際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Final Showcase
                  PrestoPRIME
                   FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161


          Crowdsourcing video annotation
   Michiel Hildebrand, VU University Amsterdam
and Lora Aroyo, Riste Gligorov, Jacco van Ossenbruggen, Guus Schreiber
                and Maarten Brinkerink, Lotte Baltussen, Johan Oomen, Erwin Verbruggen
FINAL
         SHOWCASE
          21.- 22.11.2012
                  VIENNA




P                                                                                        Access            C
     Planning/Checking-                 Enrichment               Monitoring and
R         in/Ingest                                            Running Preservation                        O
                                  Video Quality assessment                             Multivalent
O                                                                                        framework
                                                                                                           N
     Preservation Planning          Fingerprint content        Managing Archive
D    Metadata Mapping and                 tracking
                                                                                                           S
                                                                     Services
U          Validating               Rights Ontology and                                  Access          U
C     Storage and Master               RightsDraw                Policy based Long-    for Master        M
             Levels                 Crowdsourcing video        term Data Management        level
E                                                                                         materials
                                                                                                           E
                                      annotation; Waisda
R                                                                                                          R


                       Integration Platforms: Rosetta  P4


                  Knowledge and Services: PrestoCentre


             Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)          FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME                        2
FINAL
   SHOWCASE
   21.- 22.11.2012
                     Motivation
           VIENNA




 Goal 1: Collecttime-basedvideo annotations

 Goal 2: Improve access to video fragments

 Goal 3: Connect with the public




      Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)   FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME   3
FINAL
SHOWCASE
21.- 22.11.2012
        VIENNA




   Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)   FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME   4
FINAL
SHOWCASE
21.- 22.11.2012
                  Results
        VIENNA




                  2009 TIMAF European Best Practices Award



                  2010 EuroITV Winner Grand Challenge



                  2010 ArchivesNext Best Archives on the Web Award



                   2012 Nominated for Dutch Game Award



   Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)   FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME   5
FINAL
SHOWCASE
21.- 22.11.2012
                  Results Goal 1 : annotation
        VIENNA    Number of tags collected in 4 months by semi-professionals from NCRV and Waisda users




   Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)            FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME                              6
FINAL
SHOWCASE
21.- 22.11.2012
                  Results Goal 1 : annotation
        VIENNA    Percentage of tags found in GTAA (Professional), WordNet (Dutch Dictionary), Google




   Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)            FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME                                 7
FINAL
        SHOWCASE
        21.- 22.11.2012
                          Results Goal 1 : annotation
                VIENNA    Panofsky-Shatford matrix for 1,313 Waisdatags from 1stWaisda pilot




                               Abstract          General                    Specific           Total

Who                                   10                 166                   177             31%
                                      73                                           12          57%
What                                                    563
Where                                   0                    68                      8          7%
When                                    4                    31                      6          5%
Total                                 7%                74%                       9%




           Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)            FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME                        8
FINAL
SHOWCASE
21.- 22.11.2012
                  Results Goal 2 : search
        VIENNA




   Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)   FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME   9
FINAL
SHOWCASE
21.- 22.11.2012
                  Results Goal 2 : search
        VIENNA    Mean Average Precision of fragment retrieval using 50 queries and 198 videos




   Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)            FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME                          10
FINAL
SHOWCASE
21.- 22.11.2012
                  Results Goal 3: user engagment
        VIENNA    Number of users 2nd pilot Waisda




            735                                      1000s
            registered                                 anonymous




   Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)            FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME   11
FINAL
SHOWCASE
21.- 22.11.2012
                  Results goal 3: user engagment
        VIENNA    User visits for Waisda 1st pilot




   Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)               FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME   12
FINAL
   SHOWCASE
    21.- 22.11.2012
                      Lessons learned
            VIENNA




 Use short video fragments
 Expect tags:
    in a user vocabulary
    mainly general descriptions of What and Who
 Time-based annotations enable:
    within-video search
    high recall fragment retrieval
 Large number of contributors
    provide additional motivation (short term goal)

       Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)   FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME   13
FINAL
SHOWCASE
21.- 22.11.2012
                    Outcomes
        VIENNA      Waisda white label available under GPL open source license




                  http://github.com/beeldengeluid/waisda




   Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)              FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME        14
FINAL
SHOWCASE
21.- 22.11.2012
                  Outcomes : student projects
        VIENNA    Detecting emotions in Waisda tags (Master project Wouter Meys)




   Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)            FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME            15
FINAL
SHOWCASE
21.- 22.11.2012
                  Outcomes : student projects
        VIENNA    Short term goals within Waisda through missions (master project Olga Beza)




   Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)            FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME                        16
FINAL
SHOWCASE
21.- 22.11.2012
                  Outcomes : student projects
        VIENNA    Waisda for fictional movies (PhD research Liliana Melgar)




   Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)             FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME      17
FINAL
SHOWCASE
21.- 22.11.2012
                  Outcomes : new collections
        VIENNA




                                    Film institute Netherlands




                                    Dutch broadcaster




                                    Europeana V2




   Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)   FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME   18
FINAL
       SHOWCASE
       21.- 22.11.2012
                         Install your own Waisda?
               VIENNA




1. git clone https://github.com/beeldengeluid/waisda.git
2. setup MySQL database
3. add videos
            identifier
            title
            duration
            URL video source
            URL key frame
4. style user interface
            Logo
            color scheme
            static pages
5. deploy in Jetty or Tomcat


          Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)   FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME   19
FINAL
  SHOWCASE
  21.- 22.11.2012
                    Integration : Waisda API
          VIENNA




videos                                                             tags
 submit                                                            export
 update                                                            sync




     Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)   FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME              20
FINAL
SHOWCASE
21.- 22.11.2012
                  Integration : Tag Gardening
        VIENNA




              videos                                 annotations




                              tags



   Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)   FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME     21
FINAL
SHOWCASE
21.- 22.11.2012
                  Integration : Tag Gardening
        VIENNA




   Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)   FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME   22
FINAL
   SHOWCASE
   21.- 22.11.2012
                     challenges
           VIENNA




 Maintain Waisda? white label

 Improve quality of tags
    Waisda: collect specific types of tags
    Processing: filter tags to improve precision




      Michiel Hildebrand (VUA)   FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME   23

More Related Content

Crowdsourcing video annotation

  • 1. Final Showcase PrestoPRIME FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161 Crowdsourcing video annotation Michiel Hildebrand, VU University Amsterdam and Lora Aroyo, Riste Gligorov, Jacco van Ossenbruggen, Guus Schreiber and Maarten Brinkerink, Lotte Baltussen, Johan Oomen, Erwin Verbruggen
  • 2. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 VIENNA P Access C Planning/Checking- Enrichment Monitoring and R in/Ingest Running Preservation O Video Quality assessment Multivalent O framework N Preservation Planning Fingerprint content Managing Archive D Metadata Mapping and tracking S Services U Validating Rights Ontology and Access U C Storage and Master RightsDraw Policy based Long- for Master M Levels Crowdsourcing video term Data Management level E materials E annotation; Waisda R R Integration Platforms: Rosetta P4 Knowledge and Services: PrestoCentre Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 2
  • 3. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Motivation VIENNA Goal 1: Collecttime-basedvideo annotations Goal 2: Improve access to video fragments Goal 3: Connect with the public Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 3
  • 4. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 VIENNA Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 4
  • 5. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Results VIENNA 2009 TIMAF European Best Practices Award 2010 EuroITV Winner Grand Challenge 2010 ArchivesNext Best Archives on the Web Award 2012 Nominated for Dutch Game Award Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 5
  • 6. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Results Goal 1 : annotation VIENNA Number of tags collected in 4 months by semi-professionals from NCRV and Waisda users Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 6
  • 7. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Results Goal 1 : annotation VIENNA Percentage of tags found in GTAA (Professional), WordNet (Dutch Dictionary), Google Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 7
  • 8. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Results Goal 1 : annotation VIENNA Panofsky-Shatford matrix for 1,313 Waisdatags from 1stWaisda pilot Abstract General Specific Total Who 10 166 177 31% 73 12 57% What 563 Where 0 68 8 7% When 4 31 6 5% Total 7% 74% 9% Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 8
  • 9. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Results Goal 2 : search VIENNA Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 9
  • 10. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Results Goal 2 : search VIENNA Mean Average Precision of fragment retrieval using 50 queries and 198 videos Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 10
  • 11. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Results Goal 3: user engagment VIENNA Number of users 2nd pilot Waisda 735 1000s registered anonymous Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 11
  • 12. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Results goal 3: user engagment VIENNA User visits for Waisda 1st pilot Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 12
  • 13. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Lessons learned VIENNA Use short video fragments Expect tags: in a user vocabulary mainly general descriptions of What and Who Time-based annotations enable: within-video search high recall fragment retrieval Large number of contributors provide additional motivation (short term goal) Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 13
  • 14. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Outcomes VIENNA Waisda white label available under GPL open source license http://github.com/beeldengeluid/waisda Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 14
  • 15. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Outcomes : student projects VIENNA Detecting emotions in Waisda tags (Master project Wouter Meys) Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 15
  • 16. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Outcomes : student projects VIENNA Short term goals within Waisda through missions (master project Olga Beza) Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 16
  • 17. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Outcomes : student projects VIENNA Waisda for fictional movies (PhD research Liliana Melgar) Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 17
  • 18. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Outcomes : new collections VIENNA Film institute Netherlands Dutch broadcaster Europeana V2 Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 18
  • 19. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Install your own Waisda? VIENNA 1. git clone https://github.com/beeldengeluid/waisda.git 2. setup MySQL database 3. add videos identifier title duration URL video source URL key frame 4. style user interface Logo color scheme static pages 5. deploy in Jetty or Tomcat Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 19
  • 20. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Integration : Waisda API VIENNA videos tags submit export update sync Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 20
  • 21. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Integration : Tag Gardening VIENNA videos annotations tags Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 21
  • 22. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 Integration : Tag Gardening VIENNA Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 22
  • 23. FINAL SHOWCASE 21.- 22.11.2012 challenges VIENNA Maintain Waisda? white label Improve quality of tags Waisda: collect specific types of tags Processing: filter tags to improve precision Michiel Hildebrand (VUA) FP7-ICT-2007-3 231161PrestoPRIME 23