際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Professor Katrina Pritchard
&
Dr Helen Williams
School of Management, Swansea University
Summer Sessions
Qualitative Research Support
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
About us
Advanced
Qualitative
Methods
Leadership
Teaching
UG, PGT &
MBA
Gendered
expectations
as & at
work
Podcast:
Prefer not
to say
Inequalities
In
Entrepreneurship
Negotiating
Difference
At
Work
Based at
Swansea University
Exploring complex identities
at work
Research funding from
Swansea University
CIPD
ISBE
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
1. The Coding and Analysis Process
2. What is coding?
 What is a code?
 Introduction to coding techniques
 Coding exercise 1
 Coding exercise 2
3. What is Analysis
 Overview of different analytic approaches
 Analytic Exercise (Reflexive Thematic Analysis)
 Importance of piloting and trying different approaches out
What To Expect
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Break-out discussion:
1. Individually, note down three  five (or more)
challenges you have with coding and analysis?
2. As a group, discuss your common challenges and be
prepared to share these with the room.
The Coding and Analytic Process
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Part 1: The Coding and Analytic Process
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
The Coding and Analysis Process
Transcripts Contribution
Prep &
anonymising
data (i.e.,
textual, visual)
Initial data
review
Initial coding
stages
Codes are
organised
Organised
codes are
grouped into
common
themes
Themes are
organised and
developed
Themes are
written up as
initial
findings
Analysis is
written
up/specific
data further
analysed
Data management, GDPR, security
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Before you even begin the analytic stages
of your research, a lot of work needs to
take place.
Your analysis is only as good as the data
you collect!
There are many different forms of data!
We tend to rely on textual data (but there
are many other forms)
Thinking About Your Data
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA-NC
A Useful Baking Analogy
Much like baking a cake, a finished qualitative
analysis is a combination of lots of different
ingredients (data), skills and processes.
The cake is not existent prior to it being baked!
The cake will be different depending on how you
choose to bake it.
Braun & Clarke (2016)
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Quick
Overview:
Ordering
Data
 Induction, deduction, and abduction are forms of (logical-ish)
reasoning that are used in every type of research (qualitative and
quantitative alike)
 These forms of thinking are not concepts, nor are they methods or
tools of data analysis, but means of connecting and generating
ideas. They represent the intellectual building blocks of research.
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Part 2. Coding Data
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Is it a Code or a Theme?
Codes
 An analytic unit
 Captures narrow observations
or labels specific entities in
your data (people, places,
objects etc.)
 One-dimensional (mostly!)
 Thin on meaning
Themes
 An analytic basket
 Capture multiple aspects and
facets
 Capture multiple meanings
in your data (formed from
codes)
 Help to organise aspects of
data in ways to link to your
research questions
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Coding is a critical step in organising
qualitative data
Provides an organised means to
begin engagement with data
Committing to the careful,
systematic analysis of all relevant
reports and observations
Why Code?
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
 Coding involves systematically reviewing data and searching for aspects
that appear interesting, relevant, provoking  in relation to the (research)
question  and then writing brief descriptions (codes) next to them.
 Coding provides a foundation for insight because  when done well - it
requires purposeful, critical engagement with the data.
 Coding is a systematic interrogation of the data, identifying meaning and
patterns across the dataset (this is often seen a means of achieving rigour).
We must always recognise the role and subjectivity of the analyst!
What is Coding?
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Key question:
Does this person take the time to get to know and understand others in order to
build relationships with a broad range of people?
Deductive Coding
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
What is coding inductively?
Descriptive
Coding
 features, types, tropes, stylistic/linguistic
features, juxtapositions/tensions, etc.
Organising
Descriptive
Codes
 Labels/topics/types of
material
Connecting
Codes to
Research
 Grouping codes around
common meanings
Creating
Substantive
Codes
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
 In (truly) inductive research often your coding is done
around a central organising concept
 Often this is framed by your research question
 You are not coding to a predefined set of agreed
patterns or indicators (often called a codebook).
Inductive Coding
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Frequency
Repetition
Juxtapositions/tensions/linguistic anomalies
Use of metaphor(s)
Sequences
Absences
Essentially you are looking at:
 1) What is the individual talking about?
 2) How is the individual talking about it?
 3) Why is the individual talking about it in that way?
Starting Off: What to look for?
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Take look at Transcript 1.
Now code the data with the following research
question in mind:
How do managers experiences loss at work?
Coding Exercise
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Part 3: Data Analysis
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
The Role of Research Positionality
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Realism Relativism
Objectivism Subjectivism
Pragmatism
Critical Realism
Interpretivism
Constructivism
Ontology
Epistemology
Qualitative
Quantitative
Phenomenology
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
 Discourse/Discursive Approaches
 Narrative Approaches
 Reflexive Thematic Approaches
 Content Approaches*
(often routed in positivist assumptions)
 Thematic Approaches
 Grounded Approaches (supposedly abductive)
 Phenomenological Approaches
Types of Analysis
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Stage Process
1 Familiarisation
2 Coding
3 Develop initial themes
4 Further develop and refine themes
5 Refine, define, label (name) themes
6 Writing up your work (tell the story of your participants)
Reflexive Thematic Analysis (Braun & Clarke, 2021)
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
IPAs Six-stage Analytic Process
IPAs six-stage analytic process (Eatough & Smith, 2017; Smith et al., 2022)
Stage Process
1 Read and re-read transcripts to get to know the data
2 Make initial notes to systematically capture observations
3 Develop initial themes for each case
4 Search for connections across initial themes within the case
5 Move to next case
6
Identify connections and patterns across all cases (once above steps completed for each
case)
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Doing Analysis (RTA)
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Using free macros to support coding
DOWNLOAD THE MACRO:
Babbage, D. R., & Terry, G. (2023, April
19). Thematic analysis coding
management macro.
https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/ZA7B6
(ALWAYS CITE THIS IN YOUR WORK)
WATCH OUR VIDEO WITH A STEP BY
STEP GUIDE:
https://wordpress.com/page/breakingbinaries
research.wordpress.com/480
USE TRACK
CHANGES
COMMENTS IN
WORD TO CODE
AND ADD NOTES
TO YOUR DATA
RUN THE MACRO TO CREATE
AN EXCEL SPREADSHEET OF
YOUR CODES AND NOTES
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Data triangulation?
Member checking?
Multiple coders may, however, be beneficial in a reflexive
manner (e.g., to sense-check ideas, or to explore multiple
assumptions or interpretations of the data).
If analysis does involve more than one researcher, the approach
should be collaborative and reflexive, aiming to achieve richer
interpretations of meaning, rather than attempting to achieve
consensus of meaning.
Validity, Rigour, and Reliability?
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
Too many themes (which are focused on single
units of meaning  i.e., codes being used as
themes)
Thin descriptions (often only capturing high-level
semantic and/or literal meanings)
One word themes
Beware Analytic Foreclosure
(Connelly & Peltzer, 2016)
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
@ProfKPritchard
@HelenCWilliams
@BreakBinaries
helen.c.williams@swansea.ac.uk
k.l.pritchard@swansea.ac.uk

More Related Content

Breaking Binaries Research Session on Coding and Analysis

  • 1. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Professor Katrina Pritchard & Dr Helen Williams School of Management, Swansea University Summer Sessions Qualitative Research Support
  • 2. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. About us Advanced Qualitative Methods Leadership Teaching UG, PGT & MBA Gendered expectations as & at work Podcast: Prefer not to say Inequalities In Entrepreneurship Negotiating Difference At Work Based at Swansea University Exploring complex identities at work Research funding from Swansea University CIPD ISBE
  • 3. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. 1. The Coding and Analysis Process 2. What is coding? What is a code? Introduction to coding techniques Coding exercise 1 Coding exercise 2 3. What is Analysis Overview of different analytic approaches Analytic Exercise (Reflexive Thematic Analysis) Importance of piloting and trying different approaches out What To Expect
  • 4. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Break-out discussion: 1. Individually, note down three five (or more) challenges you have with coding and analysis? 2. As a group, discuss your common challenges and be prepared to share these with the room. The Coding and Analytic Process
  • 5. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Part 1: The Coding and Analytic Process
  • 6. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. The Coding and Analysis Process Transcripts Contribution Prep & anonymising data (i.e., textual, visual) Initial data review Initial coding stages Codes are organised Organised codes are grouped into common themes Themes are organised and developed Themes are written up as initial findings Analysis is written up/specific data further analysed Data management, GDPR, security
  • 7. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Before you even begin the analytic stages of your research, a lot of work needs to take place. Your analysis is only as good as the data you collect! There are many different forms of data! We tend to rely on textual data (but there are many other forms) Thinking About Your Data
  • 8. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA-NC A Useful Baking Analogy Much like baking a cake, a finished qualitative analysis is a combination of lots of different ingredients (data), skills and processes. The cake is not existent prior to it being baked! The cake will be different depending on how you choose to bake it. Braun & Clarke (2016)
  • 9. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Quick Overview: Ordering Data Induction, deduction, and abduction are forms of (logical-ish) reasoning that are used in every type of research (qualitative and quantitative alike) These forms of thinking are not concepts, nor are they methods or tools of data analysis, but means of connecting and generating ideas. They represent the intellectual building blocks of research. This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC
  • 10. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Part 2. Coding Data
  • 11. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Is it a Code or a Theme? Codes An analytic unit Captures narrow observations or labels specific entities in your data (people, places, objects etc.) One-dimensional (mostly!) Thin on meaning Themes An analytic basket Capture multiple aspects and facets Capture multiple meanings in your data (formed from codes) Help to organise aspects of data in ways to link to your research questions
  • 12. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Coding is a critical step in organising qualitative data Provides an organised means to begin engagement with data Committing to the careful, systematic analysis of all relevant reports and observations Why Code? This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY
  • 13. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Coding involves systematically reviewing data and searching for aspects that appear interesting, relevant, provoking in relation to the (research) question and then writing brief descriptions (codes) next to them. Coding provides a foundation for insight because when done well - it requires purposeful, critical engagement with the data. Coding is a systematic interrogation of the data, identifying meaning and patterns across the dataset (this is often seen a means of achieving rigour). We must always recognise the role and subjectivity of the analyst! What is Coding?
  • 14. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Key question: Does this person take the time to get to know and understand others in order to build relationships with a broad range of people? Deductive Coding
  • 15. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. What is coding inductively? Descriptive Coding features, types, tropes, stylistic/linguistic features, juxtapositions/tensions, etc. Organising Descriptive Codes Labels/topics/types of material Connecting Codes to Research Grouping codes around common meanings Creating Substantive Codes
  • 16. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. In (truly) inductive research often your coding is done around a central organising concept Often this is framed by your research question You are not coding to a predefined set of agreed patterns or indicators (often called a codebook). Inductive Coding
  • 17. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Frequency Repetition Juxtapositions/tensions/linguistic anomalies Use of metaphor(s) Sequences Absences Essentially you are looking at: 1) What is the individual talking about? 2) How is the individual talking about it? 3) Why is the individual talking about it in that way? Starting Off: What to look for?
  • 18. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Take look at Transcript 1. Now code the data with the following research question in mind: How do managers experiences loss at work? Coding Exercise
  • 19. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Part 3: Data Analysis
  • 20. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. The Role of Research Positionality 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Realism Relativism Objectivism Subjectivism Pragmatism Critical Realism Interpretivism Constructivism Ontology Epistemology Qualitative Quantitative Phenomenology
  • 21. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Discourse/Discursive Approaches Narrative Approaches Reflexive Thematic Approaches Content Approaches* (often routed in positivist assumptions) Thematic Approaches Grounded Approaches (supposedly abductive) Phenomenological Approaches Types of Analysis
  • 22. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Stage Process 1 Familiarisation 2 Coding 3 Develop initial themes 4 Further develop and refine themes 5 Refine, define, label (name) themes 6 Writing up your work (tell the story of your participants) Reflexive Thematic Analysis (Braun & Clarke, 2021)
  • 23. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. IPAs Six-stage Analytic Process IPAs six-stage analytic process (Eatough & Smith, 2017; Smith et al., 2022) Stage Process 1 Read and re-read transcripts to get to know the data 2 Make initial notes to systematically capture observations 3 Develop initial themes for each case 4 Search for connections across initial themes within the case 5 Move to next case 6 Identify connections and patterns across all cases (once above steps completed for each case)
  • 24. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Doing Analysis (RTA)
  • 25. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Using free macros to support coding DOWNLOAD THE MACRO: Babbage, D. R., & Terry, G. (2023, April 19). Thematic analysis coding management macro. https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/ZA7B6 (ALWAYS CITE THIS IN YOUR WORK) WATCH OUR VIDEO WITH A STEP BY STEP GUIDE: https://wordpress.com/page/breakingbinaries research.wordpress.com/480 USE TRACK CHANGES COMMENTS IN WORD TO CODE AND ADD NOTES TO YOUR DATA RUN THE MACRO TO CREATE AN EXCEL SPREADSHEET OF YOUR CODES AND NOTES
  • 26. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Data triangulation? Member checking? Multiple coders may, however, be beneficial in a reflexive manner (e.g., to sense-check ideas, or to explore multiple assumptions or interpretations of the data). If analysis does involve more than one researcher, the approach should be collaborative and reflexive, aiming to achieve richer interpretations of meaning, rather than attempting to achieve consensus of meaning. Validity, Rigour, and Reliability?
  • 27. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. Too many themes (which are focused on single units of meaning i.e., codes being used as themes) Thin descriptions (often only capturing high-level semantic and/or literal meanings) One word themes Beware Analytic Foreclosure (Connelly & Peltzer, 2016)
  • 28. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved.
  • 29. 息 2023 Breaking Binaries Research. All rights reserved. @ProfKPritchard @HelenCWilliams @BreakBinaries helen.c.williams@swansea.ac.uk k.l.pritchard@swansea.ac.uk

Editor's Notes

  • #14: Committing to the careful, systematic analysis of all relevant reports and observations; Coming to a descriptive-interpretive understanding of experiences and observations by carefully representing their meanings; Enable us to organizing these understandings into clusters of similar experiences and observations Integrating categories into some kind of coherent story and contribution (empirical and/or theoretical).