This document provides an overview of a public affairs breakout session discussing strategies for improving communication through newspapers and other public affairs tools. Key points discussed include:
1) Transitioning newspapers to focus more on effects-based communication by exploiting strengths like analysis and addressing weaknesses like timeliness.
2) Implementing a "PA kill chain" approach to public affairs that mirrors the targeting process for identifying audiences, developing messages, selecting appropriate media, engaging audiences, and assessing effectiveness.
3) Pursuing "convergence" of public affairs tools and eliminating barriers between internal and external communication approaches.
3. Introduction
Its not that the Navy has a better
story to tell, its just that it knows
how to tell the story.
Loren B. Thompson
Chief Operating Officer
Lexington Institute
4. Introduction
90% Updated frequently = motivated to add value
82% Clear communication = motivated to add value
65% Most information received seems irrelevant
40% Too much corporate speak or jargon
39% Hear about big changes too late
5. Overview
Newspaper Transition
Public Web project
PA Kill Chain & Convergence
Effects-Based Newspapers
Know strengths
Overcome weaknesses
Plan
Target
Trends
Countering the trends
6. PA Kill Chain
Operations
Find, Fix, Track, Target, Engage, Assess
Public Affairs
FIND
Identify communication need, desired effect
FIX
Identify audiences, messages
TRACK
Adjust messages/audiences as more info becomes available
TARGET
Identify appropriate weapon system (media formats)
ENGAGE
Single/multiple formats to achieve desired effect
ASSESS
Fight for feedback, measure effect
7. Convergence
Coordinate use of all comms weapons systems
Web, print, video, radio, F2F, e-mail, papers, radio, civ
media, etc.
Eliminate tribal representative mentality
Comms targeted at internal audiences, regardless of
method used, is Internal
Internal=External, External=Internal
Eliminate internalexternal disconnect
Already executing some convergence
Telephone systems w/AF Radio News
CC Topics
Inclement weather notices thru local media
8. Convergence
Newspapers
54% (62%) weekly adult readers
40% (48%) of weekly 18-24 readers
1.9% drop in circulation (2004-2005)
Cable news
Small audience (2-3 million)
No growth in cable news for three years
Network news
34% drop in ratings since 1996 (59% since 1969)
Radio
Dropping news
13% radio talk-show audience
9. Convergence
Magazines
50% drop in popularity since 1994
Web
68% U.S. population online
56% have no knowledge of blogs
16% read blogs
9% maintain blogs
72% prefer printed newspapers
11% get majority of news online
In the U.S., the average amount of time spent reading
news online in 2004 was just 7 minutes per day.
10. Effects-Based
Newspapers
Exploit the strengths
Analysis and interpretation
Multiple perspectives
Recognize personal/team achievements
Multiple audiences
Sense of community
Commander/reader participation
Quantity of news
Advance news
Features
Serial coverage & Themes
11. Effects-Based
Newspapers
Overcome the weaknesses
Not timely
Limited access to experts/authorities
No dirty laundry topics
Perceived low objectivity, credibility
No two-way communications
Multiple audiences=shotgun targeting
Dated medium in information age
12. Effects-Based
Newspapers
Planned
Contract for capability
No-cost equipment/personnel support, upgrades
Infographics design?
Seek end-of-year funding
Take the team approach
Services, FSC, base photo lab, ACC, AFNEWS
Implement 3-week planning process
Stick to weekly/daily production schedules
Anticipate commanders needs
Demand more!
13. Effects-Based
Newspapers
Targeted Audience driven
No such thing as mass Internal Audience
Communities of interest
See, experience, feel organization differently
Different methods for accessing information
Know base demographics
Know who reads, how they read (pulse surveys)
Target messages, delivery toward readers
Address the me factor
Localize
Use style & content, and special content
Fight for feedback
Form a steering committee
14. Effects-Based
Newspapers
Targeted Key elements
Leaders
Link Airmen/leaders through a free flow of news/information
Provide avenues for feedback
Mission
Help Airmen understand their roles in the Air Force
Explain how policies, programs and operations affect Airmen
People
Promote good citizenship/build pride as members of the civilian
community at home and abroad
Recognize individual and team achievements
Infrastructure
Explain how policies, programs and operations affect Airmen
15. Effects-Based
Newspapers
Targeted Community Themed AF & Local
Leaders
Who are they?
What are they saying?
Mission
GWOT/OIF/OEF were at war!
What are we doing and where are we doing it?
People
Programs retirement, retention, housing, AEF, activities, etc.
Recognition
Recreation
Devlopment
Infrastructure
Improvements, new services, changes to existing services
16. Trends
What were seeing
No/little war coverage
No/little leadership involvement
No/little two-way communication
No/little information graphic use
Poor/blah photography
Decreased emphasis on community/sports
Many one-source stories
No/little localization
Briefs not used effectively
Dated presentations
No/little strategy for redesign efforts
17. Trends
Countering the trends
War coverage in every issue
Training reinforce basics
Training advanced
techniques
Seek leader involvement at all
levels
Apply visual journalism
processes
Implement a redesign process
Put emphasis on
community/sports
Abandon pure-J mindset
19. Trends
Fast Facts
Checklists
Diagrams
Quizzes
Surveys/Polls
Charts/Graphs
Book Reviews
Movie Reviews
Lists
20. Conclusion
The workshop was great, but my PAO will
never let me do this kind of stuff.
-- ACC student
2005 AF Journalists Workshop
Editor's Notes
#7: F2T2EA Another avenue that will lead to compression of the kill chain entails eliminating what Jumper calls cultural stovepipes within the F2T2EA cycle. Stovepipes refers to specialized career fields, such as space, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, and communications, that contribute data to the warfighter The service also instituted a task-force approach to develop requirements.
#8: F2T2EA Another avenue that will lead to compression of the kill chain entails eliminating what Jumper calls cultural stovepipes within the F2T2EA cycle. Stovepipes refers to specialized career fields, such as space, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, and communications, that contribute data to the warfighter The service also instituted a task-force approach to develop requirements.
#9: F2T2EA Another avenue that will lead to compression of the kill chain entails eliminating what Jumper calls cultural stovepipes within the F2T2EA cycle. Stovepipes refers to specialized career fields, such as space, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, and communications, that contribute data to the warfighter The service also instituted a task-force approach to develop requirements.
#10: F2T2EA Another avenue that will lead to compression of the kill chain entails eliminating what Jumper calls cultural stovepipes within the F2T2EA cycle. Stovepipes refers to specialized career fields, such as space, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, and communications, that contribute data to the warfighter The service also instituted a task-force approach to develop requirements.
#11: F2T2EA Another avenue that will lead to compression of the kill chain entails eliminating what Jumper calls cultural stovepipes within the F2T2EA cycle. Stovepipes refers to specialized career fields, such as space, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, and communications, that contribute data to the warfighter The service also instituted a task-force approach to develop requirements.
#12: F2T2EA Another avenue that will lead to compression of the kill chain entails eliminating what Jumper calls cultural stovepipes within the F2T2EA cycle. Stovepipes refers to specialized career fields, such as space, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, and communications, that contribute data to the warfighter The service also instituted a task-force approach to develop requirements.
#13: F2T2EA Another avenue that will lead to compression of the kill chain entails eliminating what Jumper calls cultural stovepipes within the F2T2EA cycle. Stovepipes refers to specialized career fields, such as space, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, and communications, that contribute data to the warfighter The service also instituted a task-force approach to develop requirements.
#14: F2T2EA Another avenue that will lead to compression of the kill chain entails eliminating what Jumper calls cultural stovepipes within the F2T2EA cycle. Stovepipes refers to specialized career fields, such as space, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, and communications, that contribute data to the warfighter The service also instituted a task-force approach to develop requirements.
#15: F2T2EA Another avenue that will lead to compression of the kill chain entails eliminating what Jumper calls cultural stovepipes within the F2T2EA cycle. Stovepipes refers to specialized career fields, such as space, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, and communications, that contribute data to the warfighter The service also instituted a task-force approach to develop requirements.
#16: F2T2EA Another avenue that will lead to compression of the kill chain entails eliminating what Jumper calls cultural stovepipes within the F2T2EA cycle. Stovepipes refers to specialized career fields, such as space, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, and communications, that contribute data to the warfighter The service also instituted a task-force approach to develop requirements.
#17: F2T2EA Another avenue that will lead to compression of the kill chain entails eliminating what Jumper calls cultural stovepipes within the F2T2EA cycle. Stovepipes refers to specialized career fields, such as space, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, and communications, that contribute data to the warfighter The service also instituted a task-force approach to develop requirements.
#18: F2T2EA Another avenue that will lead to compression of the kill chain entails eliminating what Jumper calls cultural stovepipes within the F2T2EA cycle. Stovepipes refers to specialized career fields, such as space, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, and communications, that contribute data to the warfighter The service also instituted a task-force approach to develop requirements.
#19: F2T2EA Another avenue that will lead to compression of the kill chain entails eliminating what Jumper calls cultural stovepipes within the F2T2EA cycle. Stovepipes refers to specialized career fields, such as space, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, and communications, that contribute data to the warfighter The service also instituted a task-force approach to develop requirements.
#20: F2T2EA Another avenue that will lead to compression of the kill chain entails eliminating what Jumper calls cultural stovepipes within the F2T2EA cycle. Stovepipes refers to specialized career fields, such as space, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, and communications, that contribute data to the warfighter The service also instituted a task-force approach to develop requirements.
#21: F2T2EA Another avenue that will lead to compression of the kill chain entails eliminating what Jumper calls cultural stovepipes within the F2T2EA cycle. Stovepipes refers to specialized career fields, such as space, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance, and communications, that contribute data to the warfighter The service also instituted a task-force approach to develop requirements.