際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
EXPERIENCE WITH THE APPLICATION OF
AHP METHOD IN THE EMPLOYEE'S
COMPETENCY PROFILE OF INSTITUTE
OF INDUSTRIAL ENGINEERING AND
MANAGEMENT
Ing. Luk叩邸 Jur鱈k
Ing. Monika ujakov叩
Prof. Ing. Peter Sak叩l
The paper is a part of the submitted KEGA project
No. 037STU-4/2012 Implementation
of the subject of Sustainable Corporate Social
Responsibility into the study programme of
Industrial Management in the second degree of
study at STU MTF Trnava.
The paper is also part of the upcoming grant VEGA
project No. 1/0510/15 "Sustainable Strategic
Management vs. sustainable Corporate Social
Responsibility vs. Integrated Management System
for Strategic Business Units".
2/18
Layout
1 Analysis of University Training for Strategic Managers
of the 21ST Century
2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee
of UPIM  Model 1  EMS QUT (Evaluation model of
Sustainability Quality of University Teacher)
3 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation of Teacher
Competency Profile of UPIM  Model 2  EMSUT
(Evaluation Model for Selection of University Teacher)
3/18
1 Analysis of University Training for Strategic Managers
of the 21ST Century
A competency approach comes to the fore in the area
of teaching activities. Teacher status is now changing. Specialists
create a new model of university teacher as a professional. This
model is associated with the search for identity of teacher as a
high-educated expert on education and teaching. The modern
view of the teacher as a professional requires a high level of
autonomy, self-awareness and self-control in the performance of
his profession.
4/18
2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee
of UPIM  Model 1  EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of
Sustainability Quality of University Teacher)
Competency profile of teacher is a summary of key
competencies and from stemming therefrom capabilities,
which characterize the performance profession.
Application of AHP method for evaluation of
competency profile of an employee Institute of Industrial
Engineering and Management was carried out through the use
of Expert Choice.
5/18
6/18
2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee
of UPIM  Model 1  EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of
Sustainability Quality of University Teacher)
The starting point for the application of AHP method is to create a
hierarchical structure. Top element of the hierarchical structure is goal
of problem.
Determination of objective decision-making
The aim was to evaluate the competency profile of an employee of
Institute of Industrial Engineering and Management.
Alternatives of solution
Alternative of solution represent the employees of Institute of
Industrial Engineering and Management of Faculty of Materials
Science and Technology in Trnava. It was selected sample of five
employees of the Institute, who provided their data for processing
proposal competency profile.
7/18
2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee
of UPIM  Model 1  EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of
Sustainability Quality of University Teacher)
Proposal of criteria for evaluation of alternatives solve
8/18
2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee
of UPIM  Model 1  EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of
Sustainability Quality of University Teacher)
9/18
2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee
of UPIM  Model 1  EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of
Sustainability Quality of University Teacher)
Proposal of criteria for evaluation of alternatives solve
Solving the problem through use of the software Expert Choice:
 Determination and input of objective criteria and alternatives
to the decision problem.
 Assigning weight to individual criterion by pairwise
comparison of criteria.
 Evaluation of alternatives by paired comparisons for individual
criteria.
 Evaluation of the optimal alternative solution.
10/18
2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee
of UPIM  Model 1  EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of
Sustainability Quality of University Teacher)
Determine the weights of criteria
In the figure, can be seen that the most important criterion of
first-level hierarchical structure is the criterion Cooperation and
the criterion Qualification has the lowest weight.
11/18
2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee
of UPIM  Model 1  EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of
Sustainability Quality of University Teacher)
Evaluation of alternatives
The employees of UPIM MTF STU are named as P1, P2, P3, P4
and P5 in tables. Figure shows the ranking of employees. Most
competent employee is employee P1, then employees P2, P5,
P3 and on last position is employee P4.
12/18
2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee
of UPIM  Model 1  EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of
Sustainability Quality of University Teacher)
3 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation of Teacher
Competency Profile of UPIM  Model 2  EMSUT
(Evaluation Model for Selection of University Teacher)
Other model was designed based on recommendations
from the personnel department faculty. It is competency model
for the assessment of candidates for a job position as a university
teacher.
Determination of objective decision-making
The objective of decision-making was to determine
selection of the most suitable candidate for the job position of
university teacher and to creating of Model 2, as the proposal of
competency profile of candidate to job position of teacher of
Institute Industrial Engineering and Management.
13/18
Alternatives of solution
Alternative solutions are presented by employees of
Institute of Industrial Engineering and Management MTF STU in
Trnava. Employees were contacted through a questionnaire. It
was selected sample 6 random respondents.
14/18
3 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation of Teacher
Competency Profile of UPIM  Model 2  EMSUT
(Evaluation Model for Selection of University Teacher)
For the Model 2 was selected 12 key criteria that candidate have to met by the
for the job position of teacher of UPIM namely:
 Knowledge of a foreign language;
 Tolerance (multicultural thinking);
 Ability to lead of people;
 Ability to motivate of people;
 Empathy;
 Critical thinking;
 Ability of self-control;
 Nature and natural intelligence;
 Diligence;
 Responsibility;
 Knowledge of the subject taught;
 Communication and rhetorical skills;
15/18
3 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation of Teacher
Competency Profile of UPIM  Model 2  EMSUT
(Evaluation Model for Selection of University Teacher)
Determine the weights of criteria
In Figure, it can be seen that the most important criterion is
Responsibility and criterion Knowledge of foreign language has
the least weight.
16/18
3 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation of Teacher
Competency Profile of UPIM  Model 2  EMSUT
(Evaluation Model for Selection of University Teacher)
Evaluation of alternatives
Evaluation of alternatives can be performed by using the
pairwise comparisons. Respondent indicated as P1 is on the first
position, followed by the respondent labelled P5 and
respondent P3 takes last position.
17/18
3 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation of Teacher
Competency Profile of UPIM  Model 2  EMSUT
(Evaluation Model for Selection of University Teacher)
Thank you for your attention
lukas.jurik@stuba.sk
monika.sujakova@stuba.sk

More Related Content

Similar to EXPERIENCE WITH THE APPLICATION OF AHP METHOD IN THE EMPLOYEE'S COMPETENCY PROFILE OF INSTITUTE OF INDUSTRIAL ENGINEERING AND MANAGEMENT (20)

PDF
A HYBRID METHODS DSS FOR THE BEST PERFORMING LECTURERS SELECTION
ijscai
PDF
A HYBRID METHODS DSS FOR THE BEST PERFORMING LECTURERS SELECTION
ijscai
PDF
A HYBRID METHODS DSS FOR THE BEST PERFORMING LECTURERS SELECTION
ijscai
PDF
A HYBRID METHODS DSS FOR THE BEST PERFORMING LECTURERS SELECTION
ijscai
PDF
A HYBRID METHODS DSS FOR THE BEST PERFORMING LECTURERS SELECTION
ijscai
PDF
12223ijscai01.pdf
ijscai
PDF
A HYBRID METHODS DSS FOR THE BEST PERFORMING LECTURERS SELECTION
ijscai
PDF
Multi Criteria Decision Making Methodology on Selection of a Student for All ...
ijtsrd
PDF
Customer and Stakeholder Perspective using Analytical Hierarchy Process Metho...
sececonf
PDF
Implementation of AHP-MAUT and AHP-Profile Matching Methods in OJT Student Pl...
Gede Surya Mahendra
PDF
Application of analytical hierarchy process (ahp) in the curriculum
Alexander Decker
DOCX
FGIC2019FGIC 2nd Conference on Governance and Integrity 2019
ChereCheek752
PDF
International Refereed Journal of Engineering and Science (IRJES)
irjes
PDF
H045074150
IJERA Editor
PDF
A Model of Hybrid Approach for FAHP and TOPSIS with Supporting by DSS
IJERA Editor
PPTX
Education System and Employ-ability: From multicultural team perspective
Jayanthi Thiyagarajan
PDF
Mary Ann Downey ILSHRM Presentation
Mel-O-Cream Donuts International, Inc.
PPTX
148320592081
prachi ghoghari
PPTX
Analytic Hierarchy Process Presentation.pptx
SantanuMisra9
PPTX
Total Quality Management in Higher Education
Prof. A.Balasubramanian
A HYBRID METHODS DSS FOR THE BEST PERFORMING LECTURERS SELECTION
ijscai
A HYBRID METHODS DSS FOR THE BEST PERFORMING LECTURERS SELECTION
ijscai
A HYBRID METHODS DSS FOR THE BEST PERFORMING LECTURERS SELECTION
ijscai
A HYBRID METHODS DSS FOR THE BEST PERFORMING LECTURERS SELECTION
ijscai
A HYBRID METHODS DSS FOR THE BEST PERFORMING LECTURERS SELECTION
ijscai
12223ijscai01.pdf
ijscai
A HYBRID METHODS DSS FOR THE BEST PERFORMING LECTURERS SELECTION
ijscai
Multi Criteria Decision Making Methodology on Selection of a Student for All ...
ijtsrd
Customer and Stakeholder Perspective using Analytical Hierarchy Process Metho...
sececonf
Implementation of AHP-MAUT and AHP-Profile Matching Methods in OJT Student Pl...
Gede Surya Mahendra
Application of analytical hierarchy process (ahp) in the curriculum
Alexander Decker
FGIC2019FGIC 2nd Conference on Governance and Integrity 2019
ChereCheek752
International Refereed Journal of Engineering and Science (IRJES)
irjes
H045074150
IJERA Editor
A Model of Hybrid Approach for FAHP and TOPSIS with Supporting by DSS
IJERA Editor
Education System and Employ-ability: From multicultural team perspective
Jayanthi Thiyagarajan
Mary Ann Downey ILSHRM Presentation
Mel-O-Cream Donuts International, Inc.
148320592081
prachi ghoghari
Analytic Hierarchy Process Presentation.pptx
SantanuMisra9
Total Quality Management in Higher Education
Prof. A.Balasubramanian

Recently uploaded (10)

PPTX
ANIn Mumbai 2025 | Revolutionizing Passenger Travel with AI by Dr. Rajendra P...
AgileNetwork
PDF
Can employees write their own First Incident Report?
Writegenic AI
PDF
ANIn Pune 2025 | Workshop - - la- carte Agile by Dhiren Shah
AgileNetwork
PPTX
Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS) Practice
joshuadeleonlpt
PDF
White Paper Distributed Global Leadership Model
katjadm
PDF
High performance chiller designed for Data centres
Carrier Air Conditioner India
PDF
Steering Excellence in Turbulent Times: A Strategic Governance Toolkit
exec7
PDF
SpatzAI Micro-Conflict Resolution Toolkit - Fairer Teamwork Globally
Desmond Sherlock
PDF
UNI Concept Proposal UN Green Helmets Ministry of Peace Foundational Security
LHelferty
PDF
ANIn Mumbai 2025 | Optimising Product Backlog in SaaS by Naveen Kumar
AgileNetwork
ANIn Mumbai 2025 | Revolutionizing Passenger Travel with AI by Dr. Rajendra P...
AgileNetwork
Can employees write their own First Incident Report?
Writegenic AI
ANIn Pune 2025 | Workshop - - la- carte Agile by Dhiren Shah
AgileNetwork
Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS) Practice
joshuadeleonlpt
White Paper Distributed Global Leadership Model
katjadm
High performance chiller designed for Data centres
Carrier Air Conditioner India
Steering Excellence in Turbulent Times: A Strategic Governance Toolkit
exec7
SpatzAI Micro-Conflict Resolution Toolkit - Fairer Teamwork Globally
Desmond Sherlock
UNI Concept Proposal UN Green Helmets Ministry of Peace Foundational Security
LHelferty
ANIn Mumbai 2025 | Optimising Product Backlog in SaaS by Naveen Kumar
AgileNetwork
Ad

EXPERIENCE WITH THE APPLICATION OF AHP METHOD IN THE EMPLOYEE'S COMPETENCY PROFILE OF INSTITUTE OF INDUSTRIAL ENGINEERING AND MANAGEMENT

  • 1. EXPERIENCE WITH THE APPLICATION OF AHP METHOD IN THE EMPLOYEE'S COMPETENCY PROFILE OF INSTITUTE OF INDUSTRIAL ENGINEERING AND MANAGEMENT Ing. Luk叩邸 Jur鱈k Ing. Monika ujakov叩 Prof. Ing. Peter Sak叩l
  • 2. The paper is a part of the submitted KEGA project No. 037STU-4/2012 Implementation of the subject of Sustainable Corporate Social Responsibility into the study programme of Industrial Management in the second degree of study at STU MTF Trnava. The paper is also part of the upcoming grant VEGA project No. 1/0510/15 "Sustainable Strategic Management vs. sustainable Corporate Social Responsibility vs. Integrated Management System for Strategic Business Units". 2/18
  • 3. Layout 1 Analysis of University Training for Strategic Managers of the 21ST Century 2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee of UPIM Model 1 EMS QUT (Evaluation model of Sustainability Quality of University Teacher) 3 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation of Teacher Competency Profile of UPIM Model 2 EMSUT (Evaluation Model for Selection of University Teacher) 3/18
  • 4. 1 Analysis of University Training for Strategic Managers of the 21ST Century A competency approach comes to the fore in the area of teaching activities. Teacher status is now changing. Specialists create a new model of university teacher as a professional. This model is associated with the search for identity of teacher as a high-educated expert on education and teaching. The modern view of the teacher as a professional requires a high level of autonomy, self-awareness and self-control in the performance of his profession. 4/18
  • 5. 2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee of UPIM Model 1 EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of Sustainability Quality of University Teacher) Competency profile of teacher is a summary of key competencies and from stemming therefrom capabilities, which characterize the performance profession. Application of AHP method for evaluation of competency profile of an employee Institute of Industrial Engineering and Management was carried out through the use of Expert Choice. 5/18
  • 6. 6/18 2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee of UPIM Model 1 EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of Sustainability Quality of University Teacher)
  • 7. The starting point for the application of AHP method is to create a hierarchical structure. Top element of the hierarchical structure is goal of problem. Determination of objective decision-making The aim was to evaluate the competency profile of an employee of Institute of Industrial Engineering and Management. Alternatives of solution Alternative of solution represent the employees of Institute of Industrial Engineering and Management of Faculty of Materials Science and Technology in Trnava. It was selected sample of five employees of the Institute, who provided their data for processing proposal competency profile. 7/18 2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee of UPIM Model 1 EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of Sustainability Quality of University Teacher)
  • 8. Proposal of criteria for evaluation of alternatives solve 8/18 2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee of UPIM Model 1 EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of Sustainability Quality of University Teacher)
  • 9. 9/18 2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee of UPIM Model 1 EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of Sustainability Quality of University Teacher) Proposal of criteria for evaluation of alternatives solve
  • 10. Solving the problem through use of the software Expert Choice: Determination and input of objective criteria and alternatives to the decision problem. Assigning weight to individual criterion by pairwise comparison of criteria. Evaluation of alternatives by paired comparisons for individual criteria. Evaluation of the optimal alternative solution. 10/18 2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee of UPIM Model 1 EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of Sustainability Quality of University Teacher)
  • 11. Determine the weights of criteria In the figure, can be seen that the most important criterion of first-level hierarchical structure is the criterion Cooperation and the criterion Qualification has the lowest weight. 11/18 2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee of UPIM Model 1 EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of Sustainability Quality of University Teacher)
  • 12. Evaluation of alternatives The employees of UPIM MTF STU are named as P1, P2, P3, P4 and P5 in tables. Figure shows the ranking of employees. Most competent employee is employee P1, then employees P2, P5, P3 and on last position is employee P4. 12/18 2 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation Employee of UPIM Model 1 EMS QUT (Evaluation Model of Sustainability Quality of University Teacher)
  • 13. 3 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation of Teacher Competency Profile of UPIM Model 2 EMSUT (Evaluation Model for Selection of University Teacher) Other model was designed based on recommendations from the personnel department faculty. It is competency model for the assessment of candidates for a job position as a university teacher. Determination of objective decision-making The objective of decision-making was to determine selection of the most suitable candidate for the job position of university teacher and to creating of Model 2, as the proposal of competency profile of candidate to job position of teacher of Institute Industrial Engineering and Management. 13/18
  • 14. Alternatives of solution Alternative solutions are presented by employees of Institute of Industrial Engineering and Management MTF STU in Trnava. Employees were contacted through a questionnaire. It was selected sample 6 random respondents. 14/18 3 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation of Teacher Competency Profile of UPIM Model 2 EMSUT (Evaluation Model for Selection of University Teacher)
  • 15. For the Model 2 was selected 12 key criteria that candidate have to met by the for the job position of teacher of UPIM namely: Knowledge of a foreign language; Tolerance (multicultural thinking); Ability to lead of people; Ability to motivate of people; Empathy; Critical thinking; Ability of self-control; Nature and natural intelligence; Diligence; Responsibility; Knowledge of the subject taught; Communication and rhetorical skills; 15/18 3 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation of Teacher Competency Profile of UPIM Model 2 EMSUT (Evaluation Model for Selection of University Teacher)
  • 16. Determine the weights of criteria In Figure, it can be seen that the most important criterion is Responsibility and criterion Knowledge of foreign language has the least weight. 16/18 3 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation of Teacher Competency Profile of UPIM Model 2 EMSUT (Evaluation Model for Selection of University Teacher)
  • 17. Evaluation of alternatives Evaluation of alternatives can be performed by using the pairwise comparisons. Respondent indicated as P1 is on the first position, followed by the respondent labelled P5 and respondent P3 takes last position. 17/18 3 Application of AHP Method for Evaluation of Teacher Competency Profile of UPIM Model 2 EMSUT (Evaluation Model for Selection of University Teacher)
  • 18. Thank you for your attention lukas.jurik@stuba.sk monika.sujakova@stuba.sk