Adult female field crickets are more influenced by their adult acoustic social environment than their juvenile environment in terms of reproductive behavior. A study exposed female crickets to song or no song as juveniles and adults in a factorial design. It found that adult acoustic exposure had a stronger effect, reducing contact with speakers, increasing time to contact, and increasing distance settled from speakers compared to juvenile exposure. This suggests plasticity in reproductive behavior remains throughout adulthood rather than being fixed during development. This plasticity may have facilitated rapid evolution of sexual signals and mating behavior in these crickets.
1 of 25
Download to read offline
More Related Content
Insect love songs: how the social environment influences mating behavior
1. Adult acoustic experience
influences reproductive behavior
more than does juvenile
experience in female field crickets
Elizabeth Swanger, Marlene Zuk
University of Minnesota
Graduate Program in Ecology, Evolution, and
Behavior
swang009@umn.edu
August 5, 2014
3. The social environment
influences mating behavior
Kasumovic & Brooks 2011, Quart Rev Biol 83: 181. Fowler-Finn & Rodriguez 2011, J Evol Biol 66: 459.
Females often attend to the quantity and
attractiveness of signaling males and adjust their
mating thresholds and preferences accordingly.
4. Social environment, mate choice
plasticity, and selection
selection
social
environment
responses
to sexual
signals
5. Timescale of phenotypic
plasticity
Bill Hubick; Wikimedia Commons; Michael Hrabar
1Marler 1970. J Comp Phys Psych Monogr 71: 1. 2Sheehan & Tibbetts 2011. Science 334: 1272.
CRITICAL WINDOW1 FIXED DURING
DEVELOPMENT
FLEXIBLE THROUGHOUT
ADULTHOOD2
6. Social environment, mate choice
plasticity, and selection
Is reproductive behavior fixed based on
experiences during development?
Does it remain flexible throughout adulthood?
What are the relative roles of the juvenile and adult
social environments in adult females responses to
sexual signals?
7. The Pacific field cricket
(Teleogryllus oceanicus)
Tinghitella et al. 2011. J Evol Biol 24: 1199.
8. Acoustic sexual signals in T.
oceanicus
Zuk et al. 2008. Anim Behav 76: 1065.
CALLING SONG
Long-distance attractor
Long chirp followed by
short chirps
COURTSHIP SONG
Short-range
More variable, long and
short chirps
Females accept or reject
11. Mating experience influences
responses to subsequent mates
Rebar et al. 2011. Behav Ecol 22: 303.
Females previously mated to males with nonpreferred
courtship songs exhibit stronger preferences in favor of their
next mate, regardless of his attractiveness.
Time to remate (1/t)
Spermatophore
retention (min)
12. Juvenile acoustic experience
influences responses to signals
Mating experience influences
responses to subsequent mates
WHEN DOES SOCIAL
EXPERIENCE MATTER MORE?
13. Factorial design:
Stage x acoustic environment
Song Song
No Song Song
Song No Song
No Song No Song
Juvenile
environment
Adult
environment Responsiveness to calling song
14. Factorial design:
Stage x acoustic environment
Song Song
No Song Song
Song No Song
No Song No Song
Juvenile
environment
Adult
environment Responsiveness to calling song
15. Factorial design:
Stage x acoustic environment
Song Song
No Song Song
Song No Song
No Song No Song
Juvenile
environment
Adult
environment Responsiveness to calling song
16. Adult exposure to song reduces
contact with speaker
Adult environment:
p = 0.001
Juvenile environment:
p = 0.07
Juvenile Environment:
No Song
Juvenile Environment:
Song
17. Adult song exposure increases
time to contact speaker
Juvenile Environment:
No Song
Adult environment:
p = 0.046
Juvenile environment:
p > 0.20
Juvenile Environment:
Song
18. Adult song exposure increases
distance settled from speaker
Juvenile Environment:
No Song
Juvenile Environment:
Song
Adult environment:
p = 0.024
Juvenile environment:
p > 0.70
19. What is the timescale of plasticity
in reproductive behavior?
Pet Solutions Pet Care Corner; Brian Robin
What are the relative roles of juvenile and adult
social experience in determining female
responses to sexual signals?
20. Behavioral shifts should track
demographic shifts
Time (days)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
BJSmit on Flickr; miracleofnature.org
21. Social environment, mate choice
plasticity, and selection
selection
social
environment
responses
to sexual
signals
22. Plasticity in mating behavior may
have facilitated rapid evolution
Wikimedia Commons, Nathan Bailey
selection
social
environment
responses
to sexual
signals
23. Plasticity in mating behavior may
have facilitated rapid evolution
Kauai
Hawaii
Maui
Molokai
Oahu
>90%
~0-10%
~50%
24. How ELSE does behavior
influence evolution?
Roaming Romeos:
evolution in silence
selects for male crickets
with increased exploratory
behaviors.
Dr. Susan Balenger
Assembly Hall
12:20-12:40
25. THANK YOU!
Committee: Mark Bee, Emilie Snell-Rood,
Marla Spivak, Dave Stephens
Zuk Lab: Susan Balenger, Beth Bastiaans,
Justa Heinen-Kay, and small horde of
undergrads, especially Patrick OHare and
Paul Swim
UMN Graduate Program in Ecology,
Evolution, and Behavior especially Sarah
Jaumann, Virginia Heinen, and Mike Wells
Friends and Family
You!
Funding Sources:
Editor's Notes
#3: Mate choice is really common in nature and is major component of sexual selection. Some individuals, usually females, preferentially mate with the most ornamented members of the opposite sex, usually males. While females of a species tend to agree on preferring more ornamentedbrighter, bigger, faster signaling, or louderindividuals, theres still variation. Some females still mate with males that are less bright, smaller, and signal slower or quieter. Females can vary in their choice behavior for a lot of reasons, but Im particularly interested in how they use their social environment to decide who to mate with.
#4: One of the ways females can tell who is in their social environment is to attend to the sexual signals they can perceive around them. When sexual signals propagate over some medium, like vibrational or acoustic signals, the quantity and attractiveness of those signals tell females something about the quantity and attractiveness of the males they might mate with.
#5: The effects of the social environment produce a cool feedback loop: the strength and direction of selection influence the composition of the social environment, which influences female responses to male signals, which then determine what selection on those same signals looks like. For this study, Im focusing on how the social environment influences individual females responses to sexual signals.
#6: A key component of plastic phenotypes is the timescale on which they are plastic. Some traits, like song learning in many birds, become fixed based on experience during critical windows in juvenile development. Males and females learn their songs and preferences, respectively, based on what they hear around them during this critical window. Similarly, the size of many insects is fixed once they reach adulthood, but for physical limitations: if you have an exoskeleton, you dont get to grow anymore. Other traits, in contrast, can remain flexible throughout adulthood: adult female Polistes fuscatus paper wasps learn the faces of nestmates (as opposed to strangers) and adjust their aggressive behavior accordingly.
#7: So with this study, I looked at three related questions: is reproductive behavior fixed based on experiences during development? Or does it remain flexible throughout adulthood? Or if experiences during both stages are important in determining female behavior, what are their relative roles?
#8: I looked at these questions in the Pacific field cricket, Teleogryllus oceanicus, which is native to Australia and throughout the Pacific. It was introduced by human activity to Hawaii, where I work.
#9: T. oceanicus males sing two distinct songs: one is a long-distance calling song that attracts females from long distances and consists of a long chirp followed by series of short chirps. Once theyve made contact with a female, they sing a short-range courtship song that is also composed of long and short chirps, but is more variable. Females can accept or reject males at this stage.
#10: So we already know adult females have functional ears, allowing them to perceive and localize male calling songs. But T. oceanicus undergoes an extended period of development and possesses functioning ears for the last few larval instars. This means they have an opportunity to perceive and assess their social environment prior to actually making mating decisions.
#11: T. oceanicus females vary in their mating behavior based on social experiences, both during rearing and adulthood. Lets say this female on top was reared in the presence of calling song, which simulates a social environment full of males. The female on the bottom was reared in silence, simulating a scarcity of mates. If you presence both females with an attractive male song, they beeline for it. But if you present them with an unattractive male song, the female reared in silence beelines, but the female reared in the presence of song is slower to approach.
#22: The effects of the social environment produce a cool feedback loop: the strength and direction of selection influence the composition of the social environment, which influences female responses to male signals, which then determine what selection on those same signals looks like. For this study, Im focusing on how the social environment influences individual females responses to sexual signals.