ݺߣ

ݺߣShare a Scribd company logo
The depiction, creation, and fascination with ruins in the 18th century were transformed
in meaninig as the culture of sensibility took hold and the gave way to the more dramatic
and intensely emotional imagery of Romanticism. Ruins maintained a multi-valiant construction
of meaning, at times seeming dirtectly at odds with their form and intention. The legacy of this
is still felt today, in intentionally tattered designer blue jeans and purposefullydistressed furniture,
to the current trend in post-industrial urban exploration. It seems we need not just reminders of our
immortality, but also symbols of our humble, ruinous virtue, no matter the level of contrivance.
The growing affluent leisure class began to take Grand Tours of
Europe in order to experience first hand the storied natural and historical sites of the continent.
Armed with Edmund Burke’s A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime
and Beautiful, one could hike in the Alps or follow the Appian Way to Rome and behold views,
beautiful or sublime, heretofore only promised through painted or drawn imagery and descriptions.
The archeological uncovering of the buried cities of Herculaneum and Pompeii presented a domestic
version of antiquity quite different from the well known, grand, lingering remains of the public
buildings and infrastructure of ancient Rome and Greece. Architects, artists, theorists and
connoisseurs such as Charles-Louis Clérissaeau and Marc Atoine Laugier among others, in their
search for architectural origins, stripped the historicist ideals long attached to ancient ruins through
rational analysis and measured drawings. These structures could now be seen as the remnants of
functional buildings, artifacts of domestic and public lives, thus placing them into the realm of the
uncanny, or what Sigmund Freud would later call “heimlich.” The great Italian draughtsman
Piranesi published studied etchings of ancient ruins as well as imagined prisons, which were broadly
disseminated in France and Britain feeding into and helping generate the Runenlust which would
take hold of the landed gentry for much of the next century.
As the century progressed a culture of sensibility
takes hold. No longer is it rationality and trained cognition which makes one moral and virtuous,
but rather one’s capacity to perceive deeply through the senses and respond intuitively and
emotionally in the appropriate way. In this context, the rigidly ordered, and rational becomes passé
at best, tyrannical at worst. As a result of this, the highly formalized French Vista Garden gives way
to the irregularity of the “natural” picturesque English garden. Mountains and volcanoes, once
viewed as perversions of God’s perfect creation, are now seen in a morally positive light, suggesting
the upheaval of the pre-dilluvian, “mundane egg” (Brodey) synonymous with the nature of mankind
and thus triggering the sympathetic response so desired by the proponents of sensibility. The ruined
and fragmented are held aloft across the strata of the arts, from the fragmented irregular narrative of
novels like “Tristam Shandy” or “The Sorrows of Young Werther” to the deliberately designed ruins
of Francois Nicolas Henri Racine de Monville’s Column House.
At the core of sensibility is a
supposed appreciation for the natural, the common, and the un-manicured. Through this impulse
peasants and commoners became ironically further subjugated and objectified by the upper-class.
Marie Antoinette famously had her miniature village and working dairy, Petite Trianon, built. The
paintings of Greuze and Vernet, which celebrated the common and rural, became very popular, and
the rustic peasants, in a bizarre spectacle of simulacra, could be hired to play silent, idealized versions
of themselves on the garden estates of sensible men. Ruins real and imagined were shipped back
home as souvenirs from one’s travels and placed or constructed in picturesque gardens. There they
sat, becoming more ruined or in the case of some fabricated ruins becoming unappealingly ruined.
Examples of manufatured ruins:
Racine de Monville’s Column House
Marie Antoinette’s Petite Trianon,Pattern books by thouin, Hirschfeld and Lugar,
Robert Adam’s design for a bridge with a ruined balastrade in Yorkshire, John Soane’s designed ruins for
his garden at ealing.
Below is the begining of the graphic approach. It will stretch further in increments of 9 inches. Ideally it
would unfold like an accordian or could be navigated over like a large painting. There is a mix of digital
hand drawing and collage forms. Overall it is structured as a loose narrative. There will be explanatory
text added throughout. and additional imagery/text explaining the legacy of our fascination with ruins.

More Related Content

What's hot (19)

Creative Industries 1: 9 neoclassic period updated
Creative Industries 1: 9  neoclassic period updatedCreative Industries 1: 9  neoclassic period updated
Creative Industries 1: 9 neoclassic period updated
Elisa Raho
Chapter 26 Rococo to Neoclassical (Lim Jie Ning Clare)
Chapter 26  Rococo to Neoclassical (Lim Jie Ning Clare)Chapter 26  Rococo to Neoclassical (Lim Jie Ning Clare)
Chapter 26 Rococo to Neoclassical (Lim Jie Ning Clare)
Clare Clare
Humanism and the Allure of Antiquity PART 2
Humanism and the Allure of Antiquity PART 2Humanism and the Allure of Antiquity PART 2
Humanism and the Allure of Antiquity PART 2
Jacques de Beaufort
Arts
Arts Arts
Arts
Christine Mhariz
MAPEH 9 ART CONTIN
MAPEH 9 ART CONTINMAPEH 9 ART CONTIN
MAPEH 9 ART CONTIN
Dang de Leon
10 Neoclassicism to Romanticism
10  Neoclassicism to Romanticism10  Neoclassicism to Romanticism
10 Neoclassicism to Romanticism
Montgomery County Community College
Baroque art
Baroque artBaroque art
Baroque art
HzlTndr
Humanism and the Allure of Antiquity PART 1
Humanism and the Allure of Antiquity PART 1Humanism and the Allure of Antiquity PART 1
Humanism and the Allure of Antiquity PART 1
Jacques de Beaufort
The Modern History Painting
The Modern History PaintingThe Modern History Painting
The Modern History Painting
Westchester Community College
Caravaggio , his life, his style, his first masterpiece
Caravaggio , his life, his style, his first masterpiece Caravaggio , his life, his style, his first masterpiece
Caravaggio , his life, his style, his first masterpiece
giovannacasaretto
AH2 TEST 1 REVIEW
AH2 TEST 1 REVIEWAH2 TEST 1 REVIEW
AH2 TEST 1 REVIEW
Jacques de Beaufort
Jacques Louis David 3.0
Jacques Louis David 3.0Jacques Louis David 3.0
Jacques Louis David 3.0
Jerry Daperro
Romantic Landscape Painting
Romantic Landscape PaintingRomantic Landscape Painting
Romantic Landscape Painting
Westchester Community College
Medievel to Renaissance PART 1
Medievel to Renaissance PART 1Medievel to Renaissance PART 1
Medievel to Renaissance PART 1
Jacques de Beaufort
Reformation to Baroque 3
Reformation to Baroque 3Reformation to Baroque 3
Reformation to Baroque 3
Jacques de Beaufort
Baroque Art
Baroque ArtBaroque Art
Baroque Art
shemgiecuizon
Realism
Realism Realism
Realism
divinedarkspell
Fayum mummy portraits
Fayum mummy portraitsFayum mummy portraits
Fayum mummy portraits
Sotirios Raptis
Chapter 16 study guide (artforms)
Chapter 16 study guide (artforms)Chapter 16 study guide (artforms)
Chapter 16 study guide (artforms)
Jacques de Beaufort

Similar to Straube nicholas p4 abstract_02 (20)

Straube nicholas p4_rough
Straube nicholas p4_roughStraube nicholas p4_rough
Straube nicholas p4_rough
nstraube
Spotlight text 1
Spotlight text 1Spotlight text 1
Spotlight text 1
paul collinson
Roman Ruins
Roman RuinsRoman Ruins
Roman Ruins
Amanda Reed
Critical Aesthetics: Race, Class, Gender and Cultural Capital in Art and Design
Critical Aesthetics: Race, Class, Gender and Cultural Capital in Art and DesignCritical Aesthetics: Race, Class, Gender and Cultural Capital in Art and Design
Critical Aesthetics: Race, Class, Gender and Cultural Capital in Art and Design
Tony Ward
Rococo to Realism 1
Rococo to Realism 1Rococo to Realism 1
Rococo to Realism 1
Jacques de Beaufort
Art111 unit10 final_gothic_v_quarles
Art111 unit10 final_gothic_v_quarlesArt111 unit10 final_gothic_v_quarles
Art111 unit10 final_gothic_v_quarles
kweenipie
Local vs. Global Art
Local vs. Global ArtLocal vs. Global Art
Local vs. Global Art
ICCU202 / MUIC
Painting color - history. jacques lassaigne, robert l. delevoy
Painting   color - history. jacques lassaigne, robert l. delevoyPainting   color - history. jacques lassaigne, robert l. delevoy
Painting color - history. jacques lassaigne, robert l. delevoy
Ana Maria de la Cueva
Ch.28 rococo
Ch.28 rococoCh.28 rococo
Ch.28 rococo
guestf0358d
Constructing Curiosity ݺߣshow.pptx
Constructing Curiosity ݺߣshow.pptxConstructing Curiosity ݺߣshow.pptx
Constructing Curiosity ݺߣshow.pptx
MiaJackson14
Literature during medieval period
Literature during medieval periodLiterature during medieval period
Literature during medieval period
ellaboi
10242016 StrayerUniversityBookshelfTheHumanitiesCultu.docx
10242016 StrayerUniversityBookshelfTheHumanitiesCultu.docx10242016 StrayerUniversityBookshelfTheHumanitiesCultu.docx
10242016 StrayerUniversityBookshelfTheHumanitiesCultu.docx
paynetawnya
NCC PROTO-RENAISSANCE
NCC PROTO-RENAISSANCENCC PROTO-RENAISSANCE
NCC PROTO-RENAISSANCE
65swiss
Art History for art appreciation lessons
Art History for art appreciation lessonsArt History for art appreciation lessons
Art History for art appreciation lessons
kramEtrauc
Western Art History for Art Appreciation
Western Art History for Art AppreciationWestern Art History for Art Appreciation
Western Art History for Art Appreciation
kramEtrauc
Rococo to Realism (condensed)
Rococo to Realism (condensed)Rococo to Realism (condensed)
Rococo to Realism (condensed)
Jacques de Beaufort
Week 9.rococo and neoclassicism overview
Week 9.rococo and neoclassicism overviewWeek 9.rococo and neoclassicism overview
Week 9.rococo and neoclassicism overview
asilkentent
Terms Ch 16
Terms Ch 16 Terms Ch 16
Terms Ch 16
Jacques de Beaufort
Critical Space Part 2
Critical Space Part 2Critical Space Part 2
Critical Space Part 2
Tony Ward
Ncc art100 ch.6
Ncc art100 ch.6Ncc art100 ch.6
Ncc art100 ch.6
65swiss
Straube nicholas p4_rough
Straube nicholas p4_roughStraube nicholas p4_rough
Straube nicholas p4_rough
nstraube
Critical Aesthetics: Race, Class, Gender and Cultural Capital in Art and Design
Critical Aesthetics: Race, Class, Gender and Cultural Capital in Art and DesignCritical Aesthetics: Race, Class, Gender and Cultural Capital in Art and Design
Critical Aesthetics: Race, Class, Gender and Cultural Capital in Art and Design
Tony Ward
Art111 unit10 final_gothic_v_quarles
Art111 unit10 final_gothic_v_quarlesArt111 unit10 final_gothic_v_quarles
Art111 unit10 final_gothic_v_quarles
kweenipie
Painting color - history. jacques lassaigne, robert l. delevoy
Painting   color - history. jacques lassaigne, robert l. delevoyPainting   color - history. jacques lassaigne, robert l. delevoy
Painting color - history. jacques lassaigne, robert l. delevoy
Ana Maria de la Cueva
Constructing Curiosity ݺߣshow.pptx
Constructing Curiosity ݺߣshow.pptxConstructing Curiosity ݺߣshow.pptx
Constructing Curiosity ݺߣshow.pptx
MiaJackson14
Literature during medieval period
Literature during medieval periodLiterature during medieval period
Literature during medieval period
ellaboi
10242016 StrayerUniversityBookshelfTheHumanitiesCultu.docx
10242016 StrayerUniversityBookshelfTheHumanitiesCultu.docx10242016 StrayerUniversityBookshelfTheHumanitiesCultu.docx
10242016 StrayerUniversityBookshelfTheHumanitiesCultu.docx
paynetawnya
NCC PROTO-RENAISSANCE
NCC PROTO-RENAISSANCENCC PROTO-RENAISSANCE
NCC PROTO-RENAISSANCE
65swiss
Art History for art appreciation lessons
Art History for art appreciation lessonsArt History for art appreciation lessons
Art History for art appreciation lessons
kramEtrauc
Western Art History for Art Appreciation
Western Art History for Art AppreciationWestern Art History for Art Appreciation
Western Art History for Art Appreciation
kramEtrauc
Week 9.rococo and neoclassicism overview
Week 9.rococo and neoclassicism overviewWeek 9.rococo and neoclassicism overview
Week 9.rococo and neoclassicism overview
asilkentent
Critical Space Part 2
Critical Space Part 2Critical Space Part 2
Critical Space Part 2
Tony Ward
Ncc art100 ch.6
Ncc art100 ch.6Ncc art100 ch.6
Ncc art100 ch.6
65swiss

Straube nicholas p4 abstract_02

  • 1. The depiction, creation, and fascination with ruins in the 18th century were transformed in meaninig as the culture of sensibility took hold and the gave way to the more dramatic and intensely emotional imagery of Romanticism. Ruins maintained a multi-valiant construction of meaning, at times seeming dirtectly at odds with their form and intention. The legacy of this is still felt today, in intentionally tattered designer blue jeans and purposefullydistressed furniture, to the current trend in post-industrial urban exploration. It seems we need not just reminders of our immortality, but also symbols of our humble, ruinous virtue, no matter the level of contrivance. The growing affluent leisure class began to take Grand Tours of Europe in order to experience first hand the storied natural and historical sites of the continent. Armed with Edmund Burke’s A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful, one could hike in the Alps or follow the Appian Way to Rome and behold views, beautiful or sublime, heretofore only promised through painted or drawn imagery and descriptions. The archeological uncovering of the buried cities of Herculaneum and Pompeii presented a domestic version of antiquity quite different from the well known, grand, lingering remains of the public buildings and infrastructure of ancient Rome and Greece. Architects, artists, theorists and connoisseurs such as Charles-Louis Clérissaeau and Marc Atoine Laugier among others, in their search for architectural origins, stripped the historicist ideals long attached to ancient ruins through rational analysis and measured drawings. These structures could now be seen as the remnants of functional buildings, artifacts of domestic and public lives, thus placing them into the realm of the uncanny, or what Sigmund Freud would later call “heimlich.” The great Italian draughtsman Piranesi published studied etchings of ancient ruins as well as imagined prisons, which were broadly disseminated in France and Britain feeding into and helping generate the Runenlust which would take hold of the landed gentry for much of the next century. As the century progressed a culture of sensibility takes hold. No longer is it rationality and trained cognition which makes one moral and virtuous, but rather one’s capacity to perceive deeply through the senses and respond intuitively and emotionally in the appropriate way. In this context, the rigidly ordered, and rational becomes passé at best, tyrannical at worst. As a result of this, the highly formalized French Vista Garden gives way to the irregularity of the “natural” picturesque English garden. Mountains and volcanoes, once viewed as perversions of God’s perfect creation, are now seen in a morally positive light, suggesting the upheaval of the pre-dilluvian, “mundane egg” (Brodey) synonymous with the nature of mankind and thus triggering the sympathetic response so desired by the proponents of sensibility. The ruined and fragmented are held aloft across the strata of the arts, from the fragmented irregular narrative of novels like “Tristam Shandy” or “The Sorrows of Young Werther” to the deliberately designed ruins of Francois Nicolas Henri Racine de Monville’s Column House. At the core of sensibility is a supposed appreciation for the natural, the common, and the un-manicured. Through this impulse peasants and commoners became ironically further subjugated and objectified by the upper-class. Marie Antoinette famously had her miniature village and working dairy, Petite Trianon, built. The paintings of Greuze and Vernet, which celebrated the common and rural, became very popular, and the rustic peasants, in a bizarre spectacle of simulacra, could be hired to play silent, idealized versions of themselves on the garden estates of sensible men. Ruins real and imagined were shipped back home as souvenirs from one’s travels and placed or constructed in picturesque gardens. There they sat, becoming more ruined or in the case of some fabricated ruins becoming unappealingly ruined. Examples of manufatured ruins: Racine de Monville’s Column House Marie Antoinette’s Petite Trianon,Pattern books by thouin, Hirschfeld and Lugar, Robert Adam’s design for a bridge with a ruined balastrade in Yorkshire, John Soane’s designed ruins for his garden at ealing. Below is the begining of the graphic approach. It will stretch further in increments of 9 inches. Ideally it would unfold like an accordian or could be navigated over like a large painting. There is a mix of digital hand drawing and collage forms. Overall it is structured as a loose narrative. There will be explanatory text added throughout. and additional imagery/text explaining the legacy of our fascination with ruins.