Understanding the English language as a distinct and stable entity has increasingly come into question across disciplines, often calling for more translingual approaches to writing instruction that take into account multiple manifestations of world Englishes (Canagarajah; Horner and Trimbur; Kachru). Since what Paul Matsuda calls the "division of labor" in the mid-twentieth century, SLW has often been seen as a distinct discipline from composition, rhetoric, and professional/technical writing, both pedagogically and epistemologically (Matsuda; Seargeant). Specifically, technical communication has rarely taken into account world Englishes approaches, often relying on standardized notions of "plain English" (Bokor). This presentation will argue that SLW pedagogies developed in what Anne Ruggles Gere calls the "extracurriculum of composition," where writing instruction came into contact with more diverse student populations. Archival research within the Kautz Family YMCA Archives clearly shows how pre-disciplinary forms of both technical communication and second language writing informed each other at the turn of the twentieth century in pre-professional spaces like the Young Men's Christian Association (YMCA). Constructions of technical writing based on "plain English" emerged out of translingual contexts, where students, industrial workers, and engineers came to the writing situation with diverse linguistic backgrounds, though these backgrounds are often hidden by the native speaker ideal and notions of "plain English." Examining these translingual spaces will demonstrate the constitutive nature of technical communication and SLW, both disciplinarily and historiographically. Recovering earlier translingual contexts can help scholars and instructors reimagine the disciplinary relationship between technical communication and SLW, providing opportunities to bring a world Englishes paradigm into the technical communication classroom and beyond.
1 of 31
Download to read offline
More Related Content
"Plain English" and the YMCA Technical Writing Classroom: Re-Covering Pre-Professional Moments in Second Language Writing History
1. "PLAIN ENGLISH¡± AND THE YMCA
TECHNICAL WRITING CLASSROOM
RECOVERING PRE-PROFESSIONAL MOMENTS IN
SLW
Lance Cummings
SLW Symposium 2014
2. BEFORE THE PROFESSIONALIZATION OF ACADEMIA, COMPOSITION,
SLW, AND TECHNICAL WRITING EXISTED IN AN INTERDEPENDENT
RELATIONSHIP, WHERE THE IDEA OF ¡°PLAIN ENGLISH¡± DEVELOPED
NEW OR STRONGER CONNOTATIONS THAT EXCLUDED LINGUISTIC
VARIETY.
1. PRE-PROFESSIONAL CONTEXTS
2. BRIEF OVERVIEW OF THE YMCA
3. TIMELINE ANALYSIS WITH ARCHIVAL
MATERIAL
4. POSSIBLE IMPLICATIONS FOR TW AND
SLW
4. DIVISION OF LABOR
The second-language
component does not appear in
the work of influential historians
of composition
studies¡because ESL writing
has not been considered as
part of composition studies
since it began to move to- ward
the status of a profession during
the 1960s.
Matsuda, ¡°Composition Studie
and ESL¡¡±
5. TWO CULTURES
English teachers saw
engineers as soulless
technicians, while engineers
saw English teachers as
dreaming aesthetes,
promoting ¡°refinement and
culture¡± to the exclusion of
reality.
Connors, ¡°The Rise ¡¡±
9. ¡°[The YMCA] shall meet the young stranger as he
enters our city, take him by the hand, direct him to
a boarding house where he may find a quiet home
pervaded with Christian influences¡¡±
¨COriginal Boston Constitution, 1851
12. Timeline
1850s
? Start of English Department (Kitzhaber)
? First ESL Class at Cincinnati YMCA
? Plain English
1890s
? Harvard Reports
? First Required Writing Course
? Development of Industrial Work Dept. and Educational Work Dept.
? Grammar in ¡°Plain English¡±
? ¡°Take over¡± of Engineering by technical fields (Connors)
1900s
? ESL and Engineering Service Learning in YMCA
? English course of study splits literature and composition
? ¡°Literacy Crisis¡± in Engineering (Connors)
15. Timeline
1850s
? Plain English
? Start of English Department (Kitzhaber)
? First ESL Class at Cincinnati YMCA
1890s
? Harvard Reports
? First Required Writing Course
? Development of Industrial Work Dept. and Educational Work Dept.
? Grammar in ¡°Plain English¡±
? ¡°Take over¡± of Engineering by technical fields (Connors)
1900s
? ¡°Literacy Crisis¡± in Engineering (Connors)
? ESL and Engineering Service Learning in YMCA
? English course of study splits literature and composition
17. Timeline
1850s
? Plain English
? Start of English Department (Kitzhaber)
? First ESL Class at Cincinnati YMCA
1890s
? Harvard Reports
? First Required Writing Course
? Development of Industrial Work Dept. and Educational Work Dept.
? Grammar in ¡°Plain English¡±
? ¡°Take over¡± of Engineering by technical fields (Connors)
1900s
? ¡°Literacy Crisis¡± in Engineering (Connors)
? ESL and Engineering Service Learning in YMCA
? English course of study splits literature and composition
19. Timeline
1850s
? Plain English
? Start of English Department (Kitzhaber)
? First ESL Class at Cincinnati YMCA
1890s
? Harvard Reports
? First Required Writing Course
? Development of Industrial Work Dept. and Educational Work Dept.
? Grammar in ¡°Plain English¡±
? ¡°Take over¡± of Engineering by technical fields (Connors)
1900s
? ¡°Literacy Crisis¡± in Engineering (Connors)
? ESL and Engineering Service Learning in YMCA
? English course of study splits literature and composition
21. 1910s
? Development of Roberts Method
? Course of Study for ¡°Coming Americans¡±
? First ESL Class at U of M (Matsuda)
? First Technical Writing textbooks written (Connors)
1920s
? Fred Newton Scott¡¯s ¡°English as a Mode of Behavior¡±
? YMCA focus on Business English
? Genre approach develops in Technical Writing
23. ¡°Thousands of foreign-speaking men work in
dangerous places in the mines and their prime
need is to learn simple words and phrases
descriptive of their daily vocation.¡±
¨CPeter Roberts, English for Coming Americans
25. 1910s
? First ESL Class at U of M (Matsuda)
? Development of Roberts Method
? Course of Study for ¡°Coming Americans¡±
? First Technical Writing textbooks written (Connors)
1920s
? Fred Newton Scott¡¯s ¡°English as a Mode of Behavior¡±
? YMCA focus on Business English
? Genre approach develops in Technical Writing
26. ¡°The nation debases its language with slang, with
hybrid and foreign words, the impure alloys and the
cheap imports of its verbal coinage, mere tokens
that should not be legal tender on the intellectual
exchanges.¡±
¨CT.A. Rickard, A Guide to Technical Writing
28. 1910s
? First ESL Class at U of M (Matsuda)
? Development of Roberts Method
? Course of Study for ¡°Coming Americans¡±
? First Technical Writing textbooks written (Connors)
1920s
? Fred Newton Scott¡¯s ¡°English as a Mode of Behavior¡±
? YMCA focus on Business English
? Genre approach develops in Technical Writing
31. IMPLICATIONS
? Understand of TW resistance to World Englishes and
translingualism
? Interdependent understanding of SLW and TW
? SLW can inform TW (and vice versa)
? Understanding ¡°Plain English¡± in Multiple Contexts
? Augmenting both SLW and TW instruction with
service learning
Editor's Notes
#2: -Dissertation background
-Young Men¡¯s Christian Association
-See the discourses and practices in different ways
#7: -Boxes
-in preprofessonal contexts, complicated networks of practices
-plain English
#11: -22 million between 1890 and 1930
-1907: reached million in one year
-also paralleled urban growth
-New York 1.5 -5.6 million between 1890-1920
#12: - Some obvious things about that
- English Immigrant and Yale Graduate
- Began his work as a pastor and advocate for Slav Miners
- Special Secretary of Immigrant Affairs for YMCA
Wrote all of his own textbooks
1909 - 1600 students, 1911 - 13,000, 1909 Formal Course of study
#13: - Some obvious things about that
- English Immigrant and Yale Graduate
- Began his work as a pastor and advocate for Slav Miners
- Special Secretary of Immigrant Affairs for YMCA
Wrote all of his own textbooks
1909 - 1600 students, 1911 - 13,000, 1909 Formal Course of study