際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Harsh Narain
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
 The   myth of composite culture states that:
   The composite culture is pre-eminently the culture
    supervenient upon the mingling of the Hindu &
    Muslim cultural stream.
   The Hindus should be thankful to Muslims for their
    contribution to the composite culture.
   It is this phase of Indian culture which is of
    paramount importance as conducive to communal
    harmony& national integration.
   Such composite cultures are always desirable.
 The protagonists of this concept of
 composite Indian culture states that all was
 well between Hindus & Muslims before the
 inception of British rule in India.

 Our leaders are propagating the myth that
 the confluence of cultures is always good.
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
In 1194 AD Ghuris
   Lieutenant Qutubuddin
Aibak destroyed 27 Hindu
   temples at Delhi & built
     the Quwwat-ul-Islam
mosque with their debris.
Shaykh al-Islam of Sultan Iltutmish,
Diya ad-Din Barani, Sahifah-I Nat-I Muhammadi
Muslim culture is anti-culture or counter-
             culture in our body politics.
 During the British rule, it was taken for
 granted that the expressions Indian
 philosophy, Indian religion & Indian
 culture stood for philosophy, religion &
 culture of India.

 Everybody   was convinced that, even
 though the Muslims had permanently
 settled in India, their philosophy, religion &
 culture were alien; that their rule was a
 foreign rule
It was Lala Lajpat Rai who was
   the first to moot the idea that
 the Hindus & Muslims have
      coalesced into an Indian
people and the Muslim rule
     in India was not a foreign
                            rule.

Since then non-communal and
 secularist historians began to
                   follow the suit.
 These   secularist historians claims that;
   Muslims established their rule in India as foreign
   invaders.

   They established for all time and became Indians,
   forgetting all about their native lands.

   Secularist historians states that Muslims ruled
   India from within India, unlike British who
   exercised their sway over India from afar.
 Mere permanent settlement in a country does
 not entitle a plunderer to be looked upon as
 indigenous.

 The bulk of Muslims were preoccupied with
 uprooting Hindu religion and culture within
 limitations.

 TheirUlama exhorted them off & on to make
 the best of their sword to root out Hindus &
 convert India in Dar-al-Islam.
PAKISTAN, India 1947
   Trains packed with refugees-
Hindus and Sikhs headed for India
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
The dead - Punjab, 1947
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
Muslims massacred
         the unbelievers;
          enslaved them;
     wreaked all sorts of
  indignities upon them;
          converted them
forcibly; destroyed their
            language and
       literature, art and
                  culture.
Amir Khusrau
Aamir Khusrau
 In the eyes of Islam, Hindu society was
  nothing more than a hunting ground of the
  Muslims.
 It was a rule of Muslims, for the Muslims,
  and by the Muslims.
   The sovereign is mentioned as known as King of
    the Islam.
   The territories of his empire are referred to as the
    Land of the Islam
   Its armies as Soldiers of Islam
   Its religious and judicial head as Shaikh-ul-Islam
 He began to demolish Hindu temples & the
 Hindus were converted by reckless use of
 force throughout his sojourn in Kashmir.

 Heis said to have converted 37,000
 Hindus to Islam.
Jalal ad-Din Khalji,
Diya ad-Din Barani, Tarikh-I Firozshsahi
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
 Theologicalethics divide humanity into
 believers & non-believers, which may be
 Christians & heathens, Muslims & kafirs, or
 people of God & people of devil.

 This division is between holy and unholy,
 as if only the members of a particular
 religion can be truly good & those of other
 beliefs must be evil, however good they
 may be.
Quran, 4.89
Quran, 8.12
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
   Try to convert the kafirs to Islam.

   If any of them resist,
    1.   Try to consign them to the grave before Allah consign them to
         hell-fire, plunder & loot their property movable &
         immovable, enslave them, menfolk, womenfolk & children
         alike.

    2.   Or, where imposition of Jizya is permissible, let the Kafirs
         escape death and compound their offence of Kufr by
         disgracefully paying Jiziya.

    3.   If you still find yourself too weak to deal with the Kafirs, take
         recourse to hejira (wholesale exodus) & bide your time.
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
1.   Mecca and Medina, which only the
     Muslims are permitted to visit and inhabit
     and which the kafirs cannot even pass
     through.
2.   Hijaz, the heartland of Arabia, Mecca and
     Medina, the kafirs may only pass through
     but where they are not permitted to bury
     or cremate their dead.
3.   The rest of the territories of the world.
Mecca, Dar-al-Islam
The Great Mosque in Mecca
The Great Mosque in Mecca
Pilgrims in Mecca
A territory that has never been a Dar al-
 Islam.


A   territory that is no longer a Dar al-Islam.
 Dar-al-Islamchanges to Dar-al-Harb under
 following conditions:
   When the territory in question adjoins a Dar al-
    Harb, without any Dar al-Islam intervening
    between the two.
   When no Muslim or Dhimmi therein enjoys the
    security due to him on the basis of former
    protection rights.
   When the rule of the kafirs is freely and absolutely
    exercised.
Iqbal
 The Muslims in Dar-al-Harb have two
 alternatives:

   To embark upon Jihad with a view to converting
   the Dar-al-Harb into a Dar-al-Islam.

   Failing which, to migrate to a safer territory.
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
Dec. 25, 2003 in Gaza city
Activists wave black Islamic Jihad flags.
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
 All
    civilizations are on the way to
 transformation into the world civilization.

 Culture
       cannot remain uninfluenced by the
 phenomenon .

 And Indian culture is still maintaining its
 identity, its native genius.
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
 Many  people are rather embarrassed and
 exasperated by the dialectical character of
 this great, multidimensional religion.

 Because  they fail to find in it a stationary
 point to strike at.
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
Dara Shikoh believed
both Kufr and Islam to
   be the pathways to
                  God.
     He wrote a book
               entitled
 Samudrasangama in
             Sanskrit.
  He held Upnishad in
  the highest esteem.
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
Religion is one and it
has several branches
which are equal, true,
  and equally true. All
  prophets are equal,
        equally true..
The Buddha does on
     occasion prescribe
   worship of Gods and
            Goddesses.
 In the countries where
   Buddhism spread, it
never came into conflict
with the ancient modes
     of worship of those
                country.
Jainism knows no
   creator of the cosmos.
  It prescribes worship of
liberated Human beings.
Hinduism provides
choice for deity suited to
ones own temperament
or spiritual competence,
           which is called
         adhikara-bheda.
It is a religion based on
    theology. Judaism is
an Abrahmic religion. It
       is a theology more
              than religion
Christianity cannot
  admit into its heaven
   anyone bereft of an
absolute faith in Jesus,
        whereas Islam
 subordinates the faith
    in Jesus to faith in
          Mohammed.
 It
   has non-negotiable belief in angels.
  Heaven and hell, Day of judgment;

 Allahseated on the Empyrean on the
  seventh heaven;

 Allahsangel Gabriel, flowed his words to
  the Prophet in the form of Quran;

 It   is a religion iconoclastic to the core;
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
 Say:   O kafirs!

 I   worship not that which ye worship

 nor   worship ye that which I worship

 And    I shall not worship that which ye worship

 Nor   will ye worship that which I worship

 Unto    you your religion, and unto me my religion.
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture
Harsh narain   myths of composite culture

More Related Content

Harsh narain myths of composite culture

  • 3. The myth of composite culture states that: The composite culture is pre-eminently the culture supervenient upon the mingling of the Hindu & Muslim cultural stream. The Hindus should be thankful to Muslims for their contribution to the composite culture. It is this phase of Indian culture which is of paramount importance as conducive to communal harmony& national integration. Such composite cultures are always desirable.
  • 4. The protagonists of this concept of composite Indian culture states that all was well between Hindus & Muslims before the inception of British rule in India. Our leaders are propagating the myth that the confluence of cultures is always good.
  • 6. In 1194 AD Ghuris Lieutenant Qutubuddin Aibak destroyed 27 Hindu temples at Delhi & built the Quwwat-ul-Islam mosque with their debris.
  • 7. Shaykh al-Islam of Sultan Iltutmish, Diya ad-Din Barani, Sahifah-I Nat-I Muhammadi
  • 8. Muslim culture is anti-culture or counter- culture in our body politics.
  • 9. During the British rule, it was taken for granted that the expressions Indian philosophy, Indian religion & Indian culture stood for philosophy, religion & culture of India. Everybody was convinced that, even though the Muslims had permanently settled in India, their philosophy, religion & culture were alien; that their rule was a foreign rule
  • 10. It was Lala Lajpat Rai who was the first to moot the idea that the Hindus & Muslims have coalesced into an Indian people and the Muslim rule in India was not a foreign rule. Since then non-communal and secularist historians began to follow the suit.
  • 11. These secularist historians claims that; Muslims established their rule in India as foreign invaders. They established for all time and became Indians, forgetting all about their native lands. Secularist historians states that Muslims ruled India from within India, unlike British who exercised their sway over India from afar.
  • 12. Mere permanent settlement in a country does not entitle a plunderer to be looked upon as indigenous. The bulk of Muslims were preoccupied with uprooting Hindu religion and culture within limitations. TheirUlama exhorted them off & on to make the best of their sword to root out Hindus & convert India in Dar-al-Islam.
  • 13. PAKISTAN, India 1947 Trains packed with refugees- Hindus and Sikhs headed for India
  • 15. The dead - Punjab, 1947
  • 17. Muslims massacred the unbelievers; enslaved them; wreaked all sorts of indignities upon them; converted them forcibly; destroyed their language and literature, art and culture.
  • 20. In the eyes of Islam, Hindu society was nothing more than a hunting ground of the Muslims. It was a rule of Muslims, for the Muslims, and by the Muslims. The sovereign is mentioned as known as King of the Islam. The territories of his empire are referred to as the Land of the Islam Its armies as Soldiers of Islam Its religious and judicial head as Shaikh-ul-Islam
  • 21. He began to demolish Hindu temples & the Hindus were converted by reckless use of force throughout his sojourn in Kashmir. Heis said to have converted 37,000 Hindus to Islam.
  • 22. Jalal ad-Din Khalji, Diya ad-Din Barani, Tarikh-I Firozshsahi
  • 24. Theologicalethics divide humanity into believers & non-believers, which may be Christians & heathens, Muslims & kafirs, or people of God & people of devil. This division is between holy and unholy, as if only the members of a particular religion can be truly good & those of other beliefs must be evil, however good they may be.
  • 28. Try to convert the kafirs to Islam. If any of them resist, 1. Try to consign them to the grave before Allah consign them to hell-fire, plunder & loot their property movable & immovable, enslave them, menfolk, womenfolk & children alike. 2. Or, where imposition of Jizya is permissible, let the Kafirs escape death and compound their offence of Kufr by disgracefully paying Jiziya. 3. If you still find yourself too weak to deal with the Kafirs, take recourse to hejira (wholesale exodus) & bide your time.
  • 30. 1. Mecca and Medina, which only the Muslims are permitted to visit and inhabit and which the kafirs cannot even pass through. 2. Hijaz, the heartland of Arabia, Mecca and Medina, the kafirs may only pass through but where they are not permitted to bury or cremate their dead. 3. The rest of the territories of the world.
  • 32. The Great Mosque in Mecca
  • 33. The Great Mosque in Mecca
  • 35. A territory that has never been a Dar al- Islam. A territory that is no longer a Dar al-Islam.
  • 36. Dar-al-Islamchanges to Dar-al-Harb under following conditions: When the territory in question adjoins a Dar al- Harb, without any Dar al-Islam intervening between the two. When no Muslim or Dhimmi therein enjoys the security due to him on the basis of former protection rights. When the rule of the kafirs is freely and absolutely exercised.
  • 37. Iqbal
  • 38. The Muslims in Dar-al-Harb have two alternatives: To embark upon Jihad with a view to converting the Dar-al-Harb into a Dar-al-Islam. Failing which, to migrate to a safer territory.
  • 41. Dec. 25, 2003 in Gaza city Activists wave black Islamic Jihad flags.
  • 43. All civilizations are on the way to transformation into the world civilization. Culture cannot remain uninfluenced by the phenomenon . And Indian culture is still maintaining its identity, its native genius.
  • 47. Many people are rather embarrassed and exasperated by the dialectical character of this great, multidimensional religion. Because they fail to find in it a stationary point to strike at.
  • 49. Dara Shikoh believed both Kufr and Islam to be the pathways to God. He wrote a book entitled Samudrasangama in Sanskrit. He held Upnishad in the highest esteem.
  • 51. Religion is one and it has several branches which are equal, true, and equally true. All prophets are equal, equally true..
  • 52. The Buddha does on occasion prescribe worship of Gods and Goddesses. In the countries where Buddhism spread, it never came into conflict with the ancient modes of worship of those country.
  • 53. Jainism knows no creator of the cosmos. It prescribes worship of liberated Human beings.
  • 54. Hinduism provides choice for deity suited to ones own temperament or spiritual competence, which is called adhikara-bheda.
  • 55. It is a religion based on theology. Judaism is an Abrahmic religion. It is a theology more than religion
  • 56. Christianity cannot admit into its heaven anyone bereft of an absolute faith in Jesus, whereas Islam subordinates the faith in Jesus to faith in Mohammed.
  • 57. It has non-negotiable belief in angels. Heaven and hell, Day of judgment; Allahseated on the Empyrean on the seventh heaven; Allahsangel Gabriel, flowed his words to the Prophet in the form of Quran; It is a religion iconoclastic to the core;
  • 59. Say: O kafirs! I worship not that which ye worship nor worship ye that which I worship And I shall not worship that which ye worship Nor will ye worship that which I worship Unto you your religion, and unto me my religion.