ºÝºÝߣ

ºÝºÝߣShare a Scribd company logo
The Role of People and
Sensors in the Development of
Smart Cities
A Systematic Literature
Review
Felipe Silva Ferraz fsf@cesar.org.br
Italberto Figueira Dantas italberto@ufpi.edu.br
Introduction
¡è? Over the last few years, with rapid population growth, issues like air
pollution, water scarcity, and intense traffic conditions, have
become more evident.
¡è? Trying to mitigate them, the concept of Smart City was presented,
which uses technology and human resources to manage urban
resources.
¡è? But, it is not clear what role is occupied in the different stages of
evolution, which leads a city to be considered Smart.
¡è? We used the SLR method to analyze scientific publications, and thus
to determine what is the role of the human factor, represented by
people, and technological, represented by sensors, in the
development of smart cities.
Background
¡è? In the last century, the number of cities in the world with more than
1 million inhabitants jumped from 20 to 450 [1].
¡è? In 2007, the number of people living in urban centers exceeded
50% of the world population [1].
¡è? Technology is a way to solve the problems caused by the
population growth [2].
¡è? In the current scenario, every initiative is important if it helps
understand the growth of great urban centers and how it occurs,
as well as what measures should be adopted to extinguish the
problems caused by it, from a scientific and economic point of
view.
¡è? In this work, we intend to provide the current panorama of the
scientific researches made in the field of Smart Cities that talk
about their development based on the participation of people and
the use of sensors,
Systematic Literature Review (SLR)
¡è? Research Question: What is the role of people and sensors in
the development of Smart Cities?
¡è? Q1.1. What is the influence of the participation of people or use
of sensors in the study?;
¡è? Q1.2. What is the level of previous infrastructure so the study
proposal is viable?;
¡è? Q1.3. What stage of social organization the city needs to be in
so the study is viable?;
¡è? Q1.4. What is the contribution of the study for the scientific
community?;
¡è? Q1.5. How was the study validated?;
¡è? Q.1.6. What was the main feature of the city affected by the
study?.
SLR Execution
¡è? Four steps were defined and for two of them, exclusion
criterion were defined as well:
¡è? ST01. The search must be done in the selected bases Scopus,
IEEExplore, Science Direct and Compendex.
¡è? ST02. This stage eliminates primary studies that do not attend
the purposes of this study.
¡è? ST03. Publications not excluded on the previous step will be
re-evaluated based on their title, abstract or full text.
¡è? ST04. Search for referenced of the remaining publications
must be made (snowballing search).
SLR Execution
¡è? Initially 1121 publications were found.
¡è? After applying exclusion criterion, we obtained 45
publications.
¡è? Each publication was evaluated under the subquestions
point of view.
¡è? Results of sub-questions were compared with the other
results.
Results
¡è? Question Q1.1 Analysis
¡è? When a society is not organized to sustain initiatives to
create a Smart City, Technology is the most expressive
element to start the process.
¡è? In cities with no infrastructure and control of their resources,
the administration of the city prefer to invest their efforts to
acquire technologies.
¡è? When there are available infrastructure, human resource is
the most discussed issue, indicating the influence it may
have on the development of the city.
¡è? The human perception of the environment is being explored
in the monitoring of natural resources and urban
environment, being as important as the sensors in the
information acquisition.
Results
¡è? Question Q1.4 Analysis
¡è? Implementation was the most used method to validate the
efforts. It may indicate that there are not many options to test
the previously available proposals, which made the researchers
responsible for developing their own tools to validate their
proposals.
¡è? Economic aspects were not addressed, It may indicate that
more researches about the economic features of Smart Cities
are necessary.
¡è? Question Q1.6 Analysis
¡è? Governance was the area that received more attention. This
result may point to a city in the Chaotic level as Governance as
the area that should get more attention, since it deals with the
decision making about the future of the city.
Conclusion
¡è? Results obtained during the protocol test show it could be
used in a consistent way to reach the objectives of this
study.
¡è? We could notice that people and sensors have great
importance when developing Smart Cities. Their
importance changes ac- cording to the level of
technological and social development each city is in, as
well as the needs each city defines as priority.
Future Works
¡è? The economic aspect was showed pretty deficient, from
almost all analyzed points of view. So, this theme needs to
be deeply analyzed, in order to understand better the
relationship with the cities technological and social
elements.
¡è? This research was realized considering just a period of five
years of study. A new protocol execution can be made,
with a bigger range, in order to analyze the evolution of the
researched aspects with the development of new scientific
studies about Smart Cities, making it possible to enhance
the knowledge about how people and sensors influence the
Smart Cities development, drawing an evolutionary profile.
References
¡è? [1] ?C. E. A. Mulligan and M. Olsson, ¡°Architectural
Implications of Smart City Business Models : An
Evolutionary Perspective,¡± IEEE Communications
Magazine, vol. 51, no. 6, Jun. 2013, pp. 80¨C85.
¡è? [2] ?C. E. A. Mulligan and M. Olsson, ¡°Architectural
Implications of Smart City Business Models : An
Evolutionary Perspective,¡± IEEE Communications
Magazine, vol. 51, no. 6, Jun. 2013, pp. 80¨C85.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked (11)

PhrasalverbsPhrasalverbs
Phrasalverbs
naslyvalentina
?
§Ó§í§Ô§à§Õ§ß§í§Û §ã§ä§Ñ§â§ä New hu 20.01.17
§Ó§í§Ô§à§Õ§ß§í§Û §ã§ä§Ñ§â§ä New hu 20.01.17§Ó§í§Ô§à§Õ§ß§í§Û §ã§ä§Ñ§â§ä New hu 20.01.17
§Ó§í§Ô§à§Õ§ß§í§Û §ã§ä§Ñ§â§ä New hu 20.01.17
TianDe
?
½üÇê¤Î¶Ù´Ç³¦°ì±ð°ù¥Í¥Ã¥È¥ï©`¥¯
½üÇê¤Î¶Ù´Ç³¦°ì±ð°ù¥Í¥Ã¥È¥ï©`¥¯½üÇê¤Î¶Ù´Ç³¦°ì±ð°ù¥Í¥Ã¥È¥ï©`¥¯
½üÇê¤Î¶Ù´Ç³¦°ì±ð°ù¥Í¥Ã¥È¥ï©`¥¯
Yuji Oshima
?
Stress management in bpo
Stress management in bpoStress management in bpo
Stress management in bpo
Projects Kart
?
Gst in india
Gst in indiaGst in india
Gst in india
prajwal chakrasali
?
DrogasDrogas
Drogas
Sary Rodriguez
?
AnorexiaAnorexia
Anorexia
Sary Rodriguez
?
What we do - Routes and Branches
What we do - Routes and BranchesWhat we do - Routes and Branches
What we do - Routes and Branches
RoutesandBranches
?
Bvs pr¨¦sentation atelier comp¨¦titivit¨¦Bvs pr¨¦sentation atelier comp¨¦titivit¨¦
Bvs pr¨¦sentation atelier comp¨¦titivit¨¦
Missioneco72
?
INTI - RESISTENTE DE VERDAD
INTI - RESISTENTE DE VERDADINTI - RESISTENTE DE VERDAD
INTI - RESISTENTE DE VERDAD
Luis Alberto Damian Maldonado
?
PhrasalverbsPhrasalverbs
Phrasalverbs
naslyvalentina
?
§Ó§í§Ô§à§Õ§ß§í§Û §ã§ä§Ñ§â§ä New hu 20.01.17
§Ó§í§Ô§à§Õ§ß§í§Û §ã§ä§Ñ§â§ä New hu 20.01.17§Ó§í§Ô§à§Õ§ß§í§Û §ã§ä§Ñ§â§ä New hu 20.01.17
§Ó§í§Ô§à§Õ§ß§í§Û §ã§ä§Ñ§â§ä New hu 20.01.17
TianDe
?
½üÇê¤Î¶Ù´Ç³¦°ì±ð°ù¥Í¥Ã¥È¥ï©`¥¯
½üÇê¤Î¶Ù´Ç³¦°ì±ð°ù¥Í¥Ã¥È¥ï©`¥¯½üÇê¤Î¶Ù´Ç³¦°ì±ð°ù¥Í¥Ã¥È¥ï©`¥¯
½üÇê¤Î¶Ù´Ç³¦°ì±ð°ù¥Í¥Ã¥È¥ï©`¥¯
Yuji Oshima
?
Stress management in bpo
Stress management in bpoStress management in bpo
Stress management in bpo
Projects Kart
?
What we do - Routes and Branches
What we do - Routes and BranchesWhat we do - Routes and Branches
What we do - Routes and Branches
RoutesandBranches
?
Bvs pr¨¦sentation atelier comp¨¦titivit¨¦Bvs pr¨¦sentation atelier comp¨¦titivit¨¦
Bvs pr¨¦sentation atelier comp¨¦titivit¨¦
Missioneco72
?

Similar to The role of people and sensores in the development of the smart cities: A systematic literature review (20)

dynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptx
dynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptxdynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptx
dynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptx
akhileshakm
?
dynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptx
dynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptxdynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptx
dynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptx
moh2020
?
Smart cities and open data platforms
Smart cities and open data platformsSmart cities and open data platforms
Smart cities and open data platforms
LD4SC
?
World Smart Cities. EURA Conference 2013, Enschede, the Netherlands
 World Smart Cities. EURA Conference 2013, Enschede, the Netherlands World Smart Cities. EURA Conference 2013, Enschede, the Netherlands
World Smart Cities. EURA Conference 2013, Enschede, the Netherlands
Olga Gil, PhD (olgagil@olgagil.es)
?
Open Data Innovation in Smart Cities: Challenges and Trends
Open Data Innovation in Smart Cities: Challenges and TrendsOpen Data Innovation in Smart Cities: Challenges and Trends
Open Data Innovation in Smart Cities: Challenges and Trends
Edward Curry
?
Smart cities
Smart citiesSmart cities
Smart cities
Association for Project Management
?
City and Society 2016 - Seminar Paper - Sagi Ganot
City and Society 2016 - Seminar Paper - Sagi GanotCity and Society 2016 - Seminar Paper - Sagi Ganot
City and Society 2016 - Seminar Paper - Sagi Ganot
Sagi Ganot-Shachar
?
PWC: Data Driven Cities [2016]
PWC: Data Driven Cities [2016]PWC: Data Driven Cities [2016]
PWC: Data Driven Cities [2016]
Filipp Paster
?
URBAN LIFECYCLE MANAGEMENT : a RESEARCH PROGRAM FOR SMART GOVERNMENT OF SMAR...
URBAN LIFECYCLE MANAGEMENT :  a RESEARCH PROGRAM FOR SMART GOVERNMENT OF SMAR...URBAN LIFECYCLE MANAGEMENT :  a RESEARCH PROGRAM FOR SMART GOVERNMENT OF SMAR...
URBAN LIFECYCLE MANAGEMENT : a RESEARCH PROGRAM FOR SMART GOVERNMENT OF SMAR...
Universit¨¦ Paris-Dauphine
?
IRJET- Implement to a Smart City
IRJET- Implement to a Smart CityIRJET- Implement to a Smart City
IRJET- Implement to a Smart City
IRJET Journal
?
The Evolution of Smart Cities and Connected Communities
The Evolution of Smart Cities and Connected Communities The Evolution of Smart Cities and Connected Communities
The Evolution of Smart Cities and Connected Communities
UPS Longitudes
?
AN INTRODUCTION ON LITERATURE OF SMART CITY
AN INTRODUCTION ON LITERATURE OF SMART CITYAN INTRODUCTION ON LITERATURE OF SMART CITY
AN INTRODUCTION ON LITERATURE OF SMART CITY
civej
?
The Need for Smart Cities in India
The Need for Smart Cities in IndiaThe Need for Smart Cities in India
The Need for Smart Cities in India
dbpublications
?
A global perspective on urban health equity
A global perspective on urban health equityA global perspective on urban health equity
A global perspective on urban health equity
Dr. Ebele Mogo
?
Open Smart Cities in Canada - Webinar 3 - English
Open Smart Cities in Canada - Webinar 3 - EnglishOpen Smart Cities in Canada - Webinar 3 - English
Open Smart Cities in Canada - Webinar 3 - English
Open North
?
Assignment On Smart City.Pdf
Assignment On Smart City.PdfAssignment On Smart City.Pdf
Assignment On Smart City.Pdf
Monica Gero
?
Survey on the Satisfaction of Residents in Creating a Civilized City in Beiji...
Survey on the Satisfaction of Residents in Creating a Civilized City in Beiji...Survey on the Satisfaction of Residents in Creating a Civilized City in Beiji...
Survey on the Satisfaction of Residents in Creating a Civilized City in Beiji...
ijtsrd
?
Open Smart Cities in Canada V1.0 Guide
Open Smart Cities in Canada V1.0 GuideOpen Smart Cities in Canada V1.0 Guide
Open Smart Cities in Canada V1.0 Guide
Communication and Media Studies, Carleton University
?
From Aspiration to Reality: Open Smart Cities
From Aspiration to Reality: Open Smart CitiesFrom Aspiration to Reality: Open Smart Cities
From Aspiration to Reality: Open Smart Cities
Communication and Media Studies, Carleton University
?
Challenges, Opportunities and Risks for a Smart Future
Challenges, Opportunities and Risks for a Smart FutureChallenges, Opportunities and Risks for a Smart Future
Challenges, Opportunities and Risks for a Smart Future
MLOVE ConFestival
?
dynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptx
dynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptxdynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptx
dynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptx
akhileshakm
?
dynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptx
dynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptxdynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptx
dynamic_capabilities_of_a_smart_city.pptx
moh2020
?
Smart cities and open data platforms
Smart cities and open data platformsSmart cities and open data platforms
Smart cities and open data platforms
LD4SC
?
World Smart Cities. EURA Conference 2013, Enschede, the Netherlands
 World Smart Cities. EURA Conference 2013, Enschede, the Netherlands World Smart Cities. EURA Conference 2013, Enschede, the Netherlands
World Smart Cities. EURA Conference 2013, Enschede, the Netherlands
Olga Gil, PhD (olgagil@olgagil.es)
?
Open Data Innovation in Smart Cities: Challenges and Trends
Open Data Innovation in Smart Cities: Challenges and TrendsOpen Data Innovation in Smart Cities: Challenges and Trends
Open Data Innovation in Smart Cities: Challenges and Trends
Edward Curry
?
City and Society 2016 - Seminar Paper - Sagi Ganot
City and Society 2016 - Seminar Paper - Sagi GanotCity and Society 2016 - Seminar Paper - Sagi Ganot
City and Society 2016 - Seminar Paper - Sagi Ganot
Sagi Ganot-Shachar
?
PWC: Data Driven Cities [2016]
PWC: Data Driven Cities [2016]PWC: Data Driven Cities [2016]
PWC: Data Driven Cities [2016]
Filipp Paster
?
URBAN LIFECYCLE MANAGEMENT : a RESEARCH PROGRAM FOR SMART GOVERNMENT OF SMAR...
URBAN LIFECYCLE MANAGEMENT :  a RESEARCH PROGRAM FOR SMART GOVERNMENT OF SMAR...URBAN LIFECYCLE MANAGEMENT :  a RESEARCH PROGRAM FOR SMART GOVERNMENT OF SMAR...
URBAN LIFECYCLE MANAGEMENT : a RESEARCH PROGRAM FOR SMART GOVERNMENT OF SMAR...
Universit¨¦ Paris-Dauphine
?
IRJET- Implement to a Smart City
IRJET- Implement to a Smart CityIRJET- Implement to a Smart City
IRJET- Implement to a Smart City
IRJET Journal
?
The Evolution of Smart Cities and Connected Communities
The Evolution of Smart Cities and Connected Communities The Evolution of Smart Cities and Connected Communities
The Evolution of Smart Cities and Connected Communities
UPS Longitudes
?
AN INTRODUCTION ON LITERATURE OF SMART CITY
AN INTRODUCTION ON LITERATURE OF SMART CITYAN INTRODUCTION ON LITERATURE OF SMART CITY
AN INTRODUCTION ON LITERATURE OF SMART CITY
civej
?
The Need for Smart Cities in India
The Need for Smart Cities in IndiaThe Need for Smart Cities in India
The Need for Smart Cities in India
dbpublications
?
A global perspective on urban health equity
A global perspective on urban health equityA global perspective on urban health equity
A global perspective on urban health equity
Dr. Ebele Mogo
?
Open Smart Cities in Canada - Webinar 3 - English
Open Smart Cities in Canada - Webinar 3 - EnglishOpen Smart Cities in Canada - Webinar 3 - English
Open Smart Cities in Canada - Webinar 3 - English
Open North
?
Assignment On Smart City.Pdf
Assignment On Smart City.PdfAssignment On Smart City.Pdf
Assignment On Smart City.Pdf
Monica Gero
?
Survey on the Satisfaction of Residents in Creating a Civilized City in Beiji...
Survey on the Satisfaction of Residents in Creating a Civilized City in Beiji...Survey on the Satisfaction of Residents in Creating a Civilized City in Beiji...
Survey on the Satisfaction of Residents in Creating a Civilized City in Beiji...
ijtsrd
?
Challenges, Opportunities and Risks for a Smart Future
Challenges, Opportunities and Risks for a Smart FutureChallenges, Opportunities and Risks for a Smart Future
Challenges, Opportunities and Risks for a Smart Future
MLOVE ConFestival
?

Recently uploaded (20)

DealBook of Ukraine: 2025 edition | AVentures Capital
DealBook of Ukraine: 2025 edition | AVentures CapitalDealBook of Ukraine: 2025 edition | AVentures Capital
DealBook of Ukraine: 2025 edition | AVentures Capital
Yevgen Sysoyev
?
[Webinar] Scaling Made Simple: Getting Started with No-Code Web Apps
[Webinar] Scaling Made Simple: Getting Started with No-Code Web Apps[Webinar] Scaling Made Simple: Getting Started with No-Code Web Apps
[Webinar] Scaling Made Simple: Getting Started with No-Code Web Apps
Safe Software
?
Both Feet on the Ground - Generative Artificial Intelligence
Both Feet on the Ground - Generative Artificial IntelligenceBoth Feet on the Ground - Generative Artificial Intelligence
Both Feet on the Ground - Generative Artificial Intelligence
Pete Nieminen
?
Brave Browser Crack 1.45.133 Activated 2025
Brave Browser Crack 1.45.133 Activated 2025Brave Browser Crack 1.45.133 Activated 2025
Brave Browser Crack 1.45.133 Activated 2025
kherorpacca00126
?
Gojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptx
Gojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptxGojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptx
Gojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptx
V3cube
?
Stronger Together: Combining Data Quality and Governance for Confident AI & A...
Stronger Together: Combining Data Quality and Governance for Confident AI & A...Stronger Together: Combining Data Quality and Governance for Confident AI & A...
Stronger Together: Combining Data Quality and Governance for Confident AI & A...
Precisely
?
Replacing RocksDB with ScyllaDB in Kafka Streams by Almog Gavra
Replacing RocksDB with ScyllaDB in Kafka Streams by Almog GavraReplacing RocksDB with ScyllaDB in Kafka Streams by Almog Gavra
Replacing RocksDB with ScyllaDB in Kafka Streams by Almog Gavra
ScyllaDB
?
UiPath Agentic Automation Capabilities and Opportunities
UiPath Agentic Automation Capabilities and OpportunitiesUiPath Agentic Automation Capabilities and Opportunities
UiPath Agentic Automation Capabilities and Opportunities
DianaGray10
?
Unlocking DevOps Secuirty :Vault & Keylock
Unlocking DevOps Secuirty :Vault & KeylockUnlocking DevOps Secuirty :Vault & Keylock
Unlocking DevOps Secuirty :Vault & Keylock
HusseinMalikMammadli
?
Unlock AI Creativity: Image Generation with DALL¡¤E
Unlock AI Creativity: Image Generation with DALL¡¤EUnlock AI Creativity: Image Generation with DALL¡¤E
Unlock AI Creativity: Image Generation with DALL¡¤E
Expeed Software
?
AIXMOOC 2.3 - Modelli di reti neurali con esperimenti di addestramento
AIXMOOC 2.3 - Modelli di reti neurali con esperimenti di addestramentoAIXMOOC 2.3 - Modelli di reti neurali con esperimenti di addestramento
AIXMOOC 2.3 - Modelli di reti neurali con esperimenti di addestramento
Alessandro Bogliolo
?
30B Images and Counting: Scaling Canva's Content-Understanding Pipelines by K...
30B Images and Counting: Scaling Canva's Content-Understanding Pipelines by K...30B Images and Counting: Scaling Canva's Content-Understanding Pipelines by K...
30B Images and Counting: Scaling Canva's Content-Understanding Pipelines by K...
ScyllaDB
?
UiPath Document Understanding - Generative AI and Active learning capabilities
UiPath Document Understanding - Generative AI and Active learning capabilitiesUiPath Document Understanding - Generative AI and Active learning capabilities
UiPath Document Understanding - Generative AI and Active learning capabilities
DianaGray10
?
Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4
Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4
Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4
Margaret Maynard-Reid
?
FinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptx
FinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptxFinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptx
FinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptx
Tracxn
?
Cloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in Aviation
Cloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in AviationCloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in Aviation
Cloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in Aviation
Assem mousa
?
Future-Proof Your Career with AI Options
Future-Proof Your  Career with AI OptionsFuture-Proof Your  Career with AI Options
Future-Proof Your Career with AI Options
DianaGray10
?
L01 Introduction to Nanoindentation - What is hardness
L01 Introduction to Nanoindentation - What is hardnessL01 Introduction to Nanoindentation - What is hardness
L01 Introduction to Nanoindentation - What is hardness
RostislavDaniel
?
A Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin Engineering
A Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin EngineeringA Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin Engineering
A Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin Engineering
Daniel Lehner
?
Wondershare Filmora Crack 14.3.2.11147 Latest
Wondershare Filmora Crack 14.3.2.11147 LatestWondershare Filmora Crack 14.3.2.11147 Latest
Wondershare Filmora Crack 14.3.2.11147 Latest
udkg888
?
DealBook of Ukraine: 2025 edition | AVentures Capital
DealBook of Ukraine: 2025 edition | AVentures CapitalDealBook of Ukraine: 2025 edition | AVentures Capital
DealBook of Ukraine: 2025 edition | AVentures Capital
Yevgen Sysoyev
?
[Webinar] Scaling Made Simple: Getting Started with No-Code Web Apps
[Webinar] Scaling Made Simple: Getting Started with No-Code Web Apps[Webinar] Scaling Made Simple: Getting Started with No-Code Web Apps
[Webinar] Scaling Made Simple: Getting Started with No-Code Web Apps
Safe Software
?
Both Feet on the Ground - Generative Artificial Intelligence
Both Feet on the Ground - Generative Artificial IntelligenceBoth Feet on the Ground - Generative Artificial Intelligence
Both Feet on the Ground - Generative Artificial Intelligence
Pete Nieminen
?
Brave Browser Crack 1.45.133 Activated 2025
Brave Browser Crack 1.45.133 Activated 2025Brave Browser Crack 1.45.133 Activated 2025
Brave Browser Crack 1.45.133 Activated 2025
kherorpacca00126
?
Gojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptx
Gojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptxGojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptx
Gojek Clone Multi-Service Super App.pptx
V3cube
?
Stronger Together: Combining Data Quality and Governance for Confident AI & A...
Stronger Together: Combining Data Quality and Governance for Confident AI & A...Stronger Together: Combining Data Quality and Governance for Confident AI & A...
Stronger Together: Combining Data Quality and Governance for Confident AI & A...
Precisely
?
Replacing RocksDB with ScyllaDB in Kafka Streams by Almog Gavra
Replacing RocksDB with ScyllaDB in Kafka Streams by Almog GavraReplacing RocksDB with ScyllaDB in Kafka Streams by Almog Gavra
Replacing RocksDB with ScyllaDB in Kafka Streams by Almog Gavra
ScyllaDB
?
UiPath Agentic Automation Capabilities and Opportunities
UiPath Agentic Automation Capabilities and OpportunitiesUiPath Agentic Automation Capabilities and Opportunities
UiPath Agentic Automation Capabilities and Opportunities
DianaGray10
?
Unlocking DevOps Secuirty :Vault & Keylock
Unlocking DevOps Secuirty :Vault & KeylockUnlocking DevOps Secuirty :Vault & Keylock
Unlocking DevOps Secuirty :Vault & Keylock
HusseinMalikMammadli
?
Unlock AI Creativity: Image Generation with DALL¡¤E
Unlock AI Creativity: Image Generation with DALL¡¤EUnlock AI Creativity: Image Generation with DALL¡¤E
Unlock AI Creativity: Image Generation with DALL¡¤E
Expeed Software
?
AIXMOOC 2.3 - Modelli di reti neurali con esperimenti di addestramento
AIXMOOC 2.3 - Modelli di reti neurali con esperimenti di addestramentoAIXMOOC 2.3 - Modelli di reti neurali con esperimenti di addestramento
AIXMOOC 2.3 - Modelli di reti neurali con esperimenti di addestramento
Alessandro Bogliolo
?
30B Images and Counting: Scaling Canva's Content-Understanding Pipelines by K...
30B Images and Counting: Scaling Canva's Content-Understanding Pipelines by K...30B Images and Counting: Scaling Canva's Content-Understanding Pipelines by K...
30B Images and Counting: Scaling Canva's Content-Understanding Pipelines by K...
ScyllaDB
?
UiPath Document Understanding - Generative AI and Active learning capabilities
UiPath Document Understanding - Generative AI and Active learning capabilitiesUiPath Document Understanding - Generative AI and Active learning capabilities
UiPath Document Understanding - Generative AI and Active learning capabilities
DianaGray10
?
Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4
Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4
Build with AI on Google Cloud Session #4
Margaret Maynard-Reid
?
FinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptx
FinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptxFinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptx
FinTech - US Annual Funding Report - 2024.pptx
Tracxn
?
Cloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in Aviation
Cloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in AviationCloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in Aviation
Cloud of everything Tech of the 21 century in Aviation
Assem mousa
?
Future-Proof Your Career with AI Options
Future-Proof Your  Career with AI OptionsFuture-Proof Your  Career with AI Options
Future-Proof Your Career with AI Options
DianaGray10
?
L01 Introduction to Nanoindentation - What is hardness
L01 Introduction to Nanoindentation - What is hardnessL01 Introduction to Nanoindentation - What is hardness
L01 Introduction to Nanoindentation - What is hardness
RostislavDaniel
?
A Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin Engineering
A Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin EngineeringA Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin Engineering
A Framework for Model-Driven Digital Twin Engineering
Daniel Lehner
?
Wondershare Filmora Crack 14.3.2.11147 Latest
Wondershare Filmora Crack 14.3.2.11147 LatestWondershare Filmora Crack 14.3.2.11147 Latest
Wondershare Filmora Crack 14.3.2.11147 Latest
udkg888
?

The role of people and sensores in the development of the smart cities: A systematic literature review

  • 1. The Role of People and Sensors in the Development of Smart Cities A Systematic Literature Review Felipe Silva Ferraz fsf@cesar.org.br Italberto Figueira Dantas italberto@ufpi.edu.br
  • 2. Introduction ¡è? Over the last few years, with rapid population growth, issues like air pollution, water scarcity, and intense traffic conditions, have become more evident. ¡è? Trying to mitigate them, the concept of Smart City was presented, which uses technology and human resources to manage urban resources. ¡è? But, it is not clear what role is occupied in the different stages of evolution, which leads a city to be considered Smart. ¡è? We used the SLR method to analyze scientific publications, and thus to determine what is the role of the human factor, represented by people, and technological, represented by sensors, in the development of smart cities.
  • 3. Background ¡è? In the last century, the number of cities in the world with more than 1 million inhabitants jumped from 20 to 450 [1]. ¡è? In 2007, the number of people living in urban centers exceeded 50% of the world population [1]. ¡è? Technology is a way to solve the problems caused by the population growth [2]. ¡è? In the current scenario, every initiative is important if it helps understand the growth of great urban centers and how it occurs, as well as what measures should be adopted to extinguish the problems caused by it, from a scientific and economic point of view. ¡è? In this work, we intend to provide the current panorama of the scientific researches made in the field of Smart Cities that talk about their development based on the participation of people and the use of sensors,
  • 4. Systematic Literature Review (SLR) ¡è? Research Question: What is the role of people and sensors in the development of Smart Cities? ¡è? Q1.1. What is the influence of the participation of people or use of sensors in the study?; ¡è? Q1.2. What is the level of previous infrastructure so the study proposal is viable?; ¡è? Q1.3. What stage of social organization the city needs to be in so the study is viable?; ¡è? Q1.4. What is the contribution of the study for the scientific community?; ¡è? Q1.5. How was the study validated?; ¡è? Q.1.6. What was the main feature of the city affected by the study?.
  • 5. SLR Execution ¡è? Four steps were defined and for two of them, exclusion criterion were defined as well: ¡è? ST01. The search must be done in the selected bases Scopus, IEEExplore, Science Direct and Compendex. ¡è? ST02. This stage eliminates primary studies that do not attend the purposes of this study. ¡è? ST03. Publications not excluded on the previous step will be re-evaluated based on their title, abstract or full text. ¡è? ST04. Search for referenced of the remaining publications must be made (snowballing search).
  • 6. SLR Execution ¡è? Initially 1121 publications were found. ¡è? After applying exclusion criterion, we obtained 45 publications. ¡è? Each publication was evaluated under the subquestions point of view. ¡è? Results of sub-questions were compared with the other results.
  • 7. Results ¡è? Question Q1.1 Analysis ¡è? When a society is not organized to sustain initiatives to create a Smart City, Technology is the most expressive element to start the process. ¡è? In cities with no infrastructure and control of their resources, the administration of the city prefer to invest their efforts to acquire technologies. ¡è? When there are available infrastructure, human resource is the most discussed issue, indicating the influence it may have on the development of the city. ¡è? The human perception of the environment is being explored in the monitoring of natural resources and urban environment, being as important as the sensors in the information acquisition.
  • 8. Results ¡è? Question Q1.4 Analysis ¡è? Implementation was the most used method to validate the efforts. It may indicate that there are not many options to test the previously available proposals, which made the researchers responsible for developing their own tools to validate their proposals. ¡è? Economic aspects were not addressed, It may indicate that more researches about the economic features of Smart Cities are necessary. ¡è? Question Q1.6 Analysis ¡è? Governance was the area that received more attention. This result may point to a city in the Chaotic level as Governance as the area that should get more attention, since it deals with the decision making about the future of the city.
  • 9. Conclusion ¡è? Results obtained during the protocol test show it could be used in a consistent way to reach the objectives of this study. ¡è? We could notice that people and sensors have great importance when developing Smart Cities. Their importance changes ac- cording to the level of technological and social development each city is in, as well as the needs each city defines as priority.
  • 10. Future Works ¡è? The economic aspect was showed pretty deficient, from almost all analyzed points of view. So, this theme needs to be deeply analyzed, in order to understand better the relationship with the cities technological and social elements. ¡è? This research was realized considering just a period of five years of study. A new protocol execution can be made, with a bigger range, in order to analyze the evolution of the researched aspects with the development of new scientific studies about Smart Cities, making it possible to enhance the knowledge about how people and sensors influence the Smart Cities development, drawing an evolutionary profile.
  • 11. References ¡è? [1] ?C. E. A. Mulligan and M. Olsson, ¡°Architectural Implications of Smart City Business Models : An Evolutionary Perspective,¡± IEEE Communications Magazine, vol. 51, no. 6, Jun. 2013, pp. 80¨C85. ¡è? [2] ?C. E. A. Mulligan and M. Olsson, ¡°Architectural Implications of Smart City Business Models : An Evolutionary Perspective,¡± IEEE Communications Magazine, vol. 51, no. 6, Jun. 2013, pp. 80¨C85.