際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
The Internet and International Relations
             The Democratic Nature of Social Media
                                Presentation by David Quinn
Information technology
               (IT) has become an
Introduction   essential tool for the
               global circulation of
               power, waging of war, and
               imagining of peace

                            Der Derian (2003)
Examples
The Philippines | 2002
                 Protests by text messages to
                  mobilize & coordinate their
                  action

                 TXT MSG traffic doubled to
                  over 70 million a day*

                 Intensity of the protests forced
                  the Supreme Court to declare
                  the presidency void


                   *(NP Action, 2005).
Ukraine | (2004)
 Text messages played a role in coordinating young
  Ukrainians in their Orange Revolution

 Internet was used to recruit volunteers, organise
  campaigns, raise funds, report breaking news

 Protests led to a re-vote
Iran | (2009)
                 Role of social media as a
                  communication tool in
                  coordinating and
                  publicizing
                  mass protests

                 Twitter provided up-to-the-
                  minute updates from the
                  street level

                 Global media forced to rely
                  on Twitter feeds

                 Viral videos - Death of
                  Iranian woman caught on
                  camera phone spread
CNN
Iran | (2009)
  Government succeeded in imposing
   restrictions on Internet use and TXT MSG
  Twitter proved virtually impervious
   In less than a month tweets about
   the elections from approximately
   480,000 users
State Department
 Impact of Twitter widely
                heralded as victory for
                democracy
Questioning
               Real impact on international
the Hype        relations is still far from
                understood

               Longer term impact less clear
Did Twitter fundamentally alter the
future of Iran?

                 or

Did it merely serve to function as a lot
of digital hot air?
Assessing the Democratic Nature
of the Internet & New Media
Democratic Nature of the Internet
Deeply embedded ideological belief:

   Regan (1989): the Goliath of
    totalitarianism will be brought down
    by the David of the microchip

   Barlow (1996): act of naturewhere all may enter
    without privilege or prejudice according by race,
    economic power, military force, or station of birth.

   Hattotuwa (2009): technologies that work in concert to
    empower communities to better engage with
    governance and democracy
Democratization of the Media

 Decentralization of the media

 Media culture from passive to active
  participation

 Increased transparency of information

 Questions over accuracy of information
Democratization of Power

 It diffuses and redistributes power and points of
  centralization.

 Cannot direct one another by force

 Challenges traditional power of governments and
  states.

 Enables different actors to produce deep global
  effects.
Make Poverty History campaign
Democratization of Extremism

 Concerns about destabilizing externalities.

 Sunstein (2001) - Personalization of the Internet:
  breeding ground for extremism.
堰看敬艶厩艶姻.

             Etling et al. (2009) -
              infrastructure for
              expressing minority
              points of view.

             Beckman Centre for
              Internet and Society
              (2009) - Very little
              support for terrorism
              or violent jihad in the
              Arabic blogosphere
              and quite a lot of
              concern.
Empirical Work
Best and Wade (2005)
 Measure the global effect of the Internet on
  democracy over the period 1992 to 2002.

 Internet penetration explains more variation in
  the democratic development within a country
  than does literacy rates and some of the
  geographic regions.

 Butacknowledge the degree to which the
  Internet affects a nation is likely to be subject to
  a large number of variables.
Limitations of the Internet &
Social Media on Democracy
Limitations in the Digital Divide
  1.6 billion Internet
   users worldwide.

  70% live in the 24
   richest countries.

  Developing countries
   account for just 13.2%

  Half of all web pages in English
but potential for expansion
 Mobile phones are critical
  element in the dissemination
  of information globally

 Mobile phone subscribers
 are increasing globally

 By 2011, it is estimated that
  there will be another billion
  mobile phone owners

 One Laptop Per Child
  (www.laptop.org)
For all their promise, there are
              sharp limits on what Twitter and
              other Web tools such as
Limitations   Facebook and blogs can do for
              citizens in authoritarian
              societies...no amount of
              Twittering forced Irans leaders to
              change course.

                       John Palfrey et al. (2009:1)
1. Information hard to distil

2. Governments can limit
   access to the Internet when
   threatened

3. The demographics of online
   communities

4. Authoritarian regimes can
   also commandeer the
   Internet for their own means
However, the Twittering
continues
Conclusions

  This points towards an efficacy of the Internet


  Fear of larger economic and political
   consequences = prevention of further
   censorship


  Iran, Ukraine and the Philippines highlight the
   ability of the Internet to be forefront of global
   political change,
Conclusions

  Internet = powerful tool for fostering
   democracy and development.


  Policy makers should not organise or
   control the Internet, but instead ensure
   that people have the access and training
   to effectively participate online.
Ad

Recommended

Power of social media
Power of social media
karamnav
GLOBALISATION-CULTURAL AND SOCIAL
GLOBALISATION-CULTURAL AND SOCIAL
Ankur Goyal
Effects of Globalization to E-Commerce, Vice Versa
Effects of Globalization to E-Commerce, Vice Versa
Eileen Rose Quilon
Impact of social media
Impact of social media
SamiaTasneem2
globalization-190706113049.pptx
globalization-190706113049.pptx
RowenaFlores12
social media and mental health
social media and mental health
ramkumar g s
Tourisme durable Tsinjoriake
Office Nationale du Tourisme Madagascar
Globalization, ICTs, and the Information society
Globalization, ICTs, and the Information society
Boutkhil Guemide
Globalization
Globalization
cguccione
Adolescencia en tiempos de pandemia
Andr辿s Oliva
Impact of Social Media on Politics
Impact of Social Media on Politics
Rob Levish
Impact of Globalization
Impact of Globalization
Salahuddin Sohag
Presentation on Globalization
Presentation on Globalization
ESSAYSHARK.com
Units 11, 12. globalization
Units 11, 12. globalization
Dudas-Historia
Internet Censorship
Internet Censorship
becnicholas
Why Social Media Is Important?
Why Social Media Is Important?
HarsimranSingh310
Globalisation
Globalisation
CoEP
Pro globalist vs. Anti globalist
Pro globalist vs. Anti globalist
Munish Goyal
Presentation on Terrorism | PPT
Presentation on Terrorism | PPT
Saleh Ibne Omar
Does The Internet Encourage Democracy?
Does The Internet Encourage Democracy?
Maps of World
Short History of U.S. Public Diplomacy
Short History of U.S. Public Diplomacy
U.S Embassy in Belgrade (Serbia) / U.S. Department of State
Sunstein: Democracy and the Internet
Sunstein: Democracy and the Internet
Mia Eaker
Social Media and Relationships
Social Media and Relationships
Sabine Matook
The internet and democracy
The internet and democracy
hotmanila
International relations
International relations
Nayyera Anbreen
Actors of international relations
Actors of international relations
Sayotters
Introduction to information technology lecture 1
Introduction to information technology lecture 1
adpafit
Thesis: THE ROLE OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY ON COMMERCIAL BANKS IN NIGERIA
Thesis: THE ROLE OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY ON COMMERCIAL BANKS IN NIGERIA
Seun Otukoya
Web whisperers
Web whisperers
jilloviatt
E era ir-us-fp
E era ir-us-fp
Daniel Aguirre Az坦car

More Related Content

What's hot (11)

Globalization
Globalization
cguccione
Adolescencia en tiempos de pandemia
Andr辿s Oliva
Impact of Social Media on Politics
Impact of Social Media on Politics
Rob Levish
Impact of Globalization
Impact of Globalization
Salahuddin Sohag
Presentation on Globalization
Presentation on Globalization
ESSAYSHARK.com
Units 11, 12. globalization
Units 11, 12. globalization
Dudas-Historia
Internet Censorship
Internet Censorship
becnicholas
Why Social Media Is Important?
Why Social Media Is Important?
HarsimranSingh310
Globalisation
Globalisation
CoEP
Pro globalist vs. Anti globalist
Pro globalist vs. Anti globalist
Munish Goyal
Presentation on Terrorism | PPT
Presentation on Terrorism | PPT
Saleh Ibne Omar
Globalization
Globalization
cguccione
Adolescencia en tiempos de pandemia
Andr辿s Oliva
Impact of Social Media on Politics
Impact of Social Media on Politics
Rob Levish
Impact of Globalization
Impact of Globalization
Salahuddin Sohag
Presentation on Globalization
Presentation on Globalization
ESSAYSHARK.com
Units 11, 12. globalization
Units 11, 12. globalization
Dudas-Historia
Internet Censorship
Internet Censorship
becnicholas
Why Social Media Is Important?
Why Social Media Is Important?
HarsimranSingh310
Globalisation
Globalisation
CoEP
Pro globalist vs. Anti globalist
Pro globalist vs. Anti globalist
Munish Goyal
Presentation on Terrorism | PPT
Presentation on Terrorism | PPT
Saleh Ibne Omar

Viewers also liked (9)

Does The Internet Encourage Democracy?
Does The Internet Encourage Democracy?
Maps of World
Short History of U.S. Public Diplomacy
Short History of U.S. Public Diplomacy
U.S Embassy in Belgrade (Serbia) / U.S. Department of State
Sunstein: Democracy and the Internet
Sunstein: Democracy and the Internet
Mia Eaker
Social Media and Relationships
Social Media and Relationships
Sabine Matook
The internet and democracy
The internet and democracy
hotmanila
International relations
International relations
Nayyera Anbreen
Actors of international relations
Actors of international relations
Sayotters
Introduction to information technology lecture 1
Introduction to information technology lecture 1
adpafit
Thesis: THE ROLE OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY ON COMMERCIAL BANKS IN NIGERIA
Thesis: THE ROLE OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY ON COMMERCIAL BANKS IN NIGERIA
Seun Otukoya
Does The Internet Encourage Democracy?
Does The Internet Encourage Democracy?
Maps of World
Sunstein: Democracy and the Internet
Sunstein: Democracy and the Internet
Mia Eaker
Social Media and Relationships
Social Media and Relationships
Sabine Matook
The internet and democracy
The internet and democracy
hotmanila
International relations
International relations
Nayyera Anbreen
Actors of international relations
Actors of international relations
Sayotters
Introduction to information technology lecture 1
Introduction to information technology lecture 1
adpafit
Thesis: THE ROLE OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY ON COMMERCIAL BANKS IN NIGERIA
Thesis: THE ROLE OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY ON COMMERCIAL BANKS IN NIGERIA
Seun Otukoya
Ad

Similar to The Internet And International Relations (20)

Web whisperers
Web whisperers
jilloviatt
E era ir-us-fp
E era ir-us-fp
Daniel Aguirre Az坦car
Authoritarian Governments in Cyberspace
Authoritarian Governments in Cyberspace
evgeny.morozov
SOCIAL MEDIA - BIG BROTHER IS WATCHING YOU
SOCIAL MEDIA - BIG BROTHER IS WATCHING YOU
Arshad Sharif
Jones And Turner iran seattle presentation
Jones And Turner iran seattle presentation
Cameron Jones
Political change in the digital age
Political change in the digital age
Krishna Mohan
Group Political Communication In CMC
Group Political Communication In CMC
aazim javed
Brown and Beige Aesthetic Vintage Group Project Presentation.pdf
Brown and Beige Aesthetic Vintage Group Project Presentation.pdf
venuspatatag4
IMPLICATIONS OF MEDIA AND INFORMATION.pptx
IMPLICATIONS OF MEDIA AND INFORMATION.pptx
NORRISBREGENTE1
The political influence of social medias
The political influence of social medias
FlorianEricJacques
Technology, human rights & movement building around the world
Technology, human rights & movement building around the world
TechSoup Canada
Mac201 arab spring
Mac201 arab spring
Rob Jewitt
English presentation
English presentation
GinaSoler10
Global digital divide niamh and ben
Global digital divide niamh and ben
Niamh Cashell
64The Empire Strikes Back Social Media Uprisings and .docx
64The Empire Strikes Back Social Media Uprisings and .docx
evonnehoggarth79783
Journalism, Disinformation and Facebook: How to Survive an Earthquake
Journalism, Disinformation and Facebook: How to Survive an Earthquake
Self-employed
Journalism, Disinformation and Facebook: How to Survive an Earthquake
Journalism, Disinformation and Facebook: How to Survive an Earthquake
Self-employed
Scanning the Digital Landscape
Scanning the Digital Landscape
Philippine Press Institute
Global, Mobile Internets lecture - USYD MECO3065
Global, Mobile Internets lecture - USYD MECO3065
University of Sydney
[2011] Citizen techology & Open Government - Jared Ford
[2011] Citizen techology & Open Government - Jared Ford
e-Democracy Conference
Web whisperers
Web whisperers
jilloviatt
Authoritarian Governments in Cyberspace
Authoritarian Governments in Cyberspace
evgeny.morozov
SOCIAL MEDIA - BIG BROTHER IS WATCHING YOU
SOCIAL MEDIA - BIG BROTHER IS WATCHING YOU
Arshad Sharif
Jones And Turner iran seattle presentation
Jones And Turner iran seattle presentation
Cameron Jones
Political change in the digital age
Political change in the digital age
Krishna Mohan
Group Political Communication In CMC
Group Political Communication In CMC
aazim javed
Brown and Beige Aesthetic Vintage Group Project Presentation.pdf
Brown and Beige Aesthetic Vintage Group Project Presentation.pdf
venuspatatag4
IMPLICATIONS OF MEDIA AND INFORMATION.pptx
IMPLICATIONS OF MEDIA AND INFORMATION.pptx
NORRISBREGENTE1
The political influence of social medias
The political influence of social medias
FlorianEricJacques
Technology, human rights & movement building around the world
Technology, human rights & movement building around the world
TechSoup Canada
Mac201 arab spring
Mac201 arab spring
Rob Jewitt
English presentation
English presentation
GinaSoler10
Global digital divide niamh and ben
Global digital divide niamh and ben
Niamh Cashell
64The Empire Strikes Back Social Media Uprisings and .docx
64The Empire Strikes Back Social Media Uprisings and .docx
evonnehoggarth79783
Journalism, Disinformation and Facebook: How to Survive an Earthquake
Journalism, Disinformation and Facebook: How to Survive an Earthquake
Self-employed
Journalism, Disinformation and Facebook: How to Survive an Earthquake
Journalism, Disinformation and Facebook: How to Survive an Earthquake
Self-employed
Global, Mobile Internets lecture - USYD MECO3065
Global, Mobile Internets lecture - USYD MECO3065
University of Sydney
[2011] Citizen techology & Open Government - Jared Ford
[2011] Citizen techology & Open Government - Jared Ford
e-Democracy Conference
Ad

The Internet And International Relations

  • 1. The Internet and International Relations The Democratic Nature of Social Media Presentation by David Quinn
  • 2. Information technology (IT) has become an Introduction essential tool for the global circulation of power, waging of war, and imagining of peace Der Derian (2003)
  • 4. The Philippines | 2002 Protests by text messages to mobilize & coordinate their action TXT MSG traffic doubled to over 70 million a day* Intensity of the protests forced the Supreme Court to declare the presidency void *(NP Action, 2005).
  • 5. Ukraine | (2004) Text messages played a role in coordinating young Ukrainians in their Orange Revolution Internet was used to recruit volunteers, organise campaigns, raise funds, report breaking news Protests led to a re-vote
  • 6. Iran | (2009) Role of social media as a communication tool in coordinating and publicizing mass protests Twitter provided up-to-the- minute updates from the street level Global media forced to rely on Twitter feeds Viral videos - Death of Iranian woman caught on camera phone spread
  • 7. CNN
  • 8. Iran | (2009) Government succeeded in imposing restrictions on Internet use and TXT MSG Twitter proved virtually impervious In less than a month tweets about the elections from approximately 480,000 users
  • 10. Impact of Twitter widely heralded as victory for democracy Questioning Real impact on international the Hype relations is still far from understood Longer term impact less clear
  • 11. Did Twitter fundamentally alter the future of Iran? or Did it merely serve to function as a lot of digital hot air?
  • 12. Assessing the Democratic Nature of the Internet & New Media
  • 13. Democratic Nature of the Internet Deeply embedded ideological belief: Regan (1989): the Goliath of totalitarianism will be brought down by the David of the microchip Barlow (1996): act of naturewhere all may enter without privilege or prejudice according by race, economic power, military force, or station of birth. Hattotuwa (2009): technologies that work in concert to empower communities to better engage with governance and democracy
  • 14. Democratization of the Media Decentralization of the media Media culture from passive to active participation Increased transparency of information Questions over accuracy of information
  • 15. Democratization of Power It diffuses and redistributes power and points of centralization. Cannot direct one another by force Challenges traditional power of governments and states. Enables different actors to produce deep global effects.
  • 17. Democratization of Extremism Concerns about destabilizing externalities. Sunstein (2001) - Personalization of the Internet: breeding ground for extremism.
  • 18. 堰看敬艶厩艶姻. Etling et al. (2009) - infrastructure for expressing minority points of view. Beckman Centre for Internet and Society (2009) - Very little support for terrorism or violent jihad in the Arabic blogosphere and quite a lot of concern.
  • 20. Best and Wade (2005) Measure the global effect of the Internet on democracy over the period 1992 to 2002. Internet penetration explains more variation in the democratic development within a country than does literacy rates and some of the geographic regions. Butacknowledge the degree to which the Internet affects a nation is likely to be subject to a large number of variables.
  • 21. Limitations of the Internet & Social Media on Democracy
  • 22. Limitations in the Digital Divide 1.6 billion Internet users worldwide. 70% live in the 24 richest countries. Developing countries account for just 13.2% Half of all web pages in English
  • 23. but potential for expansion Mobile phones are critical element in the dissemination of information globally Mobile phone subscribers are increasing globally By 2011, it is estimated that there will be another billion mobile phone owners One Laptop Per Child (www.laptop.org)
  • 24. For all their promise, there are sharp limits on what Twitter and other Web tools such as Limitations Facebook and blogs can do for citizens in authoritarian societies...no amount of Twittering forced Irans leaders to change course. John Palfrey et al. (2009:1)
  • 25. 1. Information hard to distil 2. Governments can limit access to the Internet when threatened 3. The demographics of online communities 4. Authoritarian regimes can also commandeer the Internet for their own means
  • 27. Conclusions This points towards an efficacy of the Internet Fear of larger economic and political consequences = prevention of further censorship Iran, Ukraine and the Philippines highlight the ability of the Internet to be forefront of global political change,
  • 28. Conclusions Internet = powerful tool for fostering democracy and development. Policy makers should not organise or control the Internet, but instead ensure that people have the access and training to effectively participate online.