ݺߣ

ݺߣShare a Scribd company logo
1 / 30
Japan and the West
Thought and Philosophy
2 / 30
Today in History...
14 July 1789: Storming of the Bastille
3 / 30
Rights of Man
Aug. 1789: Declaration of the
Rights of Man and of the
Citizen
Drew on other similar
precedents:
?
US Declaration of
Independence (1776)
?
UK Bill of Rights (1689)
4 / 30
Universal Rights
?
1: Men are born and remain free and equal in rights.
?
3: The principle of any sovereignty resides essentially
in the Nation.
?
5: The law has the right to forbid only actions harmful
to society.
?
10. No one may be disturbed for his opinions, even
religious ones, provided that their manifestation does
not trouble the public order established by the law.
?
11. The free communication of thoughts and of
opinions is one of the most precious rights of man
5 / 30
Ideas spread...
Europe 1810
6 / 30
Late Tokugawa thinking
?
Confucianism
? Historical tradition with great prestige
?
'Japanese learning' (kokugaku)
? Mid-Tokugawa reaction to perceived dominance
of thought from China
?
Dutch studies (rangaku)
? Through translations of imported books starting
from 1770s
7 / 30
Dutch Learning
?
Started with translation of Tafel Anatomia (also
Ontleedkundige Tafelen) by Sugita Gempaku
(1733-1817) and colleagues.
8 / 30
Dutch knowledge spreads
?
From late c18 more publications of translations
made easier by Inamura Sampaku's Edo Halma
Dutch-Japanese dictionary (1796)
?
1814: first J-E dictionary: Angeria Gorin Taisei
9 / 30
Dutch knowledge spreads
?
From late c18 more publications of translations
made easier by Inamura Sampaku's Edo Halma
Dutch-Japanese dictionary (1796)
?
1814: first J-E dictionary: Angeria Gorin Taisei
10 / 30
Dutch knowledge spreads
?
From late c18 more publications of translations
made easier by Inamura Sampaku's Edo Halma
Dutch-Japanese dictionary (1796)
?
1814: first J-E dictionary: Angeria Gorin Taisei
OZִ
11 / 30
Iwakura Mission
?
1871-3
?
Visited apx. 20
countries
1.Renegotiate
unequal treaties
2.Gather useful
information
12 / 30
Nakae Chomin(Tokusuke) 1847-1901
?
Studied philosophy, history and French literature in
Paris
?
Translated Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712-78)
? The Social Contract
? Division of
?
'sovereign', the people, the 'general will'
?
'government' which deals with specific
applications of law.
13 / 30
Nakae Chomin
?
Left Meiji govt. disillusioned
?
From 1874: propagated 'western
democratic' ideas through
education and newspapers.
?
Attempted to promote:
? egalitarianism
? liberalism
?
Briefly entered Diet (1890), again
left in disgust...
15 / 30
Self-help
?
First ideas to enter Japan were those of English-
language writers: J.S. Mill (On Liberty), J. Bentham
(utilitarianism), H. Spencer (social darwinism) etc.
?
1871: Nakamura Masanao translated Samuel
Smiles' Self-Help.
? when the majority of a nation's people help
themselves, that state is filled with vigor and
is strong in spirit
16 / 30
Meirokusha C The Meiji 6 Society
?
1874 - c1900
?
A group of intellectual aimed at
promoting 'enlightenment and
civilisation'
? Fukuzawa Yukichi
? Mori Arinori
? Mitsukuri Rinsho etc
?
Published Meiroku Zasshi until
1875 when banned
17 / 30
Bunmei kaika _ ...
?
Enlightenment movement, 1868-1890apx
?
Western ideas imported rapidly and haphazardly
?
Radicals demanded 'westernisation' of every aspect
of Japanese life:
? there is not one thing in which we excel...All
that Japan has to be proud of is its scenery
Fukuzawa Yukichi*
* Ward R.E. (1968) Political Development in Modern Japan, Princeton Univ. Press
18 / 30
Return to Japan
?
conservative reaction (>1880s)
?
Motoda Eifu(Nagazane) (1818-1891)
?
Confucian scholar, deeply concerned at western
influence in education (espec. Ethics)
?
Along with Inoue Kowashi, responsible for
Confucian elements of Imperial Rescript on
Education...
19 / 30
Imperial Rescript on Education
?
Kyoiku ni kansuru chokugo ( vZ )
?
Issued 20 Oct 1890
Killed off educational
liberalism seen in 1870s
Created a 'basis for moral
orthodoxy'
Remained the
fundamental of ethical
principles until 1945.
20 / 30
NISHIDA Kitaro (1870-1945)
?
 the most significant and
influential Japanese philosopher
of the twentieth-century*
?
Attended Tokyo Imperial Univ.
1891-4
?
Studied Zen in Kyoto
?
1914, Prof. of Philosophy Kyoto
Imperial Univ.
* http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/nishida-kitaro/
21 / 30
Work
?
frustrating for its repetitive and often obscure style,
exceedingly abstract formulations, and detailed but
frequently dead-end investigations
?
Absolute nothingness (zettai-mu)
?
Theology: relationship between the self and the
infinite.
?
Politics: nation, culture, religion
?
basho
22 / 30
The 'Kyoto School'
?
Collection of thinkers with a variety of approaches
and outlooks, perhaps united by an interest in
'nothingness'.
?
Neither simply 'western' nor 'eastern'
?
Closely linked with religious thought, particularly
Mahayana Buddhism (Zen)
?
Politically contentious...
23 / 30
D.(Daisetz)T. Suzuki (1870-1966)
?
Studied at Tokyo Imperial Univ.
?
1890s invited to travel to US to translate Japanese
and Chinese religious texts
?
1911: married 'Theosophist' Beatrice Lane
1920s-50s
Published many works and
translations which introduced
Zen Buddhism to 'the West'
particularly the US.
24 / 30
Martin HEIDEGGER (1889-1976)
?
His ideas have exerted a seminal
influence on the development of
contemporary European philosophy
?
At Univ. of Frieburg taught Tanabe
Hajime (founder member of Kyoto
School)
?
Seems to have been influenced by
ideas from Zen Buddhism and Tao-
ism.
?
Suspected of being a Nazi.
25 / 30
WATSUJI Tetsuro (1889-1960)
?
Tokyo: Studied under Nitobe Inazo,
later became friends with Natsume
Soseki.
?
Graduated from Tokyo Imperial Univ. in
1912
?
Taught at various places until 1925,
Kyoto Univ.
?
Spent 14 months in Germany 1927-8.
26 / 30
Climate and Culture
?
Cultures are determined by climates
?
There are three climatic areas:
? Monsoon (China, India, Japan?)
? Desert (Arabia, Africa, Mongolia)
? Meadow (Europe)
?
Each creates its own type of culture/character
27 / 30
Climatic meanings...
?
Meadow / Europe
? Nature is benign, 'rational', orderly
? European 'science'
?
Monsoon / Asia
? Nature is dangerous, aggressive, unpredictable
? Asian 'resignation to fate'
28 / 30
But...
?
Japan's climate was unique and different...
?
On the edge of the 'monsoon' zone C 4 seasons
?
Japan home to a distinctive form of selfless action,
different to both Asian 'passivity' and Western
'individualism'
?
Indictment of 'western' individualism, materialism
and rationalism
29 / 30
Climatic determinism...
?
There's only one climate so there can only be one
possible culture
?
Climates don't change so why should cultures?
?
Perhaps it's not just by chance that the climate best
suited for a superlatively creative culture happens
to occur in Japan
?
Japan is 'non-Western' and also 'non-Asian'.
30 / 30
Publications (a lot of!!)
?
1920: Nihon Kodai Bunka (Japan's Ancient Culture)
?
1925: Nihon Seishin-shi Kenkyu (Researches on
Japan's Spiritual History)
?
1935: Fudo (Climate and Culture, 1961)
?
1936: Koshi (Confucius)
?
1937: Rinrigaku (Ethics)
?
Etc etc...
31 / 30
Next Week...
?
Exam
?
Prepare to write two short essays (apx. 15mins
each) on two people mentioned during these
lectures.

More Related Content

JW-14 thought+philosophy

  • 1. 1 / 30 Japan and the West Thought and Philosophy
  • 2. 2 / 30 Today in History... 14 July 1789: Storming of the Bastille
  • 3. 3 / 30 Rights of Man Aug. 1789: Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen Drew on other similar precedents: ? US Declaration of Independence (1776) ? UK Bill of Rights (1689)
  • 4. 4 / 30 Universal Rights ? 1: Men are born and remain free and equal in rights. ? 3: The principle of any sovereignty resides essentially in the Nation. ? 5: The law has the right to forbid only actions harmful to society. ? 10. No one may be disturbed for his opinions, even religious ones, provided that their manifestation does not trouble the public order established by the law. ? 11. The free communication of thoughts and of opinions is one of the most precious rights of man
  • 5. 5 / 30 Ideas spread... Europe 1810
  • 6. 6 / 30 Late Tokugawa thinking ? Confucianism ? Historical tradition with great prestige ? 'Japanese learning' (kokugaku) ? Mid-Tokugawa reaction to perceived dominance of thought from China ? Dutch studies (rangaku) ? Through translations of imported books starting from 1770s
  • 7. 7 / 30 Dutch Learning ? Started with translation of Tafel Anatomia (also Ontleedkundige Tafelen) by Sugita Gempaku (1733-1817) and colleagues.
  • 8. 8 / 30 Dutch knowledge spreads ? From late c18 more publications of translations made easier by Inamura Sampaku's Edo Halma Dutch-Japanese dictionary (1796) ? 1814: first J-E dictionary: Angeria Gorin Taisei
  • 9. 9 / 30 Dutch knowledge spreads ? From late c18 more publications of translations made easier by Inamura Sampaku's Edo Halma Dutch-Japanese dictionary (1796) ? 1814: first J-E dictionary: Angeria Gorin Taisei
  • 10. 10 / 30 Dutch knowledge spreads ? From late c18 more publications of translations made easier by Inamura Sampaku's Edo Halma Dutch-Japanese dictionary (1796) ? 1814: first J-E dictionary: Angeria Gorin Taisei OZִ
  • 11. 11 / 30 Iwakura Mission ? 1871-3 ? Visited apx. 20 countries 1.Renegotiate unequal treaties 2.Gather useful information
  • 12. 12 / 30 Nakae Chomin(Tokusuke) 1847-1901 ? Studied philosophy, history and French literature in Paris ? Translated Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712-78) ? The Social Contract ? Division of ? 'sovereign', the people, the 'general will' ? 'government' which deals with specific applications of law.
  • 13. 13 / 30 Nakae Chomin ? Left Meiji govt. disillusioned ? From 1874: propagated 'western democratic' ideas through education and newspapers. ? Attempted to promote: ? egalitarianism ? liberalism ? Briefly entered Diet (1890), again left in disgust...
  • 14. 15 / 30 Self-help ? First ideas to enter Japan were those of English- language writers: J.S. Mill (On Liberty), J. Bentham (utilitarianism), H. Spencer (social darwinism) etc. ? 1871: Nakamura Masanao translated Samuel Smiles' Self-Help. ? when the majority of a nation's people help themselves, that state is filled with vigor and is strong in spirit
  • 15. 16 / 30 Meirokusha C The Meiji 6 Society ? 1874 - c1900 ? A group of intellectual aimed at promoting 'enlightenment and civilisation' ? Fukuzawa Yukichi ? Mori Arinori ? Mitsukuri Rinsho etc ? Published Meiroku Zasshi until 1875 when banned
  • 16. 17 / 30 Bunmei kaika _ ... ? Enlightenment movement, 1868-1890apx ? Western ideas imported rapidly and haphazardly ? Radicals demanded 'westernisation' of every aspect of Japanese life: ? there is not one thing in which we excel...All that Japan has to be proud of is its scenery Fukuzawa Yukichi* * Ward R.E. (1968) Political Development in Modern Japan, Princeton Univ. Press
  • 17. 18 / 30 Return to Japan ? conservative reaction (>1880s) ? Motoda Eifu(Nagazane) (1818-1891) ? Confucian scholar, deeply concerned at western influence in education (espec. Ethics) ? Along with Inoue Kowashi, responsible for Confucian elements of Imperial Rescript on Education...
  • 18. 19 / 30 Imperial Rescript on Education ? Kyoiku ni kansuru chokugo ( vZ ) ? Issued 20 Oct 1890 Killed off educational liberalism seen in 1870s Created a 'basis for moral orthodoxy' Remained the fundamental of ethical principles until 1945.
  • 19. 20 / 30 NISHIDA Kitaro (1870-1945) ? the most significant and influential Japanese philosopher of the twentieth-century* ? Attended Tokyo Imperial Univ. 1891-4 ? Studied Zen in Kyoto ? 1914, Prof. of Philosophy Kyoto Imperial Univ. * http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/nishida-kitaro/
  • 20. 21 / 30 Work ? frustrating for its repetitive and often obscure style, exceedingly abstract formulations, and detailed but frequently dead-end investigations ? Absolute nothingness (zettai-mu) ? Theology: relationship between the self and the infinite. ? Politics: nation, culture, religion ? basho
  • 21. 22 / 30 The 'Kyoto School' ? Collection of thinkers with a variety of approaches and outlooks, perhaps united by an interest in 'nothingness'. ? Neither simply 'western' nor 'eastern' ? Closely linked with religious thought, particularly Mahayana Buddhism (Zen) ? Politically contentious...
  • 22. 23 / 30 D.(Daisetz)T. Suzuki (1870-1966) ? Studied at Tokyo Imperial Univ. ? 1890s invited to travel to US to translate Japanese and Chinese religious texts ? 1911: married 'Theosophist' Beatrice Lane 1920s-50s Published many works and translations which introduced Zen Buddhism to 'the West' particularly the US.
  • 23. 24 / 30 Martin HEIDEGGER (1889-1976) ? His ideas have exerted a seminal influence on the development of contemporary European philosophy ? At Univ. of Frieburg taught Tanabe Hajime (founder member of Kyoto School) ? Seems to have been influenced by ideas from Zen Buddhism and Tao- ism. ? Suspected of being a Nazi.
  • 24. 25 / 30 WATSUJI Tetsuro (1889-1960) ? Tokyo: Studied under Nitobe Inazo, later became friends with Natsume Soseki. ? Graduated from Tokyo Imperial Univ. in 1912 ? Taught at various places until 1925, Kyoto Univ. ? Spent 14 months in Germany 1927-8.
  • 25. 26 / 30 Climate and Culture ? Cultures are determined by climates ? There are three climatic areas: ? Monsoon (China, India, Japan?) ? Desert (Arabia, Africa, Mongolia) ? Meadow (Europe) ? Each creates its own type of culture/character
  • 26. 27 / 30 Climatic meanings... ? Meadow / Europe ? Nature is benign, 'rational', orderly ? European 'science' ? Monsoon / Asia ? Nature is dangerous, aggressive, unpredictable ? Asian 'resignation to fate'
  • 27. 28 / 30 But... ? Japan's climate was unique and different... ? On the edge of the 'monsoon' zone C 4 seasons ? Japan home to a distinctive form of selfless action, different to both Asian 'passivity' and Western 'individualism' ? Indictment of 'western' individualism, materialism and rationalism
  • 28. 29 / 30 Climatic determinism... ? There's only one climate so there can only be one possible culture ? Climates don't change so why should cultures? ? Perhaps it's not just by chance that the climate best suited for a superlatively creative culture happens to occur in Japan ? Japan is 'non-Western' and also 'non-Asian'.
  • 29. 30 / 30 Publications (a lot of!!) ? 1920: Nihon Kodai Bunka (Japan's Ancient Culture) ? 1925: Nihon Seishin-shi Kenkyu (Researches on Japan's Spiritual History) ? 1935: Fudo (Climate and Culture, 1961) ? 1936: Koshi (Confucius) ? 1937: Rinrigaku (Ethics) ? Etc etc...
  • 30. 31 / 30 Next Week... ? Exam ? Prepare to write two short essays (apx. 15mins each) on two people mentioned during these lectures.

Editor's Notes

  • #5: liberty, property, safety and resistance against oppression. ll the citizens, being equal in the eyes of the law, are equally admissible to all public dignities, places, and employments, according to their capacity and without distinction other than that of their virtues and of their talents, Universal was not meant to include C women, slaves, children?
  • #8: Besides Kaitai Shinsho, he also authored Rangaku Kotohajime (Beginning of Dutch Studies). At a rate of one page a week/month, the work was published in 1774. As an example of how difficult this work was, the collaborators had to study and discuss for several days before they realised that "neus" (nose) in Dutch, being a bulb on the front, meant hana () in Japanese.
  • #12: Also took along abx 60 studenst who were left in various countries to learn various subjects. One of who was Nakae Chomin
  • #13: In this desired social contract, everyone will be free because they all forfeit the same amount of rights and impose the same duties on all. Rousseau argues that it is illogical for a man to surrender his freedom for slavery; thus, the participants must have a right to choose the laws under which they live. Although the contract imposes new laws, including those safeguarding and regulating property, a person can exit it at any time (except in a time of need, for this is desertion), and is again as free as when he was born.
  • #16: a social theory that applies the law of the survival of the fittest to society; humanitarian impulses had to be resisted as nothing should be allowed to interfere with nature's laws, including the social struggle for existence. Spencer's association with Social Darwinism might have its origin in a specific interpretation of his support for competition. Whereas in biology the competition of various organisms can result in the death of a species or organism, the kind of competition Spencer advocated is closer to the one used by economists, where competing individuals or firms improve the well being of the rest of society. Spencer viewed private charity positively so long as it did not encourage the procreation of the unworthy SH said to have sold over 1 million copies in Meiji Japan C and to have been read by 'every meiji youth' C more sales in Japan than in the uK and US combined. Turned into a play too remember! Toyoda Sakichi read it! Success may have been partly due to its style: orders from above! Which was what people were used to it was almost Confucian! Independet peolke = inde nation C Fukuzawa yukichi
  • #17: introduce western ethics and the elements of western civilization to Japan. It played a prominent role in introducing and popularizing Western ideas during the early Meiji Broad variety of viewpoints within - Debate between confucians C moral strength of west Logicians C emphasises rationality. Several enthusiastic westernizers later became nationalists. Mori Arinori C education minsiter in Ito Hirobumi's cabinet C empahsised central control over curriculum and a neo-confucian morality. Although he was later criticised for beinga nationalist he was actually assassinated in 1889 C stabbed on teh day the Meiji Const was issued C apparently for having failed to observe proper protocol when visiting Ise Shrine two years earlier...by an ultra-nationalist! Christian
  • #18: Westernisation because it embodied 'universal' ideal was almost unavoidable C progress WAS westernisation.
  • #20: Various drafts between 1880 and 90 C eventually all references to confucianism left out as it was thought this would make people skeptical C fall in prestige of Conf. Thought
  • #31: Human beings are both individual and social How to become a truly ethical human being? Answer seems to be connected to Zen thinking and involves 'forgetting the self'