Powered Chatbot and Popularization.pdf
ChatGPT A.I. Powered Chatbot and Popularization.pdf
StanleySamson1
?
inside the internet - understanding the TCP/IP protocol
inside the internet - understanding the TCP/IP protocol
shainweniton02
?
Ad

Algorithms are already our bosses