These days it seems like that the popular media mostly highlights the inevitable doom of brick-and-mortar retailers and the boom of online retailers such as amazon and alibaba.
However, in doing so, it is easy to overlook the valuable lessons thought by previous disruptive innovations in brick-and-mortar retailers and what building blocks made them successful before e-commerce stole the limelight of popular media.
Full Article on History of Disruptions in Retailing: https://jawwad.me/understanding-history-disruptions-retailing/
1 of 1
Download to read offline
More Related Content
Understanding the History of Disruptions in Retailing
1. History of Disruptions in Retailing
Adapted from HBR Article Patterns of Disruption in Retailing
by Clayton M. Christensen and Richard S. Tedlow & The Piton.
Original State 1st Disruption 2nd Disruption
(Sustaining Innovation)
3rd Disruption 4th Disruption
Timeline Before 1900s 1900-1940 1940-1970 1970-1990 1990 to Present
Profitability GM=45% Turn=2.5x
ROI=113%
GM=40% Turn=3x
ROI=120%
GM=40% Turn=3x
ROI = 120%
GM= 23% Turn=5x
ROI=115%
GM=5% Turn=25x
ROI=125%
Retailer
Types
Specialty Stores
Aka Local Corner Stores
1. Department Stores
Aka General Merchants
Example: Macys Marshall Fields
2. Catalog Retailers
1. Malls
Aka Strip Centers, Mass
Retailers
Example: Gap, Malls
2. Specialty Catalogs
Discount Dept Stores
Aka Category Killers, Value
Players, Club Stores
Example: Costco, Kmart, Target
Also include specialty discount
stores HomeDepot, Staples, etc
Internet Retailing
Aka e-commerce
Example: Amazon, eBay, Dell
Introduced Navigation as a
business where business can
become affiliated with the
customer by providing info.
Business
Model
Higher service, high
inventory, high prices,
and local knowledge.
Shopping Experience:
Behind-the-Counter
lower service, lower prices
Shopping Experience: Self-
Service Shopping Cart
Enabling Technology: Railroad
(department stores) and Rural
Free Mail Delivery (Catalog
Retailers)
Product Selection: Standard
Products
Targeted selection
Shopping Experience:
Suburban Life
Enabling Technology:
Automobile
Product Selection: Mass
Market Products
lower service, lower prices
Shopping Experience: One-Stop
Shopping
Enabling Technology: Computer
Systems, Distribution Systems,
and Vendor Management
Product Selection:
Commoditization (global
megabrands) and private brands
Shopping Experience:
Online Virtual Shopping and
Services
Enabling Technology:
Internet and Navigation-as-a-
business.
Product Selection: Infinite
and Customization
Mission of Retailing: The right
product, In the right place, at the right
price and at the right time
Profitability: Largely determined
by two factors: Margin and Turn
by jawwad.me