ºÝºÝߣ

ºÝºÝߣShare a Scribd company logo
Brooke Murray-Carter
German Culture Through Film
Ingeborg Majer-O'Sickey
Good Bye, Lenin! Film Review
Paper #5
12/18/2012
Brooke Carter
Paper 5
12/18/2012
¡°Favorite of Film Festivals to Families: Good Bye, Lenin!¡±
An important geopolitical atmosphere developed while Allied occupation occurred in Germany
after WWII that helped result in the split of West and East effectively producing a nation caught in an
identity crisis as the western capitalist system had to engulf the eastern socialists. Given the difficult
and even bizarre situation of the peaceful reunification of Germany in 1989 some natural tensions
between the diverse cultures would of course prove problematic. How better to relate an awkward
collaboration between two distinct ideological systems than through a tear-jerking drama/comedy
dripping with a sarcasm so oblivious that it becomes an intricate and hilarious satire in Wolfgang
Becker's Good Bye, Lenin (2003)!
The Kerner family is introduced to the audience by the oblivious narrator and son Alex who
remarks first upon his cosmological aspirations to go to space, his father leaving to the west with his
enemy-of-the-state girlfriend, and then his mother who becomes dedicated to the socialist fatherland
after this crushing news. Alex Kerner (Daniel Bruhl) is the typical eastern German teenager who is put
in a conundrum when his beloved mother, Christiane (Katrin Sab), falls into a heart attack for eight
months during the period of 1989-90 after seeing him taking part in a protest against the communist
government. During the period of Christiane's coma the Iron Curtain falls and capitalism is put in affect
in the east; radically changing the lives of all Eastern Germans drastically from the simple such as
Spreewald pickles to a whole new western currency. Christiane awakens after this period but under the
risk of another heart attack if she receives any shock because of this Alex convinces his family, friends,
and girlfriend to keep up the ruse that the GDR still maintains the East to comfort his mother in her last
days.
Fitting in with other films such as The Lives of Others(2006) and Life is Beautiful (1997), Good
Bye, Lenin! incorporates an element of universality by incorporating a family structure attempting to
cope with a changing political world which they have no control over. This clever approach in applying
a tragic family's experience allows anyone to openly enjoy this film which will become an even richer
experience if you can get in on the inside cultural jokes that are making constant political commentary.
Coke's formula has been invented in East Germany; which is a lie that Alex perpetuates to his mother
through his self created news broadcasts and relays the continued theme of falsified reality. Becker also
makes reference to the disturbing appetite of consumers and downfall of communism to the rise of
capitalism in the sequence of Christiane's first walk outside of the apartment. She is dumbfound at the
advertisement, ¡°Nazi¡± graffiti, and a crane helicopter hauling off the statue of Lenin in a very literal
transition of the title. The most dangerous form of propagandized material it would seem then would be
in the ones we create for ourselves.
This film could be seen as a romance or a drama that is among the favorites of film festivals but
can be enjoyed by any persons due to the family dynamics displayed.

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

The French Revolution and Les Mis¨¦rables
The French Revolution and Les Mis¨¦rablesThe French Revolution and Les Mis¨¦rables
The French Revolution and Les Mis¨¦rables
Alexandra Kulik
?
Goodbye lenin
Goodbye leninGoodbye lenin
Goodbye lenin
eftihia67
?
Salinger
SalingerSalinger
Salinger
asiyat1975
?
Lap of Luxury Complete
  Lap of Luxury Complete    Lap of Luxury Complete
Lap of Luxury Complete
nosaegreht
?
6. walter scott
6. walter scott6. walter scott
6. walter scott
Anto Henry
?
The American Lab
The American LabThe American Lab
The American Lab
Ashman Ellzey
?
edition 1951 cover
edition 1951 coveredition 1951 cover
edition 1951 cover
Vanessa Moore
?
Mise en scene in film openings
Mise en scene in film openingsMise en scene in film openings
Mise en scene in film openings
George_Mugglestone
?
Top ten best movies of 2013
Top ten best movies of 2013Top ten best movies of 2013
Top ten best movies of 2013
dawnining
?
Eloquence & Civic Life: The Oratory of Daniel Webster
Eloquence & Civic Life: The Oratory of Daniel WebsterEloquence & Civic Life: The Oratory of Daniel Webster
Eloquence & Civic Life: The Oratory of Daniel Webster
Jim Farrell
?
Michael Jackson 1
Michael Jackson 1Michael Jackson 1
Michael Jackson 1
Terry Shropshire
?
The Evolution of Radio Drama
The Evolution of Radio DramaThe Evolution of Radio Drama
The Evolution of Radio Drama
Louise Maxwell
?
Robert frost 001
Robert frost 001Robert frost 001
Robert frost 001
Nadine Guevarra
?
Week 10 citizen kane
Week 10 citizen kaneWeek 10 citizen kane
Week 10 citizen kane
Shepherd University
?
Dracula Legend
Dracula LegendDracula Legend
Dracula Legend
Andreea Melinescu
?
Macbeth
MacbethMacbeth
Macbeth
guestf5751ed
?
Jack London
Jack London Jack London
Jack London
Benn¨¦ Erandi Herrera
?
Drama summer task 2012
Drama summer task 2012Drama summer task 2012
Drama summer task 2012
Welling School Sixth Form
?
Film ERASMUS+ 70 YEH
Film ERASMUS+ 70 YEHFilm ERASMUS+ 70 YEH
Film ERASMUS+ 70 YEH
Haris Evaggelou
?
Realism in the Charles Dicken¡¯s Novel
Realism in the Charles Dicken¡¯s NovelRealism in the Charles Dicken¡¯s Novel
Realism in the Charles Dicken¡¯s Novel
JigneshPanchasara
?

Viewers also liked (20)

Lugares por visitar lejano orienteLugares por visitar lejano oriente
Lugares por visitar lejano oriente
Bicho Lucia
?
Uncommon Quotes
Uncommon QuotesUncommon Quotes
Uncommon Quotes
Ravishankar M K
?
KernelKernel
Kernel
jannet170309
?
Glosario  de terminosGlosario  de terminos
Glosario de terminos
lucy santana
?
Razvojni potencijal koncepta karijernog vo?enja i savetovanja u osnovnim i sr...
Razvojni potencijal koncepta karijernog vo?enja i savetovanja u osnovnim i sr...Razvojni potencijal koncepta karijernog vo?enja i savetovanja u osnovnim i sr...
Razvojni potencijal koncepta karijernog vo?enja i savetovanja u osnovnim i sr...
Beogradska otvorena ?kola
?
Clasificaciones finalesClasificaciones finales
Clasificaciones finales
guest94607b6
?
Tarea #1   formacion de formadores - profesora miriamTarea #1   formacion de formadores - profesora miriam
Tarea #1 formacion de formadores - profesora miriam
Gisela Cardenas
?
El consejo nacional electoralEl consejo nacional electoral
El consejo nacional electoral
mafer03_v
?
Evaluacion finalEvaluacion final
Evaluacion final
lindamar2783
?
Triangulos semejantesTriangulos semejantes
Triangulos semejantes
Miguel Piedrahita
?
Capgemini_Smart Meter POV_2009
Capgemini_Smart Meter POV_2009Capgemini_Smart Meter POV_2009
Capgemini_Smart Meter POV_2009
Jeffrey Norman
?
SOFTWARESOFTWARE
SOFTWARE
gazdaly
?
How to involve my School to an ERASMUS + project
How to involve my School to an ERASMUS + project How to involve my School to an ERASMUS + project
How to involve my School to an ERASMUS + project
Sofoklis Sotiriou
?
Protocolo de actuaci¨®n policialProtocolo de actuaci¨®n policial
Protocolo de actuaci¨®n policial
Escuela de Capacitaci¨®n Judicial - Poder Judicial de San Juan - Argentina
?
¥À¥¤¥Ê¥ß¥Ã¥¯ŽÚ¸æ¤Î¸ÄÉƤȒˆ´ó
¥À¥¤¥Ê¥ß¥Ã¥¯ŽÚ¸æ¤Î¸ÄÉƤȒˆ´ó¥À¥¤¥Ê¥ß¥Ã¥¯ŽÚ¸æ¤Î¸ÄÉƤȒˆ´ó
¥À¥¤¥Ê¥ß¥Ã¥¯ŽÚ¸æ¤Î¸ÄÉƤȒˆ´ó
Yusuke Ando
?
Proceso salud   enfermedadProceso salud   enfermedad
Proceso salud enfermedad
Javier Vasquez Rumiche
?
Ejemplo de un c¨¢lculo de dietaEjemplo de un c¨¢lculo de dieta
Ejemplo de un c¨¢lculo de dieta
No¨¦ Gonz¨¢lez Gallegos
?
Lugares por visitar lejano orienteLugares por visitar lejano oriente
Lugares por visitar lejano oriente
Bicho Lucia
?
Glosario  de terminosGlosario  de terminos
Glosario de terminos
lucy santana
?
Razvojni potencijal koncepta karijernog vo?enja i savetovanja u osnovnim i sr...
Razvojni potencijal koncepta karijernog vo?enja i savetovanja u osnovnim i sr...Razvojni potencijal koncepta karijernog vo?enja i savetovanja u osnovnim i sr...
Razvojni potencijal koncepta karijernog vo?enja i savetovanja u osnovnim i sr...
Beogradska otvorena ?kola
?
Clasificaciones finalesClasificaciones finales
Clasificaciones finales
guest94607b6
?
Tarea #1   formacion de formadores - profesora miriamTarea #1   formacion de formadores - profesora miriam
Tarea #1 formacion de formadores - profesora miriam
Gisela Cardenas
?
El consejo nacional electoralEl consejo nacional electoral
El consejo nacional electoral
mafer03_v
?
Evaluacion finalEvaluacion final
Evaluacion final
lindamar2783
?
Triangulos semejantesTriangulos semejantes
Triangulos semejantes
Miguel Piedrahita
?
Capgemini_Smart Meter POV_2009
Capgemini_Smart Meter POV_2009Capgemini_Smart Meter POV_2009
Capgemini_Smart Meter POV_2009
Jeffrey Norman
?
SOFTWARESOFTWARE
SOFTWARE
gazdaly
?
How to involve my School to an ERASMUS + project
How to involve my School to an ERASMUS + project How to involve my School to an ERASMUS + project
How to involve my School to an ERASMUS + project
Sofoklis Sotiriou
?
¥À¥¤¥Ê¥ß¥Ã¥¯ŽÚ¸æ¤Î¸ÄÉƤȒˆ´ó
¥À¥¤¥Ê¥ß¥Ã¥¯ŽÚ¸æ¤Î¸ÄÉƤȒˆ´ó¥À¥¤¥Ê¥ß¥Ã¥¯ŽÚ¸æ¤Î¸ÄÉƤȒˆ´ó
¥À¥¤¥Ê¥ß¥Ã¥¯ŽÚ¸æ¤Î¸ÄÉƤȒˆ´ó
Yusuke Ando
?
Proceso salud   enfermedadProceso salud   enfermedad
Proceso salud enfermedad
Javier Vasquez Rumiche
?
Ejemplo de un c¨¢lculo de dietaEjemplo de un c¨¢lculo de dieta
Ejemplo de un c¨¢lculo de dieta
No¨¦ Gonz¨¢lez Gallegos
?

Similar to Brooke Carter Paper 5 (20)

The Caucasian Chalk Circle
The Caucasian Chalk CircleThe Caucasian Chalk Circle
The Caucasian Chalk Circle
bear1189
?
publish paper in PG journal Tragic vision
publish paper in PG journal Tragic visionpublish paper in PG journal Tragic vision
publish paper in PG journal Tragic vision
bassim jizanie
?
[Hi 366] Smoke Signals: Counternarratives of Indigenous Identity
[Hi 366] Smoke Signals: Counternarratives of Indigenous Identity[Hi 366] Smoke Signals: Counternarratives of Indigenous Identity
[Hi 366] Smoke Signals: Counternarratives of Indigenous Identity
IbironkeTychus
?
The Best Films
The Best FilmsThe Best Films
The Best Films
juditetah
?
History of the Horror Genre
History of the Horror GenreHistory of the Horror Genre
History of the Horror Genre
scook8
?
Death of a salesman By Arthur Miller - Canan Kaplan
Death of a salesman By Arthur Miller - Canan KaplanDeath of a salesman By Arthur Miller - Canan Kaplan
Death of a salesman By Arthur Miller - Canan Kaplan
-
?
E lit 46 c class 17
E lit 46 c class 17E lit 46 c class 17
E lit 46 c class 17
kimpalmore
?
Horror films
Horror filmsHorror films
Horror films
sboyadjieva
?
The mouse that roared presentation
The mouse that roared presentationThe mouse that roared presentation
The mouse that roared presentation
Kylie Mountain
?
British Realism - Post War Britain
British Realism - Post War BritainBritish Realism - Post War Britain
British Realism - Post War Britain
IAdamSmithI
?
SR
SRSR
SR
sssfcmedia
?
Communism in American Pop Culture
Communism in American Pop CultureCommunism in American Pop Culture
Communism in American Pop Culture
zinawip
?
A Cultural Materialist Reading Of Martin Crimp S Cruel And Tender Crimp S Ap...
A Cultural Materialist Reading Of Martin Crimp S Cruel And Tender  Crimp S Ap...A Cultural Materialist Reading Of Martin Crimp S Cruel And Tender  Crimp S Ap...
A Cultural Materialist Reading Of Martin Crimp S Cruel And Tender Crimp S Ap...
Erica Thompson
?
Genre in British Social Realism
Genre in British Social RealismGenre in British Social Realism
Genre in British Social Realism
hannahmedia123
?
A Song Of Ice And Fire And Hamlet Comparison
A Song Of Ice And Fire And Hamlet ComparisonA Song Of Ice And Fire And Hamlet Comparison
A Song Of Ice And Fire And Hamlet Comparison
Crystal Torres
?
Look back in angerppt
Look back in angerpptLook back in angerppt
Look back in angerppt
Afsana Benezir
?
The bad war[the truth never told about world war2]
The bad war[the truth never told about world war2]The bad war[the truth never told about world war2]
The bad war[the truth never told about world war2]
Martin Struthers
?
BFI Notes: Pressure
BFI Notes: PressureBFI Notes: Pressure
BFI Notes: Pressure
Belinda Raji
?
Thirtysomething
ThirtysomethingThirtysomething
Thirtysomething
Alex Carriere
?
The Infliction of a Rosebud (Paper 4)
The Infliction of a Rosebud (Paper 4)The Infliction of a Rosebud (Paper 4)
The Infliction of a Rosebud (Paper 4)
Sean Paine
?
The Caucasian Chalk Circle
The Caucasian Chalk CircleThe Caucasian Chalk Circle
The Caucasian Chalk Circle
bear1189
?
publish paper in PG journal Tragic vision
publish paper in PG journal Tragic visionpublish paper in PG journal Tragic vision
publish paper in PG journal Tragic vision
bassim jizanie
?
[Hi 366] Smoke Signals: Counternarratives of Indigenous Identity
[Hi 366] Smoke Signals: Counternarratives of Indigenous Identity[Hi 366] Smoke Signals: Counternarratives of Indigenous Identity
[Hi 366] Smoke Signals: Counternarratives of Indigenous Identity
IbironkeTychus
?
History of the Horror Genre
History of the Horror GenreHistory of the Horror Genre
History of the Horror Genre
scook8
?
Death of a salesman By Arthur Miller - Canan Kaplan
Death of a salesman By Arthur Miller - Canan KaplanDeath of a salesman By Arthur Miller - Canan Kaplan
Death of a salesman By Arthur Miller - Canan Kaplan
-
?
E lit 46 c class 17
E lit 46 c class 17E lit 46 c class 17
E lit 46 c class 17
kimpalmore
?
The mouse that roared presentation
The mouse that roared presentationThe mouse that roared presentation
The mouse that roared presentation
Kylie Mountain
?
British Realism - Post War Britain
British Realism - Post War BritainBritish Realism - Post War Britain
British Realism - Post War Britain
IAdamSmithI
?
Communism in American Pop Culture
Communism in American Pop CultureCommunism in American Pop Culture
Communism in American Pop Culture
zinawip
?
A Cultural Materialist Reading Of Martin Crimp S Cruel And Tender Crimp S Ap...
A Cultural Materialist Reading Of Martin Crimp S Cruel And Tender  Crimp S Ap...A Cultural Materialist Reading Of Martin Crimp S Cruel And Tender  Crimp S Ap...
A Cultural Materialist Reading Of Martin Crimp S Cruel And Tender Crimp S Ap...
Erica Thompson
?
Genre in British Social Realism
Genre in British Social RealismGenre in British Social Realism
Genre in British Social Realism
hannahmedia123
?
A Song Of Ice And Fire And Hamlet Comparison
A Song Of Ice And Fire And Hamlet ComparisonA Song Of Ice And Fire And Hamlet Comparison
A Song Of Ice And Fire And Hamlet Comparison
Crystal Torres
?
The bad war[the truth never told about world war2]
The bad war[the truth never told about world war2]The bad war[the truth never told about world war2]
The bad war[the truth never told about world war2]
Martin Struthers
?
The Infliction of a Rosebud (Paper 4)
The Infliction of a Rosebud (Paper 4)The Infliction of a Rosebud (Paper 4)
The Infliction of a Rosebud (Paper 4)
Sean Paine
?

Brooke Carter Paper 5

  • 1. Brooke Murray-Carter German Culture Through Film Ingeborg Majer-O'Sickey Good Bye, Lenin! Film Review Paper #5 12/18/2012
  • 2. Brooke Carter Paper 5 12/18/2012 ¡°Favorite of Film Festivals to Families: Good Bye, Lenin!¡± An important geopolitical atmosphere developed while Allied occupation occurred in Germany after WWII that helped result in the split of West and East effectively producing a nation caught in an identity crisis as the western capitalist system had to engulf the eastern socialists. Given the difficult and even bizarre situation of the peaceful reunification of Germany in 1989 some natural tensions between the diverse cultures would of course prove problematic. How better to relate an awkward collaboration between two distinct ideological systems than through a tear-jerking drama/comedy dripping with a sarcasm so oblivious that it becomes an intricate and hilarious satire in Wolfgang Becker's Good Bye, Lenin (2003)! The Kerner family is introduced to the audience by the oblivious narrator and son Alex who remarks first upon his cosmological aspirations to go to space, his father leaving to the west with his enemy-of-the-state girlfriend, and then his mother who becomes dedicated to the socialist fatherland after this crushing news. Alex Kerner (Daniel Bruhl) is the typical eastern German teenager who is put in a conundrum when his beloved mother, Christiane (Katrin Sab), falls into a heart attack for eight months during the period of 1989-90 after seeing him taking part in a protest against the communist government. During the period of Christiane's coma the Iron Curtain falls and capitalism is put in affect in the east; radically changing the lives of all Eastern Germans drastically from the simple such as Spreewald pickles to a whole new western currency. Christiane awakens after this period but under the risk of another heart attack if she receives any shock because of this Alex convinces his family, friends, and girlfriend to keep up the ruse that the GDR still maintains the East to comfort his mother in her last days.
  • 3. Fitting in with other films such as The Lives of Others(2006) and Life is Beautiful (1997), Good Bye, Lenin! incorporates an element of universality by incorporating a family structure attempting to cope with a changing political world which they have no control over. This clever approach in applying a tragic family's experience allows anyone to openly enjoy this film which will become an even richer experience if you can get in on the inside cultural jokes that are making constant political commentary. Coke's formula has been invented in East Germany; which is a lie that Alex perpetuates to his mother through his self created news broadcasts and relays the continued theme of falsified reality. Becker also makes reference to the disturbing appetite of consumers and downfall of communism to the rise of capitalism in the sequence of Christiane's first walk outside of the apartment. She is dumbfound at the advertisement, ¡°Nazi¡± graffiti, and a crane helicopter hauling off the statue of Lenin in a very literal transition of the title. The most dangerous form of propagandized material it would seem then would be in the ones we create for ourselves. This film could be seen as a romance or a drama that is among the favorites of film festivals but can be enjoyed by any persons due to the family dynamics displayed.