際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
On Tuesday, April 21, 2015 7:46 PM, "Shahab, Saqib HE0"
<Saqib.Shahab@health.gov.sk.ca> wrote:
Dear Mr Thompson
Thank you for your voicemail, e mail and links. At present SK does not
have a THN (Take Home Naloxone) program and if SK was to develop
one, training materials related to that would use the best information
and evidence regarding that including when and how to administer
Naloxone and additional appropriate interventions as required to
support airway, breathing and circulation.
Thank you once again for flagging your concerns
Sincerely
Dr Saqib Shahab FRCPC
Government of Saskatchewan
Chief Medical Health Officer
Ministry of Health, Population Health Branch
3475 Albert St, Regina SK S4S 6X6
E mail: sshahab@health.gov.sk.ca
Tel: 306 787 3220
From: Gary Thompson [mailto:jgary.thompson@mail.utoronto.ca]
Sent: Tuesday, April 21, 2015 2:43 PM
To: Shahab, Saqib HE0 Subject: Re: News article April 18
Dr. Shahab:
Read with grave concern your quote of April 18
"A key feature of the take home program is training users' family or
peers to recognize signs of overdose so they know when and how to
administer the antidote, perform CPR compression's and call 911"
http://www.thestarphoenix.com/health/Opiate+antidote+kits+possible+
Sask/10983748/story.html
I hope this does not mean chest compressions only? Contraindicated
for any respiratory emergency patient.
Still not correct rescue
breaths then Naloxone
continue breaths.
Read all moderated comments 2015 AHA & ILCOR guidelines [My
moderated comment video format https://youtu.be/PX0HQuaNS_I
'Opioid overdose Response Education' BLS 891 reopened for comment
Feb. 2017]
https://volunteer.heart.org/apps/pico/Pages/PublicComment.aspx?q=89
1
My response to Emily Oliver (awaiting AHA moderator)
Quote Emily "....use of naloxone into their education programs. More
research is needed regarding educational effectiveness..."
Do we need more research on opioid poisoning resuscitation
protocols? Clinicians see opioid poisoning daily in a clinical situation.
Terminally ill are kept "comfortable" to wit OD narcotics. Cause of
death acute respiratory failure.
European Resuscitation Council Guidelines for Resuscitation 2010
Section 8.b Poisoning
http://resuscitation-guidelines.articleinmotion.com/article/S0300-
9572(10)00441-7/aim/
Opioids
Opioid poisoning causes respiratory depression followed by
respiratory insufficiency or respiratory arrest. The respiratory effects
of opioids are reversed rapidly by the opiate antagonist naloxone.
Modifications for Advanced Life Support
There are no studies supporting the use of naloxone once cardiac
arrest associated with opioid toxicity has occurred. Cardiac arrest is
usually secondary to a respiratory arrest and associated with severe
brain hypoxia. Prognosis is poor.
Agnotology is the study of culturally induced ignorance or doubt,
particularly the publication of inaccurate or misleading scientific
[medical] data. Agnotology focuses on the deliberate fomenting of
ignorance or doubt in society.
http://issuu.com/garythompson81/docs/agnotologynote.docx
Not placing blame, change this protocol of Public Health Ontario. Have
talked with all these clinicians many times in person, they live in a
state of pure guilt.
Letter Dr. Shahab
Ad

Recommended

Case reports children women
Case reports children women
Gary Thompson
TPH Dr Mckeown etal
TPH Dr Mckeown etal
Gary Thompson
Naloxone references
Naloxone references
Gary Thompson
June 1 2015 'prescription for life'
June 1 2015 'prescription for life'
Gary Thompson
Opioid Prevention Presentation. Training
Opioid Prevention Presentation. Training
DianaFabela5
Dr. Vaillancourt e-mails
Dr. Vaillancourt e-mails
Gary Thompson
2015 AHA & ILCOR CPR Guidelines refernces on opioid OD
2015 AHA & ILCOR CPR Guidelines refernces on opioid OD
Gary Thompson
June 1 'prescription for life'
June 1 'prescription for life'
Gary Thompson
June 1 prescription for life
June 1 prescription for life
Gary Thompson
June 1 prescription for life
June 1 prescription for life
Gary Thompson
Dr. d. mc keown's naloxone cpr only references
Dr. d. mc keown's naloxone cpr only references
Gary Thompson
E-mails Dr. Vaillancourt
E-mails Dr. Vaillancourt
Gary Thompson
Letter Dr. Christian Vaillancourt
Letter Dr. Christian Vaillancourt
Gary Thompson
June 1 'prescription for life'
June 1 'prescription for life'
Gary Thompson
Teaching narcan injection
Teaching narcan injection
Jack Frost
Dr mc keown's naloxone cpr only references
Dr mc keown's naloxone cpr only references
Gary Thompson
Naloxone Action Group
Naloxone Action Group
Andrew Brown
Opioid toxicity case study
Opioid toxicity case study
Neeraj Ojha
Naloxone Dosing - Medicines frequently asked Q&A.
Naloxone Dosing - Medicines frequently asked Q&A.
Kevin Jaffray
Get the SKOOP: overdose prevention - Bill Matthews - HRC 2010
Get the SKOOP: overdose prevention - Bill Matthews - HRC 2010
Harm Reduction Coalition
Letter Dr. Vaillancourt posted oct 2015
Letter Dr. Vaillancourt posted oct 2015
Gary Thompson
Naloxone saving lives
Naloxone saving lives
IDHDP
Overdose awareness and harm reduction
Overdose awareness and harm reduction
HomewardBound
The overdosebattle
The overdosebattle
AIDSCalgary
Ems world expo naloxone 11112014.handout
Ems world expo naloxone 11112014.handout
Michael Dailey
Management of Opioid Analgesic Overdose
Management of Opioid Analgesic Overdose
Sun Yai-Cheng
REVIVE! Opioid Overdose and Naloxone Education
REVIVE! Opioid Overdose and Naloxone Education
Virginia Rural Health Association
Naloxone pilot intranasal_admin_presentation
Naloxone pilot intranasal_admin_presentation
LYFDEMStraining
CPSO complaint Aug-Sept 2016
CPSO complaint Aug-Sept 2016
Gary Thompson
Complaint CPSO Aug 2016
Complaint CPSO Aug 2016
Gary Thompson

More Related Content

Similar to Letter Dr. Shahab (20)

June 1 prescription for life
June 1 prescription for life
Gary Thompson
June 1 prescription for life
June 1 prescription for life
Gary Thompson
Dr. d. mc keown's naloxone cpr only references
Dr. d. mc keown's naloxone cpr only references
Gary Thompson
E-mails Dr. Vaillancourt
E-mails Dr. Vaillancourt
Gary Thompson
Letter Dr. Christian Vaillancourt
Letter Dr. Christian Vaillancourt
Gary Thompson
June 1 'prescription for life'
June 1 'prescription for life'
Gary Thompson
Teaching narcan injection
Teaching narcan injection
Jack Frost
Dr mc keown's naloxone cpr only references
Dr mc keown's naloxone cpr only references
Gary Thompson
Naloxone Action Group
Naloxone Action Group
Andrew Brown
Opioid toxicity case study
Opioid toxicity case study
Neeraj Ojha
Naloxone Dosing - Medicines frequently asked Q&A.
Naloxone Dosing - Medicines frequently asked Q&A.
Kevin Jaffray
Get the SKOOP: overdose prevention - Bill Matthews - HRC 2010
Get the SKOOP: overdose prevention - Bill Matthews - HRC 2010
Harm Reduction Coalition
Letter Dr. Vaillancourt posted oct 2015
Letter Dr. Vaillancourt posted oct 2015
Gary Thompson
Naloxone saving lives
Naloxone saving lives
IDHDP
Overdose awareness and harm reduction
Overdose awareness and harm reduction
HomewardBound
The overdosebattle
The overdosebattle
AIDSCalgary
Ems world expo naloxone 11112014.handout
Ems world expo naloxone 11112014.handout
Michael Dailey
Management of Opioid Analgesic Overdose
Management of Opioid Analgesic Overdose
Sun Yai-Cheng
REVIVE! Opioid Overdose and Naloxone Education
REVIVE! Opioid Overdose and Naloxone Education
Virginia Rural Health Association
Naloxone pilot intranasal_admin_presentation
Naloxone pilot intranasal_admin_presentation
LYFDEMStraining
June 1 prescription for life
June 1 prescription for life
Gary Thompson
June 1 prescription for life
June 1 prescription for life
Gary Thompson
Dr. d. mc keown's naloxone cpr only references
Dr. d. mc keown's naloxone cpr only references
Gary Thompson
E-mails Dr. Vaillancourt
E-mails Dr. Vaillancourt
Gary Thompson
Letter Dr. Christian Vaillancourt
Letter Dr. Christian Vaillancourt
Gary Thompson
June 1 'prescription for life'
June 1 'prescription for life'
Gary Thompson
Teaching narcan injection
Teaching narcan injection
Jack Frost
Dr mc keown's naloxone cpr only references
Dr mc keown's naloxone cpr only references
Gary Thompson
Naloxone Action Group
Naloxone Action Group
Andrew Brown
Opioid toxicity case study
Opioid toxicity case study
Neeraj Ojha
Naloxone Dosing - Medicines frequently asked Q&A.
Naloxone Dosing - Medicines frequently asked Q&A.
Kevin Jaffray
Get the SKOOP: overdose prevention - Bill Matthews - HRC 2010
Get the SKOOP: overdose prevention - Bill Matthews - HRC 2010
Harm Reduction Coalition
Letter Dr. Vaillancourt posted oct 2015
Letter Dr. Vaillancourt posted oct 2015
Gary Thompson
Naloxone saving lives
Naloxone saving lives
IDHDP
Overdose awareness and harm reduction
Overdose awareness and harm reduction
HomewardBound
The overdosebattle
The overdosebattle
AIDSCalgary
Ems world expo naloxone 11112014.handout
Ems world expo naloxone 11112014.handout
Michael Dailey
Management of Opioid Analgesic Overdose
Management of Opioid Analgesic Overdose
Sun Yai-Cheng
Naloxone pilot intranasal_admin_presentation
Naloxone pilot intranasal_admin_presentation
LYFDEMStraining

More from Gary Thompson (16)

CPSO complaint Aug-Sept 2016
CPSO complaint Aug-Sept 2016
Gary Thompson
Complaint CPSO Aug 2016
Complaint CPSO Aug 2016
Gary Thompson
Canadian training slides july 2016
Canadian training slides july 2016
Gary Thompson
Provincial training July 2016
Provincial training July 2016
Gary Thompson
Dr. Gordon Ewy
Dr. Gordon Ewy
Gary Thompson
CPA Naloxone July 2016
CPA Naloxone July 2016
Gary Thompson
Complications Chest Compressions
Complications Chest Compressions
Gary Thompson
Red Cross First Aid
Red Cross First Aid
Gary Thompson
Heart and Stroke Foundation letter
Heart and Stroke Foundation letter
Gary Thompson
Heart and Stroke Foundation letter
Heart and Stroke Foundation letter
Gary Thompson
CBC Cross Country Check-up Jan 31 2016
CBC Cross Country Check-up Jan 31 2016
Gary Thompson
Case reports children; women
Case reports children; women
Gary Thompson
Case reports children women etc
Case reports children women etc
Gary Thompson
Case reports children and women
Case reports children and women
Gary Thompson
Case reports women and children
Case reports women and children
Gary Thompson
Letter Dr. Aaron Orkin
Letter Dr. Aaron Orkin
Gary Thompson
CPSO complaint Aug-Sept 2016
CPSO complaint Aug-Sept 2016
Gary Thompson
Complaint CPSO Aug 2016
Complaint CPSO Aug 2016
Gary Thompson
Canadian training slides july 2016
Canadian training slides july 2016
Gary Thompson
Provincial training July 2016
Provincial training July 2016
Gary Thompson
CPA Naloxone July 2016
CPA Naloxone July 2016
Gary Thompson
Complications Chest Compressions
Complications Chest Compressions
Gary Thompson
Red Cross First Aid
Red Cross First Aid
Gary Thompson
Heart and Stroke Foundation letter
Heart and Stroke Foundation letter
Gary Thompson
Heart and Stroke Foundation letter
Heart and Stroke Foundation letter
Gary Thompson
CBC Cross Country Check-up Jan 31 2016
CBC Cross Country Check-up Jan 31 2016
Gary Thompson
Case reports children; women
Case reports children; women
Gary Thompson
Case reports children women etc
Case reports children women etc
Gary Thompson
Case reports children and women
Case reports children and women
Gary Thompson
Case reports women and children
Case reports women and children
Gary Thompson
Letter Dr. Aaron Orkin
Letter Dr. Aaron Orkin
Gary Thompson
Ad

Letter Dr. Shahab

  • 1. On Tuesday, April 21, 2015 7:46 PM, "Shahab, Saqib HE0" <Saqib.Shahab@health.gov.sk.ca> wrote: Dear Mr Thompson Thank you for your voicemail, e mail and links. At present SK does not have a THN (Take Home Naloxone) program and if SK was to develop one, training materials related to that would use the best information and evidence regarding that including when and how to administer Naloxone and additional appropriate interventions as required to support airway, breathing and circulation. Thank you once again for flagging your concerns Sincerely Dr Saqib Shahab FRCPC Government of Saskatchewan Chief Medical Health Officer Ministry of Health, Population Health Branch 3475 Albert St, Regina SK S4S 6X6 E mail: sshahab@health.gov.sk.ca Tel: 306 787 3220 From: Gary Thompson [mailto:jgary.thompson@mail.utoronto.ca] Sent: Tuesday, April 21, 2015 2:43 PM To: Shahab, Saqib HE0 Subject: Re: News article April 18 Dr. Shahab: Read with grave concern your quote of April 18 "A key feature of the take home program is training users' family or peers to recognize signs of overdose so they know when and how to administer the antidote, perform CPR compression's and call 911" http://www.thestarphoenix.com/health/Opiate+antidote+kits+possible+ Sask/10983748/story.html I hope this does not mean chest compressions only? Contraindicated for any respiratory emergency patient. Still not correct rescue breaths then Naloxone continue breaths.
  • 2. Read all moderated comments 2015 AHA & ILCOR guidelines [My moderated comment video format https://youtu.be/PX0HQuaNS_I 'Opioid overdose Response Education' BLS 891 reopened for comment Feb. 2017] https://volunteer.heart.org/apps/pico/Pages/PublicComment.aspx?q=89 1 My response to Emily Oliver (awaiting AHA moderator) Quote Emily "....use of naloxone into their education programs. More research is needed regarding educational effectiveness..." Do we need more research on opioid poisoning resuscitation protocols? Clinicians see opioid poisoning daily in a clinical situation. Terminally ill are kept "comfortable" to wit OD narcotics. Cause of death acute respiratory failure. European Resuscitation Council Guidelines for Resuscitation 2010 Section 8.b Poisoning http://resuscitation-guidelines.articleinmotion.com/article/S0300- 9572(10)00441-7/aim/ Opioids Opioid poisoning causes respiratory depression followed by respiratory insufficiency or respiratory arrest. The respiratory effects of opioids are reversed rapidly by the opiate antagonist naloxone. Modifications for Advanced Life Support There are no studies supporting the use of naloxone once cardiac arrest associated with opioid toxicity has occurred. Cardiac arrest is usually secondary to a respiratory arrest and associated with severe brain hypoxia. Prognosis is poor. Agnotology is the study of culturally induced ignorance or doubt, particularly the publication of inaccurate or misleading scientific [medical] data. Agnotology focuses on the deliberate fomenting of ignorance or doubt in society. http://issuu.com/garythompson81/docs/agnotologynote.docx
  • 3. Not placing blame, change this protocol of Public Health Ontario. Have talked with all these clinicians many times in person, they live in a state of pure guilt.