The document discusses the 1984 Bhopal gas tragedy in India, where a leak of methyl isocyanate gas from a Union Carbide pesticide plant in Bhopal killed thousands. It provides background on the plant, notes that the toxic gas phosgene had previously killed an employee, and that production of methyl isocyanate began in 1980. It also discusses the aftermath of the disaster, with hospitals overwhelmed, and Union Carbide blaming employee sabotage while locals felt the company had neglected safety.
22. Who do you think was responsible
for the incident?
41. Solution
• Indian Government and UCC both were
responsible
• Indian government - twisted laws – no
infrastructure to back it
• UCC - cost cutting - neglected the safety of its
employees and that of others.
42. Who should have had jurisdiction
over this case? Was US Federal
court right?
43. Solution
Jurisdiction with India
- Inconvenience of witness and evidence
- No US citizen present
- Shared Jurisdiction ïƒ not an option
- Records and manuals in Hindi
- No contract between UCC and UCIL.