ݺߣ

ݺߣShare a Scribd company logo
Taylor Creek Algal Turf Scrubber?
(ATS?) Nutrient Recovery Facility
Performance Review (Jan 2007- Aug 2008)
TC-ATS? Operational Summary

Operation began in late
January 2007
Severe drought which ended in
early July 2007 impacted
startup operation and system
performance
Algal die-offs in September
2007 and May 2008
Investigations of water quality
conditions and operational
parameters initiated in July
2007
Causative factors remain
unidentified


                                  2
TP lb removed
            1/
               28
                  /




                             0
                                               1000
                                                        2000
                                                               3000
                                                                      4000
                                                                                                                   5000
             2/ 200
            2/ 5/2 7
               19 00
            2/ / 20 7
               2 0
            3/ 6/ 20 7
               1 0
            3/ 1/ 2 7
               1 00
            3/ 9/ 20 7
               26 0
                         7
             4/ / 20
                       0
            4/ 8/2 7
               16 00
            4/ / 2 7
               23 00
                  / 7
             5/ 200
            5/ 7/2 7
               21 00
                  / 7
             6/ 200
            6/ 3/2 7
               1 00
            6/ 1/ 20 7
               18 0
                  / 7
             7/ 200
                 2 7
             7/ /20
                       0
            7/ 9/2 7
               1 00
            7/ 6/ 2 7
               29 00
                  / 7
             8/ 200
            8/ 6/2 7
               1 00
            8/ 3/ 20 7
               26 0
                         7
             9/ / 20
                       0
            9/ 4/2 7
               10 00
            9/ / 2 7
               2 00
            10 3/ 20 7
               / 0
            10 1/ 2 7
                     0
           10 / 7/ 07
             / 20
           10 15/2 07
             /2 0
                       0
            11 2/2 7
                     0
           11 / 4/ 07
             /      20
           11 12/ 07
             / 20




    Date
           11 19/2 07
             / 0
                                                                        Projected TP Load Removal C 4,000 lbs/yr




           12 29/ 07
             / 20
           12 10/2 07
             / 0
           12 17/ 07
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  recovered-based TP load removal
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Phosphorus Removal Summary January 2007 through December 2008




             / 2 20
                7/ 07
             1 / 2 00
            1/ 6/2 7
               1 00
            1/ 3/ 20 8
               2 0
            1/ 0/ 20 8
               28 0
                         8
             2/ /20
                       0
            2/ 4/2 8
               1     00
            2/ 7/2 8
               25 00
                         8
             3/ /200
            3/ 3/2 8
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          (Projected TP Load Removal = 4,000 lbs/yr)




               10 00
            3/ /2 8
               2 00
            3/ 3/2 8
               3 00
            4/ 1/ 20 8
               1 0
            4/ 4/ 2 8
               2 00
            5/ 8/ 20 8
               1 0
            5/ 2/ 20 8
               26 0
                         8
             6/ / 20
                       0
                                                                                                                          TP Cum ulative Load Rem oved Based Upon Water Quality Calculations lb




            6/ 9/2 8
               23 00
                         8
             7/ / 20
                       0
            7/ 7/2 8
                                                                                                                                                                                                  TP Cum ulative Load Rem oved Based Upon Total Solids Recovery Calculations lb




               21 00
                         8
             8 / 20
           11 /4/ 08
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Huge disparity between water quality-based and solids




             / 1 20
           11 0 / 08
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     TC-ATS? Performance Summary




             / 20
           12 24/2 08
             /1 0
                5/ 08
                   20
                       08
                                      569.95
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Phosphorus removal performance remains below projections




                             105.78




3
Results of Investigations on TC-ATS?
Reduced Performance

 No improvement in treatment performance
 with reduced Linear Hydraulic Loading Rate
 Nutrient supplementation did not enhance
 algal productivity
 Tests addressing analytical discrepancies
 yielded no conclusive results
 Collaborative work with UF-IFAS and FDACS
 has not identified with certainty which
 factors are interfering with turf production
 and nutrient removal


                                                4
Whats being proposed?


 Continue investigation of water quality
 conditions impacting treatment performance
 Focus investigation on identification of
 substances deleterious to TC-ATS?
 performance
 Hydromentia will focus on identifying the
 agent or causative factor inhibiting algal
 growth
 Hydromentia will produce a final report
 describing their investigation and
 information gained from 3 years of operation

                                                5
Resolution

A Resolution of the Governing Board of the South
Florida Water Management District to authorize an
amendment to contract 3600000952 with
HydroMentia, Inc., for one additional year of
operation and maintenance of the Taylor Creek Algal
Turf Scrubber? Nutrient Recovery Facility, and
authorize a Sole Source Procurement as an
exception to the general standards of competition, to
extend the term from January 31, 2009 to January
31, 2010, and to increase funding in the total amount
of $300,000, for which Ad Valorem funds are
budgeted; providing an effective date. (Contract
Number 3600000952-A03) (David Unsell ext. 6888)




                                                        6

More Related Content

Ats Algal Turf Scrubber

  • 1. Taylor Creek Algal Turf Scrubber? (ATS?) Nutrient Recovery Facility Performance Review (Jan 2007- Aug 2008)
  • 2. TC-ATS? Operational Summary Operation began in late January 2007 Severe drought which ended in early July 2007 impacted startup operation and system performance Algal die-offs in September 2007 and May 2008 Investigations of water quality conditions and operational parameters initiated in July 2007 Causative factors remain unidentified 2
  • 3. TP lb removed 1/ 28 / 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 2/ 200 2/ 5/2 7 19 00 2/ / 20 7 2 0 3/ 6/ 20 7 1 0 3/ 1/ 2 7 1 00 3/ 9/ 20 7 26 0 7 4/ / 20 0 4/ 8/2 7 16 00 4/ / 2 7 23 00 / 7 5/ 200 5/ 7/2 7 21 00 / 7 6/ 200 6/ 3/2 7 1 00 6/ 1/ 20 7 18 0 / 7 7/ 200 2 7 7/ /20 0 7/ 9/2 7 1 00 7/ 6/ 2 7 29 00 / 7 8/ 200 8/ 6/2 7 1 00 8/ 3/ 20 7 26 0 7 9/ / 20 0 9/ 4/2 7 10 00 9/ / 2 7 2 00 10 3/ 20 7 / 0 10 1/ 2 7 0 10 / 7/ 07 / 20 10 15/2 07 /2 0 0 11 2/2 7 0 11 / 4/ 07 / 20 11 12/ 07 / 20 Date 11 19/2 07 / 0 Projected TP Load Removal C 4,000 lbs/yr 12 29/ 07 / 20 12 10/2 07 / 0 12 17/ 07 recovered-based TP load removal Phosphorus Removal Summary January 2007 through December 2008 / 2 20 7/ 07 1 / 2 00 1/ 6/2 7 1 00 1/ 3/ 20 8 2 0 1/ 0/ 20 8 28 0 8 2/ /20 0 2/ 4/2 8 1 00 2/ 7/2 8 25 00 8 3/ /200 3/ 3/2 8 (Projected TP Load Removal = 4,000 lbs/yr) 10 00 3/ /2 8 2 00 3/ 3/2 8 3 00 4/ 1/ 20 8 1 0 4/ 4/ 2 8 2 00 5/ 8/ 20 8 1 0 5/ 2/ 20 8 26 0 8 6/ / 20 0 TP Cum ulative Load Rem oved Based Upon Water Quality Calculations lb 6/ 9/2 8 23 00 8 7/ / 20 0 7/ 7/2 8 TP Cum ulative Load Rem oved Based Upon Total Solids Recovery Calculations lb 21 00 8 8 / 20 11 /4/ 08 Huge disparity between water quality-based and solids / 1 20 11 0 / 08 TC-ATS? Performance Summary / 20 12 24/2 08 /1 0 5/ 08 20 08 569.95 Phosphorus removal performance remains below projections 105.78 3
  • 4. Results of Investigations on TC-ATS? Reduced Performance No improvement in treatment performance with reduced Linear Hydraulic Loading Rate Nutrient supplementation did not enhance algal productivity Tests addressing analytical discrepancies yielded no conclusive results Collaborative work with UF-IFAS and FDACS has not identified with certainty which factors are interfering with turf production and nutrient removal 4
  • 5. Whats being proposed? Continue investigation of water quality conditions impacting treatment performance Focus investigation on identification of substances deleterious to TC-ATS? performance Hydromentia will focus on identifying the agent or causative factor inhibiting algal growth Hydromentia will produce a final report describing their investigation and information gained from 3 years of operation 5
  • 6. Resolution A Resolution of the Governing Board of the South Florida Water Management District to authorize an amendment to contract 3600000952 with HydroMentia, Inc., for one additional year of operation and maintenance of the Taylor Creek Algal Turf Scrubber? Nutrient Recovery Facility, and authorize a Sole Source Procurement as an exception to the general standards of competition, to extend the term from January 31, 2009 to January 31, 2010, and to increase funding in the total amount of $300,000, for which Ad Valorem funds are budgeted; providing an effective date. (Contract Number 3600000952-A03) (David Unsell ext. 6888) 6