際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Implications of the New
 NESHAP/NSPS (MACT) for the
      Oil & Gas Sector

            Presented by

            Cindy Bishop
               (B.S.Ch.E.)

American Institute of Chemical Engineers
            Dallas Chapter
            March 27, 2012


                       1
Implications of the New
        NESHAP/NSPS (MACT) for the
             Oil & Gas Sector

I. What Has Changed?
II. Who Is Affected?
III. What Needs to Be Done?
IV.When Does it Happen?
V. What If You Dont Do it?




                              2
ORIGIN

 Clean Air Act Section 111

   EPA Must List Categories of Stationary
    Sources That Cause or Contribute
    Significantly to Air Pollution
   EPA Must Issue Performance
    Standards for Each Category
      Best System of Emission
       Reduction
      Cost
      Non-air Impacts
      Energy Requirements


                       3
ORIGIN

 NSPS (40 CFR Part 60)  New Source Performance
  Standards
   New and Modified Sources
   Industry Specific
   Focus on Criteria Pollutants (VOCs, SO2)

   EPA Review Required Every 8 Years




                             4
ORIGIN
NSPS (continued)

1979  Oil & Gas Production Placed on EPAs
Priority List
June 24, 1985 - NSPS for leaking
components at gas processing plants (KKK)
October 1, 1985  SO2 regulations from
natural gas processing (LLL)




                            5
ORIGIN

 Clean Air Act Section 112

   NESHAP (40 CFR Part 63)  National Emission
    Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants
     New and Existing Sources
     Industry Specific
     Major Sources

   MACT  Maximum Achievable Control Technology
     Top 12%
     No Cost Consideration

      EPA Review Required Every 8 Years

                              6
ORIGIN

NESHAP (continued)

July 16, 1992  EPA Published List of Major
and Area Source Categories, including Oil &
Gas Production
February 12, 1998  Natural Gas
Transmission and Storage Added to List
June 17, 1999  MACT Issued (HH & HHH)
January 3, 2007  Area Sources




                           7
WHY NOW?
 January 14, 2009 suit filed
 February 4, 2010  Settlement:
    Proposed Standards by July 28, 2011
    Final Action by February 28, 2012




                           8
9
Who Is Affected?

      Operations from Well to Refinery or to Customer

Onshore & Offshore
Production (well completion and workover)
Portable Equipment
Storage
Transmission




                              10
When Does it Happen?


 Aug. 23, 2011 Rule Proposed Published
 Oct. 24, 2011 Comment Deadline
 April 3, 2012 Final Rule
 ???




                             11
What Has Changed?
NSPS
 Revised:
   Equipment Leaks (KKK)
   SO2 (LLL)

 New (OOOO):
   Hydraulic Fracturing
   Gas-driven Pneumatic Devices, Centrifugal and
    Reciprocating Compressors
   Storage Vessels

 Applies to new facilities that were constructed or
  modified after August 23, 2011


                            12
What Has Changed?
NESHAP
 Revised
   Oil & Gas Production Facilities (HH)
   Gas Transmission and Storage (HHH)

 New
   Small Glycol Dehydrators
   Storage Vessels at Major Sources

 Must Notify EPA within 1 year after rule becomes
  final




                           13
NSPS

 Oil & Gas Production, Transmission, and Distribution
                       (OOOO)

Applies to all construction, modification or
reconstruction after August 23, 2011

Includes fracking or refracking existing wellhead

Compliance date: date of final rule publication.




                              14
NSPS
 Oil & Gas Production, Transmission, and Distribution
                       (OOOO)

Reduced Emission Completion (REC)
  Route gas during flowback into collection system
  Use sandtraps, surge vessels, separators, and tanks
  during flowback and cleanout operations
  Capture and direct flowback emissions that cannot
  be routed to a gathering line to a combustion device
  (flare)




                            15
NSPS
Oil & Gas Production, Transmission, and Distribution
(OOOO)

Compressor standards
  Rotating compressor: dry seal system
  Reciprocating compressor: replace rod packing
     before 26,000 operating hours

Pneumatic controller: zero emissions of natural gas if
at gas processing plant, otherwise no more than 6 scfh
(switch to compressed air driven from gas controller)



                             16
NSPS

   Oil & Gas Production, Transmission, and Distribution
                         (OOOO)

Condensate and Crude Oil Storage Tanks

     If :
                 At least one barrel per day condensate
            or
                 At least 20 barrels per day crude oil;

     Then, 95% VOC emission reduction



                                     17
NSPS

Sulfur Recovery Units at Onshore Gas Processing
Plants

SO2 standards:

 Feed rates of 5 tons per day or greater or
 With an acid gas stream H2S concentration of
50% or greater

SO2 emission reduction of 99.9% (was 99.8%)




                          18
NSPS


LDAR (Subpart VVa instead of VV)

Applies to onshore gas processing plants

Lower leak threshold
Monitoring connectors




                            19
NSPS


Startup, Shutdown, Malfunction

No Free Pass During Startup and Shutdown

Affirmative Defense for Malfunctions

   Sudden
   Infrequent
   Not reasonably preventable
   Not caused by poor maintenance or careless
       operation

                            20
NSPS
Registration/recordkeeping

Construction, startup, and modification notifications

Well registration and 30-day notification prior to each
well completion

Annual Compliance Certification

Third Party verification

Electronic reporting

Over 20,000 completions and recompletions annually

                                21
NESHAP




   22
23
24
NESHAP Subparts HH & HHH

Addition of Small Glycol Dehydrators
Oil & Gas Production: gas flowrate < 85,000 scmd or
    0.90 Mg/yr benzene emissions

   Existing sources:    1.10 x 10-4 g BTEX/scm
   New sources:         4.66 x 10-6 g BTEX/scm
Gas Transmission & Storage: gas flowrate < 283,000 scmd or
   0.90 Mg/yr benzene emissions

   Existing sources:    6.42 x 10-5 g BTEX/scm
   New sources:         1.10x 10-5 g BTEX/scm
Types of control: process vent 損 control device or closed-
vent system


                               25
NESHAP Subparts HH & HHH

Storage Vessels
95% reduction of HAPs for all storage vessels

Process modifications
Flare
Incinerator
Carbon Filter
Condenser

Performance Testing of Control Device

Elimination of Startup, Shutdown & Malfunction
Exemption (See NSPS)


                            26
NESHAP Subparts HH & HHH


Compliance dates:

Existing sources: 3 years after the date of final rule
publication

New sources (commenced construction on or after August
23, 2011): immediately upon startup or the date of final
rule publication, whichever is later




                                27
What has industry said?
Rules will slow drilling, cut natural gas production
and reduce royalties (API)

Equipment for capturing emissions during
completions is unlikely to be as readily available as
EPA assumed, and equipment would have to spend
more time at each site than estimated.




                          28
What If You Dont Do it?
 EPA can make you do it

 Civil Penalties up to $25,000/day/violation

 Criminal Penalties $250,000 per day per
  violation and up to five years in jail.
  Corporations are subject to up to $500,000 per
  day per violation.

 $10,000 bounty




                              29
EPA Region 6 20112013 National Enforcement Initiatives
1.   Keeping raw sewage and contaminated stormwater out of our nations
     waters
2.   Preventing animal waste from contaminating surface and ground waters
3.   Cutting Toxic Air Pollution that Affects Communities Health
4.   Reducing Widespread Air Pollution from the Largest Sources, especially the
     Coal-Fired Utility, Cement, Glass, and Acid Sectors
5.   Reducing pollution from mineral processing operations
6.   ASSURING ENERGY EXTRACTION SECTOR COMPLIANCE WITH
     ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS

To address these emerging problems, EPA will develop an initiative to
  assure that energy extraction activities are complying with federal
  requirements




                                            30
   Stay on top of the rules be organized!
   Look for exemptions
   Start reviewing operations now  do not wait until
    the rules are final.
   Look for innovative/emerging technology
   EPA favors those who voluntarily disclose
    problems.




                              31
Implications of the New
NESHAP/NSPS (MACT) for the
     Oil & Gas Sector

        Presented by

        Cindy Bishop

          214-893-5646
    cbishop@cbishoplaw.com

     www.cbishoplaw.com

                32

More Related Content

Impact of New NSPS and NESHAP Regulations on Oil &amp; Gas Industry

  • 1. Implications of the New NESHAP/NSPS (MACT) for the Oil & Gas Sector Presented by Cindy Bishop (B.S.Ch.E.) American Institute of Chemical Engineers Dallas Chapter March 27, 2012 1
  • 2. Implications of the New NESHAP/NSPS (MACT) for the Oil & Gas Sector I. What Has Changed? II. Who Is Affected? III. What Needs to Be Done? IV.When Does it Happen? V. What If You Dont Do it? 2
  • 3. ORIGIN Clean Air Act Section 111 EPA Must List Categories of Stationary Sources That Cause or Contribute Significantly to Air Pollution EPA Must Issue Performance Standards for Each Category Best System of Emission Reduction Cost Non-air Impacts Energy Requirements 3
  • 4. ORIGIN NSPS (40 CFR Part 60) New Source Performance Standards New and Modified Sources Industry Specific Focus on Criteria Pollutants (VOCs, SO2) EPA Review Required Every 8 Years 4
  • 5. ORIGIN NSPS (continued) 1979 Oil & Gas Production Placed on EPAs Priority List June 24, 1985 - NSPS for leaking components at gas processing plants (KKK) October 1, 1985 SO2 regulations from natural gas processing (LLL) 5
  • 6. ORIGIN Clean Air Act Section 112 NESHAP (40 CFR Part 63) National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants New and Existing Sources Industry Specific Major Sources MACT Maximum Achievable Control Technology Top 12% No Cost Consideration EPA Review Required Every 8 Years 6
  • 7. ORIGIN NESHAP (continued) July 16, 1992 EPA Published List of Major and Area Source Categories, including Oil & Gas Production February 12, 1998 Natural Gas Transmission and Storage Added to List June 17, 1999 MACT Issued (HH & HHH) January 3, 2007 Area Sources 7
  • 8. WHY NOW? January 14, 2009 suit filed February 4, 2010 Settlement: Proposed Standards by July 28, 2011 Final Action by February 28, 2012 8
  • 9. 9
  • 10. Who Is Affected? Operations from Well to Refinery or to Customer Onshore & Offshore Production (well completion and workover) Portable Equipment Storage Transmission 10
  • 11. When Does it Happen? Aug. 23, 2011 Rule Proposed Published Oct. 24, 2011 Comment Deadline April 3, 2012 Final Rule ??? 11
  • 12. What Has Changed? NSPS Revised: Equipment Leaks (KKK) SO2 (LLL) New (OOOO): Hydraulic Fracturing Gas-driven Pneumatic Devices, Centrifugal and Reciprocating Compressors Storage Vessels Applies to new facilities that were constructed or modified after August 23, 2011 12
  • 13. What Has Changed? NESHAP Revised Oil & Gas Production Facilities (HH) Gas Transmission and Storage (HHH) New Small Glycol Dehydrators Storage Vessels at Major Sources Must Notify EPA within 1 year after rule becomes final 13
  • 14. NSPS Oil & Gas Production, Transmission, and Distribution (OOOO) Applies to all construction, modification or reconstruction after August 23, 2011 Includes fracking or refracking existing wellhead Compliance date: date of final rule publication. 14
  • 15. NSPS Oil & Gas Production, Transmission, and Distribution (OOOO) Reduced Emission Completion (REC) Route gas during flowback into collection system Use sandtraps, surge vessels, separators, and tanks during flowback and cleanout operations Capture and direct flowback emissions that cannot be routed to a gathering line to a combustion device (flare) 15
  • 16. NSPS Oil & Gas Production, Transmission, and Distribution (OOOO) Compressor standards Rotating compressor: dry seal system Reciprocating compressor: replace rod packing before 26,000 operating hours Pneumatic controller: zero emissions of natural gas if at gas processing plant, otherwise no more than 6 scfh (switch to compressed air driven from gas controller) 16
  • 17. NSPS Oil & Gas Production, Transmission, and Distribution (OOOO) Condensate and Crude Oil Storage Tanks If : At least one barrel per day condensate or At least 20 barrels per day crude oil; Then, 95% VOC emission reduction 17
  • 18. NSPS Sulfur Recovery Units at Onshore Gas Processing Plants SO2 standards: Feed rates of 5 tons per day or greater or With an acid gas stream H2S concentration of 50% or greater SO2 emission reduction of 99.9% (was 99.8%) 18
  • 19. NSPS LDAR (Subpart VVa instead of VV) Applies to onshore gas processing plants Lower leak threshold Monitoring connectors 19
  • 20. NSPS Startup, Shutdown, Malfunction No Free Pass During Startup and Shutdown Affirmative Defense for Malfunctions Sudden Infrequent Not reasonably preventable Not caused by poor maintenance or careless operation 20
  • 21. NSPS Registration/recordkeeping Construction, startup, and modification notifications Well registration and 30-day notification prior to each well completion Annual Compliance Certification Third Party verification Electronic reporting Over 20,000 completions and recompletions annually 21
  • 22. NESHAP 22
  • 23. 23
  • 24. 24
  • 25. NESHAP Subparts HH & HHH Addition of Small Glycol Dehydrators Oil & Gas Production: gas flowrate < 85,000 scmd or 0.90 Mg/yr benzene emissions Existing sources: 1.10 x 10-4 g BTEX/scm New sources: 4.66 x 10-6 g BTEX/scm Gas Transmission & Storage: gas flowrate < 283,000 scmd or 0.90 Mg/yr benzene emissions Existing sources: 6.42 x 10-5 g BTEX/scm New sources: 1.10x 10-5 g BTEX/scm Types of control: process vent 損 control device or closed- vent system 25
  • 26. NESHAP Subparts HH & HHH Storage Vessels 95% reduction of HAPs for all storage vessels Process modifications Flare Incinerator Carbon Filter Condenser Performance Testing of Control Device Elimination of Startup, Shutdown & Malfunction Exemption (See NSPS) 26
  • 27. NESHAP Subparts HH & HHH Compliance dates: Existing sources: 3 years after the date of final rule publication New sources (commenced construction on or after August 23, 2011): immediately upon startup or the date of final rule publication, whichever is later 27
  • 28. What has industry said? Rules will slow drilling, cut natural gas production and reduce royalties (API) Equipment for capturing emissions during completions is unlikely to be as readily available as EPA assumed, and equipment would have to spend more time at each site than estimated. 28
  • 29. What If You Dont Do it? EPA can make you do it Civil Penalties up to $25,000/day/violation Criminal Penalties $250,000 per day per violation and up to five years in jail. Corporations are subject to up to $500,000 per day per violation. $10,000 bounty 29
  • 30. EPA Region 6 20112013 National Enforcement Initiatives 1. Keeping raw sewage and contaminated stormwater out of our nations waters 2. Preventing animal waste from contaminating surface and ground waters 3. Cutting Toxic Air Pollution that Affects Communities Health 4. Reducing Widespread Air Pollution from the Largest Sources, especially the Coal-Fired Utility, Cement, Glass, and Acid Sectors 5. Reducing pollution from mineral processing operations 6. ASSURING ENERGY EXTRACTION SECTOR COMPLIANCE WITH ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS To address these emerging problems, EPA will develop an initiative to assure that energy extraction activities are complying with federal requirements 30
  • 31. Stay on top of the rules be organized! Look for exemptions Start reviewing operations now do not wait until the rules are final. Look for innovative/emerging technology EPA favors those who voluntarily disclose problems. 31
  • 32. Implications of the New NESHAP/NSPS (MACT) for the Oil & Gas Sector Presented by Cindy Bishop 214-893-5646 cbishop@cbishoplaw.com www.cbishoplaw.com 32