際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Review of Literature
Prof.Dr. Yogesh S. Deole
M.D. Ph.D.(Ayurveda)
Project Co-Ordinator
www.charaksamhita.com
Charak Samhita Research, Training
and Skill Development Centre
Professor, Kayachikitsa
Shastram Jyoti Prakashartham Darshanam Buddhiratmanah I
Tabhyam Bhishak Suyuktabhyam Chikitsanna Aparadhyati II
( Cha.Su.9/25,pg.64)
9/9/2020 2Dr.Yogesh Deole
OVERVIEW
Why to improve quality of review in research?
Standard parameters of writing literature
How to ? Smart tools and applications
Process of research, submission and
publication 9/9/2020 3Dr.Yogesh Deole
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 4
What is your primary objective?
Global
National
Regional
Local
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 5
Research by heart
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 6
Compulsive Impulsive
Clean and clear work
Validation and
revalidation
Reproducing the research
Questions-Activity
9/9/2020 7Dr.Yogesh Deole
Standardization Parameters of Science
爐 爐 爐 爐爛爐
 爐伍爐爐 爐爐謹た 爐朽ぇ爛爐萎お爛 爐劇ぞ爐伍 爐朽い爐爐ムが爐項爐迦ぎ爐 爐む爐爐爛爐逗爐む
 爐朽ぇ 爐 爐爐爛 爐 爐項い爐爐爐爐むお爛爐 爐むう爛爐劇ぎ爐鉦し爐伍 爐爛爐
 爐伍 爐爐 爐爐 爐 爐爐 爐朽ぞ爐оぞ爐萎ぎ爐爐朽お 爐むい爐 爐爐爐 爐爐 爐爐
爐爛 爐爐迦ぞ 爐爐оぞ爐爐 爐爐鉦爐むぞ爐ムぎ爐ムい 爐 爐 爐 爐爐 爐оぞ爐爐
 爐 爐爐むぞ爐ムぎ爐 爐爛 爐 爐爐萎ぃ爐爐鉦ざ爛 爐爛爐о爐 爐 爐爐 爐爛爐爐鉦す爐萎ぃ爐 爐,
 爐むう 爐 爐 爐爛爐むざ爐 爐 爛| (Cha.Sa.Vi.8/3)
 (Source:
http://www.carakasamhitaonline.com/mediawiki-
1.32.1/index.php?title=Rogabhishagjitiya_Vimana#Selecti
on_of_medical_treatise accessed on August 20,2019)
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole 8
Achievable goals- Scientific writing
 Comprehensive providing all information
 Referred /followed by successful, prominent and wise
persons(successful practitioners),
 With detailed meanings
 Authenticated by authorities
 Useful to all three types of learners ( with good,
moderate and poor intellect),
 Free from the deformity of reiteration
 Descending from the sages (which is written by
experienced, intuitive person)
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole 9
 With well- formed presentation, discussion and
conclusion
 having informative title and firm base
 Free from weak and difficult words
 Having comprehensive knowledge of subject
 With proper sequencing of its contents
 Committed principally to arriving at the essence of
thoughts, which reveals clear meanings and concrete
conclusion
 Focused on the particular subject without wavering
ideas and irrelevant content
 Quickly understandable with separated topics and
having definitions showed with examples. 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole 10
What we are missing & repeating.
 Idea of the work
 Accuracy of the selected topic
 Extra matter irrelevant to the subject
 Prevalence, Severity of the issue
 Lacunae and pitfalls of the previous works
 The significance of the present study
 Aims and Objectives of the research
e.g. Ayurveda is the science of life
9/9/2020 11Dr.Yogesh Deole
Process and outcomes of research
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 12
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 13
Examples
 Conceptual database of Ayurvedic medicinal plants and
assessment of physical parameters of six guna
 Comparative assessment of Ayurvedic parameters of
Ashwagandha (withania somnifera) along with clinical
evaluation for its different varieties in Grivastambha
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 14
Extracting keywords
 Conceptual database of Ayurvedic medicinal plants
 Assessment of physical parameters
 Guna ---- six
 Ayurvedic parameters of Ashwagandha (withania
somnifera)
 Comparative assessment of different varieties
 Clinical evaluation - Grivastambha
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 15
Materials & Methods
 Should make research reproducible
Detail experimental design
Describe equipments used
Define formula and symbols
Identify statistical approach
 Do not simply list your protocol, write it
out if possible
9/9/2020 16Dr.Yogesh Deole
Materials & methods in Ayurveda research
 Ayurvedic Samhitas & Commentaries
 Purusha- Adhikarana i.e. patients
 Drugs used in the clinical trial with references
 Procurement, Availability of herbs, drug
 Method of preparation of drug
 New methods utilized/modified
 Problems faced in drug preparation and
acquiring patients
9/9/2020 17Dr.Yogesh Deole
Resources
Samhita
Standard Ayurveda text books
Research Database -Ayurveda
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 18
Resources
Online sources and Standard
Journals
Systemic Reviews Database
ResearchGate
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 19
Samhita First Hand references
 http://niimh.nic.in/#/home -First hand references
 http://www.carakasamhitaonline.com/mediawiki-
1.32.1/index.php?search=Ashwagandha&title=Special%3A
Search&go=Go
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 20
Ayurveda text books
 Standard Ayurveda Text books  manual
referencing in library
 Google scholar and books, scholar alerts
https://www.google.com/search?tbm=bks&q=datab
ase+of+medicinal+plants
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 21
Ayurvedic Research Database
 Ayurvedic research database
 https://researches-in-ayurveda.co.in/ria-
search?search_api_views_fulltext=ashwagandha
 Ayurvedic Research Database by IPGTRA Jamnagar
 Shodhganga
 https://shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/simple-search?query=ashwagandha&go=
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 22
Online sources- Wiki sources
 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Withania_s
omnifera
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 23
Journal database
 http://ayushportal.nic.in/
 http://www.dharaonline.org/Search/Ashwagandha/1/0/0/journalid
 http://www.medknow.com/searcharticle.asp?author=&search=ashwagandha
&journal=Y&entries=10&pg=1&s=0
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 24
Journal database
 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=ashwag
andha+withania+somnifera
 Applying filters
 Saving articles
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 25
Systemic Reviews Database
 https://www.cochranelibrary.com/search
 https://www.equator-network.org/
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 26
RG
 https://www.researchgate.net/search.Sea
rch.html?type=researcher&query=ashwaga
ndha
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 27
Red alert : No plagiarism
Use it as
Reference
And plagiarism
check
software
9/9/2020 28Dr.Yogesh Deole
9/9/2020 29Dr.Yogesh Deole
9/9/2020 30Dr.Yogesh Deole
9/9/2020 31Dr.Yogesh Deole
9/9/2020 32Dr.Yogesh Deole
9/9/2020 33Dr.Yogesh Deole
Reference management - Mendeley
software
 https://www.mendeley.com/
 https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=mendeley+software+for+re
ferences
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 34
Process to publication
Collection  Data
Analysis  Interpretation
Reference  Research
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 35
During and Post publication
 Publicize and index your research to improve impact
 Create an account/profile on:
 Google scholar(h-index, i-index), ResearchGate(RG),
ORCID and upload the published article
 Discuss and share the links on social media NOT the
original works till publication of article
 Review citations and feedbacks periodically
 Revisit and refer your article in next ones 9/9/2020 36Dr.Yogesh Deole
Thank you!
Queries-
@dryogeshdeole@gmail.com
9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 37

More Related Content

Literary research in ayurveda dr.yogesh deole

  • 1. Review of Literature Prof.Dr. Yogesh S. Deole M.D. Ph.D.(Ayurveda) Project Co-Ordinator www.charaksamhita.com Charak Samhita Research, Training and Skill Development Centre Professor, Kayachikitsa
  • 2. Shastram Jyoti Prakashartham Darshanam Buddhiratmanah I Tabhyam Bhishak Suyuktabhyam Chikitsanna Aparadhyati II ( Cha.Su.9/25,pg.64) 9/9/2020 2Dr.Yogesh Deole
  • 3. OVERVIEW Why to improve quality of review in research? Standard parameters of writing literature How to ? Smart tools and applications Process of research, submission and publication 9/9/2020 3Dr.Yogesh Deole
  • 4. 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 4
  • 5. What is your primary objective? Global National Regional Local 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 5
  • 6. Research by heart 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 6 Compulsive Impulsive
  • 7. Clean and clear work Validation and revalidation Reproducing the research Questions-Activity 9/9/2020 7Dr.Yogesh Deole
  • 8. Standardization Parameters of Science 爐 爐 爐 爐爛爐 爐伍爐爐 爐爐謹た 爐朽ぇ爛爐萎お爛 爐劇ぞ爐伍 爐朽い爐爐ムが爐項爐迦ぎ爐 爐む爐爐爛爐逗爐む 爐朽ぇ 爐 爐爐爛 爐 爐項い爐爐爐爐むお爛爐 爐むう爛爐劇ぎ爐鉦し爐伍 爐爛爐 爐伍 爐爐 爐爐 爐 爐爐 爐朽ぞ爐оぞ爐萎ぎ爐爐朽お 爐むい爐 爐爐爐 爐爐 爐爐 爐爛 爐爐迦ぞ 爐爐оぞ爐爐 爐爐鉦爐むぞ爐ムぎ爐ムい 爐 爐 爐 爐爐 爐оぞ爐爐 爐 爐爐むぞ爐ムぎ爐 爐爛 爐 爐爐萎ぃ爐爐鉦ざ爛 爐爛爐о爐 爐 爐爐 爐爛爐爐鉦す爐萎ぃ爐 爐, 爐むう 爐 爐 爐爛爐むざ爐 爐 爛| (Cha.Sa.Vi.8/3) (Source: http://www.carakasamhitaonline.com/mediawiki- 1.32.1/index.php?title=Rogabhishagjitiya_Vimana#Selecti on_of_medical_treatise accessed on August 20,2019) 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole 8
  • 9. Achievable goals- Scientific writing Comprehensive providing all information Referred /followed by successful, prominent and wise persons(successful practitioners), With detailed meanings Authenticated by authorities Useful to all three types of learners ( with good, moderate and poor intellect), Free from the deformity of reiteration Descending from the sages (which is written by experienced, intuitive person) 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole 9
  • 10. With well- formed presentation, discussion and conclusion having informative title and firm base Free from weak and difficult words Having comprehensive knowledge of subject With proper sequencing of its contents Committed principally to arriving at the essence of thoughts, which reveals clear meanings and concrete conclusion Focused on the particular subject without wavering ideas and irrelevant content Quickly understandable with separated topics and having definitions showed with examples. 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole 10
  • 11. What we are missing & repeating. Idea of the work Accuracy of the selected topic Extra matter irrelevant to the subject Prevalence, Severity of the issue Lacunae and pitfalls of the previous works The significance of the present study Aims and Objectives of the research e.g. Ayurveda is the science of life 9/9/2020 11Dr.Yogesh Deole
  • 12. Process and outcomes of research 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 12
  • 13. 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 13
  • 14. Examples Conceptual database of Ayurvedic medicinal plants and assessment of physical parameters of six guna Comparative assessment of Ayurvedic parameters of Ashwagandha (withania somnifera) along with clinical evaluation for its different varieties in Grivastambha 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 14
  • 15. Extracting keywords Conceptual database of Ayurvedic medicinal plants Assessment of physical parameters Guna ---- six Ayurvedic parameters of Ashwagandha (withania somnifera) Comparative assessment of different varieties Clinical evaluation - Grivastambha 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 15
  • 16. Materials & Methods Should make research reproducible Detail experimental design Describe equipments used Define formula and symbols Identify statistical approach Do not simply list your protocol, write it out if possible 9/9/2020 16Dr.Yogesh Deole
  • 17. Materials & methods in Ayurveda research Ayurvedic Samhitas & Commentaries Purusha- Adhikarana i.e. patients Drugs used in the clinical trial with references Procurement, Availability of herbs, drug Method of preparation of drug New methods utilized/modified Problems faced in drug preparation and acquiring patients 9/9/2020 17Dr.Yogesh Deole
  • 18. Resources Samhita Standard Ayurveda text books Research Database -Ayurveda 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 18
  • 19. Resources Online sources and Standard Journals Systemic Reviews Database ResearchGate 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 19
  • 20. Samhita First Hand references http://niimh.nic.in/#/home -First hand references http://www.carakasamhitaonline.com/mediawiki- 1.32.1/index.php?search=Ashwagandha&title=Special%3A Search&go=Go 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 20
  • 21. Ayurveda text books Standard Ayurveda Text books manual referencing in library Google scholar and books, scholar alerts https://www.google.com/search?tbm=bks&q=datab ase+of+medicinal+plants 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 21
  • 22. Ayurvedic Research Database Ayurvedic research database https://researches-in-ayurveda.co.in/ria- search?search_api_views_fulltext=ashwagandha Ayurvedic Research Database by IPGTRA Jamnagar Shodhganga https://shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/simple-search?query=ashwagandha&go= 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 22
  • 23. Online sources- Wiki sources https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Withania_s omnifera 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 23
  • 24. Journal database http://ayushportal.nic.in/ http://www.dharaonline.org/Search/Ashwagandha/1/0/0/journalid http://www.medknow.com/searcharticle.asp?author=&search=ashwagandha &journal=Y&entries=10&pg=1&s=0 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 24
  • 25. Journal database https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=ashwag andha+withania+somnifera Applying filters Saving articles 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 25
  • 26. Systemic Reviews Database https://www.cochranelibrary.com/search https://www.equator-network.org/ 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 26
  • 28. Red alert : No plagiarism Use it as Reference And plagiarism check software 9/9/2020 28Dr.Yogesh Deole
  • 34. Reference management - Mendeley software https://www.mendeley.com/ https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=mendeley+software+for+re ferences 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 34
  • 35. Process to publication Collection Data Analysis Interpretation Reference Research 9/9/2020Dr.Yogesh Deole CSRTSDC www.charaksamhita.com 35
  • 36. During and Post publication Publicize and index your research to improve impact Create an account/profile on: Google scholar(h-index, i-index), ResearchGate(RG), ORCID and upload the published article Discuss and share the links on social media NOT the original works till publication of article Review citations and feedbacks periodically Revisit and refer your article in next ones 9/9/2020 36Dr.Yogesh Deole