際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Are Preprints the Problem?
Ivan Oransky
President, AHCJ
Vice President, Editorial, Medscape
Distinguished Writer in Residence, NYU
Co-Founder, Retraction Watch
@ivanoransky
Preprint or Peer-Reviewed Paper?
Preprint or Peer-Reviewed Paper?
Preprint or Peer-Reviewed Paper?
Preprint or Peer-Reviewed Paper?
Preprint or Peer-Reviewed Paper?
Preprint or Peer-Reviewed Paper?
The Need For Speed
The Scientific Radar Gun
 Befriend an epidemiologist
 Find outside sources
 Try to avoid Single Study Syndrome
When it comes to findings, the Covid-19 train
is an express, while the rigorous science
coach is a local. Until that local arrives at its
final destination, it may be wise to label all this
researchpreprints, peer-reviewed papers,
and for goodness sake, pronouncements
from Donald Trump with a black-box
warning: There is some evidence for this
now. It will likely turn out to be at least partially
wrong.
In other words, lets all stay six studies away.
Ad

Recommended

The relationship between PubPeer comments and the speed of retraction
The relationship between PubPeer comments and the speed of retraction
Ivan Oransky
Does Science Self-Correct?
Does Science Self-Correct?
Ivan Oransky
Why We Should Be Talking About Reproducibility -- But Not Forget About Fraud
Why We Should Be Talking About Reproducibility -- But Not Forget About Fraud
Ivan Oransky
WCRI 2019: What makes a story a story?
WCRI 2019: What makes a story a story?
Ivan Oransky
The Retraction Watch Database
The Retraction Watch Database
Ivan Oransky
Fake Peer Review: What We've Learned at Retraction Watch
Fake Peer Review: What We've Learned at Retraction Watch
Ivan Oransky
APRIN talk, Tokyo, March 2018
APRIN talk, Tokyo, March 2018
Ivan Oransky
FNLM Carlisle talk
FNLM Carlisle talk
Ivan Oransky
Does Social Psychology Really Have More Retractions?
Does Social Psychology Really Have More Retractions?
Ivan Oransky
Scientific Fraud, Retractions, and the Future of Scientific Publishing
Scientific Fraud, Retractions, and the Future of Scientific Publishing
Ivan Oransky
How Often Are Studies Wrong?
How Often Are Studies Wrong?
Ivan Oransky
How Journalists Can Effectively -- And Safely -- Report on Scientific Fraud
How Journalists Can Effectively -- And Safely -- Report on Scientific Fraud
Ivan Oransky
How to pitch reporters without being annoying
How to pitch reporters without being annoying
Ivan Oransky
Reviewers (And Editors) Behaving Badly
Reviewers (And Editors) Behaving Badly
Ivan Oransky
Does Stem Cell Research Have A Retraction Problem?
Does Stem Cell Research Have A Retraction Problem?
Ivan Oransky
Rutgers
Rutgers
Ivan Oransky
Coverage of Clinical Medicine: A Diagnosis and Treatment Plan
Coverage of Clinical Medicine: A Diagnosis and Treatment Plan
Ivan Oransky
Shoot The Messenger? Challenges in Medical Journalism
Shoot The Messenger? Challenges in Medical Journalism
Ivan Oransky
Debunking Made Easy, AHCJ 2014
Debunking Made Easy, AHCJ 2014
Ivan Oransky
Retractions, Peer Review, and Transparency
Retractions, Peer Review, and Transparency
Ivan Oransky
Post-Publication Peer Review in Science: Reflections on Retractions and Med...
Post-Publication Peer Review in Science: Reflections on Retractions and Med...
Ivan Oransky
New Media, Traditional Media: How are messages getting through in todays eco...
New Media, Traditional Media: How are messages getting through in todays eco...
Ivan Oransky
Covering Medical Studies: Tips and Tricks (my NABJ presentation)
Covering Medical Studies: Tips and Tricks (my NABJ presentation)
Ivan Oransky
Can We Still Trust Science?
Can We Still Trust Science?
Ivan Oransky
Fnlm june 10 2013 final
Fnlm june 10 2013 final
Ivan Oransky
Can You Trust What You Read In (Scientific and News)papers?
Can You Trust What You Read In (Scientific and News)papers?
Ivan Oransky
We Are All Gatekeepers Now: Scrutiny of Science Goes Public
We Are All Gatekeepers Now: Scrutiny of Science Goes Public
Ivan Oransky
Scientific Integrity and Transparency Under Scrutiny: Lessons from Retractio...
Scientific Integrity and Transparency Under Scrutiny: Lessons from Retractio...
Ivan Oransky
Design of cosmeceuticals products;sunprotection,sunscreens
Design of cosmeceuticals products;sunprotection,sunscreens
Swami ramanand teerth marathwada university
Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS)
Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS)
Dr. Anu Marhatta

More Related Content

More from Ivan Oransky (20)

Does Social Psychology Really Have More Retractions?
Does Social Psychology Really Have More Retractions?
Ivan Oransky
Scientific Fraud, Retractions, and the Future of Scientific Publishing
Scientific Fraud, Retractions, and the Future of Scientific Publishing
Ivan Oransky
How Often Are Studies Wrong?
How Often Are Studies Wrong?
Ivan Oransky
How Journalists Can Effectively -- And Safely -- Report on Scientific Fraud
How Journalists Can Effectively -- And Safely -- Report on Scientific Fraud
Ivan Oransky
How to pitch reporters without being annoying
How to pitch reporters without being annoying
Ivan Oransky
Reviewers (And Editors) Behaving Badly
Reviewers (And Editors) Behaving Badly
Ivan Oransky
Does Stem Cell Research Have A Retraction Problem?
Does Stem Cell Research Have A Retraction Problem?
Ivan Oransky
Rutgers
Rutgers
Ivan Oransky
Coverage of Clinical Medicine: A Diagnosis and Treatment Plan
Coverage of Clinical Medicine: A Diagnosis and Treatment Plan
Ivan Oransky
Shoot The Messenger? Challenges in Medical Journalism
Shoot The Messenger? Challenges in Medical Journalism
Ivan Oransky
Debunking Made Easy, AHCJ 2014
Debunking Made Easy, AHCJ 2014
Ivan Oransky
Retractions, Peer Review, and Transparency
Retractions, Peer Review, and Transparency
Ivan Oransky
Post-Publication Peer Review in Science: Reflections on Retractions and Med...
Post-Publication Peer Review in Science: Reflections on Retractions and Med...
Ivan Oransky
New Media, Traditional Media: How are messages getting through in todays eco...
New Media, Traditional Media: How are messages getting through in todays eco...
Ivan Oransky
Covering Medical Studies: Tips and Tricks (my NABJ presentation)
Covering Medical Studies: Tips and Tricks (my NABJ presentation)
Ivan Oransky
Can We Still Trust Science?
Can We Still Trust Science?
Ivan Oransky
Fnlm june 10 2013 final
Fnlm june 10 2013 final
Ivan Oransky
Can You Trust What You Read In (Scientific and News)papers?
Can You Trust What You Read In (Scientific and News)papers?
Ivan Oransky
We Are All Gatekeepers Now: Scrutiny of Science Goes Public
We Are All Gatekeepers Now: Scrutiny of Science Goes Public
Ivan Oransky
Scientific Integrity and Transparency Under Scrutiny: Lessons from Retractio...
Scientific Integrity and Transparency Under Scrutiny: Lessons from Retractio...
Ivan Oransky
Does Social Psychology Really Have More Retractions?
Does Social Psychology Really Have More Retractions?
Ivan Oransky
Scientific Fraud, Retractions, and the Future of Scientific Publishing
Scientific Fraud, Retractions, and the Future of Scientific Publishing
Ivan Oransky
How Often Are Studies Wrong?
How Often Are Studies Wrong?
Ivan Oransky
How Journalists Can Effectively -- And Safely -- Report on Scientific Fraud
How Journalists Can Effectively -- And Safely -- Report on Scientific Fraud
Ivan Oransky
How to pitch reporters without being annoying
How to pitch reporters without being annoying
Ivan Oransky
Reviewers (And Editors) Behaving Badly
Reviewers (And Editors) Behaving Badly
Ivan Oransky
Does Stem Cell Research Have A Retraction Problem?
Does Stem Cell Research Have A Retraction Problem?
Ivan Oransky
Coverage of Clinical Medicine: A Diagnosis and Treatment Plan
Coverage of Clinical Medicine: A Diagnosis and Treatment Plan
Ivan Oransky
Shoot The Messenger? Challenges in Medical Journalism
Shoot The Messenger? Challenges in Medical Journalism
Ivan Oransky
Debunking Made Easy, AHCJ 2014
Debunking Made Easy, AHCJ 2014
Ivan Oransky
Retractions, Peer Review, and Transparency
Retractions, Peer Review, and Transparency
Ivan Oransky
Post-Publication Peer Review in Science: Reflections on Retractions and Med...
Post-Publication Peer Review in Science: Reflections on Retractions and Med...
Ivan Oransky
New Media, Traditional Media: How are messages getting through in todays eco...
New Media, Traditional Media: How are messages getting through in todays eco...
Ivan Oransky
Covering Medical Studies: Tips and Tricks (my NABJ presentation)
Covering Medical Studies: Tips and Tricks (my NABJ presentation)
Ivan Oransky
Can We Still Trust Science?
Can We Still Trust Science?
Ivan Oransky
Fnlm june 10 2013 final
Fnlm june 10 2013 final
Ivan Oransky
Can You Trust What You Read In (Scientific and News)papers?
Can You Trust What You Read In (Scientific and News)papers?
Ivan Oransky
We Are All Gatekeepers Now: Scrutiny of Science Goes Public
We Are All Gatekeepers Now: Scrutiny of Science Goes Public
Ivan Oransky
Scientific Integrity and Transparency Under Scrutiny: Lessons from Retractio...
Scientific Integrity and Transparency Under Scrutiny: Lessons from Retractio...
Ivan Oransky

Recently uploaded (20)

Design of cosmeceuticals products;sunprotection,sunscreens
Design of cosmeceuticals products;sunprotection,sunscreens
Swami ramanand teerth marathwada university
Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS)
Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS)
Dr. Anu Marhatta
microbial spoilage. Pharmaceutical microbial Spoilage
microbial spoilage. Pharmaceutical microbial Spoilage
Rajakumari Rajendran
NUTRITION for basic Introduction and guide
NUTRITION for basic Introduction and guide
jrtrosales16
Mastering the Review Article: Structure, Strategy & Success
Mastering the Review Article: Structure, Strategy & Success
Rajendra Dev Bhatt
15 malnutrition in children pediatrics 1.ppt
15 malnutrition in children pediatrics 1.ppt
BECKYCHEPNGENO
Tuberculosis Nepal 2025 National Plan.pptx
Tuberculosis Nepal 2025 National Plan.pptx
Dr. Anu Marhatta
Lensee madical college javamate ni ppt che
Lensee madical college javamate ni ppt che
ashvindaka76
Navigating the Open Enrollment Period for Medicare Supplement Insurance in Sa...
Navigating the Open Enrollment Period for Medicare Supplement Insurance in Sa...
dfwdirectinsurance
nanoparticle and liposomes ppt .(NTDS)pdf
nanoparticle and liposomes ppt .(NTDS)pdf
siddhikalbande
An interesting case of facial Swelling in an autoimmune rheumatic disease Ahm...
An interesting case of facial Swelling in an autoimmune rheumatic disease Ahm...
Internal medicine department, faculty of Medicine Beni-Suef University Egypt
Tonsil anatomy, diseases and treatment options
Tonsil anatomy, diseases and treatment options
Manu Babu
OUR SRS SBRT EXPERIENCE BY DR KANHU CHARAN PATRO
OUR SRS SBRT EXPERIENCE BY DR KANHU CHARAN PATRO
Kanhu Charan
Coarse Dispersion, Physical Pharmaceutics
Coarse Dispersion, Physical Pharmaceutics
nishiprakashj
Computer aided formulation development optimization
Computer aided formulation development optimization
Swami ramanand teerth marathwada university
ADA Releases 2025 Standards of Care for Diabetes
ADA Releases 2025 Standards of Care for Diabetes
John Kriak
Irradiation to prevent TA-GvHD by Dr. Abrar Kabir Shishir.pptx
Irradiation to prevent TA-GvHD by Dr. Abrar Kabir Shishir.pptx
AbrarKabir3
Drug use in Peptic Ulcer_A complete review.pptx
Drug use in Peptic Ulcer_A complete review.pptx
Baasir Umair Khattak
Diabetes Mellitus Chapter 3 | Pathophysiology, Complications & Management
Diabetes Mellitus Chapter 3 | Pathophysiology, Complications & Management
PKLI-Institute of Nursing and Allied Health Sciences Lahore , Pakistan.
Biography and Professional Career of Dr. Seth Eidemiller
Biography and Professional Career of Dr. Seth Eidemiller
Dr. Seth Eidemiller
Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS)
Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS)
Dr. Anu Marhatta
microbial spoilage. Pharmaceutical microbial Spoilage
microbial spoilage. Pharmaceutical microbial Spoilage
Rajakumari Rajendran
NUTRITION for basic Introduction and guide
NUTRITION for basic Introduction and guide
jrtrosales16
Mastering the Review Article: Structure, Strategy & Success
Mastering the Review Article: Structure, Strategy & Success
Rajendra Dev Bhatt
15 malnutrition in children pediatrics 1.ppt
15 malnutrition in children pediatrics 1.ppt
BECKYCHEPNGENO
Tuberculosis Nepal 2025 National Plan.pptx
Tuberculosis Nepal 2025 National Plan.pptx
Dr. Anu Marhatta
Lensee madical college javamate ni ppt che
Lensee madical college javamate ni ppt che
ashvindaka76
Navigating the Open Enrollment Period for Medicare Supplement Insurance in Sa...
Navigating the Open Enrollment Period for Medicare Supplement Insurance in Sa...
dfwdirectinsurance
nanoparticle and liposomes ppt .(NTDS)pdf
nanoparticle and liposomes ppt .(NTDS)pdf
siddhikalbande
Tonsil anatomy, diseases and treatment options
Tonsil anatomy, diseases and treatment options
Manu Babu
OUR SRS SBRT EXPERIENCE BY DR KANHU CHARAN PATRO
OUR SRS SBRT EXPERIENCE BY DR KANHU CHARAN PATRO
Kanhu Charan
Coarse Dispersion, Physical Pharmaceutics
Coarse Dispersion, Physical Pharmaceutics
nishiprakashj
ADA Releases 2025 Standards of Care for Diabetes
ADA Releases 2025 Standards of Care for Diabetes
John Kriak
Irradiation to prevent TA-GvHD by Dr. Abrar Kabir Shishir.pptx
Irradiation to prevent TA-GvHD by Dr. Abrar Kabir Shishir.pptx
AbrarKabir3
Drug use in Peptic Ulcer_A complete review.pptx
Drug use in Peptic Ulcer_A complete review.pptx
Baasir Umair Khattak
Biography and Professional Career of Dr. Seth Eidemiller
Biography and Professional Career of Dr. Seth Eidemiller
Dr. Seth Eidemiller
Ad

During COVID-19, Are Preprints The Problem?