際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Maternal effects reveal
species niche dimensions
Rachel M. Germain and Benjamin Gilbert
Dept. Ecology & Evolutionary Biology, U. Toronto
Why are there so many kinds of [species]?
-G. E. Hutchinson 1958
Answer: Environmental variation
Temporal environmental variation
promotes diversity
Assumption: species demographic parameters in current conditions are independent
of conditions experienced in the previous generation
Figure modified from Levine & Rees 2002
Variable Constant
The presence of maternal effects violates
this assumption
good year bad yearseed
Galloway 2005, Sultan et al. 2006, Dyer et al. 2010, Germain et al. 2013
The presence of maternal effects violates
this assumption
good year bad year
reinforcing numeric responses
seed
Galloway 2005, Sultan et al. 2006, Dyer et al. 2010, Germain et al. 2013
The presence of maternal effects violates
this assumption
good year bad year
counteracting numeric responses
seed
Galloway 2005, Sultan et al. 2006, Dyer et al. 2010, Germain et al. 2013
The presence of maternal effects violates
this assumption
good year bad yearseed
All existing tests have:
1. included  3 species only
2. controlled for genotypic differences among
individuals
Problem: It is not known how common maternal effects
are in biological communities
How common are maternal effects, and how do
they compare to regular numeric responses?
Study system: Mediterranean annual plants
hyper-diverse  variable rainfall  many annual species
Papaver dubium
Nemophila menziesii
Uropappus lindleyi
Vulpia microstachysSalvia columbariae
Lasthenia californica
Greenhouse experiment
30 species x 2 envts (wet and dry) x 7
pots
= total 420 pots
each pot population of ~8 individuals
enumerated seed number, mass per
seed, and % seed dormancy
gls: x ~ ME*species
30 species x 2 envts (wet and dry) x 7
pots
= total 420 pots
each pot population of ~8 individuals
enumerated seed number, mass per
seed, and % seed dormancy
gls: x ~ ME*species
Greenhouse experiment
Raised the offspring generation under similar conditions for first three weeks of
growth, measured aboveground biomass as performance measure
30 species x 2 envts (wet and dry) x 7
pots
= total 420 pots
each pot population of ~8 individuals
enumerated seed number, mass per
seed, and % seed dormancy
gls: x ~ ME*species
*P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10
Orienting slide
 Seed size
 Seed number
maternal effect
regular numeric effects
Orienting slide
 Seed size
 Seed number
*P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10
Orienting slide
 Seed size
 Seed number
* = significant response
*P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10
Orienting slide
 Seed size
 Seed number
*P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10
Result 1: seed size and seed number
responses occurred in similar frequencies
 Seed size
 Seed number
six species
five species
*P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10
Result 2: seed size but not seed number
responses were bidirectional
 Seed size
 Seed number
*P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10
non-sig. ME effect
sig. ME effect
Result 3: no species responded through
both seed size and seed number
 Seed size
 Seed number
*P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10
Result 4: seed size responses are
phylogenetically convergent
 Seed size
K = 0.09, P = 0.057
*P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10
Results summary
Maternal effects:
 occurred as or more frequently than seed number
responses
 exhibited a fuller range of responses than seed
number
 were only observed in species that did not
respond through seed number
 were phylogenetically convergent
Results summary
Maternal effects:
 occurred as or more frequently than seed number
responses
 exhibited a fuller range of responses than seed
number
 were only observed in species that did not
respond through seed number
 were phylogenetically convergent
Take home message
Maternal effects are common, and should be
considered by ecologists
Germain, R. M. and B. Gilbert. (2014). Ecology Letters 17: 662-669
Acknowledgements
Jason Weir
The Gilbert Lab
Both Alexs
Some of my cats
Bruce Hall
Andrew Petri
Webpage: rgermain.wordpress.com
Email: rachel.germain@mail.utoronto.ca
Chris Blackford
Alanna Leale
Ally Mushka
Rosemary Martin
Yvonne Chan
Alicia Hou
Kevin Hawkshaw
Mags Ngo
Seed size-seed number correlations
Germain & Gilbert 2014 Eco Lett
Seed dormancy responses to the maternal
environment vary across species
Germain & Gilbert 2014 Eco Lett
Seed size effects on offspring
performance
r = 0.11, P = 0.047
Germain & Gilbert 2014 Eco Lett

More Related Content

Botany 2014 Boise, ID

  • 1. Maternal effects reveal species niche dimensions Rachel M. Germain and Benjamin Gilbert Dept. Ecology & Evolutionary Biology, U. Toronto
  • 2. Why are there so many kinds of [species]? -G. E. Hutchinson 1958 Answer: Environmental variation
  • 3. Temporal environmental variation promotes diversity Assumption: species demographic parameters in current conditions are independent of conditions experienced in the previous generation Figure modified from Levine & Rees 2002 Variable Constant
  • 4. The presence of maternal effects violates this assumption good year bad yearseed Galloway 2005, Sultan et al. 2006, Dyer et al. 2010, Germain et al. 2013
  • 5. The presence of maternal effects violates this assumption good year bad year reinforcing numeric responses seed Galloway 2005, Sultan et al. 2006, Dyer et al. 2010, Germain et al. 2013
  • 6. The presence of maternal effects violates this assumption good year bad year counteracting numeric responses seed Galloway 2005, Sultan et al. 2006, Dyer et al. 2010, Germain et al. 2013
  • 7. The presence of maternal effects violates this assumption good year bad yearseed
  • 8. All existing tests have: 1. included 3 species only 2. controlled for genotypic differences among individuals Problem: It is not known how common maternal effects are in biological communities
  • 9. How common are maternal effects, and how do they compare to regular numeric responses?
  • 10. Study system: Mediterranean annual plants hyper-diverse variable rainfall many annual species Papaver dubium Nemophila menziesii Uropappus lindleyi Vulpia microstachysSalvia columbariae Lasthenia californica
  • 11. Greenhouse experiment 30 species x 2 envts (wet and dry) x 7 pots = total 420 pots each pot population of ~8 individuals enumerated seed number, mass per seed, and % seed dormancy gls: x ~ ME*species
  • 12. 30 species x 2 envts (wet and dry) x 7 pots = total 420 pots each pot population of ~8 individuals enumerated seed number, mass per seed, and % seed dormancy gls: x ~ ME*species Greenhouse experiment Raised the offspring generation under similar conditions for first three weeks of growth, measured aboveground biomass as performance measure 30 species x 2 envts (wet and dry) x 7 pots = total 420 pots each pot population of ~8 individuals enumerated seed number, mass per seed, and % seed dormancy gls: x ~ ME*species
  • 13. *P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10 Orienting slide Seed size Seed number maternal effect regular numeric effects
  • 14. Orienting slide Seed size Seed number *P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10
  • 15. Orienting slide Seed size Seed number * = significant response *P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10
  • 16. Orienting slide Seed size Seed number *P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10
  • 17. Result 1: seed size and seed number responses occurred in similar frequencies Seed size Seed number six species five species *P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10
  • 18. Result 2: seed size but not seed number responses were bidirectional Seed size Seed number *P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10 non-sig. ME effect sig. ME effect
  • 19. Result 3: no species responded through both seed size and seed number Seed size Seed number *P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10
  • 20. Result 4: seed size responses are phylogenetically convergent Seed size K = 0.09, P = 0.057 *P < 0.05, 属P < 0.10
  • 21. Results summary Maternal effects: occurred as or more frequently than seed number responses exhibited a fuller range of responses than seed number were only observed in species that did not respond through seed number were phylogenetically convergent
  • 22. Results summary Maternal effects: occurred as or more frequently than seed number responses exhibited a fuller range of responses than seed number were only observed in species that did not respond through seed number were phylogenetically convergent
  • 23. Take home message Maternal effects are common, and should be considered by ecologists Germain, R. M. and B. Gilbert. (2014). Ecology Letters 17: 662-669
  • 24. Acknowledgements Jason Weir The Gilbert Lab Both Alexs Some of my cats Bruce Hall Andrew Petri Webpage: rgermain.wordpress.com Email: rachel.germain@mail.utoronto.ca Chris Blackford Alanna Leale Ally Mushka Rosemary Martin Yvonne Chan Alicia Hou Kevin Hawkshaw Mags Ngo
  • 25. Seed size-seed number correlations Germain & Gilbert 2014 Eco Lett
  • 26. Seed dormancy responses to the maternal environment vary across species Germain & Gilbert 2014 Eco Lett
  • 27. Seed size effects on offspring performance r = 0.11, P = 0.047 Germain & Gilbert 2014 Eco Lett

Editor's Notes

  1. I am a community ecologist, and as a community ecologist, I am interested in the mechanisms that maintain species diversity in nature, or as Hutchinson put it, why are there so many kinds of species? Here three plots from the same site, but have no species in common. Many ways to answer this question, all of which are valid, but a major one is what environmental heterogeneity.can see this here with soil colour Environmental heterogeneity promotes species diversity An answer, one answer
  2. A lot of work into how species respond to temporal variability; strong focus on how environmental variability affects seed production, and how those responses affect Doesnt matter if your parents experienced a stressful environment or not, that will not change how you respond to your environment Net decrease in diversity
  3. The presence of maternal effects violates this assumption. In plants and animals, it is well known that the environment not only affects the quantity of offspring produced, but also the quality of those offspring, which can in turn affect the number of demographic parameters in the offspring.
  4. Sometimes these maternal effects can reinforce regular numeric effects, larger seeds in addition to more
  5. Sometimes they can counteract then, smaller seeds when conditions improve; directly affect demographic parameters such as germination, dormancy, growth rate, competitive ability etc.
  6. And if you have species competing in a community, some with no ME, reinforcing Mes, or counteracting MEs, you can imagine that the population dynamics and competitive outcomes of these communities will be quite different than those with no maternal effects. The effects are likely large, and Ive actually done some modelling work to confirm this
  7. Although there are many examples of maternal effects in both plant and animal taxa, all existing tests have included less than 3 species and often control for genotypic differences amongst individuals. genetic mechanisms and possible evolution of these effects, but it is not known how common they are in biological communities, and if the strong responses identified at the genotypic level are swamped by population-level variation Problem: The prevalence.we dontknow
  8. regular numeric responses such as seed number -
  9. Ecologically relevant assemblage of species; mediterranean regions in general, but also contain high numbers of annual plants lifetime reproduction can be measured in a single growing season after germinating, annuals only have one shot at Important caveat that commercially obtained seed, rather than -picture of meiterranean plant community, put key words at bottom as bullet points?
  10. Hide bars first Highlight 4 aspects Results Example Results template Layout
  11. 4 aspects of these results that I want to emphasize
  12. 4 aspects of these results that I want to emphasize
  13. put result as its own slide, and highlight phylogenetic relatednessactually significantly clustered
  14. Seed number decreased by 85% on average in response to dry environments
  15. Seed number are not
  16. Ecologists are currently ignoring half of the ways in which species are responding to the environment
  17. Ecologists are currently ignoring half of the ways in which species are responding to the environment Suggests that these seed size responses may contribute to phylogenetic patterns across the landscape, which is a major focus of my current research
  18. The takehome messagethe one thing you need to remember, is that maternal effects are common, and should be considered by ecologists as a source of species-specific responses to environmental variation.
  19. Maternal environment singificant effect on seedling height P = 0.0001