Perfectly competitive and monopolistically competitive markets share some similarities but differ in efficiency. Both have elastic demand curves and firms unable to earn long-run profits, but perfectly competitive markets are more efficient with price equal to costs and no product differentiation or barriers to entry/exit. Monopolistically competitive markets have higher prices, product differentiation, and some barriers, resulting in deadweight loss.
1 of 2
Download to read offline
More Related Content
Competition
1. The key difference between perfectly competitive markets
and monopolistically competitive ones is efficiency.
Learning Objective
Differentiate between monopolistic competition and perfect competition
Key Points
Perfectly competitive markets have no barriers of entry or exit. Monopolistically
competitive markets have a few barriers of entry and exit.
The two markets are similar in terms of elasticity of demand, a firm's ability to make
profits in the long-run, and how to determine a firm's profit maximizing quantity
condition.
In a perfectly competitive market, all goods are substitutes. In a monopolistically
competitive market, there is a high degree of product differentiation.
Term
perfect competition
A type of market with many consumers and producers, all of whom are price takers
Give us feedback on this content:
Full Text
Perfect competition and monopolistic competition are two types of economic markets.
Similarities
One of the key similarities that perfectly competitive and monopolistically competitive markets
share is elasticity of demand in the long-run. In both circumstances, the consumers are sensitive
to price; if price goes up, demand for that product decreases. The two only differ in degree.
Firm's individual demand curves in perfectly competitive markets are perfectly elastic, which
means that an incremental increase in price will cause demand for a product to vanish ). Demand
curves in monopolistic competition are not perfectly elastic: due to the market power that firms
have, they are able to raise prices without losing all of their customers.
Demand curve in a perfectly competitive market
2. This is the demand curve in a perfectly competitive market. Note how any increase in price
would wipe out demand.
Also, in both sets of circumstances the suppliers cannot make a profit in the long-run. Ultimately,
firms in both markets will only be able to break even by selling their goods and services.
Both markets are composed of firms seeking to maximize their profits. In both of these markets,
profit maximization occurs when a firm produces goods to such a level so that its marginal costs
of production equals its marginal revenues.
Differences
One key difference between these two set of economic circumstances is efficiency. A perfectly
competitive market is perfectly efficient. This means that the price is Pareto optimal, which
means that any shift in the price would benefit one party at the expense of the other. The overall
economic surplus, which is the sum of the producer and consumer surpluses, is maximized. The
suppliers cannot influence the price of the good or service in question; the market dictates the
price. The price of the good or service in a perfectly competitive market is equal to the marginal
costs of manufacturing that good or service.
In a monopolistically competitive market the price is higher than the marginal cost of producing
the good or service and the suppliers can influence the price, granting them market power. This
decreases the consumer surplus, and by extension the market's economic surplus, and creates
deadweight loss.
Another key difference between the two is product differentiation. In a perfectly competitive
market products are perfect substitutes for each other. But in monopolistically competitive
markets the products are highly differentiated. In fact, firms work hard to emphasize the non-
price related differences between their products and their competitors'.
A final difference involves barriers to entry and exit. Perfectly competitive markets have no
barriers to entry and exit; a firm can freely enter or leave an industry based on its perception of
the market's profitability. In a monopolistic competitive market there are few barriers to entry
and exit, but still more than in a perfectly competitive market.
Give us feedback on this content:
Source: Boundless. Monopolistic Competition Compared to Perfect Competition. Boundless
Economics. Boundless, 03 Jul. 2014. Retrieved 21 Jan. 2015 from
https://www.boundless.com/economics/textbooks/boundless-economics-textbook/monopolistic-
competition-12/monopolistic-competition-75/monopolistic-competition-compared-to-perfect-
competition-285-12382/