2. Purpose of Annotation
Students monitor their inner conversation and
annotate the text to leave tracks of their thinking.
Leaving tracks like this gives them a place to hold and
remember their thoughts.
Harvey & Goudvis, 2017
3. Annotation for Surface Understanding
(Recap)
Texts that Entertain Texts that Inform
Identify the characters, setting,
problem(s) and solution(s)
Identify the main ideas and supporting
details
Linking the pronouns/other noun phrases with their referents using double-headed
arrows
For words/phrases that we do not understand
4. Connecting Thoughts on Texts
Making connections to personal experiences facilitates
understanding. Our prior experience and background
knowledge fuel the connections we make. We teach students
to activate their background knowledge and think about
these connections.
Harvey & Goudvis, 2017
5. Progression of Annotation from Middle to
Upper Primary
As students progress from
the middle primary levels
to the upper primary
levels, they work towards
deeper comprehension of
a text by asking questions,
making connections and
identifying surprising
information.
8. Why do we get students to ask
questions?
To get them to wonder about their reading
To gain information and find out the answers to their questions
To help students make inference
Harvey & Goudvis, 2017
9. Ways to ask questions about the
text
Possible question stems
I wonder...
Why...?
How...?
I'm confused...
My big question is...
10. Ask Questions
When students wonder about what they read, they learn new information
and answer their questions (Harvey & Goudvis, 2017).
P4U6 Dinosaurs Exist! Reading Comprehension
11. Ask Questions
Asking questions often leads to inferential thinking. We let students know that
inferring involves taking our background knowledge and combining it with clues in
the text to come up with a reasonable idea of what is going on. (p. 142)
P4U5 Ruby's Sunflower Close and Critical Reading 1
Background
knowledge
Clue from
the text
13. Make Connections: Activate,
Connect, Build
We teach readers to:
refer to prior personal experience;
make connections between texts and media;
activate background knowledge of the text;
connect the new to the knownuse what they know to
understand new information; and
merge thinking with new learning to build a knowledge base.
Harvey & Goudvis, 2017, p. 17
14. Make Connections: Activate,
Connect, Build
When children understand
how to connect the texts
they read to their lives,
they begin to make
connections between what
they read and the larger
world (Harvey & Goudvis,
2017).
P4U5 Rubys Sunflower - Close & Critical Reading 1
15. Make Connections: Activate,
Connect, Build
When we make text-to-self connections to the text, we merge our
prior knowledge with what we are learning from the text.
P4 Supplementary Text Rats'
Nest Reading and Viewing
17. Look for Surprising Information
As readers pay attention to unusual information, it helps them
understand how to make connections. (Harvey & Goudvis, 2017).
P5U5 A Game of Emails - Reading and Viewing 1 (Draft)
In this context of a
persuasive email, the
identification of surprising
information enables
readers to pay attention
to the points that
influence the teachers
decision of having a
gaming CCA in the
school.
I didnt
know that
gaming
can
improve
our
thinking
skills.
!
18. Look for Surprising Information
Looking out for surprising content nudges readers to pay attention to
unusual details.
Paying closer attention to unusual details enables readers to think more
critically about the text, and infer the context based on their prior
experiences.
P5U3Ten - Reading and Viewing (Draft)
The reader highlights
information that is out of the
norm: a dislike for her sibling.
This prompts the author to pay
closer attention to the
events which are to be
elaborated.
20. How do readers form opinions?
Connect prior
experiences and
knowledge with
the given
context.
Gain a deeper
understanding
of the text.
Support the
opinion with
evidence from
the text.
21. How do readers form opinions?
P4U1 A Nasty Accident (Supplementary Text)
Step 1: Activate
prior knowledge,
i.e., what
constitutes
danger on the
road
Step 2: Form an
opinion with
evidence from the
text, i.e., minibus
turning quickly at
the junction is
dangerous.
22. Modelling Through Think-aloud to
Form Opinions
P4U1 Making Ice Cream - Reading Comprehension
As readers learn to read more deeply, modelling through think-aloud can
complement annotations to connect evidence to their thought(s) about the
text.
Leaving trails of these thoughts through annotations makes thinking visible to
learners, so that they are able to see the connection between an opinion and
the text.
23. Using Sentence Starters to Form
Opinions
Identifying information at
the literal level
1
2 Using sentence starters
24. Let's Reflect!
How do readers work
towards monitoring their
own comprehension of the
text?
25. Using Sentence Starters to Form
Annotations
P4U1 Rubys Sunflower, Close and Critical Reading
26. Use of Checklists During Annotation
P4U7 Heartbeats in the Dark, Reading Comprehension
When readers monitor their comprehension, they use a repertoire
of strategies to maintain and further their understanding.
27. Summary
In Part 1 of the series, we learnt about the knowledge
bases and how annotation is used in STELLAR 2.0.
In Part 2, we learnt how annotation is explicitly taught
in STELLAR 2.0.
In Part 3, we learnt how to guide our students to
annotate a text for deeper level of understanding.
28. CREDITS: This presentation template was created by 際際滷sgo, including
icons by Flaticon, infographics & images by Freepik
Thank
You!
Editor's Notes
Dear participants,
You are encouraged to view Parts 1 and 2 of the Annotation series in the appended link before embarking on this asynchronous session.
https://www.opal2.moe.edu.sg/csl/s/stellar-teacher-mentor-20-community-page/wiki/page/view?title=2022+STELLAR+2.0+%28Lower+Primary%29+Packages
Thank you.
It is vital for teachers to model how to make inferences. This could be done through a think-aloud as shown in the example from the guidelines.
In this Reading and Viewing lesson, students read how the characters, Jun Ling and Boon Chong, persuade their teacher in allowing them to start a new co-curriculum activity (CCA) in school. In their attempt, they have included a piece of surprising information to support their stand of why gaming can be beneficial. As students mindfully sift out information that is surprising to them, it encourages them to pause and make the connection, i.e., it aids in persuading the teacher, Ms Zahara, to start a new CCA in school.
As students form an opinion based on their prior knowledge before substantiating it with evidence from the text, that enables them to gain a deeper understanding of it.
Once readers are able to visualise the process of forming opinions based on evidence at the surface level, the use of sentence starters provides a structure to build on their thoughts. It also guides them to connect what they have read to prior experiences and knowledge.