際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Underwater Gelidium harvest off southwest Portugal - 1999
Back to basics
Global shortage of bacteriological
and technical agars
Ricardo Melo + Rui Santos
Nature 528: 171172
(December 10th, 2015)
Microbiologys most important
reagent is in short supply, with
potential consequences for research,
public health and clinical labs around
the world.
already pushed wholesale prices of
agar to an all-time high of around
US$3545 per kilogram  nearly
triple the price before scarcities
began.
by Ewen Callaway
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 2
doi: 10.1038/528171a
 Gelidium
 Pterocladia/
Pterocladiella
 Gelidiella
 Gracilaria
Geography of commercial agarophytes
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 3
Our we told you so moment!
 ISS XIX  2007, Japan  Global Gelidium resource
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 4
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
16000
18000
20000
1980s 1990s 2000s
Decades
Landings(tdw)
South Africa
Chile
Mexico
Indonesia
Portugal
Japan
South Korea
Morocco
Spain
ISS XIX  2007, Japan (cont.)
 Global Gelidium production in 3 preceding decades
  16 000 t (dw)
 Stable in South Africa, Chile, Mexico, South Korea
 Collapsed in Indonesia, Portugal, Japan, Spain
 But, how sustainable this level of production?
 Maintained by Moroccos very increased landings
 Representing 73% of world landings
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 5
Our present objective is to:
 Compile available disseminated information
 More and better data communication
 Identify bottlenecks and sustainability problems
 Boost renewed attention to Gelidium resources
 Historical producer countries & others
 Disseminate a low cost stock assessment method
 Based on harvest effort statistics
 Effective use of harvest logbooks
 Coaching of harvesters for sustainability
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 6
Mean decadal landings (t ww)
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 7
Global Gelidium resource
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 8
 Has been in decline since 1960s peak
 Dramatic drop in the 2010s
 Production less than 50% of peak value
 Business as usual?
2010s mean harvest 
pre-WW II situation *
* 1940
Other take-home ideas
 Steady increase of Moroccos global share
 From 20% in the 60s up to 70% in the new century
 Global market virtually depends on sole
supplier
 Fluctuations should have DISPROPORTIONATE effect
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 9
Case study: Morocco (1)
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 10
Case study: Morocco (2)
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 11
Morocco: updated management
 Gelidium harvest
 Interdiction: October 1st  June 30th
 Only beach cast harvest, no plucking, no night harvest
 In 2010 limit was 5440 t in 2010, 6040 t in 2014
 Traceability system for Gelidium and agar commerce
 Export licence regime for Gelidium and agar
 Restrictive export quotas enforced
 Only 20% of Gelidium production
 80% must be processed in-country (Setexam, K辿nitra)
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 12
Santos, Cristo & Jesus 2003
 Describe stock assessment of Gelidium resource
based on harvest effort information
 Low cost compared with common standing stock
evaluations involving scientific diving
 Analysis of harvest effort data is highly informative
 But:
 Information on sea conditions for each harvest day must
be included to improve logbook data
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 13
Gelidium corneum harvest in Portugal: yearly
variation of harvest yield, total harvest effort, and
seasonal CPUE (Santos et al. 2003)
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 14
Training and coaching is a must
 Harvesters need to understand:
 How logbook data will be used
 The importance of providing accurate records
 Managers and scientists have to:
 Better communicate with harvesters
 Illustrate how the information obtained from harvest
effort data is to be used
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 15
Gelidium corneum harvest in Portugal: yearly
variation of standing stock, harvest yield, exploitation
rate, and catchability (Santos et al. 2003)
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 16
Data harvesting
 A difficult task finding statistical data on agarophyte harvest!
 Also complicated assessing the quality of those data!
 On-line fisheries data from governmental and research
institutions, trade associations, international experts
 Many individual researchers and friends were of great help
Previous reports by Santelices (1988), Santos and Duarte (1991), Melo et al.
(1991), Melo (1998, 2002), McHugh (2003), and Santos et al. (2003) review harvest
methods, fisheries statistics, cultivation attempts, and stock assessment of
Gelidium species
21/06/16 Melo + Santos 17
Thank you!
Jo達o Mariano  Photography
www.joaomariano.com
Antonieta Pedroso  Illustration
pantonieta@gmail.com

More Related Content

Back to basics: Global shortage of bacteriological agar

  • 1. Underwater Gelidium harvest off southwest Portugal - 1999
  • 2. Back to basics Global shortage of bacteriological and technical agars Ricardo Melo + Rui Santos
  • 3. Nature 528: 171172 (December 10th, 2015) Microbiologys most important reagent is in short supply, with potential consequences for research, public health and clinical labs around the world. already pushed wholesale prices of agar to an all-time high of around US$3545 per kilogram nearly triple the price before scarcities began. by Ewen Callaway 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 2 doi: 10.1038/528171a
  • 4. Gelidium Pterocladia/ Pterocladiella Gelidiella Gracilaria Geography of commercial agarophytes 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 3
  • 5. Our we told you so moment! ISS XIX 2007, Japan Global Gelidium resource 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 4 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000 18000 20000 1980s 1990s 2000s Decades Landings(tdw) South Africa Chile Mexico Indonesia Portugal Japan South Korea Morocco Spain
  • 6. ISS XIX 2007, Japan (cont.) Global Gelidium production in 3 preceding decades 16 000 t (dw) Stable in South Africa, Chile, Mexico, South Korea Collapsed in Indonesia, Portugal, Japan, Spain But, how sustainable this level of production? Maintained by Moroccos very increased landings Representing 73% of world landings 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 5
  • 7. Our present objective is to: Compile available disseminated information More and better data communication Identify bottlenecks and sustainability problems Boost renewed attention to Gelidium resources Historical producer countries & others Disseminate a low cost stock assessment method Based on harvest effort statistics Effective use of harvest logbooks Coaching of harvesters for sustainability 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 6
  • 8. Mean decadal landings (t ww) 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 7
  • 9. Global Gelidium resource 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 8 Has been in decline since 1960s peak Dramatic drop in the 2010s Production less than 50% of peak value Business as usual? 2010s mean harvest pre-WW II situation * * 1940
  • 10. Other take-home ideas Steady increase of Moroccos global share From 20% in the 60s up to 70% in the new century Global market virtually depends on sole supplier Fluctuations should have DISPROPORTIONATE effect 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 9
  • 11. Case study: Morocco (1) 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 10
  • 12. Case study: Morocco (2) 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 11
  • 13. Morocco: updated management Gelidium harvest Interdiction: October 1st June 30th Only beach cast harvest, no plucking, no night harvest In 2010 limit was 5440 t in 2010, 6040 t in 2014 Traceability system for Gelidium and agar commerce Export licence regime for Gelidium and agar Restrictive export quotas enforced Only 20% of Gelidium production 80% must be processed in-country (Setexam, K辿nitra) 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 12
  • 14. Santos, Cristo & Jesus 2003 Describe stock assessment of Gelidium resource based on harvest effort information Low cost compared with common standing stock evaluations involving scientific diving Analysis of harvest effort data is highly informative But: Information on sea conditions for each harvest day must be included to improve logbook data 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 13
  • 15. Gelidium corneum harvest in Portugal: yearly variation of harvest yield, total harvest effort, and seasonal CPUE (Santos et al. 2003) 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 14
  • 16. Training and coaching is a must Harvesters need to understand: How logbook data will be used The importance of providing accurate records Managers and scientists have to: Better communicate with harvesters Illustrate how the information obtained from harvest effort data is to be used 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 15
  • 17. Gelidium corneum harvest in Portugal: yearly variation of standing stock, harvest yield, exploitation rate, and catchability (Santos et al. 2003) 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 16
  • 18. Data harvesting A difficult task finding statistical data on agarophyte harvest! Also complicated assessing the quality of those data! On-line fisheries data from governmental and research institutions, trade associations, international experts Many individual researchers and friends were of great help Previous reports by Santelices (1988), Santos and Duarte (1991), Melo et al. (1991), Melo (1998, 2002), McHugh (2003), and Santos et al. (2003) review harvest methods, fisheries statistics, cultivation attempts, and stock assessment of Gelidium species 21/06/16 Melo + Santos 17
  • 19. Thank you! Jo達o Mariano Photography www.joaomariano.com Antonieta Pedroso Illustration pantonieta@gmail.com

Editor's Notes

  • #2: www.joaomariano.com
  • #12: Comparaison des densit辿s de biomasses de G.sesquipedale durant les ann辿es 1999-2010-2011-2012 et 2013 Les r辿sultats obtenus montrent synth辿tiquement: (i) Une diminution de la biomasse moyenne du Gelidium de 57% par rapport 1999 et de 36% par rapport 2012; (ii) Un braconnage intensif (collecte avant louverture de la campagne) et une d辿gradation de lhabitat du Gelidium (destruction du substrat rocheux dont elle est particuli竪rement tributaire); (iii) Une biomasse moyenne de H. incurvus qui d辿passe celle du G辿lidium. Ainsi, lINRH souligne, une fois encore, limportance du respect de la p辿riode du repos biologique de lagarophyte G. sesquipedale, et de la sensibilisation des exploitants sur la n辿cessit辿 vitale de la protection de son habitat. Leffet conjugu辿 de ces deux facteurs (non-respect de la r辿glementation et la d辿gradation de lhabitat) est lorigine de la chute de la biomasse de Gelidium et en parall竪le, une conqu棚te de son espace par lesp竪ce comp辿titive Halopithys incurvus commence prendre de lampleur.
  • #13: DIR. RG. CASABLANCA, SAFI, LAAYOUNE / Fishing Ports / Fishing villages / Landing sites
  • #14: MAPM 1905-10 29th June 2010
  • #16: The most important limiting factors for Gelidium sesquipedale harvest effort, and thus for harvest yield, which was highly correlated with effort, were bad sea conditions and low standing stocks.