ݺߣ

ݺߣShare a Scribd company logo
O&M Specimen model – alignments with
PROV, BCO
Simon Cox | Research Scientist | Environmental Information Infrastructures
3 September 2015
LAND AND WATER
Sampling features & specimens
IGSN Metadata workshop - 2015-09-03
«FeatureType»
OM_Observ ation
«FeatureType»
SF_SamplingFeature
+ lineage: LI_Lineage [0..1]
+ parameter: NamedValue [0..*]
constraints
{sampledFeature->forAll(not (oclIsKindOf
(SF_SamplingFeature) or oclIsKindOf
(OM_Observation)))}
SamplingFeatureComplex
+ role: GenericName
«FeatureType»
GFI_Feature
«FeatureType»
SF_SamplingFeatureCollection
Intention
+sampledFeature
1..*
0..*
+relatedSamplingFeature
0..*
Collection
+member 1..*
Design
+relatedObservation 0..*
SF_Specimen
+ currentLocation: Location [0..1]
+ materialClass: GenericName
+ samplingLocation: GM_Object [0..1]
+ samplingMethod: SF_Process [0..1]
+ samplingTime: TM_Object
+ size: Measure [0..1]
+ specimenType: GenericName [0..1]
SF_SamplingFeature
+ lineage: LI_Lineage [0..1]
+ parameter: NamedValue [0..*]
Location
+ geometryLocation: GM_Object
+ nameLocation: EX_GeographicDescription
GFI_Feature
SamplingFeatureComplex
+ role: GenericName
PreparationStep
+ processOperator: CI_ResponsibleParty [0..1]
+ time: TM_Object
SF_Process
+processingDetails
0..*
Intention
+sampledFeature 1..*
0..*
+relatedSamplingFeature
0..*
Cox, OGC Abstract Specification – Topic 20: Observations and Measurements 2.0
ISO 19156:2011 Geographic Information – Observations and measurements
sam-lite ontology
IGSN Metadata workshop - 2015-09-03
Cox, SJD, Ontology for observations and sampling features, with alignments to existing models,
Semantic Web Journal (in review)
http://www.semantic-web-journal.net/content/ontology-observations-and-sampling-features-alignments-existing-models
Core PROV model
IGSN Metadata workshop - 2015-09-03
samfl:Specimen rdfs:subClassOf prov:Entity .
samfl:Process rdfs:subClassOf prov:Agent .
Specimen preparation and observation trace
Lifecycle events modelled
as prov:Activity instances
• Analysis
• Sieving
• Grinding
• Splitting
• Specimen retrieval
IGSN Metadata workshop - 2015-09-03 Cox, SJD, Car, NJ, PROV and Real Things, MODSIM 2015
Other alignments and
extensions
prov:Entity ← :PhysicalEntity ← :Specimen
prov:Entity ← prov:Plan ← :SamplingProtocol
prov:Agent ← :SampleProcessingSystem
← :GrindingSystem, :PolishingSystem, :DissolvingSystem, :FusingSystem
prov:Agent ← :SampleRetrievalSystem ← :FieldSamplingSystem
prov:Agent ← :SubSamplingSystem
← :BiasedSplittingSystem
← :SizeSeparationSystem , :DensitySeparationSystem, :MagneticSeparationSystem
prov:Agent ← Instrument , Sensor
prov:wasAssociatedWith ← :wasControlledBy, :wasSponsoredBy, :wasRequestedBy
prov:wasDerivedFrom ← :unbiasedSplitFrom, :biasedSplitFrom
prov:wasDerivedFrom ← prov:hadPrimarySource ← :fieldSpecimen
IGSN Metadata workshop - 2015-09-03
Biological
Collections
Ontology
IGSN Metadata workshop - 2015-09-03
Biological
Collections
Ontology
IGSN Metadata workshop - 2015-09-03
BFO:IndependentContinuant ↔ prov:Entity
← BFO:MaterialEntity ↔ :PhysicalEntity
← BCO:MaterialSample ↔ :Specimen
BFO:Process ← prov:Activity
 observing, sampling, extraction processes
O&M, OBOE, BCO, BFO alignment
• Walls, Jones, Cox, Guralnick, Schildhauer, Buttigieg – coming soon!
IGSN Metadata workshop - 2015-09-03
LAND AND WATER
Thank youCSIRO Land and Water
Simon Cox
Research Scientist
t +61 3 9252 6342
e simon.cox@csiro.au
w www.csiro.au/people/simon.cox
Ad

Recommended

A standard for geospatial observations and measurements
A standard for geospatial observations and measurements
Simon Cox
Prov and real things
Prov and real things
Simon Cox
OM-JSON - a JSON implementation of O&M
OM-JSON - a JSON implementation of O&M
Simon Cox
Pitfalls in alignment of observation models resolved using PROV as an upper o...
Pitfalls in alignment of observation models resolved using PROV as an upper o...
Simon Cox
Leverage and Delegation in Developing an Information Model for Geology
Leverage and Delegation in Developing an Information Model for Geology
Simon Cox
Observations to Information
Observations to Information
Simon Cox
I scope noisemodel
I scope noisemodel
Debbie Wilson
LINK
LINK
Alex Gomes
Опыт ресоциализации осужденных на Дальнем Востоке
Опыт ресоциализации осужденных на Дальнем Востоке
Vadim Karastelev
Banco común de conocimientos
Fernando Trujillo Sáez
Live and learn in Ireland presentation in Boston
Live and learn in Ireland presentation in Boston
Tom Farrelly @TomFarrelly
Soa Lmanipulasi Perpangkatan Bentuk Aljabar
Soa Lmanipulasi Perpangkatan Bentuk Aljabar
Ahmad Mustofa
Identifying and Handling Children with Disabilities
Identifying and Handling Children with Disabilities
Febby Kirstin
md firmware upgrade UI spec Demo
md firmware upgrade UI spec Demo
yiwensyao
Onafhankelijk advies pensioen, hypotheek
Onafhankelijk advies pensioen, hypotheek
Eduard Jansen✔
PCIC Data Portal 2.0
PCIC Data Portal 2.0
James Hiebert
Multilateral newsletter february 2015
Multilateral newsletter february 2015
Confederation of Indian Industry
All bound up? Monetary policy in recovery and beyond
All bound up? Monetary policy in recovery and beyond
ResolutionFoundation
Vocabularies and vocabulary services for water data
Vocabularies and vocabulary services for water data
Simon Cox
Vsegda krasivye volosy_sekret_omolazhivayuschikh_ki
Vsegda krasivye volosy_sekret_omolazhivayuschikh_ki
Liza Alypova
Cross-domain data discovery and integration
Cross-domain data discovery and integration
Simon Cox
The SOSA ontology
The SOSA ontology
Simon Cox
Web standards support science data
Web standards support science data
Simon Cox
PROV ontology supports alignment of observational data (models)
PROV ontology supports alignment of observational data (models)
Simon Cox
Vocabularies, ontologies, standards for observations: developments from RDA, ...
Vocabularies, ontologies, standards for observations: developments from RDA, ...
Simon Cox
A common model for scientific observations and samples
A common model for scientific observations and samples
Simon Cox
OWL-Time and enhancements
OWL-Time and enhancements
Simon Cox

More Related Content

Viewers also liked (15)

Опыт ресоциализации осужденных на Дальнем Востоке
Опыт ресоциализации осужденных на Дальнем Востоке
Vadim Karastelev
Banco común de conocimientos
Fernando Trujillo Sáez
Live and learn in Ireland presentation in Boston
Live and learn in Ireland presentation in Boston
Tom Farrelly @TomFarrelly
Soa Lmanipulasi Perpangkatan Bentuk Aljabar
Soa Lmanipulasi Perpangkatan Bentuk Aljabar
Ahmad Mustofa
Identifying and Handling Children with Disabilities
Identifying and Handling Children with Disabilities
Febby Kirstin
md firmware upgrade UI spec Demo
md firmware upgrade UI spec Demo
yiwensyao
Onafhankelijk advies pensioen, hypotheek
Onafhankelijk advies pensioen, hypotheek
Eduard Jansen✔
PCIC Data Portal 2.0
PCIC Data Portal 2.0
James Hiebert
Multilateral newsletter february 2015
Multilateral newsletter february 2015
Confederation of Indian Industry
All bound up? Monetary policy in recovery and beyond
All bound up? Monetary policy in recovery and beyond
ResolutionFoundation
Vocabularies and vocabulary services for water data
Vocabularies and vocabulary services for water data
Simon Cox
Vsegda krasivye volosy_sekret_omolazhivayuschikh_ki
Vsegda krasivye volosy_sekret_omolazhivayuschikh_ki
Liza Alypova
Опыт ресоциализации осужденных на Дальнем Востоке
Опыт ресоциализации осужденных на Дальнем Востоке
Vadim Karastelev
Banco común de conocimientos
Fernando Trujillo Sáez
Soa Lmanipulasi Perpangkatan Bentuk Aljabar
Soa Lmanipulasi Perpangkatan Bentuk Aljabar
Ahmad Mustofa
Identifying and Handling Children with Disabilities
Identifying and Handling Children with Disabilities
Febby Kirstin
md firmware upgrade UI spec Demo
md firmware upgrade UI spec Demo
yiwensyao
Onafhankelijk advies pensioen, hypotheek
Onafhankelijk advies pensioen, hypotheek
Eduard Jansen✔
All bound up? Monetary policy in recovery and beyond
All bound up? Monetary policy in recovery and beyond
ResolutionFoundation
Vocabularies and vocabulary services for water data
Vocabularies and vocabulary services for water data
Simon Cox
Vsegda krasivye volosy_sekret_omolazhivayuschikh_ki
Vsegda krasivye volosy_sekret_omolazhivayuschikh_ki
Liza Alypova

More from Simon Cox (15)

Cross-domain data discovery and integration
Cross-domain data discovery and integration
Simon Cox
The SOSA ontology
The SOSA ontology
Simon Cox
Web standards support science data
Web standards support science data
Simon Cox
PROV ontology supports alignment of observational data (models)
PROV ontology supports alignment of observational data (models)
Simon Cox
Vocabularies, ontologies, standards for observations: developments from RDA, ...
Vocabularies, ontologies, standards for observations: developments from RDA, ...
Simon Cox
A common model for scientific observations and samples
A common model for scientific observations and samples
Simon Cox
OWL-Time and enhancements
OWL-Time and enhancements
Simon Cox
Ontology alignment – is PROV-O good enough?
Ontology alignment – is PROV-O good enough?
Simon Cox
Re-use of standard ontologies in a water quality vocabulary
Re-use of standard ontologies in a water quality vocabulary
Simon Cox
A harmonized vocabulary for water quality
A harmonized vocabulary for water quality
Simon Cox
Harmonization of vocabularies for water data
Harmonization of vocabularies for water data
Simon Cox
Some problems with standard geospatial metadata
Some problems with standard geospatial metadata
Simon Cox
Information Viewpoints and Geoscience Service Architectures
Information Viewpoints and Geoscience Service Architectures
Simon Cox
Technologies and practices for maintaining and publishing earth science vocab...
Technologies and practices for maintaining and publishing earth science vocab...
Simon Cox
Developing and publishing vocabularies
Developing and publishing vocabularies
Simon Cox
Cross-domain data discovery and integration
Cross-domain data discovery and integration
Simon Cox
Web standards support science data
Web standards support science data
Simon Cox
PROV ontology supports alignment of observational data (models)
PROV ontology supports alignment of observational data (models)
Simon Cox
Vocabularies, ontologies, standards for observations: developments from RDA, ...
Vocabularies, ontologies, standards for observations: developments from RDA, ...
Simon Cox
A common model for scientific observations and samples
A common model for scientific observations and samples
Simon Cox
OWL-Time and enhancements
OWL-Time and enhancements
Simon Cox
Ontology alignment – is PROV-O good enough?
Ontology alignment – is PROV-O good enough?
Simon Cox
Re-use of standard ontologies in a water quality vocabulary
Re-use of standard ontologies in a water quality vocabulary
Simon Cox
A harmonized vocabulary for water quality
A harmonized vocabulary for water quality
Simon Cox
Harmonization of vocabularies for water data
Harmonization of vocabularies for water data
Simon Cox
Some problems with standard geospatial metadata
Some problems with standard geospatial metadata
Simon Cox
Information Viewpoints and Geoscience Service Architectures
Information Viewpoints and Geoscience Service Architectures
Simon Cox
Technologies and practices for maintaining and publishing earth science vocab...
Technologies and practices for maintaining and publishing earth science vocab...
Simon Cox
Developing and publishing vocabularies
Developing and publishing vocabularies
Simon Cox
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

Abzymes mimickers in catalytic reactions at nanoscales
Abzymes mimickers in catalytic reactions at nanoscales
OrchideaMariaLecian
SCIENCE-G7-Quarter1-Week1-Day5.matatagptx
SCIENCE-G7-Quarter1-Week1-Day5.matatagptx
Pyumpyum
The Emergence of Signatures of AGI: The Physics of Learning
The Emergence of Signatures of AGI: The Physics of Learning
Charles Martin
Gas Exchange in Insects and structures 01
Gas Exchange in Insects and structures 01
PhoebeAkinyi1
Science 8 Quarter 4 first quiz digestive system.docx
Science 8 Quarter 4 first quiz digestive system.docx
junefermunez
GB1 Q1W1S1- Cell Theory General Biology 1
GB1 Q1W1S1- Cell Theory General Biology 1
KeannoRod1
GBSN_ Unit 1 - Introduction to Microbiology
GBSN_ Unit 1 - Introduction to Microbiology
Areesha Ahmad
Cloud Collaboration Market Challenges, Drivers, Trends, and Forecast by 2031
Cloud Collaboration Market Challenges, Drivers, Trends, and Forecast by 2031
moresonali406
Introduction to Microbiology and Microscope
Introduction to Microbiology and Microscope
vaishrawan1
How STEM Labs Are Revolutionizing Education
How STEM Labs Are Revolutionizing Education
yashfotonvr
Pneumonia Presentation for CPG Review and Mastery
Pneumonia Presentation for CPG Review and Mastery
JayricDepalobos
Introductory Material for Markov-chain Description of Abzymes Catalysis
Introductory Material for Markov-chain Description of Abzymes Catalysis
Orchidea Maria Lecian
Molecular biology and pellet weight marked
Molecular biology and pellet weight marked
nandanitiwari82528
Matt Ridley: Economic Evolution and Ideas that have Sex
Matt Ridley: Economic Evolution and Ideas that have Sex
Conservative Institute / Konzervatívny inštitút M. R. Štefánika
BP_MXene_Project_Proposal_Presentation.pptx
BP_MXene_Project_Proposal_Presentation.pptx
RoccoHunter8
Synthesis and characterization of Thiazole derivatives of N-substituted lsatin
Synthesis and characterization of Thiazole derivatives of N-substituted lsatin
Professional Content Writing's
Science Holiday Homework (interesting slide )
Science Holiday Homework (interesting slide )
aryanxkohli88
International Journal of Pharmacological Sciences (IJPS)
International Journal of Pharmacological Sciences (IJPS)
journalijps98
Pathophysiology_Unit1_BPharm CELL INJURY
Pathophysiology_Unit1_BPharm CELL INJURY
KRUTIKA CHANNE
8,9-Red Blood Cells.pdf ayurveda for life
8,9-Red Blood Cells.pdf ayurveda for life
AnkitBhardwaj874048
Abzymes mimickers in catalytic reactions at nanoscales
Abzymes mimickers in catalytic reactions at nanoscales
OrchideaMariaLecian
SCIENCE-G7-Quarter1-Week1-Day5.matatagptx
SCIENCE-G7-Quarter1-Week1-Day5.matatagptx
Pyumpyum
The Emergence of Signatures of AGI: The Physics of Learning
The Emergence of Signatures of AGI: The Physics of Learning
Charles Martin
Gas Exchange in Insects and structures 01
Gas Exchange in Insects and structures 01
PhoebeAkinyi1
Science 8 Quarter 4 first quiz digestive system.docx
Science 8 Quarter 4 first quiz digestive system.docx
junefermunez
GB1 Q1W1S1- Cell Theory General Biology 1
GB1 Q1W1S1- Cell Theory General Biology 1
KeannoRod1
GBSN_ Unit 1 - Introduction to Microbiology
GBSN_ Unit 1 - Introduction to Microbiology
Areesha Ahmad
Cloud Collaboration Market Challenges, Drivers, Trends, and Forecast by 2031
Cloud Collaboration Market Challenges, Drivers, Trends, and Forecast by 2031
moresonali406
Introduction to Microbiology and Microscope
Introduction to Microbiology and Microscope
vaishrawan1
How STEM Labs Are Revolutionizing Education
How STEM Labs Are Revolutionizing Education
yashfotonvr
Pneumonia Presentation for CPG Review and Mastery
Pneumonia Presentation for CPG Review and Mastery
JayricDepalobos
Introductory Material for Markov-chain Description of Abzymes Catalysis
Introductory Material for Markov-chain Description of Abzymes Catalysis
Orchidea Maria Lecian
Molecular biology and pellet weight marked
Molecular biology and pellet weight marked
nandanitiwari82528
BP_MXene_Project_Proposal_Presentation.pptx
BP_MXene_Project_Proposal_Presentation.pptx
RoccoHunter8
Synthesis and characterization of Thiazole derivatives of N-substituted lsatin
Synthesis and characterization of Thiazole derivatives of N-substituted lsatin
Professional Content Writing's
Science Holiday Homework (interesting slide )
Science Holiday Homework (interesting slide )
aryanxkohli88
International Journal of Pharmacological Sciences (IJPS)
International Journal of Pharmacological Sciences (IJPS)
journalijps98
Pathophysiology_Unit1_BPharm CELL INJURY
Pathophysiology_Unit1_BPharm CELL INJURY
KRUTIKA CHANNE
8,9-Red Blood Cells.pdf ayurveda for life
8,9-Red Blood Cells.pdf ayurveda for life
AnkitBhardwaj874048
Ad

O&M Specimen model – alignments with PROV, BCO

  • 1. O&M Specimen model – alignments with PROV, BCO Simon Cox | Research Scientist | Environmental Information Infrastructures 3 September 2015 LAND AND WATER
  • 2. Sampling features & specimens IGSN Metadata workshop - 2015-09-03 «FeatureType» OM_Observ ation «FeatureType» SF_SamplingFeature + lineage: LI_Lineage [0..1] + parameter: NamedValue [0..*] constraints {sampledFeature->forAll(not (oclIsKindOf (SF_SamplingFeature) or oclIsKindOf (OM_Observation)))} SamplingFeatureComplex + role: GenericName «FeatureType» GFI_Feature «FeatureType» SF_SamplingFeatureCollection Intention +sampledFeature 1..* 0..* +relatedSamplingFeature 0..* Collection +member 1..* Design +relatedObservation 0..* SF_Specimen + currentLocation: Location [0..1] + materialClass: GenericName + samplingLocation: GM_Object [0..1] + samplingMethod: SF_Process [0..1] + samplingTime: TM_Object + size: Measure [0..1] + specimenType: GenericName [0..1] SF_SamplingFeature + lineage: LI_Lineage [0..1] + parameter: NamedValue [0..*] Location + geometryLocation: GM_Object + nameLocation: EX_GeographicDescription GFI_Feature SamplingFeatureComplex + role: GenericName PreparationStep + processOperator: CI_ResponsibleParty [0..1] + time: TM_Object SF_Process +processingDetails 0..* Intention +sampledFeature 1..* 0..* +relatedSamplingFeature 0..* Cox, OGC Abstract Specification – Topic 20: Observations and Measurements 2.0 ISO 19156:2011 Geographic Information – Observations and measurements
  • 3. sam-lite ontology IGSN Metadata workshop - 2015-09-03 Cox, SJD, Ontology for observations and sampling features, with alignments to existing models, Semantic Web Journal (in review) http://www.semantic-web-journal.net/content/ontology-observations-and-sampling-features-alignments-existing-models
  • 4. Core PROV model IGSN Metadata workshop - 2015-09-03 samfl:Specimen rdfs:subClassOf prov:Entity . samfl:Process rdfs:subClassOf prov:Agent .
  • 5. Specimen preparation and observation trace Lifecycle events modelled as prov:Activity instances • Analysis • Sieving • Grinding • Splitting • Specimen retrieval IGSN Metadata workshop - 2015-09-03 Cox, SJD, Car, NJ, PROV and Real Things, MODSIM 2015
  • 6. Other alignments and extensions prov:Entity ← :PhysicalEntity ← :Specimen prov:Entity ← prov:Plan ← :SamplingProtocol prov:Agent ← :SampleProcessingSystem ← :GrindingSystem, :PolishingSystem, :DissolvingSystem, :FusingSystem prov:Agent ← :SampleRetrievalSystem ← :FieldSamplingSystem prov:Agent ← :SubSamplingSystem ← :BiasedSplittingSystem ← :SizeSeparationSystem , :DensitySeparationSystem, :MagneticSeparationSystem prov:Agent ← Instrument , Sensor prov:wasAssociatedWith ← :wasControlledBy, :wasSponsoredBy, :wasRequestedBy prov:wasDerivedFrom ← :unbiasedSplitFrom, :biasedSplitFrom prov:wasDerivedFrom ← prov:hadPrimarySource ← :fieldSpecimen IGSN Metadata workshop - 2015-09-03
  • 8. Biological Collections Ontology IGSN Metadata workshop - 2015-09-03 BFO:IndependentContinuant ↔ prov:Entity ← BFO:MaterialEntity ↔ :PhysicalEntity ← BCO:MaterialSample ↔ :Specimen BFO:Process ← prov:Activity  observing, sampling, extraction processes
  • 9. O&M, OBOE, BCO, BFO alignment • Walls, Jones, Cox, Guralnick, Schildhauer, Buttigieg – coming soon! IGSN Metadata workshop - 2015-09-03
  • 10. LAND AND WATER Thank youCSIRO Land and Water Simon Cox Research Scientist t +61 3 9252 6342 e simon.cox@csiro.au w www.csiro.au/people/simon.cox

Editor's Notes

  • #2: In order for the vision of the semantic web to be fulfilled, ontologies developed for related applications and deployed by different organizations must be aligned. Some ontologies are tied to a particular foundation ontology (such as BFO, GFO, UFO or DOLCE) by design, with their key classes in a subsumption hierarchy derived from the upper ontology. This enables rapid alignment with other ontologies developed in the same framework, but can present barriers otherwise. The Semantic Sensor Network ontology (SSN) was developed through a W3C incubator group with the goal of providing a general purpose ontology for sensor-based observations. It has seen widespread adoption in the semantic web community. On the other hand, in the geospatial community, OGC Observations and Measurements (O&M) provides the model used for standard observation services. While SSN adopts much of the terminology from O&M, full alignment has been a challenge. This is confounded by the fact that each is rooted in a different base “ontology” – SSN uses DOLCE as its foundation, while O&M is formalized as part of the ISO/TC 211 harmonised (UML) model. While some conflict derives from the tension between the frame-based UML paradigm used for O&M and the open-world, description-logics based paradigm used in SSN, this does not appear to be the whole story. A possible resolution is provided by comparing recent studies that align SSN and O&M, respectively, with the PROV-O ontology. PROV-O provides just three base classes: Entity, Activity and Agent. om:Observation is sub-classed from prov:Activity, while ssn:Observation is sub-classed from prov:Entity. This implies that, despite the same name, om:Observation and ssn:Observation denote different aspects of the observation process: the observation event, and the record of the observation event, respectively. Alignment with the simple PROV-O classes has clarified this issue in a way that had previously proved difficult to resolve. The simple 3-class base model from PROV appears to provide just enough logic to serve as a lightweight upper ontology.