際際滷

際際滷Share a Scribd company logo
+




    Theory of Knowledge

    Mini Lessons and the core ideas
    Ayca Turkkan
    September 14, 2012
+
    What is TOK?

       Theory Of Knowledge



       Theory teatre  to see



       Seeing Knowledge
+
       How do we know?

       How do we use this in our:

       Personal

       Professional

       Societal
+
    What do we do?

       Open ended questions

       Thinking critically

       Reflecting

       Develop ideas
+
    What is NOT TOK?

       Philosophy class

       Not trying to decipher the meaning of life

       Reflection on learning --- MUST
+
    What do we do in class?

       Origins and nature of knowledge




       Knowledge is defined as justified true belief
+
    Justification

       Needs to appeal to four ways of knowing (WOKs)

       Language  My Mom told me!

       Perception - I saw /see it!

       Reason  I figured it out!

       Emotion  It is obvious!

       CONTEXT  hypothetical  Murat Bey in his office? You might
        question your knowledge!
+
    Truth

       Very thick concept

       Makes a clear distinction between knowledge and belief

       Earth being flat  Everyone believed it!

       There are 9 planets in our solar system  They discovered
        Chiron!

       In practice when we say something is true we say it is beyond
        reasonable doubt.

       In simpler terms: Rational Truth  use your head and Empirical
        Truth  Look for evidence (use your eyes!)
+
    Burglar
    Woman: Honey I think someone is in the house. Please go and
     look.

    Man: There is no one in the house. Otherwise the alarm would
     have gone off.

    Woman: Maybe someone cut the wires!

    Man: Dont be silly! The dog would have barked!

    Woman: Maybe they have chloroformed the dog! Please go look!
     (And the man goes downstairs..)

    Man: There Ive looked. There is no one in the house!

    Woman: Well, maybe when you were in the kitchen he was in the
     living room! ..
+
    Belief

       Truth  objective Belief  subjective




       Comes right before knowledge
+
    Belief Knowledge Continuum
+


       Thats why we cannot say that calculators know 2 + 2 = 4!
+
    Origins of Knowledge

       Observation?      Books?

       Dreams?           Visions?

       Hunches?          Thought?

       Teachers?         Etc etc.

       TV?

       Internet?

       Family?
+
    Origins of Knowledge



       Knowledge by Acquaintance

       Knowledge by Description
+
    The Distinction

    Knowing how                      Knowing that (I know that..)

    Subjective                       Objective

    Private                          Articulated

    Can originate in experience      Public

    Can be shown                     Must have
                                      reasons/evidence/proof
    May give certainty
                                     May give certainty
    BAKING BREAD
                                     RECIPE FOR BAKING BREAD
+
    Knowledge Claims

       You are saying something that you believe to be true!
+
    True? False? Both? Neither?

       I know its raining!

       I know it is raining or it is not raining.

       I know 2 + 2 = 4

       I know two apples and two apples make four apples.

       I know how to speak English.

       I know my tooth hurts.
+
    I know it is raining!

       Needs evidence to be proven true or false

       Empirical knowledge

       You need to go and look!
+
    I know it is raining or it is not raining!

       True under all conditions!

       Simple reasoning!

       Your mind tells you that it is true.

       Double check: think of what could prove it false???
+
    I know 2 + 2 = 4

       Rational truth within the mathematical framework of base 10.

       Coherent with other mathematical statements like 34  16 = 18.

       A basic mathematical mind is all thats needed here.
+
    Two apples and two apples make 4
    apples?
       Not a Rational statement about mathematical knowledge

       There are no numbers

       Cannot be counted as mathematical proof

       Purely empirical

       Check: As you are walking out it starts drizzling, first a drop of
        raindrop on your forehead, then another. Do you have two
        drops of water on your forehead?
+
    I know how to speak English.

       Knowledge by acquaintance

       Knowing how

       Either you can do it or you cannot

       Proof is in the performance

       Empirical
+
    I know my tooth hurts.

       One of those interesting truths that is only TRUE FOR YOU.

       How can you prove it?

       The dentist may claim otherwise!
+
    Knowledge Issues

       Core of the course

       Address each knowledge claim through the framework of
        knowledge issues (knowledge problems)

       Forms the basis of both internal and external assessment

       Essay: Identify the key knowledge problems in the prescribed
        title

       Presentation: Finding knowledge issues and searching for real
        life situations
+
    Knowledge issues clarified

       Wikipedia says that Bangkok is in Thailand.

       How can I use reason to know if information from an internet
        source is accurate and reliable?

       Modern art is more meaningful than Renaissance
        representative art.

       What are the criteria to distinguish more meaningful art from
        less meaningful art?
+


       I saw a documentary last night that proves global warming is
        bogus!

       What emotional techniques do documentary makers use to
        shape our judgments?

       My eyes tell me that the teaspoon bends in a clear teacup.

       How can we know when our senses give us accurate
        information about the world?
+
    Areas of Knowledge

       IB believes that valuable knowledge resides in well-established
        disciplines.

       Mathematics

       Natural Sciences

       Human Sciences

       Art

       History

       Ethics
+
    How do we use these AOKs?

       Natural sciences:

       What is a classic scientific method?

       Know what makes a claim a scientific claim

       Meaning of truth in the scientific context

       Effects of scientific way of thinking on our beliefs
+
    Mathematics

       Axiom-theorem structure

       And how this applies to mathematical truth

       Role of logic  link to rationalism

       Theorem establishing for describing a situation
+
    Human Sciences

       Difference between human sciences and natural sciences

       Position of ethics in human sciences

       Dilemmas  free will, nature/nurture debate

       Experimental problems in human sciences
+
    Ethics

       Thoroughly understand the concept of ethics

       Strengths and weaknesses in ethics

       Role of emotion in ethics

       The concept of choice in ethics

       Role of culture in ethics

       Role of reasoning in ethics
+
    History

       The distinction between history and historiography

       Nature and problems of historical facts

       Compare and contrast history with other disciplines

       Role of bias

       Selection in the historical process
+
    Arts

       Definitions and descriptions of the central characteristics of the
        arts

       Defend the criteria for artistic judgment

       How art fits in the human experience

       Artistic knowledge versus other forms of knowledge

       Theories on the role of truth in the context of the arts
+
    Natural sciences

       Can you help me draw a scientist on the board?

       What comes to your mind when I say a scientist?

       How does a scientist look?
+
+
    Ethics

       Imagine you are a large Jewish familiy hiding from the Nazis
        during the Second World War. One day you hear the soldiers
        coming towards your house.

       You hide in a very safe spot in your basement, as a family. You
        are sure that you will not be found.

       Then the youngest member of your family, the three month old
        baby starts crying while the Nazis are upstairs in your home.

       Would you kill the baby to save 7 people? Or would you
        sacrifice all 7 people instead of killing the baby?
+
    The Arts  Effects of music

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=32A7bTalgAE&feature=plcp
+
    The Arts  Effect of music

       http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Os6raCCmAFk&feature=plcp
+
    The TOK Essay

       1200  1600 words

       Addressing knowledge issues  Understanding Knowledge
        issues

       Student voice

       Analysis of these knowledge issues

       Organization of Ideas
+
    Resources

    - Sue Bastian  TOK Category 2 Workshop Materials

    New York City, July 2012

    -   Theory of Knowledge , Sue Bastian, Pearson Baccalaureate
        2009

    -   Theory Of Knowledge  Nicholas Alchin, Hodder Murray 2006

    -   Theory of Knowledge for the IB Diploma  Richard van de
        Lagemaat, Cambridge University Press 2011

More Related Content

Tok intro

  • 1. + Theory of Knowledge Mini Lessons and the core ideas Ayca Turkkan September 14, 2012
  • 2. + What is TOK? Theory Of Knowledge Theory teatre to see Seeing Knowledge
  • 3. + How do we know? How do we use this in our: Personal Professional Societal
  • 4. + What do we do? Open ended questions Thinking critically Reflecting Develop ideas
  • 5. + What is NOT TOK? Philosophy class Not trying to decipher the meaning of life Reflection on learning --- MUST
  • 6. + What do we do in class? Origins and nature of knowledge Knowledge is defined as justified true belief
  • 7. + Justification Needs to appeal to four ways of knowing (WOKs) Language My Mom told me! Perception - I saw /see it! Reason I figured it out! Emotion It is obvious! CONTEXT hypothetical Murat Bey in his office? You might question your knowledge!
  • 8. + Truth Very thick concept Makes a clear distinction between knowledge and belief Earth being flat Everyone believed it! There are 9 planets in our solar system They discovered Chiron! In practice when we say something is true we say it is beyond reasonable doubt. In simpler terms: Rational Truth use your head and Empirical Truth Look for evidence (use your eyes!)
  • 9. + Burglar Woman: Honey I think someone is in the house. Please go and look. Man: There is no one in the house. Otherwise the alarm would have gone off. Woman: Maybe someone cut the wires! Man: Dont be silly! The dog would have barked! Woman: Maybe they have chloroformed the dog! Please go look! (And the man goes downstairs..) Man: There Ive looked. There is no one in the house! Woman: Well, maybe when you were in the kitchen he was in the living room! ..
  • 10. + Belief Truth objective Belief subjective Comes right before knowledge
  • 11. + Belief Knowledge Continuum
  • 12. + Thats why we cannot say that calculators know 2 + 2 = 4!
  • 13. + Origins of Knowledge Observation? Books? Dreams? Visions? Hunches? Thought? Teachers? Etc etc. TV? Internet? Family?
  • 14. + Origins of Knowledge Knowledge by Acquaintance Knowledge by Description
  • 15. + The Distinction Knowing how Knowing that (I know that..) Subjective Objective Private Articulated Can originate in experience Public Can be shown Must have reasons/evidence/proof May give certainty May give certainty BAKING BREAD RECIPE FOR BAKING BREAD
  • 16. + Knowledge Claims You are saying something that you believe to be true!
  • 17. + True? False? Both? Neither? I know its raining! I know it is raining or it is not raining. I know 2 + 2 = 4 I know two apples and two apples make four apples. I know how to speak English. I know my tooth hurts.
  • 18. + I know it is raining! Needs evidence to be proven true or false Empirical knowledge You need to go and look!
  • 19. + I know it is raining or it is not raining! True under all conditions! Simple reasoning! Your mind tells you that it is true. Double check: think of what could prove it false???
  • 20. + I know 2 + 2 = 4 Rational truth within the mathematical framework of base 10. Coherent with other mathematical statements like 34 16 = 18. A basic mathematical mind is all thats needed here.
  • 21. + Two apples and two apples make 4 apples? Not a Rational statement about mathematical knowledge There are no numbers Cannot be counted as mathematical proof Purely empirical Check: As you are walking out it starts drizzling, first a drop of raindrop on your forehead, then another. Do you have two drops of water on your forehead?
  • 22. + I know how to speak English. Knowledge by acquaintance Knowing how Either you can do it or you cannot Proof is in the performance Empirical
  • 23. + I know my tooth hurts. One of those interesting truths that is only TRUE FOR YOU. How can you prove it? The dentist may claim otherwise!
  • 24. + Knowledge Issues Core of the course Address each knowledge claim through the framework of knowledge issues (knowledge problems) Forms the basis of both internal and external assessment Essay: Identify the key knowledge problems in the prescribed title Presentation: Finding knowledge issues and searching for real life situations
  • 25. + Knowledge issues clarified Wikipedia says that Bangkok is in Thailand. How can I use reason to know if information from an internet source is accurate and reliable? Modern art is more meaningful than Renaissance representative art. What are the criteria to distinguish more meaningful art from less meaningful art?
  • 26. + I saw a documentary last night that proves global warming is bogus! What emotional techniques do documentary makers use to shape our judgments? My eyes tell me that the teaspoon bends in a clear teacup. How can we know when our senses give us accurate information about the world?
  • 27. + Areas of Knowledge IB believes that valuable knowledge resides in well-established disciplines. Mathematics Natural Sciences Human Sciences Art History Ethics
  • 28. + How do we use these AOKs? Natural sciences: What is a classic scientific method? Know what makes a claim a scientific claim Meaning of truth in the scientific context Effects of scientific way of thinking on our beliefs
  • 29. + Mathematics Axiom-theorem structure And how this applies to mathematical truth Role of logic link to rationalism Theorem establishing for describing a situation
  • 30. + Human Sciences Difference between human sciences and natural sciences Position of ethics in human sciences Dilemmas free will, nature/nurture debate Experimental problems in human sciences
  • 31. + Ethics Thoroughly understand the concept of ethics Strengths and weaknesses in ethics Role of emotion in ethics The concept of choice in ethics Role of culture in ethics Role of reasoning in ethics
  • 32. + History The distinction between history and historiography Nature and problems of historical facts Compare and contrast history with other disciplines Role of bias Selection in the historical process
  • 33. + Arts Definitions and descriptions of the central characteristics of the arts Defend the criteria for artistic judgment How art fits in the human experience Artistic knowledge versus other forms of knowledge Theories on the role of truth in the context of the arts
  • 34. + Natural sciences Can you help me draw a scientist on the board? What comes to your mind when I say a scientist? How does a scientist look?
  • 35. +
  • 36. + Ethics Imagine you are a large Jewish familiy hiding from the Nazis during the Second World War. One day you hear the soldiers coming towards your house. You hide in a very safe spot in your basement, as a family. You are sure that you will not be found. Then the youngest member of your family, the three month old baby starts crying while the Nazis are upstairs in your home. Would you kill the baby to save 7 people? Or would you sacrifice all 7 people instead of killing the baby?
  • 37. + The Arts Effects of music http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=32A7bTalgAE&feature=plcp
  • 38. + The Arts Effect of music http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Os6raCCmAFk&feature=plcp
  • 39. + The TOK Essay 1200 1600 words Addressing knowledge issues Understanding Knowledge issues Student voice Analysis of these knowledge issues Organization of Ideas
  • 40. + Resources - Sue Bastian TOK Category 2 Workshop Materials New York City, July 2012 - Theory of Knowledge , Sue Bastian, Pearson Baccalaureate 2009 - Theory Of Knowledge Nicholas Alchin, Hodder Murray 2006 - Theory of Knowledge for the IB Diploma Richard van de Lagemaat, Cambridge University Press 2011