際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
# NOTRANSLATION
NOJUSTICE
THE ILLUSIONARY RIGHT TO
TRANSLATION IN CRIMINAL
PROCEEDINGS
Luxembourg, EULITA 16 March 2023
PREREQUISITE
TO ANY OTHER
FAIR TRIAL RIGHT
art 6/3 a ECHR
art 14/3 a International
Covenant on Civil and Political
Rights
artt 47 (fair trial)
-
48
(
2
defence rights) of Charter
(
1st procedural) Directive 2010/64
FREE AND
ADEQUATE
LINGUISTIC ASSISTANCE
->
TO EXERCISE FULLY RIGHT OF
DEFENCE
->
SAFEGUARDING FAIRNESS
FREE
free = underpaid
Italy
7,34  /h first 2 hours
4,07  /h from 3rd hour
+
20% if urgency
ADEQUATE
right to a written translation
of all documents which are
essential to ensure that
they are able to exercise
their right of defence and to
safeguard the fairness of
the proceedings
art 3 Directive 64/2010
Italy
need for interpretation /
translation (in fact) assessed
by police officers
no control about
competence of judicial
interpreters and translators
sea rescue trial
27.000
+
pages investigation case file
German defendants
#NoTranslationNoJustice. The illusionary right to translation in Italian criminal proceedings
#NoTranslationNoJustice. The illusionary right to translation in Italian criminal proceedings
rights that are practical
and effective,not
theoretical or illusory
European Court of Human Rights, Artico vs. Italia, 1980

More Related Content

#NoTranslationNoJustice. The illusionary right to translation in Italian criminal proceedings