際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Operating Room
Planning & Scheduling
      Kjeld H. Aij MBA




                         1
Paspoort Kjeld H. Aij
 Geboren in 1973 in Schiedam
 Studeerde Biomedische Wetenschappen,
    verpleegkunde en bedrijfskunde
 Verkreeg in 2008 de graad van Master of
    Business Administration aan de Business
    School Nederland

 Promotietraject applications of LEAN in
    Healthcare
 Getrouwd met Michelle; 辿辿n zoon Steyn
 Hoofd Operatiekamers VUmc, Spreker,
    Ondernemer, Investeerder in zilver



                                              2
3
Kjeld H. Aij MBA

                   4
Kjeld H. Aij MBA

                   5
Healtcare: a business unlike all others
 Financial model does not reward ef鍖ciency
 Patients are customer and product at the same time
          Patients cannot be refused
          Interventions cannot be preempted
   More variability than in any other industry
   Many different types of care providers
          Different types of hospitals, different strategies
          Academic hospitals do almost everything
          Specialized clinics are often seen as cream skimmers
   Multiple decision makers (doctors             managers)
          Doctors are private entrepreneurs within hospital
          They cheat the system to advance patients
   Stakeholders often have con鍖icting goals
                                                                   6
Kjeld H. Aij MBA
                   7
Kjeld H. Aij MBA

                   8
Operating Room Layout




                        9
10
Operating Rooms
   Signi鍖cant source of hospitals income
   Majority of hospital admissions undergo surgery
   Cost intensive (capital and labor)
   Determines the pace of the hospital
          If the OR sneezes, the hospital has a cold
 Are a dangerous place
          >10% of the patients experience complications or an incident
 Increased less invasive surgery (endoscopic, robotic)
          more daycare / outpatient treatments
 Have a lot of variability
          Diversity surgical procedures, complications,
          every patient is different, emergencies
 Capacity is determined by availability of trained staf
                                                                         11
Surgery is a complex
 process where many
resources act together

         Kjeld H. Aij MBA

                            12
Shortage of OR staff
   Cyclical shortage (4-5 years) of personnel
   Causes of shortage
        Oscillation in training capacity due to shortsighted planning
        Drop-out in training school
        Increase of part-time percentage during occupational life
        Aging
   Fortifying effect: occurrence of employment agencies
   Effects:
        Closure of operating rooms
        Increase working pressure
        Increase of labor costs: employment agencies, salary raises,
        additional income elements


                                                                        13
Roughly speaking,
   Generation Y is defined as -


1977    < Birth Date >
                               2000
  31    < Current Age >
                               8

            Kjeld H. Aij MBA

                                      14
ICT                                                     3%                   8%                    0%
      Taal en Cultuur                                         3%                   2%                    4%
      Chemie                                                  1%                   1%                    2%
      Natuur                                                  1%                   0%                    2%
      Finance                                                 1%                   1%                    1%
      Landbouw                                                0%                   0%                    0%



    Dat geld verdienen de belangrijkste reden is om te gaan werken, is bijna vanzelfsprekend: de schoorsteen moet
    tenslotte roken. Daarnaast vertoont generatie Y verrassende verschillen in de diverse opleidingsniveaus.



      BELANGRIJKSTE REDENEN OM TE GAAN WERKEN
                                                 % totaal   Laagopgeleid     Middelhoogopgeleid      Hoogopgeleid
      Geld verdienen                               89,7%           95,3%                   87,3%               90,3%
      Zelfontplooiing                              48,9%           32,6%                   52,7%               58,1%
                                                                      65% van de jongeren zegt in eerste instantie
      Kennis opdoen                                41,3%           41,9%                 42,7%             35,5%
                                                                      op de hoogte van het salaris te letten bij het
      Iets betekenen voor de maatschappij          28,8%           32,6%                 29,1%             22,6%
                                                                      kiezen van een (volgende) baan.
      Mensen leren kennen                          28,8%           41,9%                   28,2%               12,9%




8




                                                                                                                       15
BELANGRIJKE FACTOREN BIJ KIEZEN BAAN
80%
70%
60%
50%
                                                                                                                                                                    % totaal
40%
                                                                                                                                                                    mannen
30%
20%                        53,3% van de jongeren heeft al                                                                                                           vrouwen
10%                    tussen de 2 en 5 werkgevers gehad.
0%
                                                                                                 ..
              ris              er                 en                   rk                      e.                      rk         se
                                                                                                                                     n
                                                                                                                                                             aa
                                                                                                                                                                k
           ala              sfe                 ed                   we                     im                       we         us                       z
       S               de                    jkh                nd                       rtt                    tti
                                                                                                                   g
                                                                                                                            Bo
                                                                                                                               n                      de
                     oe                   eli               ele                        pa                    nu                                 va
                                                                                                                                                  n
                    G                   og               iss                     tot                      jk                                o
                                   em                w                     eid                        eli                                ut
                                i竪r                Af                     h                       p                                  A
                            ar
                              r
                                                                     lijk                      ap
                        C                                       e                         tsch
                                                              og                        aa
                                                            M                          M




                                                                                                                                                                               16
17
Goed werkgeverschap
           Eerlijk
Binden     Beloftes nakomen en waarmaken
         Modern werkgeverschap
           Inspelen op de multiculturele arbeidsmarkt
           Talent management
           Inspelen op sabbatical
           Flexibele werktijden/thuiswerken
           Open minded
           Alumni netwerken
           Bijdragen leveren aan de work/life balans
           Een opdracht/uitdaging aanbieden ipv baan

                                                    18
vertrouwen hebben in elkaar
  trots zijn op wat we doen
plezier hebben met collega's
   met wie we samenwerken

                               19
Strategic level (year, quarter)
Allocation of OR capacity to surgical specialties



            Tactical level (month)
 Weekly allocation of OR-days to specialties



      Operational (of鍖ine) level (weeks)
  Elective & semi-urgent surgery scheduling



         Operational (online) level (days)
            Monitoring and control
         Emergency surgery scheduling

        Kjeld H. Aij MBA

                                                    20
Strategic OR planning
   Capacity dimensioning
        Operating rooms, equipment
        Staff

   Division of the capacity pie
        Contract: board  OR management  specialties




                                                        21
OR Blueprint




               22
Kjeld H. Aij MBA

                   23
Strategic OR planning
  Emergency operating rooms or not?




                                       24
Tactical OR planning
 Open block planning (common in US)
      First come 鍖rst serve operation
      Different specialties operate successively in OR
      Long changeover time, unbalanced workload, overtime
      Emergency operating room
   Closed block planning (common in Netherlands)
      Each specialty / surgeon gets blocks of time
      (ORday morning session, afternoon session)
      Each specialty / surgeon schedules its patients in these blocks, at
      least 1 week in advance
      More ef鍖cient, less waiting time for patients
      Remaining time cannot be redistributed
   Semi-open block planning: combination

                                                                            25
Process from admission to discharge




                                      26
Process within an OR session
           F.Boer, LUMC




                               27
OR utilization




             Kjeld H. Aij MBA

                                28
29
Planning based on surgeons estimate




                                       30
Stochastic Surgery durations




               Kjeld H. Aij MBA

                                  31
32
Flaw of averages




                   33
34
You are not going to get the elephant to shrink or change its size.
You need to face the fact that the elephant is 8 OR tall and 11 hr wide.
                              Steven Shafer, MD




                                                                        35
Rooster-methodieken
Flexibele
                                                Zelfroosteren
werktijden

                                             Matching
             R
             u
             i                      Intekenrooster
             l
             e
             n
                           Voorkeurrooster


                 Repeterend rooster
Vaste
werktijden
                weinig                                      veel
             zeggenschap                                zeggenschap


                                                                      36
Performance of an Operating Room
   Productivity, e.g.
        Utilization
        Ratio: procedure time / capacity
   Changeover time
   Throughput time
   % Cancellations, related to:
        patient
        anesthesia preparation
        organization
   Waiting time of emergency patients
   Overtime
   Effectiveness (eg. revisits of patient, complications)
                                                             37
Kjeld H. Aij MBA

                   38

More Related Content

Or Management Kjeld H. Aij Mba

  • 1. Operating Room Planning & Scheduling Kjeld H. Aij MBA 1
  • 2. Paspoort Kjeld H. Aij Geboren in 1973 in Schiedam Studeerde Biomedische Wetenschappen, verpleegkunde en bedrijfskunde Verkreeg in 2008 de graad van Master of Business Administration aan de Business School Nederland Promotietraject applications of LEAN in Healthcare Getrouwd met Michelle; 辿辿n zoon Steyn Hoofd Operatiekamers VUmc, Spreker, Ondernemer, Investeerder in zilver 2
  • 3. 3
  • 4. Kjeld H. Aij MBA 4
  • 5. Kjeld H. Aij MBA 5
  • 6. Healtcare: a business unlike all others Financial model does not reward ef鍖ciency Patients are customer and product at the same time Patients cannot be refused Interventions cannot be preempted More variability than in any other industry Many different types of care providers Different types of hospitals, different strategies Academic hospitals do almost everything Specialized clinics are often seen as cream skimmers Multiple decision makers (doctors managers) Doctors are private entrepreneurs within hospital They cheat the system to advance patients Stakeholders often have con鍖icting goals 6
  • 7. Kjeld H. Aij MBA 7
  • 8. Kjeld H. Aij MBA 8
  • 10. 10
  • 11. Operating Rooms Signi鍖cant source of hospitals income Majority of hospital admissions undergo surgery Cost intensive (capital and labor) Determines the pace of the hospital If the OR sneezes, the hospital has a cold Are a dangerous place >10% of the patients experience complications or an incident Increased less invasive surgery (endoscopic, robotic) more daycare / outpatient treatments Have a lot of variability Diversity surgical procedures, complications, every patient is different, emergencies Capacity is determined by availability of trained staf 11
  • 12. Surgery is a complex process where many resources act together Kjeld H. Aij MBA 12
  • 13. Shortage of OR staff Cyclical shortage (4-5 years) of personnel Causes of shortage Oscillation in training capacity due to shortsighted planning Drop-out in training school Increase of part-time percentage during occupational life Aging Fortifying effect: occurrence of employment agencies Effects: Closure of operating rooms Increase working pressure Increase of labor costs: employment agencies, salary raises, additional income elements 13
  • 14. Roughly speaking, Generation Y is defined as - 1977 < Birth Date > 2000 31 < Current Age > 8 Kjeld H. Aij MBA 14
  • 15. ICT 3% 8% 0% Taal en Cultuur 3% 2% 4% Chemie 1% 1% 2% Natuur 1% 0% 2% Finance 1% 1% 1% Landbouw 0% 0% 0% Dat geld verdienen de belangrijkste reden is om te gaan werken, is bijna vanzelfsprekend: de schoorsteen moet tenslotte roken. Daarnaast vertoont generatie Y verrassende verschillen in de diverse opleidingsniveaus. BELANGRIJKSTE REDENEN OM TE GAAN WERKEN % totaal Laagopgeleid Middelhoogopgeleid Hoogopgeleid Geld verdienen 89,7% 95,3% 87,3% 90,3% Zelfontplooiing 48,9% 32,6% 52,7% 58,1% 65% van de jongeren zegt in eerste instantie Kennis opdoen 41,3% 41,9% 42,7% 35,5% op de hoogte van het salaris te letten bij het Iets betekenen voor de maatschappij 28,8% 32,6% 29,1% 22,6% kiezen van een (volgende) baan. Mensen leren kennen 28,8% 41,9% 28,2% 12,9% 8 15
  • 16. BELANGRIJKE FACTOREN BIJ KIEZEN BAAN 80% 70% 60% 50% % totaal 40% mannen 30% 20% 53,3% van de jongeren heeft al vrouwen 10% tussen de 2 en 5 werkgevers gehad. 0% .. ris er en rk e. rk se n aa k ala sfe ed we im we us z S de jkh nd rtt tti g Bo n de oe eli ele pa nu va n G og iss tot jk o em w eid eli ut i竪r Af h p A ar r lijk ap C e tsch og aa M M 16
  • 17. 17
  • 18. Goed werkgeverschap Eerlijk Binden Beloftes nakomen en waarmaken Modern werkgeverschap Inspelen op de multiculturele arbeidsmarkt Talent management Inspelen op sabbatical Flexibele werktijden/thuiswerken Open minded Alumni netwerken Bijdragen leveren aan de work/life balans Een opdracht/uitdaging aanbieden ipv baan 18
  • 19. vertrouwen hebben in elkaar trots zijn op wat we doen plezier hebben met collega's met wie we samenwerken 19
  • 20. Strategic level (year, quarter) Allocation of OR capacity to surgical specialties Tactical level (month) Weekly allocation of OR-days to specialties Operational (of鍖ine) level (weeks) Elective & semi-urgent surgery scheduling Operational (online) level (days) Monitoring and control Emergency surgery scheduling Kjeld H. Aij MBA 20
  • 21. Strategic OR planning Capacity dimensioning Operating rooms, equipment Staff Division of the capacity pie Contract: board OR management specialties 21
  • 23. Kjeld H. Aij MBA 23
  • 24. Strategic OR planning Emergency operating rooms or not? 24
  • 25. Tactical OR planning Open block planning (common in US) First come 鍖rst serve operation Different specialties operate successively in OR Long changeover time, unbalanced workload, overtime Emergency operating room Closed block planning (common in Netherlands) Each specialty / surgeon gets blocks of time (ORday morning session, afternoon session) Each specialty / surgeon schedules its patients in these blocks, at least 1 week in advance More ef鍖cient, less waiting time for patients Remaining time cannot be redistributed Semi-open block planning: combination 25
  • 26. Process from admission to discharge 26
  • 27. Process within an OR session F.Boer, LUMC 27
  • 28. OR utilization Kjeld H. Aij MBA 28
  • 29. 29
  • 30. Planning based on surgeons estimate 30
  • 31. Stochastic Surgery durations Kjeld H. Aij MBA 31
  • 32. 32
  • 34. 34
  • 35. You are not going to get the elephant to shrink or change its size. You need to face the fact that the elephant is 8 OR tall and 11 hr wide. Steven Shafer, MD 35
  • 36. Rooster-methodieken Flexibele Zelfroosteren werktijden Matching R u i Intekenrooster l e n Voorkeurrooster Repeterend rooster Vaste werktijden weinig veel zeggenschap zeggenschap 36
  • 37. Performance of an Operating Room Productivity, e.g. Utilization Ratio: procedure time / capacity Changeover time Throughput time % Cancellations, related to: patient anesthesia preparation organization Waiting time of emergency patients Overtime Effectiveness (eg. revisits of patient, complications) 37
  • 38. Kjeld H. Aij MBA 38