An in-depth discussion of child hot car deaths (aka vehicular hyperthermia, vehicular heatstroke) and preventive measures from a parent survivor of a heatstroke victim, the late Sophia Rayne "Ray Ray" Cavaliero.
1 of 21
Download to read offline
More Related Content
Ray Rays Pledge #heatstroke awareness 2015
1. It Takes a Village:
Prevention of
Child Vehicular Heatstroke
Kristie C. Reeves-Cavaliero, Pharm.D.
President and Co-Founder,
Ray Ray’s Pledge?
2. ?Ray Ray’s Pledge? 2015
Forgotten in the Backseat:
More Common than You Think
http://youtu.be/kYGAIagq-Wg
3. ?Ray Ray’s Pledge? 2015
636+
The number of child hot car deaths
reported in the media since 1998
http://ggweather.com/heat; Accessed 3/30/15.
5. ?Ray Ray’s Pledge? 2015
Forgotten Daycare Drop-off
The #1 source
of child hot car deaths
Data on file. Ray Ray’s Pledge, 2015.
6. ?Ray Ray’s Pledge? 2015
Heat-Related Illness
? A spectrum of symptoms due to excessive
heat exposure
? Key initial physical sign to distinguish mild
illness vs. heatstroke:
? Core temperature:
? ≥104?F: heatstroke,,,,,
Becker J. Am Fam Physician 2011; 83(11):1325-30.
7. ?Ray Ray’s Pledge? 2015
Thermoregulation
? The body’s methods to maintain a healthy
temperature
? Conduction
? Direct transfer of heat from a warmer surface to a cooler
surface
? Evaporation
? Perspiration
? Radiation
? Absorption or reflection of heat without direct contact
? Eg: reflection of heat with light-colored clothing
? Convection
? Exchange of heat with surrounding air
Becker J. Am Fam Physician 2011; 83(11):1325-30.
8. ?Ray Ray’s Pledge? 2015
Heatstroke
? Also known as “hyperthermia”
? Body temperature exceeds 104?F
? + Body’s thermoregulatory mechanism is
overwhelmed and can no longer cool itself
? + Symptoms:
? Central nervous system effects: disorientation,
sluggishness, hallucinations, seizure, loss of consciousness
? Other: hot/dry skin that is flushed but not sweaty, rapid heart
rate, other heart rhythm disturbances
? Body temperature >107?F: organs shut down,
cellular damage
? Fatal if not rapidly reversed
Becker J. Am Fam Physician 2011; 83(11):1325-30.
http://ggweather.com/heat, Accessed 12/1/11.
9. ?Ray Ray’s Pledge? 2015
Heatstroke in Children
? Children are more prone to overheating
than adults:
? Immature thermoregulatory system: less
efficient than adults
? A child’s body overheats 3-5 times faster than
an adult body
? Adults more likely to modify behavior based
on environment
? (eg: remove excess clothing, get out
of a hot car)
Tsuzuki-Hayakawa K and Tochihara Y. Eur J Appl Physiol 1995;72:12–17.
http://ggweather.com/heat, Accessed 12/1/11.
10. ?Ray Ray’s Pledge? 2015
Child Vehicular Heatstroke:
An Unintended Consequence of
Moving Children to the Backseat
www.KidsandCars.org/heatstroke.html. Accessed 3/15/14.
11. ?Ray Ray’s Pledge? 2015
Child Deaths Due to
Vehicular Heatstroke:
Why Are We Talking About It?
http://kidsandcars.org/heatstroke.html, Accessed 12/1/11. NiTS Data.
http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/Pubs/811655.pdf. Accessed 3/15/14.
Vehicular Heatstroke:
3rd
leading cause of
death!
#1 cause of non-crash,
non-traffic child car
fatalities!
12. ?Ray Ray’s Pledge? 2015
Child Vehicular Heatstroke:
Understanding the Cause
Data from 494 child hot car deaths (1998 – 2010)
http://ggweather.com/heat, Accessed 12/1/11. Graph Courtesy of Jan Null, CCM.
?More than 1 in 5
heatstroke DEATHS
?Kids were supposed
to go to DAYCARE
that morning
?FORGOTTEN in the
backseat instead
?Whereabouts went
unquestioned
13. ?Ray Ray’s Pledge? 2015
Understanding the Cause
Child Vehicular Heatstroke Fatalities 2014
(n = 30)
*DNS: destination not specified
Data on file. Ray Ray’s Pledge, 2015.
? Children being
forgotten in
backseat (60%)
continues to be
predominant factor
? Forgotten daycare
drop-off continues
to be most
common intended
destination
23%
13%
27%
37%
14. ?Ray Ray’s Pledge? 2015
Children Left in Vehicles:
How Hot? How Fast?
? Rate of temperature rise in first 20 minutes: 6.25?F/ 5 minutes
? Overall rate of temperature rise through 60 minute study: 3.1?/ 5 minutes
? 80% of temperature rise in first 30 minutes
? Temperature rise begins within five minutes of shutting off ignition
? Temperature begins to plateau at 60 minutes
McClaren C et al. Pediatrics 2005; 116:e109-11. http://ggweather.com/heat,
Accessed 12/1/11.
15. ?Ray Ray’s Pledge? 2015
“How Can ANYONE Forget that a
Child is in the Backseat??”
“If you’re capable of FORGETTING your
CELLPHONE, you are potentially capable of
FORGETTING your CHILD”
David Diamond, Ph.D., USF
Weingarten G. Fatal Distraction. IN: Washington Post 2009.
http://www.pulitzer.org/works/2010-Feature-Writing.
16. ?Ray Ray’s Pledge? 2015
Common Factors Associated with
Parents Who Forgot their Children
? Stress
? Emotion
? Lack of sleep
? Change of routine
Weingarten G. Fatal Distraction. IN: Washington Post 2009.
http://www.pulitzer.org/works/2010-Feature-Writing.
21. ?Ray Ray’s Pledge? 2015
Follow the Social Media Conversation
on Child Vehicular Heatstroke!
? Common tags:
? #heatstroke, #childhotcardeath, #wheresbaby
? Upcoming social media events:
? April 22: #Run4RoRa
? in memory of Aurora Hollingsworth, Richland Hills
TX
? May 22: National Heat Awareness Day
? July (TBD): National Heatstroke
Prevention Day
Editor's Notes
Heat exhaustion: Common symptoms of heat exhaustion include headache,
weakness, dizziness, goose flesh, nausea, vomiting,
diarrhea, irritability, and loss of coordination. The skin
may appear pale or ashen, with associated tachycardia or
hypotension. Normal mentation is maintained. Patients
with heat exhaustion should remove excess clothing and
be moved to a shaded, cool environment. They should
be placed in a supine position, preferably with their legs
elevated. Oral fluids are preferred over intravenous fluids
for rehydration in those who are conscious, able to swallow,
and not losing fluids secondary to vomiting or diarrhea.
9 Vital signs should be monitored, with transport to
an emergency facility if symptoms do not improve after
20 to 30 minutes.3,6,9
Heat cramps: Heat cramps, or exercise-associated muscle cramps, can
occur in any setting, but are more common when exercising
in hot and humid environments. Dehydration,
depletion of electrolytes, and sodium losses from sweat
all accelerate in this type of environment, especially in
those who sweat profusely.18 Treatment includes rest,
prolonged stretching of affected muscle groups, and oral
sodium ingestion. Intravenous normal saline may be
used for more rapid relief, especially for severe, diffuse
cramping or when oral repletion is not possible
Thermoregulation by the body during times of heat stress is coordinated by central nervous system centers in the hypothalamus of the brain and the spinal cord; as well as peripheral centers in the skin and other organs
Conduction: degree of conduction dependent upon temperature gradient, conductive properties of the object touching the body, and what percentage of surface area is in contact
Evaporation: dependent upon sweat production (or ability to produce sweat) and vapor pressure gradient---as humidity increases, evaporation becomes progressively less effective at cooling the body
Radiation: think about reflective properties of light colored clothing or upholstry vs. heat absorbing properties with darker clothing/upholstry
Convection: convective heat exchange increases with increasing air speed and larger temperature gradient between air and skin
Bouchama A, Knochel JP. Heat stroke. N Engl J Med. 2002;346(25):
1978-1988.
Children are particularly prone to heat-related illness
because of their greater surface area to body mass
ratio compared with adults. This permits more heattransfer from the environment to the body. They also
have a diminished ability to dissipate heat because of
slower sweat rates, a higher temperature threshold for the
initiation of sweating, and production of a more diluted
sweat. Furthermore, they are slower to acclimatize to the
heat and have less of a thirst response.
REF: Bytomski JR, Squire DL. Heat illness in children. Curr Sports Med Rep.
2003;2(6):320-324.
TX data: 60% forgotten (28% of those were supposed to go to daycare that morning; in past 5 years, 63% forgotten/37% supposed to go to daycare); 12% intentional; remainder gained access; 1 case unknown
-from the graph we see that, even on a 78 degree day (ie, not that hot outside), the temperature inside a vehicle within 30 minutes of shutting off the ignition can reach 110 degrees, more than hot enough to kill a small child.
-prefrontal cortex: thinks and analyzes
-hippocampus: makes and holds onto immediate memories
-basal ganglia: nearly identical to the brains of lizards—inattentive, nonanalytical; controls voluntary but barely conscious actions; controls familiar/routine motor skills----kind of takes over as an auxiliary “autopilot”
***ie, when our prefrontal cortex and hippocampus are busily planning our day ahead on the way to work, the ignorant but efficient basal ganglia is driving the car---this explains why sometimes you drive from point a to point b without any memory of the route you took, the turns you made, or even the landmarks/ scenery you saw****
**either sudden or chronic stress can weaken the body’s more advanced components/ higher functioning centers, making them more susceptible to being overrun/ “bullied” by the more primitive “lizard brain” center
"The quality of prior parental care seems to be irrelevant,“ David Diamond, Ph.D., usf