The document summarizes a presentation on assessing the impact of smart home technologies on the UK's 2050 net-zero carbon emission target. It discusses that homes currently account for 14% of UK energy consumption. The objectives are to investigate how smart homes can reduce emissions and examine the government's role in adoption. Findings include that over 50% of homeowners found integration easy, but security and reliability were key challenges. Perceptions were that smart grids better support emissions targets than smart homes alone. Proposed guidelines include incentivizing adoption, standardizing technologies, and encouraging smart meters and energy suppliers.
1. #STEAMConf2023
A Qualitative Assessment of The Impact of Smart
Home and Environmentally Beneficial Technologies
on the UK 2050 Net-Zero Carbon Emission Target
Dr. Ghasson Shabha
Senior Lecturer, FCIBSE, MBIFM, PG Cert Ed., FHEA, IOSH
College of the Built Environment - Faculty of Computing,
Engineering and the Built Environment, BCU
Email: ghasson.shabha@bcu.ac.uk
@BCUCEBE
+44(0)121 3315425
Paul Laycock
Interim Deputy Head of College of Built Environment CIAT,
MCIOB, FHEA, PGCE, PGCED, MSc, Chartered Architectural
Technologist, Chartered Builder
Email: paul.laycock@bcu.ac.uk
@BCUCEBE
+44(0) 1213317509
2. Introduction (Facts & Figures)
29 million homes in the UK, accounting for 14% of the UKs energy consumption.
The UK has one of the highest water and energy demands in Europe which needs to
be addressed according to the Committee on Climate Change (CCC).
Fossil fuel depletion and energy demand necessitate the adoption of
renewable, low-carbon energy sources.
Existing homes emit 5 tonnes of carbon annually.
UK population currently stands at 67 million, and with an estimated 5 million more in the
next 20 years (ONS, 2023)
Rate of Urbanisation: 3% increase in the UK from 2007 to 2018 proved to be damaging to
the environment, often driven by practical imperatives of providing easily buildable housing.
Greater reliance on materials that are not most environmentally suited and the least
sustainable? (Gov, 2019; Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy, 2019a, b).
#STEAMConf2023
4. What is Smart Home Technology?
Automated dwelling with a network connecting appliances to
control water, heat, and energy in the entire house which
enables remote control and monitoring.
"smartness is facilitated through the Internet of Things (IoT).
#STEAMConf2023
6. Introduction (Facts & Figures)
Smart home technology holds a current misconception that it is principally used
by tech-savvy users with larger budgets.
Smart home technology can be used.
#STEAMConf2023
Mail Tech - One stop shop for Smart tech with some sustainable twists
MailTech
(1) Smart homes of the future are connecting more than 150 devices -
YouTube
7. #STEAMConf2023
Fab work Matthew well structured and well signposted. Clear
and well-presented sketches. The content will benefit from
further critical input and beefing up.
Can you amalgamate all weekly sections in one document
References should be collated at the end of the portfolio and
should avoid fragmentation cut and paste and put them at
the end of the portfolio.
Keep up the good work.
8. Key Benefits
Optimise energy efficiency and reduce costs.
Enhanced comfort management.
Improved security and safety.
Reduce Carbon Emissions if used in tandem with Smart Meters
and/or Smart Power Grids and energy management based on
Demand-side Management (DSM) shifts peak usage.
9. Key Barriers
Lack of awareness.
Integration challenges in existing homes.
Limited homeowners IT skills.
Installation costs and affordability.
Privacy and security concerns.
Perception of smart energy grids vs. smart home technology.
#STEAMConf2023
10. Key Research Questions?
How can smart home technology could be effectively utilised to
aid the UK government in meeting climate change targets and
mitigate the environmental impact of a home in use towards
reducing carbon emissions 2050 Target?
#STEAMConf2023
11. Objectives
1. To investigate the effectiveness of smart home technology in reducing
greenhouse gas emissions in UK households.
2. To examine government legislation's role in
leveraging these technologies.
3. To identify key impediments to smart home technology adoption
and propose solutions.
#STEAMConf2023
12. Qualitative Approach: Focuses on opinions, experiences, and
perspectives.
Interpretivism: Develops theories based on collected data.
Semi-Structured Interviews: Open-ended questions for detailed
qualitative data.
Target Participants: Knowledgeable individuals and key users of smart
home tech.
Sampling: Opportunity sampling for a diverse range of views.
Questionnaire: Addresses key themes: ease of use, challenges,
perception, changes needed, and energy consumption.
#STEAMConf2023
13. Pilot Study: Refinement of questions for clarity.
Participants: Homeowners, energy suppliers, smart homes
professionals.
Ethical Considerations: Confidentiality, anonymity, and data
protection.
Response Rate: 23% due to COVID-19 lockdown.
Data Collection: Email and virtual conversational interviews.
Engagement: Limited interest from larger companies and local
councils due to COVID-19.
16. Findings
#STEAMConf2023
Ease of Integration:
Over 50% of homeowners found integrating smart home technology to
be simple and straightforward.
This variability is attributed to homeowners' levels of technical skills and
prior experience.
Approximately 80% of smart sensor installers indicated ease of use.
One fifth of home-owners returned smart home technology due to
unresolved issues, with some needing an eight-step process to rectify
problems.
The majority indicated that government incentives are necessary to make
smart home technology more affordable and accessible.
17. Findings
#STEAMConf2023
Key Challenges:
Security concerns were a major challenge, with 40% of participants
highlighting this as their main worry.
Safety concerns on how effectively protecting their smart homes from
hackers.
Vulnerability of wireless to hackers was a recurring issue, due to
interconnected nature of smart home devices.
Maintaining a reliable Internet connection was identified as a challenge.
The cost of a stable Internet connection was perceived as a barrier,
especially when combined with the cost of installing a smart home
technology.
18. Findings
#STEAMConf2023
Perception of UK Government 2050 Net-Zero Target:
Only around 21% of homeowners believed that updated thinking
among homeowners was required to help the government to promote
adoption and reduce carbon emissions to achieve its 2050 net-zero
goal.
Government incentives and energy-saving goals were proposed as
effective strategies.
The importance of smart meters for reducing energy consumption is
highlighted by smart home installers.
Logistical complexities and technical challenges associated with the
integration of smart home technology
19. Findings
#STEAMConf2023
Perception of Smart Grid vs. Smart Home:
All participants agreed that smart grids would be beneficial in
reducing the carbon footprint of UK homes.
Smart home technology was seen as more expensive and daunting,
particularly for elderly users who may not be familiar with
technology. The decline in cognitive abilities due to aging can hinder
the effective use and implementation of smart devices.
The long-term integration of smart devices in existing residential
care homes remains uncertain.
20. Proposed Guidelines
#STEAMConf2023
1. Widespread adoption of efficient smart grid technology.
2. Affordability via government-led strategy with financial
incentives
and subsidies to home-owners.
3. Standardisation for compatibility, interoperability, and
robust
broadband & Wi-Fi.
4. Education and incentives to address security concerns.
5. Installation of smart meters with compatibility measures.
6. Encourage energy suppliers to offer free smart meters.
7. Ongoing research for additional interventions for
21. Thank you for listening
Any Questions?
#STEAMConf2023