際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
Debate: Arguing against Do human infants have
 an ability to discriminate number and to add and subtract simple numbers?


Many researchers have claimed that young infants have knowledge of number. This
conclusion has arisen from tasks such as infants showing dishabituation to events
occurring at different numbers of times to habituated events, for example showing
three compared to two dots. This conclusion is rather surprising, as tests of infants
numeracy skills show very poor understanding. For example, Cooper (1984)
demonstrated that children under 14 to 16 months cannot make even simple less-than-
or-more-than judgements. It is to be expected, then, that the methods that have lead to
these conclusions have received much criticism of their reliability. It has been proven
that infants are probably dishabituating to non-numerical elements of the stimuli
presented to them, such as the amount of black on the page, or area taken up by the
display. For example, Clearfield and Mix (2001) habituated infants to a set of dots,
before showing the same amount of dots taking up a larger area, or more dots
covering the original area size. The infants looked longer at the first condition than
the second.

For more, visit www.scholify.com

More Related Content

Similar to Scholify essay developmental, maths debate (16)

SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared ResourceSociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
sociologyexchange.co.uk
The process skills of inquiry
The process skills of inquiryThe process skills of inquiry
The process skills of inquiry
Veira Rodr狸guez
Kindergarten NK.5 lesson fishing one more one less
Kindergarten NK.5 lesson fishing one more one lessKindergarten NK.5 lesson fishing one more one less
Kindergarten NK.5 lesson fishing one more one less
susan70
Research Study Complete
Research Study CompleteResearch Study Complete
Research Study Complete
Emma Cox
V.R.I.O. Analysis
V.R.I.O. AnalysisV.R.I.O. Analysis
V.R.I.O. Analysis
Monique Jones
PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docx
PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docxPRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docx
PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docx
stilliegeorgiana
PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docx
PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docxPRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docx
PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docx
keilenettie
Counting activity
Counting activityCounting activity
Counting activity
6023835
PME-NA2011 Integers History Childrens Approaches.pdf
PME-NA2011 Integers History Childrens Approaches.pdfPME-NA2011 Integers History Childrens Approaches.pdf
PME-NA2011 Integers History Childrens Approaches.pdf
PrestonTobias
Debunking misconceptions about mathematics in the early years
Debunking misconceptions about mathematics in the early yearsDebunking misconceptions about mathematics in the early years
Debunking misconceptions about mathematics in the early years
The Australian Association of Mathematics Teachers (AAMT) Inc.
Math activities
Math activitiesMath activities
Math activities
TeresaEdwards
Math activities
Math activitiesMath activities
Math activities
TeresaEdwards
Early Numeracy
Early NumeracyEarly Numeracy
Early Numeracy
Rachel Aird
MATALLIOTAKI, E., (2012). Resolution of Division Problems by Young Children:...
MATALLIOTAKI, E., (2012).  Resolution of Division Problems by Young Children:...MATALLIOTAKI, E., (2012).  Resolution of Division Problems by Young Children:...
MATALLIOTAKI, E., (2012). Resolution of Division Problems by Young Children:...
eirinimatalliotaki
STRATEGIES-TO-PROCESS-INFORMATION-ON-A-TEXT-Copy.pptx
STRATEGIES-TO-PROCESS-INFORMATION-ON-A-TEXT-Copy.pptxSTRATEGIES-TO-PROCESS-INFORMATION-ON-A-TEXT-Copy.pptx
STRATEGIES-TO-PROCESS-INFORMATION-ON-A-TEXT-Copy.pptx
TrishaJerafusco
Iep
IepIep
Iep
Beberly Banquito
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared ResourceSociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
SociologyExchange.co.uk Shared Resource
sociologyexchange.co.uk
The process skills of inquiry
The process skills of inquiryThe process skills of inquiry
The process skills of inquiry
Veira Rodr狸guez
Kindergarten NK.5 lesson fishing one more one less
Kindergarten NK.5 lesson fishing one more one lessKindergarten NK.5 lesson fishing one more one less
Kindergarten NK.5 lesson fishing one more one less
susan70
Research Study Complete
Research Study CompleteResearch Study Complete
Research Study Complete
Emma Cox
V.R.I.O. Analysis
V.R.I.O. AnalysisV.R.I.O. Analysis
V.R.I.O. Analysis
Monique Jones
PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docx
PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docxPRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docx
PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docx
stilliegeorgiana
PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docx
PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docxPRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docx
PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OFChild and AdolescentForensic lvi.docx
keilenettie
Counting activity
Counting activityCounting activity
Counting activity
6023835
PME-NA2011 Integers History Childrens Approaches.pdf
PME-NA2011 Integers History Childrens Approaches.pdfPME-NA2011 Integers History Childrens Approaches.pdf
PME-NA2011 Integers History Childrens Approaches.pdf
PrestonTobias
Early Numeracy
Early NumeracyEarly Numeracy
Early Numeracy
Rachel Aird
MATALLIOTAKI, E., (2012). Resolution of Division Problems by Young Children:...
MATALLIOTAKI, E., (2012).  Resolution of Division Problems by Young Children:...MATALLIOTAKI, E., (2012).  Resolution of Division Problems by Young Children:...
MATALLIOTAKI, E., (2012). Resolution of Division Problems by Young Children:...
eirinimatalliotaki
STRATEGIES-TO-PROCESS-INFORMATION-ON-A-TEXT-Copy.pptx
STRATEGIES-TO-PROCESS-INFORMATION-ON-A-TEXT-Copy.pptxSTRATEGIES-TO-PROCESS-INFORMATION-ON-A-TEXT-Copy.pptx
STRATEGIES-TO-PROCESS-INFORMATION-ON-A-TEXT-Copy.pptx
TrishaJerafusco

More from jamiemack89 (6)

Scholify essay developmental, maths debate
Scholify essay developmental, maths debateScholify essay developmental, maths debate
Scholify essay developmental, maths debate
jamiemack89
Scholify essay specialised mechanisms for working memory
Scholify essay specialised mechanisms for working memoryScholify essay specialised mechanisms for working memory
Scholify essay specialised mechanisms for working memory
jamiemack89
Scholify essay do diverse executive functions
Scholify essay do diverse executive functionsScholify essay do diverse executive functions
Scholify essay do diverse executive functions
jamiemack89
Scholify essay dev selective attention
Scholify essay dev selective attentionScholify essay dev selective attention
Scholify essay dev selective attention
jamiemack89
Scholify essay developmental essay 1
Scholify essay developmental essay 1Scholify essay developmental essay 1
Scholify essay developmental essay 1
jamiemack89
Essay from scholify developmental ef
Essay from scholify developmental   efEssay from scholify developmental   ef
Essay from scholify developmental ef
jamiemack89
Scholify essay developmental, maths debate
Scholify essay developmental, maths debateScholify essay developmental, maths debate
Scholify essay developmental, maths debate
jamiemack89
Scholify essay specialised mechanisms for working memory
Scholify essay specialised mechanisms for working memoryScholify essay specialised mechanisms for working memory
Scholify essay specialised mechanisms for working memory
jamiemack89
Scholify essay do diverse executive functions
Scholify essay do diverse executive functionsScholify essay do diverse executive functions
Scholify essay do diverse executive functions
jamiemack89
Scholify essay dev selective attention
Scholify essay dev selective attentionScholify essay dev selective attention
Scholify essay dev selective attention
jamiemack89
Scholify essay developmental essay 1
Scholify essay developmental essay 1Scholify essay developmental essay 1
Scholify essay developmental essay 1
jamiemack89
Essay from scholify developmental ef
Essay from scholify developmental   efEssay from scholify developmental   ef
Essay from scholify developmental ef
jamiemack89

Scholify essay developmental, maths debate

  • 1. Debate: Arguing against Do human infants have an ability to discriminate number and to add and subtract simple numbers? Many researchers have claimed that young infants have knowledge of number. This conclusion has arisen from tasks such as infants showing dishabituation to events occurring at different numbers of times to habituated events, for example showing three compared to two dots. This conclusion is rather surprising, as tests of infants numeracy skills show very poor understanding. For example, Cooper (1984) demonstrated that children under 14 to 16 months cannot make even simple less-than- or-more-than judgements. It is to be expected, then, that the methods that have lead to these conclusions have received much criticism of their reliability. It has been proven that infants are probably dishabituating to non-numerical elements of the stimuli presented to them, such as the amount of black on the page, or area taken up by the display. For example, Clearfield and Mix (2001) habituated infants to a set of dots, before showing the same amount of dots taking up a larger area, or more dots covering the original area size. The infants looked longer at the first condition than the second. For more, visit www.scholify.com