際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
The Looming Fiscal Crisis at the Stoughton Area School District a paper by Sam Wayne
About SASD District has approximately 3,650 students Enrollment is declining at about 1% annually Per Pupil spending is very low 87% of state average Less than 90% of districts statewide High School recently failed to meet Adequate Yearly Progress standards for No Child Left Behind Legislation Performance of Disabled subgroup was not adequate
Revenue Limits In 1993, the State Legislature passed Statute 121.90 limiting the rate at which per pupil spending can increase Passed in response to statewide call for property tax relief $241.01 per pupil increase allowed next year Districts can override spending limits by passing a referendum
Effects of Revenue Limits on SASD Salaries and Benefits account for 76% of SASDs 2003-4 budget These costs rise annually at average of 5%
Possible Expenditure Reductions Republican Majority in Assembly and Senate wish to pass a Property Tax Freeze or Taxpayers Bill of Rights (TABOR) Amendment in next session In 2003, Property Tax Freeze failed to override Gov. Doyles veto by 1 vote in Senate TABOR was on the agenda this year, but did not garner enough support to come to a vote
General Provisions of Tax Freeze Districts may increase their property tax levy by $100 per pupil each year SASD projects that all increases in expenditures will be funded by property taxes Likely result- replace $241.01 per pupil increase with $100 per pupil increase If state further cuts equalization aid, the district will still be allowed only $100 per pupil increase in property tax levy
Effects of Tax Freeze on SASD Assuming state aid remains constant Tax Freeze cuts allowable growth from 2.6% to 1%
Effects of TABOR on Schools School districts may increase their per pupil spending by the previous years CPI index (inflation) Average inflation 1986-2002 is 2.94% Current revenue caps allow per pupil spending to increase by 2.6% If TABOR were enacted in 1986, it would have lowered SASD spending in 9 of 18 years between 1986 and 2002
SASDs Budget Cut Options Increase class size District policy to average 20 students per class Most classrooms in district can seat 25 students Will cut at most 20% of teachers Save $3.475 million annually if all cut immediately Eliminate non-essentials Art, Music, Phys-ed, Talented and Gifted program, advanced classes, junior varsity, and varsity sports Will cut at most 10% of expenses Neither of these, even when combined, will cut enough expenses to avoid eventual need for annual referenda
Need for Ongoing Referenda In order to provide district services at or near current levels, spending referenda will have to pass annually once General Fund is depleted To operate at bare-bones capacity, referenda will have to pass annually starting in 2015 Superintendent Dr. Myron Palomba says that annual referenda will be necessary to keep the district from shutting down
History of Referenda for SASD The district has passed all four spending referenda it has floated since 1994 1994:  $28 million 1998:  $320,000 2001:  $2.5 million 2003:  $4.5 million Past referenda were all for capital improvements District residents were not subject to bumper-sticker campaigns
Legitimizing an Ongoing Referenda To avoid a negative fund balance, the district plans on floating a referendum this year This is a good way to test public sentiment towards exceeding revenue limits, and allows for a failure before a negative fund balance In order to credibly float referenda annually, the district will have to make a few service cuts Immediately laying off 4-5 teachers may be necessary In addition, there may have to be a hiring freeze for the next few years as the public gets acclimated to voting on the district budget
Structuring an Ongoing Referenda After proposing referendum this year, use General Fund monies until they expire in 2006-2007 Each year referendum should cover all operating costs above imposed restrictions Postponing payment by lowering the amount sought only increases funds necessary in the future The public should be aware that a referendum will have to pass every year to prevent severe service cuts
Other Recommendations Lobby incoming State Senator Mark Miller and incoming Assemblyman Gary Hebl against a Property Tax Freeze, a TABOR amendment, and the current Revenue Limits This will not be very effective, because: Both men are already against these issues  Both men are generally powerless, as they are new members in the minority party Join with other school districts affected by Revenue Limits to create a lobbying force separate from WEAC

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

AACC Federal Legislative Update Webinar, Sept. 21, 2011
AACC Federal Legislative Update Webinar, Sept. 21, 2011AACC Federal Legislative Update Webinar, Sept. 21, 2011
AACC Federal Legislative Update Webinar, Sept. 21, 2011
American Association of Community Colleges
Indiana Senate Budget proposal 2022 2023
Indiana Senate Budget proposal 2022 2023Indiana Senate Budget proposal 2022 2023
Indiana Senate Budget proposal 2022 2023
Abdul-Hakim Shabazz
The affects of government budgets on inequalities
The affects of government budgets on inequalitiesThe affects of government budgets on inequalities
The affects of government budgets on inequalities
CCPANS
2013 2014 tax planning for individuals
2013 2014 tax planning for individuals2013 2014 tax planning for individuals
2013 2014 tax planning for individuals
Nexus Financial
Put FL state corporate tax dollars to work for students!
Put FL state corporate tax dollars to work for students!Put FL state corporate tax dollars to work for students!
Put FL state corporate tax dollars to work for students!
Kim Grant
Aisd budget overview for fy2012
Aisd budget overview for fy2012Aisd budget overview for fy2012
Aisd budget overview for fy2012
austinreps
2017 Federal Budget Insights
2017 Federal Budget Insights2017 Federal Budget Insights
2017 Federal Budget Insights
Bentleys (WA) Pty Ltd
Uleac non contributory pension for the elderly in lebanon part 3
Uleac non contributory pension for the elderly in lebanon part 3Uleac non contributory pension for the elderly in lebanon part 3
Uleac non contributory pension for the elderly in lebanon part 3
Lebanese Economic Association
Is Mandatory Pensions Savings the Answer?
Is Mandatory Pensions Savings the Answer?Is Mandatory Pensions Savings the Answer?
Is Mandatory Pensions Savings the Answer?
victoriamutual
The Cost of the Trump and Biden Campaign Plans
The Cost of the Trump and Biden Campaign PlansThe Cost of the Trump and Biden Campaign Plans
The Cost of the Trump and Biden Campaign Plans
Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget
Development finance impact project digital artifact
Development finance impact project  digital artifactDevelopment finance impact project  digital artifact
Development finance impact project digital artifact
Edeje Michael-Ekam
State Budget Cuts
State Budget CutsState Budget Cuts
State Budget Cuts
kjhatzi
US Fiscal Cliff Deal 2012 PPT
US Fiscal Cliff Deal 2012 PPTUS Fiscal Cliff Deal 2012 PPT
US Fiscal Cliff Deal 2012 PPT
Naman Rastogi
Ch. 5 - Taxing & Spending
Ch. 5 - Taxing & SpendingCh. 5 - Taxing & Spending
Ch. 5 - Taxing & Spending
Melissa
What's in the Latest COVID Relief Act?
What's in the Latest COVID Relief Act?What's in the Latest COVID Relief Act?
What's in the Latest COVID Relief Act?
Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget
Frank Ellis - Evolving social protection in Africa
Frank Ellis - Evolving social protection in AfricaFrank Ellis - Evolving social protection in Africa
Frank Ellis - Evolving social protection in Africa
Institute of Development Studies
Implications of public pension enhancement in Canada
Implications of public pension enhancement in CanadaImplications of public pension enhancement in Canada
Implications of public pension enhancement in Canada
Alex Mazer
The Spending Review and social care - Andrew Cozens
The Spending Review and social care - Andrew CozensThe Spending Review and social care - Andrew Cozens
The Spending Review and social care - Andrew Cozens
The King's Fund
Child Poverty A National Perspective
Child Poverty  A National PerspectiveChild Poverty  A National Perspective
Child Poverty A National Perspective
Voluntary Action LeicesterShire
Budgeting for the Next Generation: Children and the Federal Budget
Budgeting for the Next Generation: Children and the Federal BudgetBudgeting for the Next Generation: Children and the Federal Budget
Budgeting for the Next Generation: Children and the Federal Budget
Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget
Indiana Senate Budget proposal 2022 2023
Indiana Senate Budget proposal 2022 2023Indiana Senate Budget proposal 2022 2023
Indiana Senate Budget proposal 2022 2023
Abdul-Hakim Shabazz
The affects of government budgets on inequalities
The affects of government budgets on inequalitiesThe affects of government budgets on inequalities
The affects of government budgets on inequalities
CCPANS
2013 2014 tax planning for individuals
2013 2014 tax planning for individuals2013 2014 tax planning for individuals
2013 2014 tax planning for individuals
Nexus Financial
Put FL state corporate tax dollars to work for students!
Put FL state corporate tax dollars to work for students!Put FL state corporate tax dollars to work for students!
Put FL state corporate tax dollars to work for students!
Kim Grant
Aisd budget overview for fy2012
Aisd budget overview for fy2012Aisd budget overview for fy2012
Aisd budget overview for fy2012
austinreps
Uleac non contributory pension for the elderly in lebanon part 3
Uleac non contributory pension for the elderly in lebanon part 3Uleac non contributory pension for the elderly in lebanon part 3
Uleac non contributory pension for the elderly in lebanon part 3
Lebanese Economic Association
Is Mandatory Pensions Savings the Answer?
Is Mandatory Pensions Savings the Answer?Is Mandatory Pensions Savings the Answer?
Is Mandatory Pensions Savings the Answer?
victoriamutual
Development finance impact project digital artifact
Development finance impact project  digital artifactDevelopment finance impact project  digital artifact
Development finance impact project digital artifact
Edeje Michael-Ekam
State Budget Cuts
State Budget CutsState Budget Cuts
State Budget Cuts
kjhatzi
US Fiscal Cliff Deal 2012 PPT
US Fiscal Cliff Deal 2012 PPTUS Fiscal Cliff Deal 2012 PPT
US Fiscal Cliff Deal 2012 PPT
Naman Rastogi
Ch. 5 - Taxing & Spending
Ch. 5 - Taxing & SpendingCh. 5 - Taxing & Spending
Ch. 5 - Taxing & Spending
Melissa
Implications of public pension enhancement in Canada
Implications of public pension enhancement in CanadaImplications of public pension enhancement in Canada
Implications of public pension enhancement in Canada
Alex Mazer
The Spending Review and social care - Andrew Cozens
The Spending Review and social care - Andrew CozensThe Spending Review and social care - Andrew Cozens
The Spending Review and social care - Andrew Cozens
The King's Fund

Viewers also liked (7)

Averting a Fiscal Crisis
Averting a Fiscal CrisisAverting a Fiscal Crisis
Averting a Fiscal Crisis
CRFB.org
Fiscal Resilience & Fiscal Crisis: The Case Studies of Baltimore and San Bern...
Fiscal Resilience & Fiscal Crisis: The Case Studies of Baltimore and San Bern...Fiscal Resilience & Fiscal Crisis: The Case Studies of Baltimore and San Bern...
Fiscal Resilience & Fiscal Crisis: The Case Studies of Baltimore and San Bern...
Lincoln Institute of Land Policy
Weathering the Storm ABFM Present 10[1].06
Weathering the Storm ABFM Present 10[1].06Weathering the Storm ABFM Present 10[1].06
Weathering the Storm ABFM Present 10[1].06
mdpcell
MACPA 2012 PIU / Town Hall Leg / Reg Update
MACPA 2012 PIU / Town Hall Leg / Reg UpdateMACPA 2012 PIU / Town Hall Leg / Reg Update
MACPA 2012 PIU / Town Hall Leg / Reg Update
Tom Hood, CPA,CITP,CGMA
Alaska's Fiscal Crisis: The Challenge, the Solution and How to Achieve It (1....
Alaska's Fiscal Crisis: The Challenge, the Solution and How to Achieve It (1....Alaska's Fiscal Crisis: The Challenge, the Solution and How to Achieve It (1....
Alaska's Fiscal Crisis: The Challenge, the Solution and How to Achieve It (1....
Brad Keithley
Impact of Illinois state cuts - substance abuse
Impact of Illinois state cuts - substance abuseImpact of Illinois state cuts - substance abuse
Impact of Illinois state cuts - substance abuse
Health & Medicine Policy Research Group
February 2016 - States: How to get past the fiscal crisis
February 2016 - States: How to get past the fiscal crisisFebruary 2016 - States: How to get past the fiscal crisis
February 2016 - States: How to get past the fiscal crisis
FGV Brazil
Averting a Fiscal Crisis
Averting a Fiscal CrisisAverting a Fiscal Crisis
Averting a Fiscal Crisis
CRFB.org
Fiscal Resilience & Fiscal Crisis: The Case Studies of Baltimore and San Bern...
Fiscal Resilience & Fiscal Crisis: The Case Studies of Baltimore and San Bern...Fiscal Resilience & Fiscal Crisis: The Case Studies of Baltimore and San Bern...
Fiscal Resilience & Fiscal Crisis: The Case Studies of Baltimore and San Bern...
Lincoln Institute of Land Policy
Weathering the Storm ABFM Present 10[1].06
Weathering the Storm ABFM Present 10[1].06Weathering the Storm ABFM Present 10[1].06
Weathering the Storm ABFM Present 10[1].06
mdpcell
MACPA 2012 PIU / Town Hall Leg / Reg Update
MACPA 2012 PIU / Town Hall Leg / Reg UpdateMACPA 2012 PIU / Town Hall Leg / Reg Update
MACPA 2012 PIU / Town Hall Leg / Reg Update
Tom Hood, CPA,CITP,CGMA
Alaska's Fiscal Crisis: The Challenge, the Solution and How to Achieve It (1....
Alaska's Fiscal Crisis: The Challenge, the Solution and How to Achieve It (1....Alaska's Fiscal Crisis: The Challenge, the Solution and How to Achieve It (1....
Alaska's Fiscal Crisis: The Challenge, the Solution and How to Achieve It (1....
Brad Keithley
February 2016 - States: How to get past the fiscal crisis
February 2016 - States: How to get past the fiscal crisisFebruary 2016 - States: How to get past the fiscal crisis
February 2016 - States: How to get past the fiscal crisis
FGV Brazil

Similar to Fiscal Analysis of Stoughton School District Budget (20)

Speaking With One Voice 020509
Speaking With One Voice 020509Speaking With One Voice 020509
Speaking With One Voice 020509
subcoal
TABOR Summary
TABOR SummaryTABOR Summary
TABOR Summary
EducationNC
SB36
SB36SB36
SB36
weolmstead
Senate Ed VASBO Testimony - Mar 18 2015
Senate Ed  VASBO Testimony - Mar 18 2015Senate Ed  VASBO Testimony - Mar 18 2015
Senate Ed VASBO Testimony - Mar 18 2015
Richard Pembroke, SFO
Blog budget presentation
Blog budget presentationBlog budget presentation
Blog budget presentation
Jackie Klerk Waldie
Ann Arbor Public Schools: Financial Overview
Ann Arbor Public Schools: Financial OverviewAnn Arbor Public Schools: Financial Overview
Ann Arbor Public Schools: Financial Overview
Edward Vielmetti
County Executive Budget Presentation on the FY 2019 Advertised Budget Plan
County Executive Budget Presentation on the FY 2019 Advertised Budget PlanCounty Executive Budget Presentation on the FY 2019 Advertised Budget Plan
County Executive Budget Presentation on the FY 2019 Advertised Budget Plan
Fairfax County
Budget 2 9-11
Budget 2 9-11Budget 2 9-11
Budget 2 9-11
wcsd_01
Budget101
Budget101Budget101
Budget101
Jake Anderson
2011 Year-End Legislative Update
2011 Year-End Legislative Update2011 Year-End Legislative Update
2011 Year-End Legislative Update
American Association of Community Colleges
Budget Presentation 3-9-11
Budget Presentation 3-9-11Budget Presentation 3-9-11
Budget Presentation 3-9-11
wcsd_01
Jared Polis Foundation Education Report Spring 2003
Jared Polis Foundation Education Report Spring 2003Jared Polis Foundation Education Report Spring 2003
Jared Polis Foundation Education Report Spring 2003
Lisa Finkelstein
Strengthening Resources For Missouri Budget Presentation Updated Feb 2010
Strengthening Resources For Missouri Budget Presentation Updated Feb 2010Strengthening Resources For Missouri Budget Presentation Updated Feb 2010
Strengthening Resources For Missouri Budget Presentation Updated Feb 2010
Nonprofit Services Center
2013 District Meetings
2013 District Meetings2013 District Meetings
2013 District Meetings
North Carolina Association of County Commissioners
Colorado Budget Impact on St Vrain and Prop 103
Colorado Budget Impact on St Vrain and Prop 103Colorado Budget Impact on St Vrain and Prop 103
Colorado Budget Impact on St Vrain and Prop 103
JohnCr8on
Maryland FY 2013 Budget Presentation
Maryland FY 2013 Budget Presentation Maryland FY 2013 Budget Presentation
Maryland FY 2013 Budget Presentation
mdgov
Report to the community narrated
Report to the community   narratedReport to the community   narrated
Report to the community narrated
kmatsudo
Governor's Budget Update
Governor's Budget Update Governor's Budget Update
Governor's Budget Update
dvodicka
Education Funding in Michigan
Education Funding in MichiganEducation Funding in Michigan
Education Funding in Michigan
LivoniaPTSACouncil
Anoka-Henn 2011-12 Budget Hearings (Jan 2010)
Anoka-Henn 2011-12 Budget Hearings (Jan 2010)Anoka-Henn 2011-12 Budget Hearings (Jan 2010)
Anoka-Henn 2011-12 Budget Hearings (Jan 2010)
Anoka-Hennepin School District
Speaking With One Voice 020509
Speaking With One Voice 020509Speaking With One Voice 020509
Speaking With One Voice 020509
subcoal
TABOR Summary
TABOR SummaryTABOR Summary
TABOR Summary
EducationNC
Senate Ed VASBO Testimony - Mar 18 2015
Senate Ed  VASBO Testimony - Mar 18 2015Senate Ed  VASBO Testimony - Mar 18 2015
Senate Ed VASBO Testimony - Mar 18 2015
Richard Pembroke, SFO
Ann Arbor Public Schools: Financial Overview
Ann Arbor Public Schools: Financial OverviewAnn Arbor Public Schools: Financial Overview
Ann Arbor Public Schools: Financial Overview
Edward Vielmetti
County Executive Budget Presentation on the FY 2019 Advertised Budget Plan
County Executive Budget Presentation on the FY 2019 Advertised Budget PlanCounty Executive Budget Presentation on the FY 2019 Advertised Budget Plan
County Executive Budget Presentation on the FY 2019 Advertised Budget Plan
Fairfax County
Budget 2 9-11
Budget 2 9-11Budget 2 9-11
Budget 2 9-11
wcsd_01
Budget Presentation 3-9-11
Budget Presentation 3-9-11Budget Presentation 3-9-11
Budget Presentation 3-9-11
wcsd_01
Jared Polis Foundation Education Report Spring 2003
Jared Polis Foundation Education Report Spring 2003Jared Polis Foundation Education Report Spring 2003
Jared Polis Foundation Education Report Spring 2003
Lisa Finkelstein
Strengthening Resources For Missouri Budget Presentation Updated Feb 2010
Strengthening Resources For Missouri Budget Presentation Updated Feb 2010Strengthening Resources For Missouri Budget Presentation Updated Feb 2010
Strengthening Resources For Missouri Budget Presentation Updated Feb 2010
Nonprofit Services Center
Colorado Budget Impact on St Vrain and Prop 103
Colorado Budget Impact on St Vrain and Prop 103Colorado Budget Impact on St Vrain and Prop 103
Colorado Budget Impact on St Vrain and Prop 103
JohnCr8on
Maryland FY 2013 Budget Presentation
Maryland FY 2013 Budget Presentation Maryland FY 2013 Budget Presentation
Maryland FY 2013 Budget Presentation
mdgov
Report to the community narrated
Report to the community   narratedReport to the community   narrated
Report to the community narrated
kmatsudo
Governor's Budget Update
Governor's Budget Update Governor's Budget Update
Governor's Budget Update
dvodicka
Education Funding in Michigan
Education Funding in MichiganEducation Funding in Michigan
Education Funding in Michigan
LivoniaPTSACouncil

Fiscal Analysis of Stoughton School District Budget

  • 1. The Looming Fiscal Crisis at the Stoughton Area School District a paper by Sam Wayne
  • 2. About SASD District has approximately 3,650 students Enrollment is declining at about 1% annually Per Pupil spending is very low 87% of state average Less than 90% of districts statewide High School recently failed to meet Adequate Yearly Progress standards for No Child Left Behind Legislation Performance of Disabled subgroup was not adequate
  • 3. Revenue Limits In 1993, the State Legislature passed Statute 121.90 limiting the rate at which per pupil spending can increase Passed in response to statewide call for property tax relief $241.01 per pupil increase allowed next year Districts can override spending limits by passing a referendum
  • 4. Effects of Revenue Limits on SASD Salaries and Benefits account for 76% of SASDs 2003-4 budget These costs rise annually at average of 5%
  • 5. Possible Expenditure Reductions Republican Majority in Assembly and Senate wish to pass a Property Tax Freeze or Taxpayers Bill of Rights (TABOR) Amendment in next session In 2003, Property Tax Freeze failed to override Gov. Doyles veto by 1 vote in Senate TABOR was on the agenda this year, but did not garner enough support to come to a vote
  • 6. General Provisions of Tax Freeze Districts may increase their property tax levy by $100 per pupil each year SASD projects that all increases in expenditures will be funded by property taxes Likely result- replace $241.01 per pupil increase with $100 per pupil increase If state further cuts equalization aid, the district will still be allowed only $100 per pupil increase in property tax levy
  • 7. Effects of Tax Freeze on SASD Assuming state aid remains constant Tax Freeze cuts allowable growth from 2.6% to 1%
  • 8. Effects of TABOR on Schools School districts may increase their per pupil spending by the previous years CPI index (inflation) Average inflation 1986-2002 is 2.94% Current revenue caps allow per pupil spending to increase by 2.6% If TABOR were enacted in 1986, it would have lowered SASD spending in 9 of 18 years between 1986 and 2002
  • 9. SASDs Budget Cut Options Increase class size District policy to average 20 students per class Most classrooms in district can seat 25 students Will cut at most 20% of teachers Save $3.475 million annually if all cut immediately Eliminate non-essentials Art, Music, Phys-ed, Talented and Gifted program, advanced classes, junior varsity, and varsity sports Will cut at most 10% of expenses Neither of these, even when combined, will cut enough expenses to avoid eventual need for annual referenda
  • 10. Need for Ongoing Referenda In order to provide district services at or near current levels, spending referenda will have to pass annually once General Fund is depleted To operate at bare-bones capacity, referenda will have to pass annually starting in 2015 Superintendent Dr. Myron Palomba says that annual referenda will be necessary to keep the district from shutting down
  • 11. History of Referenda for SASD The district has passed all four spending referenda it has floated since 1994 1994: $28 million 1998: $320,000 2001: $2.5 million 2003: $4.5 million Past referenda were all for capital improvements District residents were not subject to bumper-sticker campaigns
  • 12. Legitimizing an Ongoing Referenda To avoid a negative fund balance, the district plans on floating a referendum this year This is a good way to test public sentiment towards exceeding revenue limits, and allows for a failure before a negative fund balance In order to credibly float referenda annually, the district will have to make a few service cuts Immediately laying off 4-5 teachers may be necessary In addition, there may have to be a hiring freeze for the next few years as the public gets acclimated to voting on the district budget
  • 13. Structuring an Ongoing Referenda After proposing referendum this year, use General Fund monies until they expire in 2006-2007 Each year referendum should cover all operating costs above imposed restrictions Postponing payment by lowering the amount sought only increases funds necessary in the future The public should be aware that a referendum will have to pass every year to prevent severe service cuts
  • 14. Other Recommendations Lobby incoming State Senator Mark Miller and incoming Assemblyman Gary Hebl against a Property Tax Freeze, a TABOR amendment, and the current Revenue Limits This will not be very effective, because: Both men are already against these issues Both men are generally powerless, as they are new members in the minority party Join with other school districts affected by Revenue Limits to create a lobbying force separate from WEAC