際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
ASSESSING AND IMPROVING
              NUTRITIONAL DIVERSITY OF
                 CROPPING SYSTEMS
 Roseline Remans, Dan Flynn, Fabrice DeClerck, Willy Diru,
  Jessica Fanzo, Kaitlyn Gaynor, Isabel Lambrecht, Joseph
Mudiope, Patrick Mutuo, Phelire Nkhoma, David Siriri, Clare
                  Sullivan and Cheryl Palm




                              CIALCA
                          October 26, 2011
Agricultural Monitoring
 Crop yields, value-cost ratios, calories per person
                    HUMAN DIET: 51 ESSENTIAL NUTRIENTS
Air, water and       Protein       Lipids-Fat   Macrominerals    Trace           Vitamins
    energy       (amino acids)    (fatty acids)                elements
    Oxygen          Histidine     Linoleic acid      Na            Fe                A
     Water         Isoleucine    Linolenic acid      K             Zn                D
Carbohydrates        Leucine                         Ca            Cu                E
                      Lysine                         Mg           Mn                 K
                  Methionine                          S             I       C (Absorbic acid)
                 Phenylalanine                       P             Fe         B1 (Thiamine)
                   Threonine                         Cl            Se         B2 (Riboflavin)
                  Tryptophan                                       Si           B3 (Niacin)
                      Valine                                      Mo      B5 (Pantothenic acid)
                                                              Co (in B12)    B6 (Pyroxidine)
                                                                  B**          B7/H (Biotin)
                                                                 Ni**     B9 (Folic acid, folacin)
Maize                                      Beans                 Cr**       B12 (Cobalamin)
                                                                                Spinach
                                                                  V**
                                                                 As**
                                                                  Li**
                                                                 Sn**
Nutritional functional diversity (FD)
                         NUTRITIONAL FUNCTIONAL DIVERSITY
= Metric to assess nutritional diversity and potential of locally available genetic
resources for food based nutrition

Database currently contains 1000 food items, including many from Africa
   Species composition
                                                   Nutritional functional diversity




 Nutritional composition
MILLENNIUM VILLAGES AND AGRO-ECOLOGICAL ZONES
UNDERNUTRITION IN MILLENNIUM VILLAGE SITES
                                                AT BASELINE




EK=Ethiopia, Koraro; GB= Ghana, Bonsaaso; KD=Kenya, Dertu; KS=Kenya, Sauri; MM=Malawi, Mwandama; MT=Malit,
Tiby; RM=Rwanda, Mayange; NI=Nigeria, Ikaram; NP=Nigeria, Pampaida; TM=Tanzania, Mbola; UR=Uganda, Ruhiira
BANANA-BASED SYSTEM                  MAIZED -BASED SYSTEMS
    RUHIIRA, UGANDA            SAURI, KENYA and MWANDAMA, MALAWI




      COMMUNITY AND ON-FARM AGRO-DIVERSITY
                                        Uganda   Kenya Malawi
# edible plant species in the community:   55     49   42
Average # edible plant species/ farm:      18     15   11
Average # livestock species/ farm:          2      2    0.5


                                                            6
% of farms                                                                  % of farms




                                   50%
                                         75%
                                                                                                         25%
                                                                                                               50%
                                                                                                                     75%




                             25%

                        0%
                                                                                                    0%




                                                             100%
                                                                                                                           100%
              Onion                                                                     Jackfruit

          Tangerine                                                                   Pigeon pea
                                                                                  Pepper (green)
        Macadamia
                                                                                         Orange
      Pomegranate
                                                                                         Carrots
         Black plum                                                                        Achak
             Fig tree                                                                 Mushroom
        Irish potato                                                   Green grams/moong beans

            Cowpea                                                                  Watermelon
                                                                                          Coffee
        Passionfruit
                                                                                        Moringa
                Peas
                                                                               Cape gooseberries
             Orange                                                                       Onyulo
       Finger millet                                                          Mulberry (Onunga)
          Sugarcane                                                                    Rosemary

    Eggplant (black)                                                                    Eggplant
                                                                                        Cabbage
      Custard apple
                                                                                     Passionfruit
            Jackfruit
                                                                                          Lemon
           Cabbage                                                                   Irish potato
              Turnip                                                Java plum (mzambarau, jamna)
              Apple                                                                     Soybean

           Sorghum                                                                      Sorghum
                                                                                       Pineapple
 Okra (local variaty)
                                                                                           Mitoo
          Black jack
                                                                                                                                  Sauri - Kenya




                                                                             Groundnut (peanut)
             Lemon                                                                   Chili pepper
Mulberry (Onunga)                                                                      Musabibu
                                         Mwandama - Malawi



           Cocoyam                                                                         Onion

        Chili pepper                                                                     Tomato
                                                                                     Spiderweed
              Lablab
                                                                                      Sugarcane
            Tomato
                                                                                          Mango
    Sweet potatoes                                                                        Guava
          Amaranth                                                                      Pumpkin
              Peach                                                                     Cocoyam

           Avocado                                                                         Apoth
                                                                                         Cassava
Groundnut (peanut)
                                                                                Black nightshade
             Papaya
                                                                                          Papaya
              Guava                                                               Sweet potatoes
           Pumpkin                                                                       Cowpea
               Bean                                                                     Avocado

             Mango                                                             Kale (sukuma wiki)
                                                                                            Bean
             Banana
                                                                                                                                                  MAIZE-BASED SYSTEMS IN SAURI, KENYA AND MWANDAMA, MALAWI




                                                                                       Amaranth
         Pigeon pea
 7




                                                                                       Black jack
            Cassava                                                                        Maize
              Maize                                                                      Banana
Nutritional Functional Diversity versus Species Diversity
Nutritional Functional Diversity


                                       Mulberry
                                       Groundnut
                                       Pumpkin

                                                                            IN COMMON
                                                                            Maize
                                                                            Banana
                                                                            Cassava
                                                                            Papaya
                                                                            Pigeon Pea
                                                                            Mango



                                               Sweet potatoes
                                               Irish potatoes
                                               Avocados
                                                         Species richness
NUTRITIONAL FD versus SPECIES RICHNESS
Nutrient Gap Analysis of Supply
% of DRI per person per day locally produced
            Mwandama, Malawi
ANALYSIS AT VILLAGE and LANDSCAPE

Nutritional FD




                                                     11
Unhealthy Soils, Unhealthy People
           Yields, Soil Health, Human Health, Economic Growth



                    Loss of nutrients, soil erosion, biodiversity

    Agriculture                                                Environmental
without proper management
                                                                degradation



        Declining                                                      Declining
    labor productivity                                       crop productivity and diversity

                             Malnutrition, illness
                                   (state of well-being)


                                                                    Deckelbaum et al., 2006
RELATIONSHIP WITH FOOD AND NUTRITION INDICATORS



                       *




                                                  *




* P<0.01
How to manage biodiversity for nutrition?
  Two main strategies


   STRATEGY 1: To restore or maintain high levels of local diversity



                                                                              Value-
Small-scale          Improved            Knowledge           Extension
                                                                              adding
 Irrigation         seed storage           sharing              and
                                                                               and
   & ISFM             facilities          platform           education
                                                                             Business


    STRATEGY 2: To facilitate the adaptation of new varieties and crops with new
      and different characteristics that benefit the population and fit changing
                                      conditions



                                                                                   14
Adoption of Agricultural Diversification Activities


                      % of farmers diversifying
                    Example Mwandama, Malawi
Analysis of Food Frequency Surveys:
Baseline and Following Introduction of Nutritious Crops
                      Food consumption patterns
                     Example Mwandama, Malawi
GLOBAL HUNGER INDEX, IFPRI 2010




GLOBAL CROP NITROGEN STRESS,




 Liu et al, PNAS

More Related Content

Remans - Assessing and improving nutritional diversity of cropping systems

  • 1. ASSESSING AND IMPROVING NUTRITIONAL DIVERSITY OF CROPPING SYSTEMS Roseline Remans, Dan Flynn, Fabrice DeClerck, Willy Diru, Jessica Fanzo, Kaitlyn Gaynor, Isabel Lambrecht, Joseph Mudiope, Patrick Mutuo, Phelire Nkhoma, David Siriri, Clare Sullivan and Cheryl Palm CIALCA October 26, 2011
  • 2. Agricultural Monitoring Crop yields, value-cost ratios, calories per person HUMAN DIET: 51 ESSENTIAL NUTRIENTS Air, water and Protein Lipids-Fat Macrominerals Trace Vitamins energy (amino acids) (fatty acids) elements Oxygen Histidine Linoleic acid Na Fe A Water Isoleucine Linolenic acid K Zn D Carbohydrates Leucine Ca Cu E Lysine Mg Mn K Methionine S I C (Absorbic acid) Phenylalanine P Fe B1 (Thiamine) Threonine Cl Se B2 (Riboflavin) Tryptophan Si B3 (Niacin) Valine Mo B5 (Pantothenic acid) Co (in B12) B6 (Pyroxidine) B** B7/H (Biotin) Ni** B9 (Folic acid, folacin) Maize Beans Cr** B12 (Cobalamin) Spinach V** As** Li** Sn**
  • 3. Nutritional functional diversity (FD) NUTRITIONAL FUNCTIONAL DIVERSITY = Metric to assess nutritional diversity and potential of locally available genetic resources for food based nutrition Database currently contains 1000 food items, including many from Africa Species composition Nutritional functional diversity Nutritional composition
  • 4. MILLENNIUM VILLAGES AND AGRO-ECOLOGICAL ZONES
  • 5. UNDERNUTRITION IN MILLENNIUM VILLAGE SITES AT BASELINE EK=Ethiopia, Koraro; GB= Ghana, Bonsaaso; KD=Kenya, Dertu; KS=Kenya, Sauri; MM=Malawi, Mwandama; MT=Malit, Tiby; RM=Rwanda, Mayange; NI=Nigeria, Ikaram; NP=Nigeria, Pampaida; TM=Tanzania, Mbola; UR=Uganda, Ruhiira
  • 6. BANANA-BASED SYSTEM MAIZED -BASED SYSTEMS RUHIIRA, UGANDA SAURI, KENYA and MWANDAMA, MALAWI COMMUNITY AND ON-FARM AGRO-DIVERSITY Uganda Kenya Malawi # edible plant species in the community: 55 49 42 Average # edible plant species/ farm: 18 15 11 Average # livestock species/ farm: 2 2 0.5 6
  • 7. % of farms % of farms 50% 75% 25% 50% 75% 25% 0% 0% 100% 100% Onion Jackfruit Tangerine Pigeon pea Pepper (green) Macadamia Orange Pomegranate Carrots Black plum Achak Fig tree Mushroom Irish potato Green grams/moong beans Cowpea Watermelon Coffee Passionfruit Moringa Peas Cape gooseberries Orange Onyulo Finger millet Mulberry (Onunga) Sugarcane Rosemary Eggplant (black) Eggplant Cabbage Custard apple Passionfruit Jackfruit Lemon Cabbage Irish potato Turnip Java plum (mzambarau, jamna) Apple Soybean Sorghum Sorghum Pineapple Okra (local variaty) Mitoo Black jack Sauri - Kenya Groundnut (peanut) Lemon Chili pepper Mulberry (Onunga) Musabibu Mwandama - Malawi Cocoyam Onion Chili pepper Tomato Spiderweed Lablab Sugarcane Tomato Mango Sweet potatoes Guava Amaranth Pumpkin Peach Cocoyam Avocado Apoth Cassava Groundnut (peanut) Black nightshade Papaya Papaya Guava Sweet potatoes Pumpkin Cowpea Bean Avocado Mango Kale (sukuma wiki) Bean Banana MAIZE-BASED SYSTEMS IN SAURI, KENYA AND MWANDAMA, MALAWI Amaranth Pigeon pea 7 Black jack Cassava Maize Maize Banana
  • 8. Nutritional Functional Diversity versus Species Diversity Nutritional Functional Diversity Mulberry Groundnut Pumpkin IN COMMON Maize Banana Cassava Papaya Pigeon Pea Mango Sweet potatoes Irish potatoes Avocados Species richness
  • 9. NUTRITIONAL FD versus SPECIES RICHNESS
  • 10. Nutrient Gap Analysis of Supply % of DRI per person per day locally produced Mwandama, Malawi
  • 11. ANALYSIS AT VILLAGE and LANDSCAPE Nutritional FD 11
  • 12. Unhealthy Soils, Unhealthy People Yields, Soil Health, Human Health, Economic Growth Loss of nutrients, soil erosion, biodiversity Agriculture Environmental without proper management degradation Declining Declining labor productivity crop productivity and diversity Malnutrition, illness (state of well-being) Deckelbaum et al., 2006
  • 13. RELATIONSHIP WITH FOOD AND NUTRITION INDICATORS * * * P<0.01
  • 14. How to manage biodiversity for nutrition? Two main strategies STRATEGY 1: To restore or maintain high levels of local diversity Value- Small-scale Improved Knowledge Extension adding Irrigation seed storage sharing and and & ISFM facilities platform education Business STRATEGY 2: To facilitate the adaptation of new varieties and crops with new and different characteristics that benefit the population and fit changing conditions 14
  • 15. Adoption of Agricultural Diversification Activities % of farmers diversifying Example Mwandama, Malawi
  • 16. Analysis of Food Frequency Surveys: Baseline and Following Introduction of Nutritious Crops Food consumption patterns Example Mwandama, Malawi
  • 17. GLOBAL HUNGER INDEX, IFPRI 2010 GLOBAL CROP NITROGEN STRESS, Liu et al, PNAS