際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Remains in the System
Recounting the Lives of Data in Mourning
Selina Ellis Gray
Lancaster University
U
%Exploring and drawing out ethico-political
dimensions behind designing for loss and
bereavement
% Thinking about commitments to design
intervention through working with material
feminist notions of care
%Address the political nature of the design
process
%Who and what is currently included within
how we currently frame sociotechnical
design in bereavement
o
Designing for Loss & Bereavement
c Capturing and analysing practices of loss with data & the material lives of data in networks
c What these practices and lives of data are saying to designing for bereavement and loss
Data, Entanglement and Remediation
Social presence and agency of the dead
The ghostly online traces
z
Steve Jones (2004) Rich history of technologies channelling the dead
Jed Brubaker & Janet Vertesi (2010) ghosts
Elaine Kasket (2012) Facebook as a Modern-Day Medium
Clive Seal (1999) Social life and presence dying before physical death
Hallam, Hockey & Howarth (1999) Troubled binaries and otherness
Tony Walter (1999) Continuing bonds and presence of the dead
Douglas Davis (2002) Sociological life after death
Hallam & Hockey (2001) Memory and material culture
Margaret Gibson (2008) Objects invoking the presence of the dead
Susan Leigh Star & Ellen Balka (2009) Shadow bodies
Making Brief Introductions
Created in Loving Memory
Data emerges post-mortem through data created by the bereaved
Data serves to invokes the social lives of the deceased
With detailed eulogies and epitaphs
Personalised and highly contextualised media
Regular updates and caretaking. Guestbook actives. Dialogue
Social networks being appropriated and data mobility
Social death
The Memory Remains
In 2014, an estimated 100,000 content moderators  twice
the headcount of Google  were thought to be at work on
monitoring and regulating online services and social
platforms (Chen, 2014).
Emerge autobiographically through day to day engagement
Accidental or sudden death
Turning to early and contemporary social networks in the
time close to death  Suicide
Public capture or sharing of material at the time of death 
Murder or violent deaths
Being Dead Smart
Constellation of Affect & Agency
A nuanced consideration of agency which
acknowledges unforeseen consequences of the day
to day engagements with networks and agency of the
computational ecology itself
The social presences and data of the deceased
recognised as an outlier or extreme  user
which needs to be taken into account within
design processes
Data and presences of the dead dont just emerge, but can live
on through data practices and long term relations
Data and presences of the dead can also be a source of distress
Thank You

More Related Content

Similar to Remains in the System: The Lives of Data in Mourning (20)

Scholarship in the Digital World
Scholarship in the Digital WorldScholarship in the Digital World
Scholarship in the Digital World
David De Roure
Let's Get Digital, Digital カ: Using Digital Humanities to Embrace Data Fuzziness
Let's Get Digital, Digital カ: Using Digital Humanities to Embrace Data FuzzinessLet's Get Digital, Digital カ: Using Digital Humanities to Embrace Data Fuzziness
Let's Get Digital, Digital カ: Using Digital Humanities to Embrace Data Fuzziness
Leah Henrickson
Open Grid Forum workshop on Social Networks, Semantic Grids and Web
Open Grid Forum workshop on Social Networks, Semantic Grids and WebOpen Grid Forum workshop on Social Networks, Semantic Grids and Web
Open Grid Forum workshop on Social Networks, Semantic Grids and Web
Noshir Contractor
Online Communities in Citizen Science
Online Communities in Citizen ScienceOnline Communities in Citizen Science
Online Communities in Citizen Science
Andrea Wiggins
Digital Trails Dave King 1 5 10 Part 1 D3
Digital Trails   Dave King   1 5 10   Part 1 D3Digital Trails   Dave King   1 5 10   Part 1 D3
Digital Trails Dave King 1 5 10 Part 1 D3
Dave King
Redes Sociales Online 多Por qu辿 compartimos?
Redes Sociales Online 多Por qu辿 compartimos?Redes Sociales Online 多Por qu辿 compartimos?
Redes Sociales Online 多Por qu辿 compartimos?
Javier Velasco, PhD
Havas Worldwide: This Digital Life
Havas Worldwide: This Digital LifeHavas Worldwide: This Digital Life
Havas Worldwide: This Digital Life
Ann O'Reilly
2010 NIH Handheld Users Meeting
2010 NIH Handheld Users Meeting2010 NIH Handheld Users Meeting
2010 NIH Handheld Users Meeting
Douglas Joubert
Digital Anthropology
Digital AnthropologyDigital Anthropology
Digital Anthropology
Fifi Stahlman
Bocconi infosfera
Bocconi infosferaBocconi infosfera
Bocconi infosfera
Luca De Biase
Introduction to Computational Social Science
Introduction to Computational Social ScienceIntroduction to Computational Social Science
Introduction to Computational Social Science
Premsankar Chakkingal
Digital Sociology: Making the Digital Central to Sociological Research
Digital Sociology: Making the Digital Central to Sociological ResearchDigital Sociology: Making the Digital Central to Sociological Research
Digital Sociology: Making the Digital Central to Sociological Research
Jessie Daniels
Developing_cyberethnographic_research_methods.pdf
Developing_cyberethnographic_research_methods.pdfDeveloping_cyberethnographic_research_methods.pdf
Developing_cyberethnographic_research_methods.pdf
correoyaya
Seeking Support in Secret
Seeking Support in SecretSeeking Support in Secret
Seeking Support in Secret
Son Vivienne
What Data Can Do: A Typology of Mechanisms . Ang竪le Christin
What Data Can Do: A Typology of Mechanisms . Ang竪le Christin What Data Can Do: A Typology of Mechanisms . Ang竪le Christin
What Data Can Do: A Typology of Mechanisms . Ang竪le Christin
eraser Juan Jos辿 Calder坦n
Online health seeking
Online health seekingOnline health seeking
Online health seeking
Pew Research Center's Internet & American Life Project
Elaine kasket
Elaine kasketElaine kasket
Elaine kasket
Irish Hospice Foundation
Perspectives on the evidence, value and impact of LIS research: conceptual ch...
Perspectives on the evidence, value and impact of LIS research: conceptual ch...Perspectives on the evidence, value and impact of LIS research: conceptual ch...
Perspectives on the evidence, value and impact of LIS research: conceptual ch...
Library and Information Science Research Coalition
MAC309 Trust in media
MAC309 Trust in mediaMAC309 Trust in media
MAC309 Trust in media
Rob Jewitt
When communication innovations lead to social exclusion
When communication innovations lead to social exclusionWhen communication innovations lead to social exclusion
When communication innovations lead to social exclusion
Petr Lupac
Scholarship in the Digital World
Scholarship in the Digital WorldScholarship in the Digital World
Scholarship in the Digital World
David De Roure
Let's Get Digital, Digital カ: Using Digital Humanities to Embrace Data Fuzziness
Let's Get Digital, Digital カ: Using Digital Humanities to Embrace Data FuzzinessLet's Get Digital, Digital カ: Using Digital Humanities to Embrace Data Fuzziness
Let's Get Digital, Digital カ: Using Digital Humanities to Embrace Data Fuzziness
Leah Henrickson
Open Grid Forum workshop on Social Networks, Semantic Grids and Web
Open Grid Forum workshop on Social Networks, Semantic Grids and WebOpen Grid Forum workshop on Social Networks, Semantic Grids and Web
Open Grid Forum workshop on Social Networks, Semantic Grids and Web
Noshir Contractor
Online Communities in Citizen Science
Online Communities in Citizen ScienceOnline Communities in Citizen Science
Online Communities in Citizen Science
Andrea Wiggins
Digital Trails Dave King 1 5 10 Part 1 D3
Digital Trails   Dave King   1 5 10   Part 1 D3Digital Trails   Dave King   1 5 10   Part 1 D3
Digital Trails Dave King 1 5 10 Part 1 D3
Dave King
Redes Sociales Online 多Por qu辿 compartimos?
Redes Sociales Online 多Por qu辿 compartimos?Redes Sociales Online 多Por qu辿 compartimos?
Redes Sociales Online 多Por qu辿 compartimos?
Javier Velasco, PhD
Havas Worldwide: This Digital Life
Havas Worldwide: This Digital LifeHavas Worldwide: This Digital Life
Havas Worldwide: This Digital Life
Ann O'Reilly
2010 NIH Handheld Users Meeting
2010 NIH Handheld Users Meeting2010 NIH Handheld Users Meeting
2010 NIH Handheld Users Meeting
Douglas Joubert
Digital Anthropology
Digital AnthropologyDigital Anthropology
Digital Anthropology
Fifi Stahlman
Bocconi infosfera
Bocconi infosferaBocconi infosfera
Bocconi infosfera
Luca De Biase
Introduction to Computational Social Science
Introduction to Computational Social ScienceIntroduction to Computational Social Science
Introduction to Computational Social Science
Premsankar Chakkingal
Digital Sociology: Making the Digital Central to Sociological Research
Digital Sociology: Making the Digital Central to Sociological ResearchDigital Sociology: Making the Digital Central to Sociological Research
Digital Sociology: Making the Digital Central to Sociological Research
Jessie Daniels
Developing_cyberethnographic_research_methods.pdf
Developing_cyberethnographic_research_methods.pdfDeveloping_cyberethnographic_research_methods.pdf
Developing_cyberethnographic_research_methods.pdf
correoyaya
Seeking Support in Secret
Seeking Support in SecretSeeking Support in Secret
Seeking Support in Secret
Son Vivienne
What Data Can Do: A Typology of Mechanisms . Ang竪le Christin
What Data Can Do: A Typology of Mechanisms . Ang竪le Christin What Data Can Do: A Typology of Mechanisms . Ang竪le Christin
What Data Can Do: A Typology of Mechanisms . Ang竪le Christin
eraser Juan Jos辿 Calder坦n
MAC309 Trust in media
MAC309 Trust in mediaMAC309 Trust in media
MAC309 Trust in media
Rob Jewitt
When communication innovations lead to social exclusion
When communication innovations lead to social exclusionWhen communication innovations lead to social exclusion
When communication innovations lead to social exclusion
Petr Lupac

Recently uploaded (20)

edit power------------oooppppppppppppppoint.pptx
edit power------------oooppppppppppppppoint.pptxedit power------------oooppppppppppppppoint.pptx
edit power------------oooppppppppppppppoint.pptx
sarikasharma627282
HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 2
HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 2HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 2
HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 2
Haraya Co by Florylyn
The CLEAR Brands CLEAR EFX Branding Guide
The CLEAR Brands CLEAR EFX Branding GuideThe CLEAR Brands CLEAR EFX Branding Guide
The CLEAR Brands CLEAR EFX Branding Guide
Adriana Yankey
TLE-GRADE 9-CLASSIFICATION OF DESSERTS AND THEIR CHARACTERISTICS.pptx
TLE-GRADE 9-CLASSIFICATION OF DESSERTS AND THEIR CHARACTERISTICS.pptxTLE-GRADE 9-CLASSIFICATION OF DESSERTS AND THEIR CHARACTERISTICS.pptx
TLE-GRADE 9-CLASSIFICATION OF DESSERTS AND THEIR CHARACTERISTICS.pptx
Jely Bermundo
Introductory f 23233224242342455Lec..pptx
Introductory f 23233224242342455Lec..pptxIntroductory f 23233224242342455Lec..pptx
Introductory f 23233224242342455Lec..pptx
khaledsameh950
Ramadhan 2 Large.pdfRamadhan 2 Large.pdf
Ramadhan 2 Large.pdfRamadhan 2 Large.pdfRamadhan 2 Large.pdfRamadhan 2 Large.pdf
Ramadhan 2 Large.pdfRamadhan 2 Large.pdf
SuryaDharma65
water_cycle.ppt vishana ppt 55555566666
water_cycle.ppt vishana ppt 55555566666water_cycle.ppt vishana ppt 55555566666
water_cycle.ppt vishana ppt 55555566666
patelvishana99
Testttt5ttttttttttttttttpower point.pptx
Testttt5ttttttttttttttttpower point.pptxTestttt5ttttttttttttttttpower point.pptx
Testttt5ttttttttttttttttpower point.pptx
sarikasharma627282
APPROPRIATETECHNOLOGIES FOR URBAN AND RURAL HOUSING
APPROPRIATETECHNOLOGIES FOR URBAN AND  RURAL HOUSINGAPPROPRIATETECHNOLOGIES FOR URBAN AND  RURAL HOUSING
APPROPRIATETECHNOLOGIES FOR URBAN AND RURAL HOUSING
JIT KUMAR GUPTA
General+System+Theory_+Foundations,+Development,+Applications.pptx
General+System+Theory_+Foundations,+Development,+Applications.pptxGeneral+System+Theory_+Foundations,+Development,+Applications.pptx
General+System+Theory_+Foundations,+Development,+Applications.pptx
rcadp2018
Wedding Planners Social Media Strategy by 際際滷sgo.pptx
Wedding Planners Social Media Strategy by 際際滷sgo.pptxWedding Planners Social Media Strategy by 際際滷sgo.pptx
Wedding Planners Social Media Strategy by 際際滷sgo.pptx
TesyaMamonto
Transform your space into a sanctuary with SPL Interiors where comfort meet...
Transform your space into a sanctuary with SPL Interiors  where comfort meet...Transform your space into a sanctuary with SPL Interiors  where comfort meet...
Transform your space into a sanctuary with SPL Interiors where comfort meet...
SPL Interiors
Ch 12 Sound 2.pptbhcycygucuhbmmmmmntydtscudbddibudbd7dbdudbudbdudvdydvs6evs7v...
Ch 12 Sound 2.pptbhcycygucuhbmmmmmntydtscudbddibudbd7dbdudbudbdudvdydvs6evs7v...Ch 12 Sound 2.pptbhcycygucuhbmmmmmntydtscudbddibudbd7dbdudbudbdudvdydvs6evs7v...
Ch 12 Sound 2.pptbhcycygucuhbmmmmmntydtscudbddibudbd7dbdudbudbdudvdydvs6evs7v...
samtheg92
Ramadhan 4 Fancy.pdfRamadhan 4 Fancy.pdf
Ramadhan 4 Fancy.pdfRamadhan 4 Fancy.pdfRamadhan 4 Fancy.pdfRamadhan 4 Fancy.pdf
Ramadhan 4 Fancy.pdfRamadhan 4 Fancy.pdf
SuryaDharma65
Women's IAccelerate Hackthon Financial Empowerment
Women's IAccelerate Hackthon Financial EmpowermentWomen's IAccelerate Hackthon Financial Empowerment
Women's IAccelerate Hackthon Financial Empowerment
indupriyapatcha
firesafetypresentatiohzuaun-181214174231.pdf
firesafetypresentatiohzuaun-181214174231.pdffiresafetypresentatiohzuaun-181214174231.pdf
firesafetypresentatiohzuaun-181214174231.pdf
ZAFIRATAHSEENHOQUE
Nitro Pro Crack Enterprise Free Download
Nitro Pro Crack Enterprise Free DownloadNitro Pro Crack Enterprise Free Download
Nitro Pro Crack Enterprise Free Download
kortez3
If I Miss This Putt I'll Kill Myself Hat
If I Miss This Putt I'll Kill Myself HatIf I Miss This Putt I'll Kill Myself Hat
If I Miss This Putt I'll Kill Myself Hat
TeeFusion
HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 01
HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 01HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 01
HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 01
Haraya Co by Florylyn
The_Canvas_of_Creative_Mastery_Newsletter_February_2025
The_Canvas_of_Creative_Mastery_Newsletter_February_2025The_Canvas_of_Creative_Mastery_Newsletter_February_2025
The_Canvas_of_Creative_Mastery_Newsletter_February_2025
AmirYakdi
edit power------------oooppppppppppppppoint.pptx
edit power------------oooppppppppppppppoint.pptxedit power------------oooppppppppppppppoint.pptx
edit power------------oooppppppppppppppoint.pptx
sarikasharma627282
HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 2
HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 2HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 2
HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 2
Haraya Co by Florylyn
The CLEAR Brands CLEAR EFX Branding Guide
The CLEAR Brands CLEAR EFX Branding GuideThe CLEAR Brands CLEAR EFX Branding Guide
The CLEAR Brands CLEAR EFX Branding Guide
Adriana Yankey
TLE-GRADE 9-CLASSIFICATION OF DESSERTS AND THEIR CHARACTERISTICS.pptx
TLE-GRADE 9-CLASSIFICATION OF DESSERTS AND THEIR CHARACTERISTICS.pptxTLE-GRADE 9-CLASSIFICATION OF DESSERTS AND THEIR CHARACTERISTICS.pptx
TLE-GRADE 9-CLASSIFICATION OF DESSERTS AND THEIR CHARACTERISTICS.pptx
Jely Bermundo
Introductory f 23233224242342455Lec..pptx
Introductory f 23233224242342455Lec..pptxIntroductory f 23233224242342455Lec..pptx
Introductory f 23233224242342455Lec..pptx
khaledsameh950
Ramadhan 2 Large.pdfRamadhan 2 Large.pdf
Ramadhan 2 Large.pdfRamadhan 2 Large.pdfRamadhan 2 Large.pdfRamadhan 2 Large.pdf
Ramadhan 2 Large.pdfRamadhan 2 Large.pdf
SuryaDharma65
water_cycle.ppt vishana ppt 55555566666
water_cycle.ppt vishana ppt 55555566666water_cycle.ppt vishana ppt 55555566666
water_cycle.ppt vishana ppt 55555566666
patelvishana99
Testttt5ttttttttttttttttpower point.pptx
Testttt5ttttttttttttttttpower point.pptxTestttt5ttttttttttttttttpower point.pptx
Testttt5ttttttttttttttttpower point.pptx
sarikasharma627282
APPROPRIATETECHNOLOGIES FOR URBAN AND RURAL HOUSING
APPROPRIATETECHNOLOGIES FOR URBAN AND  RURAL HOUSINGAPPROPRIATETECHNOLOGIES FOR URBAN AND  RURAL HOUSING
APPROPRIATETECHNOLOGIES FOR URBAN AND RURAL HOUSING
JIT KUMAR GUPTA
General+System+Theory_+Foundations,+Development,+Applications.pptx
General+System+Theory_+Foundations,+Development,+Applications.pptxGeneral+System+Theory_+Foundations,+Development,+Applications.pptx
General+System+Theory_+Foundations,+Development,+Applications.pptx
rcadp2018
Wedding Planners Social Media Strategy by 際際滷sgo.pptx
Wedding Planners Social Media Strategy by 際際滷sgo.pptxWedding Planners Social Media Strategy by 際際滷sgo.pptx
Wedding Planners Social Media Strategy by 際際滷sgo.pptx
TesyaMamonto
Transform your space into a sanctuary with SPL Interiors where comfort meet...
Transform your space into a sanctuary with SPL Interiors  where comfort meet...Transform your space into a sanctuary with SPL Interiors  where comfort meet...
Transform your space into a sanctuary with SPL Interiors where comfort meet...
SPL Interiors
Ch 12 Sound 2.pptbhcycygucuhbmmmmmntydtscudbddibudbd7dbdudbudbdudvdydvs6evs7v...
Ch 12 Sound 2.pptbhcycygucuhbmmmmmntydtscudbddibudbd7dbdudbudbdudvdydvs6evs7v...Ch 12 Sound 2.pptbhcycygucuhbmmmmmntydtscudbddibudbd7dbdudbudbdudvdydvs6evs7v...
Ch 12 Sound 2.pptbhcycygucuhbmmmmmntydtscudbddibudbd7dbdudbudbdudvdydvs6evs7v...
samtheg92
Ramadhan 4 Fancy.pdfRamadhan 4 Fancy.pdf
Ramadhan 4 Fancy.pdfRamadhan 4 Fancy.pdfRamadhan 4 Fancy.pdfRamadhan 4 Fancy.pdf
Ramadhan 4 Fancy.pdfRamadhan 4 Fancy.pdf
SuryaDharma65
Women's IAccelerate Hackthon Financial Empowerment
Women's IAccelerate Hackthon Financial EmpowermentWomen's IAccelerate Hackthon Financial Empowerment
Women's IAccelerate Hackthon Financial Empowerment
indupriyapatcha
firesafetypresentatiohzuaun-181214174231.pdf
firesafetypresentatiohzuaun-181214174231.pdffiresafetypresentatiohzuaun-181214174231.pdf
firesafetypresentatiohzuaun-181214174231.pdf
ZAFIRATAHSEENHOQUE
Nitro Pro Crack Enterprise Free Download
Nitro Pro Crack Enterprise Free DownloadNitro Pro Crack Enterprise Free Download
Nitro Pro Crack Enterprise Free Download
kortez3
If I Miss This Putt I'll Kill Myself Hat
If I Miss This Putt I'll Kill Myself HatIf I Miss This Putt I'll Kill Myself Hat
If I Miss This Putt I'll Kill Myself Hat
TeeFusion
HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 01
HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 01HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 01
HARAYA CO EVENTS MANAGEMENT by FloBach 01
Haraya Co by Florylyn
The_Canvas_of_Creative_Mastery_Newsletter_February_2025
The_Canvas_of_Creative_Mastery_Newsletter_February_2025The_Canvas_of_Creative_Mastery_Newsletter_February_2025
The_Canvas_of_Creative_Mastery_Newsletter_February_2025
AmirYakdi

Remains in the System: The Lives of Data in Mourning

  • 1. Remains in the System Recounting the Lives of Data in Mourning Selina Ellis Gray Lancaster University U
  • 2. %Exploring and drawing out ethico-political dimensions behind designing for loss and bereavement % Thinking about commitments to design intervention through working with material feminist notions of care %Address the political nature of the design process %Who and what is currently included within how we currently frame sociotechnical design in bereavement o Designing for Loss & Bereavement
  • 3. c Capturing and analysing practices of loss with data & the material lives of data in networks c What these practices and lives of data are saying to designing for bereavement and loss Data, Entanglement and Remediation
  • 4. Social presence and agency of the dead
  • 5. The ghostly online traces z Steve Jones (2004) Rich history of technologies channelling the dead Jed Brubaker & Janet Vertesi (2010) ghosts Elaine Kasket (2012) Facebook as a Modern-Day Medium Clive Seal (1999) Social life and presence dying before physical death Hallam, Hockey & Howarth (1999) Troubled binaries and otherness Tony Walter (1999) Continuing bonds and presence of the dead Douglas Davis (2002) Sociological life after death Hallam & Hockey (2001) Memory and material culture Margaret Gibson (2008) Objects invoking the presence of the dead Susan Leigh Star & Ellen Balka (2009) Shadow bodies
  • 7. Created in Loving Memory Data emerges post-mortem through data created by the bereaved Data serves to invokes the social lives of the deceased With detailed eulogies and epitaphs Personalised and highly contextualised media Regular updates and caretaking. Guestbook actives. Dialogue Social networks being appropriated and data mobility Social death
  • 8. The Memory Remains In 2014, an estimated 100,000 content moderators twice the headcount of Google were thought to be at work on monitoring and regulating online services and social platforms (Chen, 2014). Emerge autobiographically through day to day engagement Accidental or sudden death Turning to early and contemporary social networks in the time close to death Suicide Public capture or sharing of material at the time of death Murder or violent deaths
  • 10. Constellation of Affect & Agency A nuanced consideration of agency which acknowledges unforeseen consequences of the day to day engagements with networks and agency of the computational ecology itself The social presences and data of the deceased recognised as an outlier or extreme user which needs to be taken into account within design processes Data and presences of the dead dont just emerge, but can live on through data practices and long term relations Data and presences of the dead can also be a source of distress