際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Pan-Disability  Classification in Sport Penny Broomhead   Penny Broomhead Manchester Metropolitan University March 3 rd  2011
Objectives To understand  the need for classification in sport the difficulties surrounding classification in disability sport the classification process
Classification in Sport  Ensures fair and  equitable competition
Classification in Disability Sport  Sporting ability is judged by the results of the competition The winner is the most skilled or highly trained not the least disabled
Classification issues Pan disability Sports specificity Access to classification
Attributes of a good classification system Simple & Flexible Consistent & Objective Use recognised (validated) tests
Assessment The critical factor in establishing a protocol for recording results is that each assessor uses the same system and that all team members interpret the results in the same manner OSullivan et al (1981)
Attributes of a good classification  system Acceptable to competitor Sensitive  Accessible  Based on impairment
Impairment Impairments are problems in body function or structure such as a significant deviation or loss.   WHO 2000
Impairment Locomotor Sensory Cerebral Other
Why measure impairment? Impairment (deviation or loss) Loss of function, limits activity Restriction in participation, limits role   WHO 2007
Why measure impairment?
Unclassifiable? To say someone is not eligible or not classifiable is not to say they are not disabled.  The severity of the disability is not in doubt, but some disabilities do not fit into a classification system. IPC Classification Committee 2000
The Profile System Developed in 1980s for DSE by Dr Chris Meaden Fulfils criteria for a good classification system Pan disability & sport specific
Classification process Bench test Observation in competition Protests Appeals
Bench Test  Consent Eligibility Medical evidence  Code of conduct Sport specific testing
Classification status process not complete until observed in competition Status  Confirmed  Review
Classification process Protests Appeals
Interested? Attend a classification course  to be able to assess athletes for eligibility & training  to be able to accompany an athlete through the process
Objectives To understand  the need for classification in sport the difficulties surrounding classification in disability sport the classification process
Thank You for your attention Any Questions?
  With thanks to the following for the photos; Graham Bool, Photographer Danny Crates, Paralympian Joyce Martin, Photographer Karl Sachs, Beyond boundaries
Ad

Recommended

PE Physical and Personal Qualities
PE Physical and Personal Qualities
knoxpe
P5 - Rob Fogerty
P5 - Rob Fogerty
Rob Fogerty
Unit11 task3
Unit11 task3
georgiashorttt
Unit 11 task 3 Maddy Burnage
Unit 11 task 3 Maddy Burnage
maddyburnage
U11 T3 Brooke Marshall
U11 T3 Brooke Marshall
brookemarshall
U11 t3 powerpoint
U11 t3 powerpoint
brookemarshall
CHECK Intro for Investors
CHECK Intro for Investors
Juha Ruohonen
Next Generation Disability in Sport
Next Generation Disability in Sport
Eli Wolff
Disability and Sport
Disability and Sport
Benjamin Fisher
Unit 216 working with participants with disabilities in sport and active leisure
Unit 216 working with participants with disabilities in sport and active leisure
ProdecEducation
Disability presentation
Disability presentation
rutledgl
Adapted Sports
Adapted Sports
teammountmaker
Disability sport
Disability sport
Dr Saim Ali soomro
Disability sport and physical activity consultation
Disability sport and physical activity consultation
Active Gloucestershire
PHYSICAL DISABILITIES
PHYSICAL DISABILITIES
aktaorg
Presentation Of Physical Disabilities
Presentation Of Physical Disabilities
CrYsTaLXYY
Disability Powerpoint
Disability Powerpoint
VSnow47
Classifier Training Seminar Preview - SanDiego-2015 Ver_01
Classifier Training Seminar Preview - SanDiego-2015 Ver_01
Roger H Strube MD (retired)
Talent id program for cricket based on latest technology
Talent id program for cricket based on latest technology
MeghanBale
The Power of Fitness Testing
The Power of Fitness Testing
Hungry4Fitness
Kin 188 Introduction To Athletic Training
Kin 188 Introduction To Athletic Training
JLS10
Fitness assement
Fitness assement
Chris Lehner
Metrifit Overview
Metrifit Overview
Dan Peterson
Fitness assessment
Fitness assessment
SharmiladeviVijayaku
Boot camp fitness assement
Boot camp fitness assement
Chris Lehner
Introduction To The SportsPro
Introduction To The SportsPro
Chris_Gee
P5 Rob Fogerty Referral
P5 Rob Fogerty Referral
Rob Fogerty
Laboratory Management With Constrains Iamm 2010
Laboratory Management With Constrains Iamm 2010
PathKind Labs
NCAA Certification
NCAA Certification
Crazy Penguin Media
PEShare.co.uk Shared Resource
PEShare.co.uk Shared Resource
peshare.co.uk

More Related Content

Viewers also liked (9)

Disability and Sport
Disability and Sport
Benjamin Fisher
Unit 216 working with participants with disabilities in sport and active leisure
Unit 216 working with participants with disabilities in sport and active leisure
ProdecEducation
Disability presentation
Disability presentation
rutledgl
Adapted Sports
Adapted Sports
teammountmaker
Disability sport
Disability sport
Dr Saim Ali soomro
Disability sport and physical activity consultation
Disability sport and physical activity consultation
Active Gloucestershire
PHYSICAL DISABILITIES
PHYSICAL DISABILITIES
aktaorg
Presentation Of Physical Disabilities
Presentation Of Physical Disabilities
CrYsTaLXYY
Disability Powerpoint
Disability Powerpoint
VSnow47
Unit 216 working with participants with disabilities in sport and active leisure
Unit 216 working with participants with disabilities in sport and active leisure
ProdecEducation
Disability presentation
Disability presentation
rutledgl
Disability sport and physical activity consultation
Disability sport and physical activity consultation
Active Gloucestershire
PHYSICAL DISABILITIES
PHYSICAL DISABILITIES
aktaorg
Presentation Of Physical Disabilities
Presentation Of Physical Disabilities
CrYsTaLXYY
Disability Powerpoint
Disability Powerpoint
VSnow47

Similar to Efds classification presentation 02.03.11 (20)

Classifier Training Seminar Preview - SanDiego-2015 Ver_01
Classifier Training Seminar Preview - SanDiego-2015 Ver_01
Roger H Strube MD (retired)
Talent id program for cricket based on latest technology
Talent id program for cricket based on latest technology
MeghanBale
The Power of Fitness Testing
The Power of Fitness Testing
Hungry4Fitness
Kin 188 Introduction To Athletic Training
Kin 188 Introduction To Athletic Training
JLS10
Fitness assement
Fitness assement
Chris Lehner
Metrifit Overview
Metrifit Overview
Dan Peterson
Fitness assessment
Fitness assessment
SharmiladeviVijayaku
Boot camp fitness assement
Boot camp fitness assement
Chris Lehner
Introduction To The SportsPro
Introduction To The SportsPro
Chris_Gee
P5 Rob Fogerty Referral
P5 Rob Fogerty Referral
Rob Fogerty
Laboratory Management With Constrains Iamm 2010
Laboratory Management With Constrains Iamm 2010
PathKind Labs
NCAA Certification
NCAA Certification
Crazy Penguin Media
PEShare.co.uk Shared Resource
PEShare.co.uk Shared Resource
peshare.co.uk
Assessment and testing for sports players
Assessment and testing for sports players
MeghanBale
fitness of older adults Helping to delay physical frailty and .docx
fitness of older adults Helping to delay physical frailty and .docx
clydes2
Kin 189 Characteristics Of A Profession, Contemporary Issues
Kin 189 Characteristics Of A Profession, Contemporary Issues
JLS10
Certification of Fitness Professionals: Necessary or not?
Certification of Fitness Professionals: Necessary or not?
Taylor Adams
Wkf para-karate-rules
Wkf para-karate-rules
Federaci坦n Puertorrique単a de Karate
WORLD KARATE FEDERATION PARA-KARATE KATA COMPETITION RULES EFFECTIVE FROM 1....
WORLD KARATE FEDERATION PARA-KARATE KATA COMPETITION RULES EFFECTIVE FROM 1....
PKF Federaci坦n Panamericana de Karate
The Importance of an Athletic Trainer
The Importance of an Athletic Trainer
Sam Cogen, MS, LAT, ATC, CES
Classifier Training Seminar Preview - SanDiego-2015 Ver_01
Classifier Training Seminar Preview - SanDiego-2015 Ver_01
Roger H Strube MD (retired)
Talent id program for cricket based on latest technology
Talent id program for cricket based on latest technology
MeghanBale
The Power of Fitness Testing
The Power of Fitness Testing
Hungry4Fitness
Kin 188 Introduction To Athletic Training
Kin 188 Introduction To Athletic Training
JLS10
Fitness assement
Fitness assement
Chris Lehner
Metrifit Overview
Metrifit Overview
Dan Peterson
Boot camp fitness assement
Boot camp fitness assement
Chris Lehner
Introduction To The SportsPro
Introduction To The SportsPro
Chris_Gee
P5 Rob Fogerty Referral
P5 Rob Fogerty Referral
Rob Fogerty
Laboratory Management With Constrains Iamm 2010
Laboratory Management With Constrains Iamm 2010
PathKind Labs
PEShare.co.uk Shared Resource
PEShare.co.uk Shared Resource
peshare.co.uk
Assessment and testing for sports players
Assessment and testing for sports players
MeghanBale
fitness of older adults Helping to delay physical frailty and .docx
fitness of older adults Helping to delay physical frailty and .docx
clydes2
Kin 189 Characteristics Of A Profession, Contemporary Issues
Kin 189 Characteristics Of A Profession, Contemporary Issues
JLS10
Certification of Fitness Professionals: Necessary or not?
Certification of Fitness Professionals: Necessary or not?
Taylor Adams
WORLD KARATE FEDERATION PARA-KARATE KATA COMPETITION RULES EFFECTIVE FROM 1....
WORLD KARATE FEDERATION PARA-KARATE KATA COMPETITION RULES EFFECTIVE FROM 1....
PKF Federaci坦n Panamericana de Karate
Ad

Efds classification presentation 02.03.11

  • 1. Pan-Disability Classification in Sport Penny Broomhead Penny Broomhead Manchester Metropolitan University March 3 rd 2011
  • 2. Objectives To understand the need for classification in sport the difficulties surrounding classification in disability sport the classification process
  • 3. Classification in Sport Ensures fair and equitable competition
  • 4. Classification in Disability Sport Sporting ability is judged by the results of the competition The winner is the most skilled or highly trained not the least disabled
  • 5. Classification issues Pan disability Sports specificity Access to classification
  • 6. Attributes of a good classification system Simple & Flexible Consistent & Objective Use recognised (validated) tests
  • 7. Assessment The critical factor in establishing a protocol for recording results is that each assessor uses the same system and that all team members interpret the results in the same manner OSullivan et al (1981)
  • 8. Attributes of a good classification system Acceptable to competitor Sensitive Accessible Based on impairment
  • 9. Impairment Impairments are problems in body function or structure such as a significant deviation or loss. WHO 2000
  • 11. Why measure impairment? Impairment (deviation or loss) Loss of function, limits activity Restriction in participation, limits role WHO 2007
  • 13. Unclassifiable? To say someone is not eligible or not classifiable is not to say they are not disabled. The severity of the disability is not in doubt, but some disabilities do not fit into a classification system. IPC Classification Committee 2000
  • 14. The Profile System Developed in 1980s for DSE by Dr Chris Meaden Fulfils criteria for a good classification system Pan disability & sport specific
  • 15. Classification process Bench test Observation in competition Protests Appeals
  • 16. Bench Test Consent Eligibility Medical evidence Code of conduct Sport specific testing
  • 17. Classification status process not complete until observed in competition Status Confirmed Review
  • 19. Interested? Attend a classification course to be able to assess athletes for eligibility & training to be able to accompany an athlete through the process
  • 20. Objectives To understand the need for classification in sport the difficulties surrounding classification in disability sport the classification process
  • 21. Thank You for your attention Any Questions?
  • 22. With thanks to the following for the photos; Graham Bool, Photographer Danny Crates, Paralympian Joyce Martin, Photographer Karl Sachs, Beyond boundaries

Editor's Notes

  • #5: Enables people with similar degrees of function to compete as fairly as possible
  • #6: Evolved with the growth of disability sport IPC classification code Apples & pears Athletics, rowing, cycling, swimming IWAS, INAS-FID, CP ISRA
  • #7: Read slide; simple, flexible, consistent & objective, using validated, recognised tests makes it repeatable so different assessors would get the same result, if it is fair it will be acceptable to competitors Needs to be sensitive to what it is measuring, to be able to identify and differentiate. Reason I feel so strongly about classification because of Colin; UL amp & hemi on other side. Hadnt been classified in Uk, went to Barcalona & ISOD system couldnt classify him, not sensitive or flexible enough to cope with both amp & hemi on opposite sides. Had to compete as a guest, gutted. Look what happened to Jenny Ridley in Athens, classified out of competition she had been preparing years for. It shouldnt have happened to either of them, so classification needs to be accessible. Every GB competitor should have opportunity to be classified in this country in own language before going abroad to compete. There arent enough classifiers in this country & Ill explain why later. Also & NB , needs to be based on impairment. What is that & why?
  • #9: Read slide; simple, flexible, consistent & objective, using validated, recognised tests makes it repeatable so different assessors would get the same result, if it is fair it will be acceptable to competitors Needs to be sensitive to what it is measuring, to be able to identify and differentiate. Reason I feel so strongly about classification because of Colin; UL amp & hemi on other side. Hadnt been classified in Uk, went to Barcalona & ISOD system couldnt classify him, not sensitive or flexible enough to cope with both amp & hemi on opposite sides. Had to compete as a guest, gutted. Look what happened to Jenny Ridley in Athens, classified out of competition she had been preparing years for. It shouldnt have happened to either of them, so classification needs to be accessible. Every GB competitor should have opportunity to be classified in this country in own language before going abroad to compete. There arent enough classifiers in this country & Ill explain why later. Also & NB , needs to be based on impairment. What is that & why?
  • #10: Who definition of impairment is
  • #11: Impairment can be divided into Locomotor; amputation, Sensory; blind, deaf Cerebral; intellectual/psychological Other; visceral eg renal failure Paresis, amp[utation, joint ankylosis, Upper motor neurone lesions, loss of sight, Intellectual disabiliity These are permanent impairments
  • #12: Why measure impairment & not disability or handicap? Impairment is the bottom line & it won't change. You have an amputation or you dont, It can be measured objectively. The impairment causes a disability or loss of function, but if you measure disability (loss of ability) by functional testing then someone with a severe impairment who has trained, overcome their impairment to some degree and become skilful would be considered minimally disabled because they have reduced their lack of ability. Well, why not handicap? Defined by WHO as limiting or preventing role. Not everyone who has a disability has a handicap & similar disabilities can have different handicaps How do you measure that objectively? David Blunkett,Jack Ashley,Heather McCartney Franklin D Roosevelt,Stephen Hawkins,Michael Caines May well not feel handicapped by their disability and have overcome their impairment to be successful in society But think of Mozart, his impairment disabled and handicapped him
  • #13: If we apply that argument to this field athlete His impairment is that he is a trans-femoral amputee. He uses a prosthesis to run up to throw the javelin and without his prosthesis he has developed superb balance to shot put. We cant classify him differently for each event he participates in and we cant penalise him for his skill and training so he is classified by his impairment, which wont change and can be directly & objectively compared with another trans-femoral amputee. If we were classifying him on his disability he would be penalised for overcoming his impairment and developing such amazing balance. So classification is based on impairment & groups those with the potential to have the same ability, if they have the talent & training. If they win it is because of their skill. .
  • #14: There are some people who are Unclassifiable. They may be quite disabled by pain, fatigue (ME), numbness, ligamentous instability but these things may not be permanent and they may not be objectively measurable. These people do not meet the conditions for minimal functional disability of the classification system ( another reason why a sensitive test is so important) but they can still participate in their chosen sport.
  • #15: Enables (flexible) grouping for different sports Grassroots to elite level the Profile System has been used at Paralympic Games since 2000 and for International competition for Disabled people and World Equestrian Competition since 1997. It was also used for International Triathlon competition in 2007. That was a brief look at the theory & philosophy, now lets look at an example of good practice in classification The profile system was devised by CM for DSE Its strength is that it is not sport specific or disability specific as others are, so competitor categorised for any sport, used in UK for juniors up to national level& some adults in some sports up to regional level, It can be used at grassroots level up to the point where a competitor enters open or international competition Unlike other systems if avoids need for assessors to have specialist knowledge These 2 things make it very accessible. I said earlier that there arent enough classifiers in this country. The profile system goes some way to addressing that because it is so accessible. But it has not been adopted internationally by many sports, at present only equestrian & triathlon. These 2 very different sports prove the point about its flexibility.
  • #16: Client interview basic relevant information Selection of one of three scales Conduct the examination Score use assistance if available Consult graphics Match Scores to graphics Select Profile Thus select Grade/Class
  • #17: Prior to event Allowed to be accompanied by parent, coach or team manager Companion not allowed to contribute Should warm up May need technical testing eg swimming Consent ANC disqualified