際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Asian Development Bank
   CMI Technical Support Facility Exclusive Team Briefing
                   Manila, 18 June 2009




CDM in Vietnam  An Update
                                               Ha Dang Son
                                RCEE Energy and Environment
                                                    Vietnam
Outline

         CDM status of Vietnam

         DNA and CDM approval process

         Major CDM issues in Vietnam




2 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
Vietnam at a glance
  Area: 331,211.6 km2
  Population: 86,210,800
  GDP per capita: USD 1,034
  Growth rate: 8.46%
  Labor structure:
    o 52.6% in agriculture, forestry and

      fishery
    o 20.8% in industry and construction

    o 26.6% in services

  Agricultural land: 24.7m hectares
    o 9,4m hectares production land

    o 14,5m hectares forest land



  (General Statistics Office, 2008)
3 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
CDM Status

            5 CDM projects have been
             registered (as of May 2009)
                  Rang Dong Oil Field Associated Gas
                   Recovery and Utilization
                  Song Muc Hydropower Plant
                   Rehabilitation
                  Dong Thanh Landfill LFG Recovery
                  Binh Thuan 30MW Wind Power
                   Plan No.1
                  Cao Phong Reforestation Project



4 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
Registered CDM by region                                                CER issuance by region
60%                                                                      60%

50%                                                                      50%

40%                                                                      40%

30%                                                                      30%

20%                                                                      20%

10%                                                                      10%

  0%                                                                     0%
         China      India    Malaysia    Korea    Thainland Vietnam            China   India   Korea   Brazil   Mexcio Vietnam



              Vietnam has issued 4,486,500 CERs and has ranking of
                             No. 6 around the world!
       (Courtesy: TV Rheinland)


5 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
As of May 2009
    92 CDM projects have received LOA

               Hydropower plants (SSC, LSC) majorly: 47.7%
               Other renewable energy: wind, biomass (rice husk), biogas
               Waste management: landfill, composting, wastewater treatment
               Energy efficiency, incl. power co-generation
               Fuel switching
               Afforestation & reforestation
         23 CDM projects have received LOE




6 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
CDM Potentials and Challenges

       High CDM potential sector:                                          Other potential sectors:
        Renewable energy                                                       Associated gas recovery
        avoidance of GHG emission                                               Solid and liquid waste
                                                                                 management
                                                                                Biomass, biodiesel
                                                                                Energy efficiency and
                                                                                 conservation
                                                                                Fuel switch
                                                                                Afforestation/
                                                                                 reforestation (AR-CDM)




7 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
      Challenges
               Low awareness of project entities on CDM, leading to more time
                and efforts for documentation and validation
               Low awareness of local bankers on CDM, leading to difficulties in
                financing, and benchmark development
               Lack of official data for baseline emission factor (BEF)
                development
               Local consultants: limited capacity in terms of language,
                technical knowledge, and regular CDM update
               CDM market: newly developed, unstable and not yet
                standardized, thus many risks




8 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
Designated National Authority
           Institutional Frameworks:
                Viet Nam is a host country under                        National Steering
                 UNFCC/Kyoto Protocol (non-Annex 1 country)               Committee for
                National Steering Committee (VNNSC) from                 UNFCCC and KP
                 14 agencies, with 18 members                            MONRE      MPI
                Ministry of Natural Resources and                        MOIT     MARD
                 Environment (MONRE) as a National Focal
                 Agency                                                  MOST      MOET
                Department of Meteo-Hydrology and Climate               MOFA       MOJ
                 Change (DMHCC) of MONRE as DNA of
                                                                          MOF      MOC
                 Vietnam
                                                                         MOLISA    MOCI

                                                                         MOCST     VUSTA

9 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
      CDM Approval Process
                                  Project developer
                                                    PIN / PDD
                                One-door Office                                    PIN
                                                                          No
                                                                                CDM criteria
                                                                                       Yes - 25 days
                                    Vietnam DNA                                     LOE

                                   Projects developer
                                                                                   PDD

                                        VNNSC                             No    CDM criteria
                                                                                       Yes - 50 days
                                    Vietnam DNA                                    LOA

                                                                               Validation and
  (Courtesy: DNA Vietnam)                                                       Registration
10 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
DNAs Priority Activities
         Capacity building
               Research and predict CERs market
               Guidance to organizations/enterprises (state and private) to
                develop and implement CDM projects
               Propaganda and awareness raising for public and policy makers
                on CDM
               Capacity building for DNA and National Steering Committee




12 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
      Promotion and facilitation
               Action plan on attracting domestic and foreign investment
                capital in CDM-added projects
               CDM integration into environmental conventions and into
                national/sectoral/local development strategies and plans.
               Legal documents review for supplementation modification to
                support CDM




13 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
Failures: Lessons Learnt from DOE
                                  1                                                      3
                     Limited understanding and                            Local language and competence
                       proof of Additionality

                                   1                                                     4
                          Limited evidence for                                  Limited evidence of
                           CDM consideration                                 Local Stakeholder Process

                                                                                      4
                                     2                                       Communication between
                                Missing LoA                                      PD and DOE

                                 2
                                                                                        5
                           Application of
                                                                          Data missing during monitoring
                      outdated methodologies

                                  3                                                      5
                        Benchmark missing in                              Data monitoring not according to
                            host country                                      monitoring methodology

 (Courtesy: TV Rheinland)
14 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
Grids Baseline Emission Factor
         Different sources for calculation
               EVN National Dispatching Centers data: net power generation,
                average efficiency and fuel type
                 Song Bung 4 HPP (TSF): EF = 569.49 tCO2/GWh

               EVN Institute of Energys data: based on fuel consumption and
                net power generation
                 Binh Thuan Wind Power: EF = 644.8 tCO2/GWh

               5th Master Plan on Power Development: based on total net
                power generation, total fuel consumption
                 Dong Thanh Landfill: EF = 617.6 tCO2/GWh (AMS-I.D)

         Expected to have official EF by 2010
               MONREs request to MOIT to provide official EF


15 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
Benchmark Availability
         Official regulations
               MOITs decision on benchmark for SSC power plant
               MOITs decision on benchmark for LSC power plant
               State Banks regulation on ceiling rate
         Commercial mid-term interest rate
               Not easy to have certified data
               Can refer to IFI sources (WB, ADB, IMF)




16 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
ODA Diversion
          Rationale
                UNFCCCs rule on ODA diversion
                Hanoi Core Statement on Aid Effectiveness
                Decree 131/2006/ND-CP on ODA Management and Utilization
                Circular 58/2008/TTLT-BTC-BTN&MT                   
          Justification and modification
                ODA considered as States Budget, registered to state account,
                 allocated to public agencies/SOEs
                Commercial loan, on-lending: justify terms of loan
                MONRE to consider an option of proportional share of CERs
                 based on ODA contribution to projects total capital



17 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
19 | TSF Team Briefing  Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009

More Related Content

CDM Vietnam Update

  • 1. Asian Development Bank CMI Technical Support Facility Exclusive Team Briefing Manila, 18 June 2009 CDM in Vietnam An Update Ha Dang Son RCEE Energy and Environment Vietnam
  • 2. Outline CDM status of Vietnam DNA and CDM approval process Major CDM issues in Vietnam 2 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
  • 3. Vietnam at a glance Area: 331,211.6 km2 Population: 86,210,800 GDP per capita: USD 1,034 Growth rate: 8.46% Labor structure: o 52.6% in agriculture, forestry and fishery o 20.8% in industry and construction o 26.6% in services Agricultural land: 24.7m hectares o 9,4m hectares production land o 14,5m hectares forest land (General Statistics Office, 2008) 3 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
  • 4. CDM Status 5 CDM projects have been registered (as of May 2009) Rang Dong Oil Field Associated Gas Recovery and Utilization Song Muc Hydropower Plant Rehabilitation Dong Thanh Landfill LFG Recovery Binh Thuan 30MW Wind Power Plan No.1 Cao Phong Reforestation Project 4 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
  • 5. Registered CDM by region CER issuance by region 60% 60% 50% 50% 40% 40% 30% 30% 20% 20% 10% 10% 0% 0% China India Malaysia Korea Thainland Vietnam China India Korea Brazil Mexcio Vietnam Vietnam has issued 4,486,500 CERs and has ranking of No. 6 around the world! (Courtesy: TV Rheinland) 5 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
  • 6. As of May 2009 92 CDM projects have received LOA Hydropower plants (SSC, LSC) majorly: 47.7% Other renewable energy: wind, biomass (rice husk), biogas Waste management: landfill, composting, wastewater treatment Energy efficiency, incl. power co-generation Fuel switching Afforestation & reforestation 23 CDM projects have received LOE 6 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
  • 7. CDM Potentials and Challenges High CDM potential sector: Other potential sectors: Renewable energy Associated gas recovery avoidance of GHG emission Solid and liquid waste management Biomass, biodiesel Energy efficiency and conservation Fuel switch Afforestation/ reforestation (AR-CDM) 7 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
  • 8. Challenges Low awareness of project entities on CDM, leading to more time and efforts for documentation and validation Low awareness of local bankers on CDM, leading to difficulties in financing, and benchmark development Lack of official data for baseline emission factor (BEF) development Local consultants: limited capacity in terms of language, technical knowledge, and regular CDM update CDM market: newly developed, unstable and not yet standardized, thus many risks 8 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
  • 9. Designated National Authority Institutional Frameworks: Viet Nam is a host country under National Steering UNFCC/Kyoto Protocol (non-Annex 1 country) Committee for National Steering Committee (VNNSC) from UNFCCC and KP 14 agencies, with 18 members MONRE MPI Ministry of Natural Resources and MOIT MARD Environment (MONRE) as a National Focal Agency MOST MOET Department of Meteo-Hydrology and Climate MOFA MOJ Change (DMHCC) of MONRE as DNA of MOF MOC Vietnam MOLISA MOCI MOCST VUSTA 9 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
  • 10. CDM Approval Process Project developer PIN / PDD One-door Office PIN No CDM criteria Yes - 25 days Vietnam DNA LOE Projects developer PDD VNNSC No CDM criteria Yes - 50 days Vietnam DNA LOA Validation and (Courtesy: DNA Vietnam) Registration 10 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
  • 11. DNAs Priority Activities Capacity building Research and predict CERs market Guidance to organizations/enterprises (state and private) to develop and implement CDM projects Propaganda and awareness raising for public and policy makers on CDM Capacity building for DNA and National Steering Committee 12 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
  • 12. Promotion and facilitation Action plan on attracting domestic and foreign investment capital in CDM-added projects CDM integration into environmental conventions and into national/sectoral/local development strategies and plans. Legal documents review for supplementation modification to support CDM 13 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
  • 13. Failures: Lessons Learnt from DOE 1 3 Limited understanding and Local language and competence proof of Additionality 1 4 Limited evidence for Limited evidence of CDM consideration Local Stakeholder Process 4 2 Communication between Missing LoA PD and DOE 2 5 Application of Data missing during monitoring outdated methodologies 3 5 Benchmark missing in Data monitoring not according to host country monitoring methodology (Courtesy: TV Rheinland) 14 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
  • 14. Grids Baseline Emission Factor Different sources for calculation EVN National Dispatching Centers data: net power generation, average efficiency and fuel type Song Bung 4 HPP (TSF): EF = 569.49 tCO2/GWh EVN Institute of Energys data: based on fuel consumption and net power generation Binh Thuan Wind Power: EF = 644.8 tCO2/GWh 5th Master Plan on Power Development: based on total net power generation, total fuel consumption Dong Thanh Landfill: EF = 617.6 tCO2/GWh (AMS-I.D) Expected to have official EF by 2010 MONREs request to MOIT to provide official EF 15 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
  • 15. Benchmark Availability Official regulations MOITs decision on benchmark for SSC power plant MOITs decision on benchmark for LSC power plant State Banks regulation on ceiling rate Commercial mid-term interest rate Not easy to have certified data Can refer to IFI sources (WB, ADB, IMF) 16 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
  • 16. ODA Diversion Rationale UNFCCCs rule on ODA diversion Hanoi Core Statement on Aid Effectiveness Decree 131/2006/ND-CP on ODA Management and Utilization Circular 58/2008/TTLT-BTC-BTN&MT Justification and modification ODA considered as States Budget, registered to state account, allocated to public agencies/SOEs Commercial loan, on-lending: justify terms of loan MONRE to consider an option of proportional share of CERs based on ODA contribution to projects total capital 17 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009
  • 17. 19 | TSF Team Briefing Climate and Clean Energy Week, 15-19 June 2009