際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Nov辿 trendy ve vdeck辿m publikov叩n鱈
Pozn叩mky k v箪zkumu


                          Ladislava Such叩
                  Bratislava, 10. 10. 2011
Univerzita                   Pr哲mysl




             St叩tn鱈 spr叩va
Krize
tradin鱈ho
modelu
publikov叩n鱈?




                       "At present we (the faculty) generate
               knowledge, then give it away to the publisher,
                 then buy it back for ourselves at what have
                    become prohibitive prices" (Battin 1984)
New trends in scholarly publishing
1. Jak辿 asopisy existuj鱈 v R/SR?
   / Jak叩 je publikan鱈 praxe?
     Jak箪 je pomr OA a
        tradin鱈ch asopis哲?
     V jak箪ch oborech se
        uplatuj鱈 OA asopisy?
     Jak辿 finann鱈 modely
        vyu転鱈vaj鱈?
     Jak箪 druh recenzn鱈ho
        鱈zen鱈?
2. Jak辿 jsou postoje vdc哲 k OA a
   nov箪m m辿di鱈m?
     Panuje d哲vra k OA
        asopis哲m?
     Jak叩 je ochota k
        publikov叩n鱈 v re転imu OA?
     Jak辿 jsou motivace pro OA?
SOAP Survey
 43 033 respondent哲 celkem
 279 respondent哲 z R
 88 respondent哲 ze Slovenska

DOAJ Directory of Open Access
 7121 OA asopis哲
 52 esk箪ch OA asopis哲
 25 slovensk箪ch OA asopis哲

Dal邸鱈 zdroje
 Seznam recenzovan箪ch
   neimpaktovan箪ch asopis哲
   Rady pro v箪zkum, v箪voj a
   inovace (R)
 Centr叩lny register publikanej
   innosti V (SR)
 ()
Poet asopis哲 s oteven箪m
                p鱈stupem v DOAJ - poad鱈 dle zem鱈
1400


                                                                                                               2002
1200
                                                                                                               2003

1000                                                                                                           2004

                                                                                                               2005
 800
                                                                                                               2006

 600                                                                                                           2007

                                                                                                               2008
 400
                                                                                                               2009

 200                                                                                                           2010

                                                                                                               2011
   0
       United   Brazil    United   Spain   India   Germany Canada Romania   Italy   Turkey    Czech Slovakia
       States            Kingdom                                                             Republic
         1        2        3        4       5        6       7       8       9       10        29      45
Poet asopis哲 s oteven箪m p鱈stupem
                         2002-2011
60




50




40




30                                                                          Czech Republic
                                                                            Slovakia


20




10




 0
     2002    2003   2004   2005   2006   2007   2008   2009   2010   2011
Zn叩te ve sv辿m oboru asopis, kter箪
         publikuje l叩nky s oteven箪m
                   p鱈stupem?
100%

90%

80%

70%

60%
                                                I don't know
50%
                                                No

40%                                             Yes


30%

20%

10%

 0%
        Total       Czech Republic   Slovakia
Kolik l叩nk哲 jste publikoval/a za
           posledn鱈ch 5 let v re転imu
            oteven辿ho p鱈stupu?
100%

90%

80%

70%

60%                                            More than 10
                                               I do not know
50%
                                               6 to 10

40%                                            1 to 5
                                               0
30%

20%

10%

 0%
       Total       Czech Republic   Slovakia
Mysl鱈te si, 転e oteven箪 p鱈stup je nebo
            by mohl b箪t pro v叩邸 obor p鱈nosem?
          100%

           90%

           80%

           70%

           60%

           50%

           40%

           30%

           20%

           10%

                0%
                     Total        CZ            SK
I do not care        408          3             3
I have no opinion    2747         24            11
No                   1447         14            4
Yes                  38022        232           69
M鱈t p鱈stup k publikovan箪m l叩nk哲m z
       oblasti p鱈rodn鱈ch vd a medic鱈ny pro
              veejnost nen鱈 p鱈nosn辿
100%


90%


80%


70%


60%                                     Strongly disagree
                                        Disagree
50%
                                        Neither agree nor disagree
                                        Agree
40%
                                        Strongly agree
30%


20%


10%


 0%
         Total       CZ         SK
Faktory rozhoduj鱈c鱈 o v箪bru asopisu
                    pro publikov叩n鱈
120,0%



100,0%



 80,0%



 60,0%


                                                 Total
 40,0%                                           CZ
                                                 SK

 20,0%



  0,0%
V箪邸e poplatku za posledn鱈 publikovan箪
                           l叩nek
                    100%

                    90%

                    80%

                    70%

                    60%

                    50%

                    40%

                    30%

                    20%

                    10%

                        0%
                             Total   CZ        SK
More than 3000 ($4100)       35     1         0
1001-3000 ($1350-$4100)    2222    14        3
501-1000 ($700-$1350)      2844    16        0
251-500 ($350-$700)        1354    6         1
Up to 250 ($350)            1640    18        4
No charge                    11367   73        28
 opakov叩n鱈 studie SOAP pro lok叩ln鱈
  prosted鱈 v esk辿m a slovensk辿m jazyce (s
  m鱈rn箪mi 炭pravami)
 邸eten鱈 mezi vydavateli esk箪ch a
  slovensk箪ch vdeck箪ch asopis哲 (dotazn鱈k
  nebo dolov叩n鱈 dat z www)
 kvalitativn鱈 studie zamen叩 na
  publikan鱈 chov叩n鱈 vdc哲 (?)
Obr叩zky:
 Gideon Burton, Friendlydrag0n, katiew
  (Flickr.com)

Kontakt:
 sucha@phil.muni.cz
 http://kisk.phil.muni.cz

More Related Content

New trends in scholarly publishing

  • 1. Nov辿 trendy ve vdeck辿m publikov叩n鱈 Pozn叩mky k v箪zkumu Ladislava Such叩 Bratislava, 10. 10. 2011
  • 2. Univerzita Pr哲mysl St叩tn鱈 spr叩va
  • 3. Krize tradin鱈ho modelu publikov叩n鱈? "At present we (the faculty) generate knowledge, then give it away to the publisher, then buy it back for ourselves at what have become prohibitive prices" (Battin 1984)
  • 5. 1. Jak辿 asopisy existuj鱈 v R/SR? / Jak叩 je publikan鱈 praxe? Jak箪 je pomr OA a tradin鱈ch asopis哲? V jak箪ch oborech se uplatuj鱈 OA asopisy? Jak辿 finann鱈 modely vyu転鱈vaj鱈? Jak箪 druh recenzn鱈ho 鱈zen鱈? 2. Jak辿 jsou postoje vdc哲 k OA a nov箪m m辿di鱈m? Panuje d哲vra k OA asopis哲m? Jak叩 je ochota k publikov叩n鱈 v re転imu OA? Jak辿 jsou motivace pro OA?
  • 6. SOAP Survey 43 033 respondent哲 celkem 279 respondent哲 z R 88 respondent哲 ze Slovenska DOAJ Directory of Open Access 7121 OA asopis哲 52 esk箪ch OA asopis哲 25 slovensk箪ch OA asopis哲 Dal邸鱈 zdroje Seznam recenzovan箪ch neimpaktovan箪ch asopis哲 Rady pro v箪zkum, v箪voj a inovace (R) Centr叩lny register publikanej innosti V (SR) ()
  • 7. Poet asopis哲 s oteven箪m p鱈stupem v DOAJ - poad鱈 dle zem鱈 1400 2002 1200 2003 1000 2004 2005 800 2006 600 2007 2008 400 2009 200 2010 2011 0 United Brazil United Spain India Germany Canada Romania Italy Turkey Czech Slovakia States Kingdom Republic 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 29 45
  • 8. Poet asopis哲 s oteven箪m p鱈stupem 2002-2011 60 50 40 30 Czech Republic Slovakia 20 10 0 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
  • 9. Zn叩te ve sv辿m oboru asopis, kter箪 publikuje l叩nky s oteven箪m p鱈stupem? 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% I don't know 50% No 40% Yes 30% 20% 10% 0% Total Czech Republic Slovakia
  • 10. Kolik l叩nk哲 jste publikoval/a za posledn鱈ch 5 let v re転imu oteven辿ho p鱈stupu? 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% More than 10 I do not know 50% 6 to 10 40% 1 to 5 0 30% 20% 10% 0% Total Czech Republic Slovakia
  • 11. Mysl鱈te si, 転e oteven箪 p鱈stup je nebo by mohl b箪t pro v叩邸 obor p鱈nosem? 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Total CZ SK I do not care 408 3 3 I have no opinion 2747 24 11 No 1447 14 4 Yes 38022 232 69
  • 12. M鱈t p鱈stup k publikovan箪m l叩nk哲m z oblasti p鱈rodn鱈ch vd a medic鱈ny pro veejnost nen鱈 p鱈nosn辿 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% Strongly disagree Disagree 50% Neither agree nor disagree Agree 40% Strongly agree 30% 20% 10% 0% Total CZ SK
  • 13. Faktory rozhoduj鱈c鱈 o v箪bru asopisu pro publikov叩n鱈 120,0% 100,0% 80,0% 60,0% Total 40,0% CZ SK 20,0% 0,0%
  • 14. V箪邸e poplatku za posledn鱈 publikovan箪 l叩nek 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Total CZ SK More than 3000 ($4100) 35 1 0 1001-3000 ($1350-$4100) 2222 14 3 501-1000 ($700-$1350) 2844 16 0 251-500 ($350-$700) 1354 6 1 Up to 250 ($350) 1640 18 4 No charge 11367 73 28
  • 15. opakov叩n鱈 studie SOAP pro lok叩ln鱈 prosted鱈 v esk辿m a slovensk辿m jazyce (s m鱈rn箪mi 炭pravami) 邸eten鱈 mezi vydavateli esk箪ch a slovensk箪ch vdeck箪ch asopis哲 (dotazn鱈k nebo dolov叩n鱈 dat z www) kvalitativn鱈 studie zamen叩 na publikan鱈 chov叩n鱈 vdc哲 (?)
  • 16. Obr叩zky: Gideon Burton, Friendlydrag0n, katiew (Flickr.com) Kontakt: sucha@phil.muni.cz http://kisk.phil.muni.cz