狠狠撸

狠狠撸Share a Scribd company logo

KARGIL WAR OF 1999 A CASE OF PERCEPTUAL FAILURE THAT STARTED FROM PAKISTAN ARMY COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA IN 1990

?
?
Agha A
Agha A

KARGIL WAR OF 1999 A CASE OF PERCEPTUAL FAILURE THAT STARTED FROM PAKISTAN ARMY COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA IN 1990

1 of 17
KARGIL WAR OF 1999 A CASE OF PERCEPTUAL FAILURE THAT STARTED FROM PAKISTAN ARMY COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA IN 1990
PERCEPTUAL FAILURE OF COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA IN SPONSORING A BOOK THAT CREATED UNREALISTIC PERCEPTIONS IN PAKISTAN ARMY ? April 2019 ? DOI: ? 10.13140/RG.2.2.14521.42089 ? Project: ? Military History ? Agha H Amin
KARGIL WAR OF 1999 A CASE OF PERCEPTUAL FAILURE THAT STARTED FROM PAKISTAN ARMY COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA IN 1990 https://anchor.fm/omnibus- dubitandum/episodes/india- pakistanarmy-kargil-perception- staffcollege-pakistan-forads- e3jpgf
? PERCEPTUAL FAILURE OF PAKISTAN ARMYS STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA ? RAJPUTS AND MANY RACES IN INDIA ARE FAMOUS FOR BRAVERY IN BATTLE FIELD BUT ONE MAJ GEN JAVED HASSAN BELIEVED OTHERWISE !!!!!!!!! A very serious flaw of this book is lack of serious research in analyzing mindset of the principal characters who launched Kargil operation. Naseem Zehra claims that she was researching the book from 2002 or so.In 17 years she could have easily discovered that Javed Hassan authored a book sponsored by Pakistan Armys staff college which made all kind of bogus
claims like claiming that “the Hindu belief system lacked commitment for sacrifice on battlefield” (page-58- India – A Study in Profile-Brigadier Javed Hassan) .That India would be unable to sustain reverses (page208). Naseem Zehra could have related this book to Javed Hassans preconceived gross underestimation of India. The most dangerous part of this book was that it was sponsored by bcommand and staff college Quettas “Faculty of Research and Doctrinal Studies” and was distributed to all officers by Pakistan Army book club. This was seriously relevant to the issue as there was a widespread mass mindset in
Pakistan Army inunderestimating India.This I personally saw in my service in Pakistan Army in 1981-94. However Naseem Zehra does not point out any such thing.Just shows how ham handedly she worked on the book. All along the book if Naseem Zehra had done her home work carefully , something entirely feasible and easy to do she could have answered many questions, like Major General Javed Hassans gross under estimation of the Indians like the discussion on page 119 :- India - FORADS staff college Quetta and KARGIL COLLECTIVE PERCEPTUAL FAILURE OF PAKISTAN ARMY AT
KARGIL http://www.lulu.com/content/paperback- book/naseem-zehras-too-late-after-the- event-kargil-book-analysed/24642306 ? DETAILS ON PODCAST ON JAVED HASSANS BOOK SPONSORED BY FORADS COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA https://anchor.fm/omnibus- dubitandum/episodes/India---FORADS- staff-college-Quetta-and-KARGIL- COLLECTIVE-PERCEPTUAL-FAILURE- OF-PAKISTAN-ARMY-AT-KARGIL-e3jpgf ?
OUT OF 13 US MILITARY DEATHS IN 2003 BECAUSE OF ACTUAL ENEMY ACTION 7 WERE AT FOB SHKIN WHICH WAS SIMPLY A TACTICAL DIASASTER SITTING DUCK LOCATION ? October 2012 ? DOI: ? 10.13140/RG.2.2.31673.26729
? Projects: ? Afghanistan Studies ? Military History of India Pakistan Bangladesh Nepal Iran Afghanistan Burma Central Asian Republics China and Turkey ? Decision Making ? Afghan War and Military History ? Anatomy of Incompetence of all kinds ? US Military History ? European History ? Agha H Amin
?
KARGIL WAR OF 1999 A CASE OF PERCEPTUAL FAILURE THAT STARTED FROM PAKISTAN ARMY COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA IN 1990
KARGIL WAR OF 1999 A CASE OF PERCEPTUAL FAILURE THAT STARTED FROM PAKISTAN ARMY COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA IN 1990
KARGIL WAR OF 1999 A CASE OF PERCEPTUAL FAILURE THAT STARTED FROM PAKISTAN ARMY COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA IN 1990
KARGIL WAR OF 1999 A CASE OF PERCEPTUAL FAILURE THAT STARTED FROM PAKISTAN ARMY COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA IN 1990
KARGIL WAR OF 1999 A CASE OF PERCEPTUAL FAILURE THAT STARTED FROM PAKISTAN ARMY COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA IN 1990
KARGIL WAR OF 1999 A CASE OF PERCEPTUAL FAILURE THAT STARTED FROM PAKISTAN ARMY COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA IN 1990
KARGIL WAR OF 1999 A CASE OF PERCEPTUAL FAILURE THAT STARTED FROM PAKISTAN ARMY COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA IN 1990

More Related Content

KARGIL WAR OF 1999 A CASE OF PERCEPTUAL FAILURE THAT STARTED FROM PAKISTAN ARMY COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA IN 1990

  • 2. PERCEPTUAL FAILURE OF COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA IN SPONSORING A BOOK THAT CREATED UNREALISTIC PERCEPTIONS IN PAKISTAN ARMY ? April 2019 ? DOI: ? 10.13140/RG.2.2.14521.42089 ? Project: ? Military History ? Agha H Amin
  • 3. KARGIL WAR OF 1999 A CASE OF PERCEPTUAL FAILURE THAT STARTED FROM PAKISTAN ARMY COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA IN 1990 https://anchor.fm/omnibus- dubitandum/episodes/india- pakistanarmy-kargil-perception- staffcollege-pakistan-forads- e3jpgf
  • 4. ? PERCEPTUAL FAILURE OF PAKISTAN ARMYS STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA ? RAJPUTS AND MANY RACES IN INDIA ARE FAMOUS FOR BRAVERY IN BATTLE FIELD BUT ONE MAJ GEN JAVED HASSAN BELIEVED OTHERWISE !!!!!!!!! A very serious flaw of this book is lack of serious research in analyzing mindset of the principal characters who launched Kargil operation. Naseem Zehra claims that she was researching the book from 2002 or so.In 17 years she could have easily discovered that Javed Hassan authored a book sponsored by Pakistan Armys staff college which made all kind of bogus
  • 5. claims like claiming that “the Hindu belief system lacked commitment for sacrifice on battlefield” (page-58- India – A Study in Profile-Brigadier Javed Hassan) .That India would be unable to sustain reverses (page208). Naseem Zehra could have related this book to Javed Hassans preconceived gross underestimation of India. The most dangerous part of this book was that it was sponsored by bcommand and staff college Quettas “Faculty of Research and Doctrinal Studies” and was distributed to all officers by Pakistan Army book club. This was seriously relevant to the issue as there was a widespread mass mindset in
  • 6. Pakistan Army inunderestimating India.This I personally saw in my service in Pakistan Army in 1981-94. However Naseem Zehra does not point out any such thing.Just shows how ham handedly she worked on the book. All along the book if Naseem Zehra had done her home work carefully , something entirely feasible and easy to do she could have answered many questions, like Major General Javed Hassans gross under estimation of the Indians like the discussion on page 119 :- India - FORADS staff college Quetta and KARGIL COLLECTIVE PERCEPTUAL FAILURE OF PAKISTAN ARMY AT
  • 7. KARGIL http://www.lulu.com/content/paperback- book/naseem-zehras-too-late-after-the- event-kargil-book-analysed/24642306 ? DETAILS ON PODCAST ON JAVED HASSANS BOOK SPONSORED BY FORADS COMMAND AND STAFF COLLEGE QUETTA https://anchor.fm/omnibus- dubitandum/episodes/India---FORADS- staff-college-Quetta-and-KARGIL- COLLECTIVE-PERCEPTUAL-FAILURE- OF-PAKISTAN-ARMY-AT-KARGIL-e3jpgf ?
  • 8. OUT OF 13 US MILITARY DEATHS IN 2003 BECAUSE OF ACTUAL ENEMY ACTION 7 WERE AT FOB SHKIN WHICH WAS SIMPLY A TACTICAL DIASASTER SITTING DUCK LOCATION ? October 2012 ? DOI: ? 10.13140/RG.2.2.31673.26729
  • 9. ? Projects: ? Afghanistan Studies ? Military History of India Pakistan Bangladesh Nepal Iran Afghanistan Burma Central Asian Republics China and Turkey ? Decision Making ? Afghan War and Military History ? Anatomy of Incompetence of all kinds ? US Military History ? European History ? Agha H Amin
  • 10. ?