際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo

India Israel comparison (spirituality and practicality)

R
Ramesh BN

Recently Indian prime minister Modi, compared India with Israel. I have compiled why it is a wrong comparison.

1 of 9
Download to read offline
Table of Contents Comparison of India and Israel (spirituality and practicality)..............................................................1 How Indians using spirituality behave in various situation..............................................................1 How Israelis using practicality behave in various situation.............................................................3 Indians turn any spiritual statement upside down in practical world....................................................5 Going deeper into psychology of Indians and Israelis.........................................................................5 Confusion..............................................................................................................................................7 Outcome of this confusion................................................................................................................7 India looses its brand due to confusion.............................................................................................8 What india needs to do.....................................................................................................................8 Summary...............................................................................................................................................9 Comparison of India and Israel (spirituality and practicality) 1) Indians are spiritual people. While Israelis are practical people. 2) Indians expect everything will be taken care by god. While Israelis do it them selves. 3) Indians forgive and forget, live and let live. While Israelis pay for what they get. Get for what they pay. Basically Indians are basically spiritual people. Known for simplicity spiritual solutions Israelis are basically practical people. Known for optimization, efficiency, value for money practical solutions Example:- How Indians using spirituality behave in various situation. Customer situation Indian spiritual answer Indian spiritual reasoning New phone is not working Adjust karo We did our best, It is upto god. Write complaint. Judge is taking bribe Adjust karo Judge's wife is having cancer. It is fine Principal is taking bribe Adjust karo He is doing charity with money
Employee is doing stock trading in office hours Adjust karo He needs some extra money. Manager is corrupt, taking bribe Everybody does, adjust karo I am doing for company. I take my part. Police is taking bribe Everybody does, adjust karo He is paid less salary, so ok. Machine is not working The bug is in some other component. It is not my responsibility. (gods will) (I am not bothered) Doing incomplete/defective office work. Oh, is it? I tried my best. I was told only that much. That was as in document. Road is not good Adjust and live Not my duty. (gods will) People sleeping in govt department I did my work. I did what was assigned to me. Why should I bother about others work. A person is working for nation, charity He is mad His karma. Laugh at him. Hospital doing unwanted operations. They need to live It is business. It is justified in my business. Sell unwanted software to customer My business is just to sell. Users karma. I just sell. I taking bribe My work needs it. Tell gods name and take. All done for stomach god, wife god. Making defect product and selling My business is just to sell. Users karma. I just sell. I telling lies and doing fraud My work needs it. Remember gods name and tell lie. All done for stomach god, wife god. Create loop holes in law, business processes for increasing our profit. Exploit people where ever possible. My work needs it. Users karma let them face it. Keep city clean Tell, city has to be clean. Do nothing. Not my work. I am busy meditating
How Israelis using practicality behave in various situation. Customer situation Israelis practical answer Israelis practical reasoning New phone is not working Find route cause. Find how to prevent it. Fix now. They have trusted us by buying our goods. We need to help them. Judge is taking bribe Create mechanism for judge to avoid taking bribe. Create support mechanism for judges. Judges do well, when no perverted forces influence them. Monitor and ensure they work as expected. Principal is taking bribe Create legal ways of generating money principal needs. Ensure principal does school work properly. Principal is in school business. His goal is teaching. Money shortage should not be bottle neck. Employee is doing stock trading in office hours Define policy and inform him. What is right and wrong. This is part of market economy. Companies get money from investors like him investing in shares. Manager is corrupt, taking bribe Create incentives for manager. He gets share in projects success. Aligning managers profit to companies profit is dual benefit. Police is taking bribe Give training on how to interact, understand. Ensure he is monitored and given proper payment for good work. Based on customer feedback. People take bribe when salary is less, lack training. Machine is not working Understand why it is not working. If bug is in some other component talk to that team. Give all cooperation to solve it. Customer comes first. Doing incomplete/defective office work. Oh. Is there a way to rectify that. Rectify right now. Look at big picture. Imagine customers problems. Solve it from his perspective. Road is not good Take leadership and get necessary funding to get it fixed. Make people pay for good roads. It is my responsibility my surrounding is good. Understand dynamics of economy and work with it. People sleeping in govt department Assign work such that value for money given is ensured. Measure, monitor, incentivise people. Make use of time to skill improvement, take more responsibility. Value for salary taken has to be given. A person is working for nation, Create article about him. Make Such people are needed. We
charity him role model. Find what motivates him. Find how to invest and expand his operation. need to work with them. Hospital doing unwanted operations. Do measurable, justifiable operations. Evaluate pros and cons. It is business. But do work correctly. Sell unwanted software to customer My business is just to show value to customer. The law allows for convincing and selling. Up to them to use it once they have paid. Customer is free to use/notuse the way they want. There is limited scope to go deep into customers needs. We can only show value of our software and sell them. I taking bribe Convert it to business development fees, commission. Explain what is right and wrong. Have approval processes, monitoring as needed. Making defective product and selling Discuss what it takes to make quality products. He has taken risk to make product, proper funding and guidance ca make him successful entrepreneur. I telling lies and doing fraud Discuss and arrive at what is allowed and correct. People need to do business with confidence. Need to legalize and normalize lies and frauds as needed in society. Create loop holes in law, business processes for increasing our profit. Document what is allowed and what is left open for interpretation. Monitor usage of laws and then make necessary changes. Keep city clean Create processes and systems for people to invest in keeping city clean. Monitor and implement
Indians turn any spiritual statement upside down in practical world. Spiritual statement-1 1. See god in everybody. 2. It is same soul in everybody. 3. Every bodies soul is same. How spiritual statement-1 is used 1. His money is my money. (same soul) 2. Weather he enjoys his money or I enjoy his money it goes to same soul. (same soul) 3. His wife is my wife. (same soul) 4. His property is my property. (same soul) 5. Which ever way money comes, it is meant for me. (same soul) Other similar misuse of spiritual statement 1) His pain is my pain, So we should help others. (spiritual) My enjoyment is his enjoyment, So I should enjoy with his money. (if above is true, this is also true) 2) We all need to work for being happy. (spiritual) We are already happy, without working. Why work then? (if above is true, this is also true) 3) Everything happens by gods wish (spiritual) I robbed, lied , and raped. (It was all gods wish) 4) Everything goes to god. It does not matter what I do. Exploit, rob, rape, do fraud as you like. (It all goes to god) This ends-up creating mess for themselves and others. Going deeper into psychology of Indians and Israelis People develop psychology according to what challenges they face and how they are taught to address the challenges. 1. Indians tell, liberate from greed and cooperate in world. Israelis tell, liberate from meaning less beliefs and operate in world. 2. Indians tell, find solution by cooperating with environment Israelis tell, model practical problems and design solution considering market forces, using mathematical modeling.
3. Indians find spiritual justifications and explanation to worldly problems. Israelis find practical explanations and justifications to worldly problems. 4. Indians, invent, understand, cooperate and explain world from simple life perspective. Israelis, invent, market, expand, create wealth, control and manage world practically.
Confusion For every practical problem, needs, there is a spiritual angle with similar words. Due to this Indians confuse everything.. Example:- Indian administrators (lawyers, judges, police, business men) are expected to be practical people. They are given training to become practical people. But instead of becoming practical people like Israelis, they become criminals(using spiritual justification for personal gains), non functional officers(not giving expected output). Because they don't understand practical problems, practical approaches. Those who are disenchanted with this confusion, they use spiritual justification to solve practical problems, creating new practical problems. (Reservation problem, women empowerment problem, problem with empowerment of weaker section) (At international level see problems in various treaties, agreements india has made with china, pakistan, bangladesh, various USA universities). Outcome of this confusion There is pervasive starvation of wealth, money, enjoyment, appreciation in indian environment. So people sometime switch between practical and spiritual interoperably. Also indians remain poor as none of the practical problems are approached from practical perspective..
India looses its brand due to confusion What Indians and Israelis are respected for in the world? The world respects india for simplicity spirituality non violence honesty and integrity The world respects Israel for richness efficiency and performance practicality meaningful justifications value for money calibrated use of power. honesty and integrity in business Indians boasting, surgical strikes as world power creates a funny situation. We need first become really practical people. What india needs to do 1. Create mechanism to manage duality (practicality and spirituality) 2. Create mechanism to manage practicality. 3. Allow spiritual people to continue spirituality. (This is good for environment)
Summary India's portfolio is in spiritual achievements. India is a world superpower on spirituality. We need to gradually build practical portfolio. We need to discover balance between spirituality and practicality. Israel is a practical super power.

More Related Content

India Israel comparison (spirituality and practicality)

  • 1. Table of Contents Comparison of India and Israel (spirituality and practicality)..............................................................1 How Indians using spirituality behave in various situation..............................................................1 How Israelis using practicality behave in various situation.............................................................3 Indians turn any spiritual statement upside down in practical world....................................................5 Going deeper into psychology of Indians and Israelis.........................................................................5 Confusion..............................................................................................................................................7 Outcome of this confusion................................................................................................................7 India looses its brand due to confusion.............................................................................................8 What india needs to do.....................................................................................................................8 Summary...............................................................................................................................................9 Comparison of India and Israel (spirituality and practicality) 1) Indians are spiritual people. While Israelis are practical people. 2) Indians expect everything will be taken care by god. While Israelis do it them selves. 3) Indians forgive and forget, live and let live. While Israelis pay for what they get. Get for what they pay. Basically Indians are basically spiritual people. Known for simplicity spiritual solutions Israelis are basically practical people. Known for optimization, efficiency, value for money practical solutions Example:- How Indians using spirituality behave in various situation. Customer situation Indian spiritual answer Indian spiritual reasoning New phone is not working Adjust karo We did our best, It is upto god. Write complaint. Judge is taking bribe Adjust karo Judge's wife is having cancer. It is fine Principal is taking bribe Adjust karo He is doing charity with money
  • 2. Employee is doing stock trading in office hours Adjust karo He needs some extra money. Manager is corrupt, taking bribe Everybody does, adjust karo I am doing for company. I take my part. Police is taking bribe Everybody does, adjust karo He is paid less salary, so ok. Machine is not working The bug is in some other component. It is not my responsibility. (gods will) (I am not bothered) Doing incomplete/defective office work. Oh, is it? I tried my best. I was told only that much. That was as in document. Road is not good Adjust and live Not my duty. (gods will) People sleeping in govt department I did my work. I did what was assigned to me. Why should I bother about others work. A person is working for nation, charity He is mad His karma. Laugh at him. Hospital doing unwanted operations. They need to live It is business. It is justified in my business. Sell unwanted software to customer My business is just to sell. Users karma. I just sell. I taking bribe My work needs it. Tell gods name and take. All done for stomach god, wife god. Making defect product and selling My business is just to sell. Users karma. I just sell. I telling lies and doing fraud My work needs it. Remember gods name and tell lie. All done for stomach god, wife god. Create loop holes in law, business processes for increasing our profit. Exploit people where ever possible. My work needs it. Users karma let them face it. Keep city clean Tell, city has to be clean. Do nothing. Not my work. I am busy meditating
  • 3. How Israelis using practicality behave in various situation. Customer situation Israelis practical answer Israelis practical reasoning New phone is not working Find route cause. Find how to prevent it. Fix now. They have trusted us by buying our goods. We need to help them. Judge is taking bribe Create mechanism for judge to avoid taking bribe. Create support mechanism for judges. Judges do well, when no perverted forces influence them. Monitor and ensure they work as expected. Principal is taking bribe Create legal ways of generating money principal needs. Ensure principal does school work properly. Principal is in school business. His goal is teaching. Money shortage should not be bottle neck. Employee is doing stock trading in office hours Define policy and inform him. What is right and wrong. This is part of market economy. Companies get money from investors like him investing in shares. Manager is corrupt, taking bribe Create incentives for manager. He gets share in projects success. Aligning managers profit to companies profit is dual benefit. Police is taking bribe Give training on how to interact, understand. Ensure he is monitored and given proper payment for good work. Based on customer feedback. People take bribe when salary is less, lack training. Machine is not working Understand why it is not working. If bug is in some other component talk to that team. Give all cooperation to solve it. Customer comes first. Doing incomplete/defective office work. Oh. Is there a way to rectify that. Rectify right now. Look at big picture. Imagine customers problems. Solve it from his perspective. Road is not good Take leadership and get necessary funding to get it fixed. Make people pay for good roads. It is my responsibility my surrounding is good. Understand dynamics of economy and work with it. People sleeping in govt department Assign work such that value for money given is ensured. Measure, monitor, incentivise people. Make use of time to skill improvement, take more responsibility. Value for salary taken has to be given. A person is working for nation, Create article about him. Make Such people are needed. We
  • 4. charity him role model. Find what motivates him. Find how to invest and expand his operation. need to work with them. Hospital doing unwanted operations. Do measurable, justifiable operations. Evaluate pros and cons. It is business. But do work correctly. Sell unwanted software to customer My business is just to show value to customer. The law allows for convincing and selling. Up to them to use it once they have paid. Customer is free to use/notuse the way they want. There is limited scope to go deep into customers needs. We can only show value of our software and sell them. I taking bribe Convert it to business development fees, commission. Explain what is right and wrong. Have approval processes, monitoring as needed. Making defective product and selling Discuss what it takes to make quality products. He has taken risk to make product, proper funding and guidance ca make him successful entrepreneur. I telling lies and doing fraud Discuss and arrive at what is allowed and correct. People need to do business with confidence. Need to legalize and normalize lies and frauds as needed in society. Create loop holes in law, business processes for increasing our profit. Document what is allowed and what is left open for interpretation. Monitor usage of laws and then make necessary changes. Keep city clean Create processes and systems for people to invest in keeping city clean. Monitor and implement
  • 5. Indians turn any spiritual statement upside down in practical world. Spiritual statement-1 1. See god in everybody. 2. It is same soul in everybody. 3. Every bodies soul is same. How spiritual statement-1 is used 1. His money is my money. (same soul) 2. Weather he enjoys his money or I enjoy his money it goes to same soul. (same soul) 3. His wife is my wife. (same soul) 4. His property is my property. (same soul) 5. Which ever way money comes, it is meant for me. (same soul) Other similar misuse of spiritual statement 1) His pain is my pain, So we should help others. (spiritual) My enjoyment is his enjoyment, So I should enjoy with his money. (if above is true, this is also true) 2) We all need to work for being happy. (spiritual) We are already happy, without working. Why work then? (if above is true, this is also true) 3) Everything happens by gods wish (spiritual) I robbed, lied , and raped. (It was all gods wish) 4) Everything goes to god. It does not matter what I do. Exploit, rob, rape, do fraud as you like. (It all goes to god) This ends-up creating mess for themselves and others. Going deeper into psychology of Indians and Israelis People develop psychology according to what challenges they face and how they are taught to address the challenges. 1. Indians tell, liberate from greed and cooperate in world. Israelis tell, liberate from meaning less beliefs and operate in world. 2. Indians tell, find solution by cooperating with environment Israelis tell, model practical problems and design solution considering market forces, using mathematical modeling.
  • 6. 3. Indians find spiritual justifications and explanation to worldly problems. Israelis find practical explanations and justifications to worldly problems. 4. Indians, invent, understand, cooperate and explain world from simple life perspective. Israelis, invent, market, expand, create wealth, control and manage world practically.
  • 7. Confusion For every practical problem, needs, there is a spiritual angle with similar words. Due to this Indians confuse everything.. Example:- Indian administrators (lawyers, judges, police, business men) are expected to be practical people. They are given training to become practical people. But instead of becoming practical people like Israelis, they become criminals(using spiritual justification for personal gains), non functional officers(not giving expected output). Because they don't understand practical problems, practical approaches. Those who are disenchanted with this confusion, they use spiritual justification to solve practical problems, creating new practical problems. (Reservation problem, women empowerment problem, problem with empowerment of weaker section) (At international level see problems in various treaties, agreements india has made with china, pakistan, bangladesh, various USA universities). Outcome of this confusion There is pervasive starvation of wealth, money, enjoyment, appreciation in indian environment. So people sometime switch between practical and spiritual interoperably. Also indians remain poor as none of the practical problems are approached from practical perspective..
  • 8. India looses its brand due to confusion What Indians and Israelis are respected for in the world? The world respects india for simplicity spirituality non violence honesty and integrity The world respects Israel for richness efficiency and performance practicality meaningful justifications value for money calibrated use of power. honesty and integrity in business Indians boasting, surgical strikes as world power creates a funny situation. We need first become really practical people. What india needs to do 1. Create mechanism to manage duality (practicality and spirituality) 2. Create mechanism to manage practicality. 3. Allow spiritual people to continue spirituality. (This is good for environment)
  • 9. Summary India's portfolio is in spiritual achievements. India is a world superpower on spirituality. We need to gradually build practical portfolio. We need to discover balance between spirituality and practicality. Israel is a practical super power.