ºÝºÝߣ

ºÝºÝߣShare a Scribd company logo
Efficiency
and Equity
Micro-economie
Foundation
Alaleh Mani
2011
Self Interest, Social Interest
ï‚› Make  a choice to get out most of scarce
  resources
ï‚› Social Interest has two dimensions
Efficiency




                             Fairess
Resource allocation (Alternative
     nonmarket) Methods
Methods            Definition        Advantages              Disadvantage            Example
                                                             s
Command            Rule of order     organization with       Big system ,no          Allocate labor
                                     clear                   monitoring.             inside firms
                                     responsibilities        Delivering food in
                                     monitoring              north Korea
Majority rule      Rule of vote      If it affects           self interest and       tax for health or
                                     many                    Bureaucrats             education in vote
                                     Common
                                     resource
Contest            Rule of Winner    Motivation              Need                    Prize to motivate
                                                             Monitoring
First come first   Rule of first     Resource allocate                               High way
served                               to one in                                       no reservation
                                     sequence                                        Restaurant
Lottery            Rule of luck      No distinction                                  Give land to airlines
                                                                                     Fishing right
                                     found
                                                                                     Spectrum cell phone

Personal           Rule of Right     Marriage partner        Skin color and          Allocation job to
                                                             gender                  whites
characteristic     personality                               discrimination
Force              Rule of crucial   Enforcing law, courts
                                     Transfer wealth to
                                                             Feel living in safety   War
Demand and Marginal Benefit
ï‚› Demand=     Value the seller get=Price the
  buyer pay=Marginal benefit
ï‚› D=MB
 ∑(individual demand)=Social demand
market demand curve=economy’s
  marginal benefit curve
MSB=Market Demand
Price=#of $ you pay to lose other goods or
  services to obtain this good or service
Consumer Surplus
Value or Marginal benefit of good minus the price paid ,summed over quan
Supply and Marginal Cost
ï‚› Supply=Marginal   cost=Minimum supply
  price
ï‚› S=MC
 ∑(individual Supply)=Market demand
market supply curve=economy’s marginal
  social cost curve
MSC=Market Supply
Producer Surplus
Price received minus its minimum supply price or marginal cost, summed over q
Equilibrium in Market
Elasticity and Surplus
Efficiency and invisible hand
Underproduction and
Overproduction
ï‚› DWL=Deadweight   loss=Scale of
  inefficiency:
Inefficiency in production decrease the
  surplus


                              Shortage
                              Under Production
                   Waste
                   Over
                   production
Obstacle to Efficiency
Market Failure Cause Underproduction or
  Shortage and Overproduction or Waste:
ï‚› Price and Quantity regulation
ï‚› Taxes and subsidies
ï‚› Externalities
ï‚› Public goods and Common resources
ï‚› Monopoly
ï‚› High Transaction Costs
method
Price and       Limitation By          Underproducti   Minimum Wage
                regulation                             Rent Cap, ceiling
Quantity                               on              Limit permission of
regulation                                             Production
Tax             Increase the price     Underproducti
                to pay decrease
                the price to
                                       on
                receive
subsidies       Decrease the           Underproducti   Government
                price to pay                           payment to
                ,increase the price
                                       on              producers
                to receive
                Cost for other than    Overproductio   Contamination,
                buyer and seller                       phone in public
                                       n
Externalities   Benefit for other      Underproducti   Smoke detector,
                than buyer or seller
                                       on
Public good     Consumer same          Underproducti   National defense,
                time no pay                            Law enforcement
                   Free_RIDER
                                       on

 common         No owner, everyone
                use and put the cost
                                       Overproductio   Atlantic Salmon       Majority rule
resources       on others              n
                Tragedy of Commons

Monopoly        Sole provider of a     Underproducti
                good ,price
                maker
                                       on
ï‚› Under   Production cause:
          1.    Long line or Queue
          2.   Wasting time
          3.   Black Market
          4.   rubbery
ï‚› Over   production cause:
          1.   Waste
          2.   Destruction
          3.   Illnesses
Fairness of Market
ï‚› Victim of natural disaster
ï‚› Low skilled workers under living wage
ï‚› Principals of fairness is universally vague
ï‚› Make the economic pie greater in lowest
  cost
ï‚› No equity
Games have rules and result
     Utilitarian

                                     Same desire
                                    and capacity
               Fair result
                                    The wealthier
                                    the lesser MB
Economy as a
   game                             Both better off
                          The big
                         tradeoff
                                     …Symmetry
               Fair rules
                                      Principal
The Big Tradeoff
  Cost of Income
     transfer:
                                             Income Tax

      Tax
  collecting    Administratio
                                Employment                Capital
 agency, IRS      n Costs
   Welfare
administratin
       g,                        Work less                Save less
 Healthcare        Transfer
      sys
Tax payer           Costs                Less Quantity
Costs
Accountant
Lawyer
Auditor                                Economy Shrink
Modified version of Utilitarian
ï‚›   Theory of Justice :
    1.   Lowe tax
    2.   Consider all transfer and administration cost
    Symmetry Principal:
    1.   Behave toward others same as you expect them
         behave toward you (religion)
    2.   Equality in opportunity (economy)

    Nozick Principals
    1.Protect Private Property by enforcing law =every thing
          has an owner, theft is prevented ,strong will not
          prevail
    2.Private Property can only exchange voluntary=no theft
ï‚› In Competitive Market, respect to private
  property right and voluntary exchange
  without 6 obstacle, resources would be
  fair and efficient.

More Related Content

Efficiency and equity

  • 2. Self Interest, Social Interest ï‚› Make a choice to get out most of scarce resources ï‚› Social Interest has two dimensions Efficiency Fairess
  • 3. Resource allocation (Alternative nonmarket) Methods Methods Definition Advantages Disadvantage Example s Command Rule of order organization with Big system ,no Allocate labor clear monitoring. inside firms responsibilities Delivering food in monitoring north Korea Majority rule Rule of vote If it affects self interest and tax for health or many Bureaucrats education in vote Common resource Contest Rule of Winner Motivation Need Prize to motivate Monitoring First come first Rule of first Resource allocate High way served to one in no reservation sequence Restaurant Lottery Rule of luck No distinction Give land to airlines Fishing right found Spectrum cell phone Personal Rule of Right Marriage partner Skin color and Allocation job to gender whites characteristic personality discrimination Force Rule of crucial Enforcing law, courts Transfer wealth to Feel living in safety War
  • 4. Demand and Marginal Benefit ï‚› Demand= Value the seller get=Price the buyer pay=Marginal benefit ï‚› D=MB ï‚› ∑(individual demand)=Social demand market demand curve=economy’s marginal benefit curve MSB=Market Demand Price=#of $ you pay to lose other goods or services to obtain this good or service
  • 5. Consumer Surplus Value or Marginal benefit of good minus the price paid ,summed over quan
  • 6. Supply and Marginal Cost ï‚› Supply=Marginal cost=Minimum supply price ï‚› S=MC ï‚› ∑(individual Supply)=Market demand market supply curve=economy’s marginal social cost curve MSC=Market Supply
  • 7. Producer Surplus Price received minus its minimum supply price or marginal cost, summed over q
  • 11. Underproduction and Overproduction ï‚› DWL=Deadweight loss=Scale of inefficiency: Inefficiency in production decrease the surplus Shortage Under Production Waste Over production
  • 12. Obstacle to Efficiency Market Failure Cause Underproduction or Shortage and Overproduction or Waste: ï‚› Price and Quantity regulation ï‚› Taxes and subsidies ï‚› Externalities ï‚› Public goods and Common resources ï‚› Monopoly ï‚› High Transaction Costs
  • 13. method Price and Limitation By Underproducti Minimum Wage regulation Rent Cap, ceiling Quantity on Limit permission of regulation Production Tax Increase the price Underproducti to pay decrease the price to on receive subsidies Decrease the Underproducti Government price to pay payment to ,increase the price on producers to receive Cost for other than Overproductio Contamination, buyer and seller phone in public n Externalities Benefit for other Underproducti Smoke detector, than buyer or seller on Public good Consumer same Underproducti National defense, time no pay Law enforcement Free_RIDER on common No owner, everyone use and put the cost Overproductio Atlantic Salmon Majority rule resources on others n Tragedy of Commons Monopoly Sole provider of a Underproducti good ,price maker on
  • 14. ï‚› Under Production cause: 1. Long line or Queue 2. Wasting time 3. Black Market 4. rubbery ï‚› Over production cause: 1. Waste 2. Destruction 3. Illnesses
  • 15. Fairness of Market ï‚› Victim of natural disaster ï‚› Low skilled workers under living wage ï‚› Principals of fairness is universally vague ï‚› Make the economic pie greater in lowest cost ï‚› No equity
  • 16. Games have rules and result Utilitarian Same desire and capacity Fair result The wealthier the lesser MB Economy as a game Both better off The big tradeoff …Symmetry Fair rules Principal
  • 17. The Big Tradeoff Cost of Income transfer: Income Tax Tax collecting Administratio Employment Capital agency, IRS n Costs Welfare administratin g, Work less Save less Healthcare Transfer sys Tax payer Costs Less Quantity Costs Accountant Lawyer Auditor Economy Shrink
  • 18. Modified version of Utilitarian ï‚› Theory of Justice : 1. Lowe tax 2. Consider all transfer and administration cost Symmetry Principal: 1. Behave toward others same as you expect them behave toward you (religion) 2. Equality in opportunity (economy) Nozick Principals 1.Protect Private Property by enforcing law =every thing has an owner, theft is prevented ,strong will not prevail 2.Private Property can only exchange voluntary=no theft
  • 19. ï‚› In Competitive Market, respect to private property right and voluntary exchange without 6 obstacle, resources would be fair and efficient.